Aretha Franklin Estate Settlement: Wills, Jury Verdict, and IRS Deal

The Aretha Franklin estate settlement took five years to resolve after the singer died on August 16, 2018, without a formally drafted will. A six-person Michigan jury validated a handwritten 2014 will found under a couch cushion in her Bloomfield Hills home, the estate paid off nearly $8 million in federal tax debt, and in late 2023 a probate judge distributed her real estate holdings among her four sons: Clarence, Edward, Ted White II, and Kecalf Franklin.¹

Franklin’s estate was valued at roughly $80 million at her death.² For nine months, the case looked like a straightforward intestacy matter, with assets set to divide equally among the four sons under Michigan law. Then, in May 2019, Franklin’s niece Sabrina Owens found three handwritten documents in Franklin’s home. Two were dated 2010 and stored in a locked cabinet. The third, dated 2014, was tucked inside a spiral notebook wedged under a sofa cushion.³

The Two Handwritten Wills

Michigan recognizes holographic wills, meaning a handwritten document can be legally valid if the material portions are in the person’s own handwriting, it is signed, and it is dated. Neither of Franklin’s documents had been witnessed or prepared by an attorney, but both potentially met those requirements.⁴

Both documents said Franklin’s four sons would share income from her music royalties and copyrights, and both required ongoing financial support for Clarence Franklin, who has schizophrenia and lives under legal guardianship.⁵ But the two versions diverged on the details that mattered most:

The 2010 document named Ted White II and Sabrina Owens as co-executors. The 2014 document crossed out Ted’s name and replaced him with Kecalf Franklin.⁶
The 2010 version required Kecalf and Edward to earn a business degree or certificate before they could inherit. The 2014 version dropped that condition.¹
The 2014 document specifically left Franklin’s primary residence in Bloomfield Hills, along with its furnishings and cars, to Kecalf and his children. The 2010 version had no such bequest.⁴

The sons split along those lines. Ted White II argued the 2010 document should govern because it had been kept under lock and key, was notarized, and was signed multiple times. He called the 2014 notebook “merely a draft.” Kecalf and Edward backed the 2014 version as their mother’s most recent wishes. Clarence, living in a group home under guardianship, did not participate in the litigation.⁷

The 2023 Jury Verdict

The trial began on July 10, 2023, in Oakland County Probate Court before Judge Jennifer Callaghan and lasted two days.⁸ On July 11, the six-person jury ruled that the 2014 document was a valid will under Michigan law and superseded the 2010 version. The decision turned on a basic principle: when two wills are inconsistent, the more recent one generally revokes the earlier one. The jury accepted that Franklin’s name written at the bottom of the 2014 document, with a smiley face drawn inside the letter “A,” was a valid signature.⁹ The court also rejected any legal effect for voicemail messages in which Franklin had discussed yet another plan for her estate.⁶

After the verdict, Kecalf Franklin told reporters: “I’m very, very happy. I just wanted my mother’s wishes to be adhered to.”⁵

How the Properties Were Divided

On November 28, 2023, Judge Callaghan issued a ruling distributing Franklin’s real estate holdings under the terms of the 2014 will:

Kecalf Franklin received the Bloomfield Hills home, described as the estate’s “crown jewel,” which had been valued at $1.1 million in 2018.¹⁰
Ted White II was awarded a house in Detroit, though the estate had already sold that property for $300,000 before the ruling.
Edward Franklin received another property under the 2014 will, though the address was not publicly detailed.¹¹
A fourth property, valued at more than $1 million, was to be sold with proceeds split equally among the four sons, because the 2014 will did not clearly name a recipient.

The judge did not issue a final ruling on music assets at that time, though the will appeared to indicate the sons would share royalty income. A status conference on remaining issues was scheduled for January 2024.¹¹

The $7.8 Million IRS Settlement

Running alongside the will fight was a large tax bill. The IRS contended Franklin had accumulated nearly $8 million in unpaid federal income taxes, penalties, and interest over the seven years before her death.¹²

In April 2021, the estate reached an agreement with the IRS on a $7.8 million claim, though roughly $3 million had already been paid at the end of 2018. The plan directed an initial $800,000 payment and then 45% of all future estate revenue toward the remaining balance, with another 40% held in escrow for other state and federal taxes and 15% covering administrative costs. Each son also received $50,000 within five days of the court’s approval.¹³ Estate income came from music royalties, licensing, and Hollywood productions, including the Jennifer Hudson biopic “Respect.” The estate cleared the remaining tax debt with a cashier’s check delivered to the IRS in July 2022.¹²

Why It Took Five Years

The Franklin case has become a widely cited example of what informal estate planning costs. Years of legal fees, probate expenses, and tax payments substantially reduced what remained of the $80 million estate for her heirs.²

Franklin’s handwritten notes were ambiguous, sometimes barely legible, and left major questions unanswered. They didn’t clearly address specific assets, didn’t create a properly structured trust for Clarence’s special needs care, and didn’t account for the tax consequences of a large and complex estate. Because the documents were contested, everything played out publicly through probate rather than privately through a trust. The 2010 will had tried to set up a special needs account for Clarence with a $750 weekly allowance and a separate bank account funded at up to $2,000 or $2,500 per month, but estate planning professionals have questioned whether those provisions would have created a valid trust or could have put Clarence’s government benefits at risk.⁴

The probate case, filed under number 2018-0000384527-DA, ran from Franklin’s death in August 2018 through the property distribution rulings in late 2023. Resolving it required a change of personal representative, a $7.8 million IRS settlement, a jury trial, and multiple judicial hearings before her sons finally received clear title to their inheritance.¹⁴

1
NPR. Aretha Franklin Will Estate Sons Inheritance
2
Forbes. Aretha Franklin Estate Settles IRS Tax Claims
3
VOA News. Handwritten Wills Found in Aretha Franklin’s Home
4
AARP. Aretha Franklin Estate Competing Wills Court Case
5
People. All About Aretha Franklin’s Children
6
Justia Verdict. The Struggle Over Aretha Franklin’s Estate
7
Michigan Public. Aretha Franklin’s Sons Battle Over Handwritten Wills 5 Years After Her Death
8
BBC. Aretha Franklin Will Ruling
9
The Conversation. Why a Handwritten Will Found in Aretha Franklin’s Couch Got R-E-S-P-E-C-T From a Jury
10
WDET. Judge Awards Real Estate to Aretha Franklin’s Sons Citing Handwritten Will
11
NPR. Judge Awards Aretha Franklin Properties to Sons Per Handwritten Will
12
Detroit Free Press. Aretha Franklin’s Tax Debt Paid by Estate
13
The New York Times. Aretha Franklin Taxes
14
Axios Detroit. Trial Over Aretha Franklin Estate