10 Reasons the Death Penalty Should Be Abolished

There are strong reasons the death penalty should be abolished: it has sent innocent people to die, it does not deter crime, it falls hardest on defendants who are poor, Black, or prosecuted in a handful of aggressive counties, it costs taxpayers far more than life imprisonment, and the executions themselves go wrong often enough that even the Supreme Court has split sharply over whether current methods are constitutional. Twenty-three states and the District of Columbia have ended capital punishment, while roughly 2,100 people remain on death row nationwide.1Death Penalty Information Center. State by State

Innocent People Keep Being Sentenced to Death

Since 1973, at least 202 people sentenced to death in the United States have been exonerated. Researchers estimate roughly one wrongful death sentence for every eight or nine executions carried out. Some of the people later cleared came within hours of being killed by the state.

DNA testing has done most of the heavy lifting in uncovering these errors, with the first death row DNA exoneration occurring in 1993.2National Library of Medicine. Visible Proofs: Forensic Views of the Body – Rescued From Death Row: Kirk Bloodsworth and the Innocence Project But biological evidence exists in only a fraction of cases. Everywhere else, wrongful convictions turn on eyewitness misidentifications, coerced confessions, informant testimony, and prosecutorial misconduct, and those errors are caught only if someone is still looking.

Prosecutors are required under Brady v. Maryland to disclose evidence favorable to the defense.3Justia. Brady v. Maryland, 373 U.S. 83 (1963) Violations typically surface only after a conviction, and sometimes after an execution. Most mistakes in the justice system can be corrected. An execution cannot.

Much of the Forensic Evidence Does Not Hold Up

About a third of death row exonerations have involved at least one piece of discredited forensic evidence. Bite mark matching, microscopic hair comparison, and older arson investigation methods were sold to juries as reliable science and later exposed as something closer to guesswork.

A 2015 joint review by the FBI and the Department of Justice found that FBI examiners gave erroneous testimony in 96 percent of cases involving microscopic hair analysis. Of 268 cases reviewed where that testimony was used against defendants at trial, 257 contained scientifically invalid statements.4Federal Bureau of Investigation. FBI Testimony on Microscopic Hair Analysis Contained Errors in at Least 90 Percent of Cases in Ongoing Review A 2023 National Institute of Justice study identified systematic errors across more than 30 forensic disciplines. Jurors tend to trust anything presented as science, and in capital cases that trust has sent innocent people to death row on evidence that would not survive peer review.

There Is No Credible Evidence It Deters Crime

The usual argument for keeping the death penalty is that it prevents murders. The research does not support that claim. In 2012, the National Research Council reviewed more than three decades of deterrence studies and concluded they “are not informative about whether capital punishment decreases, increases, or has no effect on homicide rates.” The council recommended that the studies not be used to shape policy.5National Academies Press. Deterrence and the Death Penalty

In polling of the country’s leading criminologists, 88 percent said they do not believe the death penalty deters homicide. Murder rates in states without the death penalty have remained consistently lower than rates in states that retain it, and the gap has widened since 1990. States that abolish capital punishment do not see murder rates spike afterward.

Race, Wealth, and Geography Decide Who Gets Sentenced

Capital punishment is not applied according to the severity of the crime. It tracks where the crime happened, who the victim was, and how much money the defendant has.

Professor David Baldus’s landmark Georgia study found defendants were 4.3 times more likely to receive a death sentence when the victim was white than when the victim was Black. A federal review found that in 82 percent of studies examined, the race of the victim correlated with capital charging or sentencing.6Office of Justice Programs. Death Penalty Sentencing: Research Indicates Pattern of Racial Disparities Three-quarters of death sentences today involve white victims, even though roughly half of all homicide victims in the country are Black.

In McCleskey v. Kemp, the Supreme Court acknowledged this statistical evidence but held that a defendant would have to prove intentional racial discrimination by the specific decision-makers in his own case to win relief.7Justia. McCleskey v. Kemp, 481 U.S. 279 (1987) That standard is nearly impossible to meet, and the disparities have not improved in the decades since.

Money shapes outcomes nearly as much. Federal law requires at least two attorneys in a capital case, one with specific death penalty experience.8Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 18 U.S. Code 3005 – Counsel and Witnesses in Capital Cases In practice, publicly funded defense teams are chronically underfunded. Federal panel attorneys earn $175 per hour in non-capital cases and $223 in capital cases, a modest bump for work that is far more complex.9United States Courts. Funding Crisis Leaves Defense Lawyers Working Without Pay Defendants who can afford top private counsel and independent experts almost never end up on death row for the same crimes that send indigent defendants there.

Geography compounds everything else. The majority of death sentences come from about 1 percent of the nation’s counties.10PubMed Central (PMC). Learning to Kill: Why a Small Handful of Counties Generates the Bulk of US Death Sentences Whether you live or die can depend on which prosecutor’s desk your case lands on.

Capital Juries Are Filtered Before Trial

Before a capital trial starts, the jury pool is screened through a process called death qualification. Anyone who says they could not consider imposing a death sentence is removed. The result is juries that are whiter, more male, and more conviction-prone than a representative cross-section of the community. Black Americans, and Black women in particular, are excluded at disproportionately high rates because they are more likely to oppose capital punishment. Studies have found that death-qualified juries also give more credence to prosecution evidence and deliberate less thoroughly than juries that have not been filtered this way.

