Restrictive covenants are enforceable when they protect a legitimate interest and impose restrictions that are reasonable in scope, duration, and geographic reach. That basic test applies whether the covenant sits in a property deed, an employment contract, or a business sale agreement. Covenants that reach too far, last too long, or collide with federal or state law get struck down, rewritten by a court, or ignored.
Whether yours holds up depends on which type of covenant it is, what state you’re in, and how carefully it was drafted.
The Four Questions Courts Ask
Jurisdictions phrase it differently, but every court evaluating a restrictive covenant works through roughly the same four questions. A covenant has to satisfy all of them.
Does it protect a legitimate interest? The covenant has to shield something real. For an employer, that means trade secrets, proprietary methods, or established customer relationships. For a homeowners association, it means preserving property values and neighborhood character. A covenant that exists only to punish someone or to suppress competition serves no legitimate purpose and won’t be enforced.
Is the geography reasonable? A non-compete covering the metro area where the employer actually does business is likely enforceable. One that bars a former employee from working anywhere in the country usually is not. For real estate covenants, the geography is inherently limited to the subdivision or planned community.
Is the duration reasonable? Employment non-competes in the range of six months to two years are most commonly upheld, with the acceptable length depending on the industry and the employee’s access to sensitive information. Business sale covenants regularly survive at three to five years. A ten-year restriction of any kind draws heavy skepticism.
Is the activity scope reasonable? The restriction cannot sweep broader than necessary. A non-compete that prevents a software engineer from working as a restaurant manager restricts far more than needed to protect the employer. The covenant should target the specific work that could cause competitive harm, not the person’s entire career.
Courts weigh these together rather than in isolation. A wide geographic reach may survive if the duration is short and the activity scope is narrow. The question is whether the restriction, taken as a whole, goes further than necessary.
Enforceability by Covenant Type
Real Estate Covenants
Deed restrictions and HOA CC&Rs typically regulate things like fence height, exterior paint colors, RV parking, or commercial activity in a residential neighborhood. These covenants “run with the land,” binding not just the original parties but every future owner. For that to work, the covenant must have been intended to bind successors, must relate directly to the use of the land, and must be recorded in the public land records.
Recording matters because once a covenant is in the public records, every later purchaser is deemed to have constructive notice. You’re bound even if your deed never mentions the restriction and your agent never flagged it. The law treats you as though you knew, because a title search would have found it.
Employment Covenants
Employment agreements use three main types of restrictive covenants: non-competes (barring work for a competitor), non-solicitation clauses (barring contact with former clients or recruiting of former colleagues), and non-disclosure agreements (barring the sharing of confidential information). Non-competes draw the most scrutiny because they directly limit a person’s ability to earn a living.
There is no federal ban on non-competes. The FTC attempted a nationwide ban in 2024, but the rule was vacated in court, and on February 12, 2026, the FTC removed the Non-Compete Clause Rule from the Code of Federal Regulations.1Federal Register. Revision of the Negative Option Rule, Withdrawal of the CARS Rule, Removal of the Non-Compete Rule The agency retains authority under Section 5 of the FTC Act to challenge specific agreements it considers unfair methods of competition, but it does so case by case.2Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 15 USC 45 – Unfair Methods of Competition Unlawful
So enforceability of your non-compete depends almost entirely on state law. Four states ban non-competes in employment outright. More than thirty others impose restrictions such as income thresholds, meaning the covenant only applies to employees above a specified salary, or durational caps. The state where you work is the first thing to check.
Business Sale Covenants
When someone buys a business, the buyer typically requires the seller to sign a covenant not to compete. Courts give these covenants significantly more latitude than employment non-competes. The reasoning: the seller voluntarily chose to sell, was compensated for the goodwill, and shouldn’t be allowed to take it back by opening a rival shop across the street. Three-to-five-year restrictions with broad geographic reach are routinely upheld here, even though the same terms in an employment agreement would likely fail.
Covenants Courts Will Not Enforce No Matter What
Discriminatory Property Restrictions
Older property deeds across the country still contain covenants prohibiting sales based on race or religion. In 1948, the Supreme Court held in Shelley v. Kraemer that judicial enforcement of racially restrictive covenants violated the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment.3Justia. Shelley v Kraemer, 334 US 1 (1948) The Fair Housing Act of 1968 made it illegal to refuse to sell or rent a dwelling based on race, color, religion, sex, familial status, or national origin.4Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 42 USC 3604 – Discrimination in the Sale or Rental of Housing and Other Prohibited Practices These covenants still appear in some deeds. They are legally void.