It Costs More Than Life in Prison

The death penalty is often defended as cheaper than warehousing someone for life. The data runs the other direction, and the gap is wide. A review by the Ohio Legislative Service Commission found that capital cases cost between 2.5 and 5 times more than comparable non-capital cases. In some jurisdictions a single capital prosecution runs $1 million to $3 million more than seeking life imprisonment.

Those costs show up at every stage. Pre-trial investigation requires forensic experts, mental health evaluations, and a complete life-history workup on the defendant. The trial itself is bifurcated, one proceeding to determine guilt and a second to decide sentence, doubling court time, security costs, and attorney hours. Jury selection alone can take weeks.

After conviction, the appeals process stretches for years. Prisoners executed in 2020 had spent an average of nearly 19 years on death row.11Bureau of Justice Statistics. Capital Punishment, 2020 – Statistical Tables Each year brings direct appeals, state post-conviction proceedings, and federal habeas petitions, all funded by taxpayers. Those safeguards are necessary to minimize the risk of killing an innocent person. They also mean the cost argument for the death penalty has never been true.

Executions Go Wrong More Often Than People Realize

Between 1890 and 2010, roughly 3 percent of U.S. executions were classified as botched, meaning they involved unanticipated problems that caused unnecessary suffering or reflected gross incompetence. Lethal injection, the method commonly described as humane, has the highest botched execution rate of any method at 7.2 percent.12Death Penalty Information Center. Botched Executions

In 2014, an Oklahoma inmate writhed on the gurney, clenching his teeth and straining to lift his head for 43 minutes before dying. That same year, an Arizona inmate gasped repeatedly for an hour and 40 minutes after injection. In 2022, an Oklahoma inmate convulsed and vomited for several minutes after receiving midazolam. In 2022 in Alabama, an execution took an estimated three and a half hours after staff spent hours trying to establish intravenous access.

The problem has grown as pharmaceutical companies have cut off supply. More than 60 global healthcare companies now bar their products from being used in executions. States have turned to compounding pharmacies with less regulatory oversight, or to untested drug combinations. In Glossip v. Gross, the Supreme Court upheld Oklahoma’s use of midazolam, but Justice Sotomayor wrote in dissent that the protocol risked subjecting inmates to “the chemical equivalent of being burned at the stake,” and Justice Breyer argued that the death penalty itself is unconstitutional.13Justia. Glossip v. Gross, 576 U.S. 863 (2015) The federal government, meanwhile, rescinded its moratorium on executions and in April 2026 expanded the federal protocol to include the firing squad.14United States Department of Justice. The Justice Department Takes Actions to Strengthen the Federal Death Penalty

Death Row Is a Second Punishment

People sentenced to death spend an average of nearly 19 years waiting to be executed.11Bureau of Justice Statistics. Capital Punishment, 2020 – Statistical Tables Most are held in conditions that amount to prolonged solitary confinement, locked alone in small cells for 22 to 24 hours a day, cut off from educational and work programs, and sharply restricted in visitation. They cannot touch family members. They live under constant uncertainty about when, or whether, the state will kill them. The Supreme Court itself has recognized that long delays combined with that uncertainty produce “immense mental anxiety amounting to a great increase in the offender’s punishment.” Some inmates deteriorate so severely that they drop their appeals and volunteer for execution.

It Does Not Deliver What Victims’ Families Need

The death penalty is often pursued in the name of victims’ families, but the long process frequently deepens their trauma rather than easing it. Capital cases drag families through decades of appeals, retrials, and resentencings, forcing them to relive the crime at every stage.

A study comparing families of murder victims in Texas and Minnesota found that Minnesota families, whose cases resolved through life sentences within roughly two years, reported more control over their healing. Texas families, whose capital appeals stretched on unpredictably, described the experience as drawn out and elusive. Not every family wants an execution pursued on their behalf, and those who oppose it often face pressure from prosecutors and victim advocates. A sentence of life without parole delivers a certain, permanent outcome and allows families to move forward without recurring court dates stretching across decades.

Standards of Decency Have Already Moved

The Eighth Amendment prohibits “cruel and unusual punishments.”15Congress.gov. U.S. Constitution – Eighth Amendment In 1958, the Supreme Court held that the phrase “must draw its meaning from the evolving standards of decency that mark the progress of a maturing society.”16Justia. Trop v. Dulles, 356 U.S. 86 (1958) Under that standard, the Court has already narrowed who can be executed. In 2002, it held that executing individuals with intellectual disabilities is unconstitutional.17Justia. Atkins v. Virginia, 536 U.S. 304 (2002) In 2005, it barred the execution of anyone who was under 18 at the time of the crime.18Justia. Roper v. Simmons, 543 U.S. 551 (2005)

More than 70 percent of countries worldwide have abolished the death penalty in law or practice. The UN Human Rights Office has called for universal abolition, citing the risk of executing innocent people and the lack of evidence that executions deter crime.19OHCHR. Death Penalty The United States is an outlier among democracies on this issue, and the arguments that once held the practice together have each failed under scrutiny.