HOA Rules Preempted by Federal Law
The FCC’s Over-the-Air Reception Devices rule prohibits private covenants, HOA rules, and local regulations from impairing the installation or use of satellite dishes one meter or less in diameter, and certain antennas, on property within the owner’s exclusive use.5eCFR. 47 CFR 1.4000 – Restrictions Impairing Reception of Television Broadcast Signals, Direct Broadcast Satellite Services, or Multichannel Multipoint Distribution Services An HOA can still enforce restrictions grounded in safety or historic preservation, but a blanket ban on satellite dishes is unenforceable. Many states have solar access laws that similarly limit HOA authority over solar panels, though the protections vary.
Restraints That Leave Someone Unable to Work
Even a narrowly drawn non-compete can fall if enforcing it would effectively prevent someone from working at all. Courts are especially reluctant to enforce covenants against lower-wage workers, employees with specialized skills that only apply in one industry, or workers in fields where the employer’s “trade secrets” are really general industry knowledge.
What Happens When a Covenant Is Overbroad
When a court decides a covenant goes too far, three things can happen depending on the state.
- Reformation. Most states let courts rewrite the covenant and enforce the revised version. A judge might cut a five-year, nationwide non-compete down to one year within a single metro area.
- Blue pencil. A smaller group of states lets courts strike unreasonable language but not add new wording. If the remaining text still makes sense, the court enforces what’s left. If not, the covenant fails.
- Red pencil. A handful of states take an all-or-nothing approach. If any part of the covenant is unreasonable, the whole thing is void.
The reformation approach creates an incentive problem worth knowing about. When employers know courts will trim an overbroad covenant down to something workable, there’s little downside to drafting aggressively. The worst outcome is ending up with what the employer should have written in the first place. Red-pencil states flip that incentive: overreach costs the covenant entirely.
What Enforcement Actually Looks Like
If the covenant holds up, the consequences come fast.
For employment covenants, the former employer’s first move is usually an injunction, a court order requiring you to stop the violating activity. Employers often request a temporary restraining order to halt the breach within days, before any full hearing. Beyond the injunction, the employer can sue for monetary damages, including lost profits attributable to the breach. Some agreements include liquidated damages clauses that specify a dollar amount per violation. Many contracts also contain a prevailing-party attorney fee provision, meaning the loser pays the winner’s legal bills.
For HOA covenants, enforcement generally starts with a written notice and a chance to fix the problem. Ignored notices lead to fines, and in most communities unpaid fines can become a lien on the property. If that fails, the HOA’s remaining option is a lawsuit seeking a court order compelling compliance. Whether the HOA can recover its legal costs depends on what the CC&Rs say about fee-shifting; some clearly authorize recovery of attorney fees, others are vague or require mediation first.
When a Covenant Loses Its Force
A covenant that was once enforceable can stop being enforceable. The main ways that happens:
- Expiration. Many real estate covenants include a sunset date, often 20 to 30 years. Employment non-competes expire by their own terms, typically within a few years.
- Mutual agreement. The affected parties can release or modify the covenant. In an HOA, this usually requires a membership vote at the threshold set by the CC&Rs.
- Abandonment. A covenant that has been widely and consistently ignored may be deemed abandoned. An HOA that never enforced its ban on front-yard fences for fifteen years will struggle to enforce it against one homeowner now. The test is a pattern of non-enforcement, not isolated exceptions.
- Laches. Related but distinct: laches applies when a party waited so long to enforce the covenant that the delay caused real harm to the other side. Mere passage of time isn’t enough; the person claiming laches has to show prejudice, such as money spent on improvements they wouldn’t have made had the covenant been enforced earlier.
- Changed circumstances. A court can refuse to enforce a real estate covenant when conditions have changed so dramatically that the restriction no longer serves its original purpose. A residential-only restriction makes little sense when the surrounding area has been rezoned commercial.
- Court order. A court can declare a covenant void if it is illegal, unconscionable, or fundamentally unfair under current circumstances.
If you’re trying to figure out whether the covenant hanging over you will actually be enforced, work the four questions first, then check your state’s law, and then look at whether any of these ending conditions apply. A covenant that passes the first two tests but has been ignored by everyone for a decade is a very different problem from one the other side has been enforcing consistently.