Can You Sue Someone for Cheating? Heart Balm Suits, Divorce, and STDs

You can sue someone for cheating, but the available claims are narrow and depend on where you live. A direct civil lawsuit against your spouse’s lover is only possible in roughly six states that still recognize old “heart balm” torts. Everywhere else, your options are limited to claims that happen to arise from the affair, such as intentional infliction of emotional distress, a personal injury suit for a transmitted disease, or raising the infidelity inside a divorce case to shift property division or alimony. Some couples also build financial consequences into a prenuptial or postnuptial agreement, though courts do not always enforce them.

Suing the Third Party in Heart Balm States

About six states still allow a betrayed spouse to file a civil lawsuit directly against the person their husband or wife had an affair with. Most states abolished these claims during the twentieth century, and the trend continues. Where the claims survive, they come in two forms.

Alienation of affection targets the third party for deliberately destroying the love and companionship in a marriage. You have to prove three things: that your marriage had genuine love and affection, that the love was destroyed, and that the third party’s conduct caused the destruction.

Criminal conversation is a civil claim despite the name. You only need to show a valid marriage existed and that the third party had sexual intercourse with your spouse during that marriage. You do not have to prove the marriage was happy or that any affection was lost. The sexual act itself is the basis of the claim.

Jury awards vary enormously, from modest judgments to verdicts in the millions. Timing is strict: statutes of limitations in these states typically run around three years from the last act of interference, and waiting past the deadline bars the claim regardless of how strong the evidence is.

Suing for Emotional Distress

Intentional infliction of emotional distress is available in every state, including those that have abolished heart balm torts. The threshold is deliberately high. You must prove the defendant’s behavior was so extreme and outrageous that it goes beyond what a reasonable person would consider tolerable.

An affair by itself almost never clears that bar. Courts look for something more: a sustained campaign of cruelty, a cheating partner openly flaunting the affair in front of children, a paramour sending threatening or taunting messages, or deliberate efforts to humiliate the betrayed spouse publicly. The conduct has to be the kind that would shock the conscience of an ordinary person.

You also need to show you suffered severe emotional harm as a direct result. That usually means therapist records, a psychologist’s diagnosis, or documentation of treatment for conditions such as depression, anxiety, or post-traumatic stress. Without that kind of evidence, courts rarely find the distress severe enough to compensate.

Suing Over an STD You Caught

If your partner contracted a sexually transmitted disease during an affair and passed it to you, you have a personal injury claim that stands on its own. It does not depend on living in a heart balm state, and it is recognized broadly.

Two legal theories apply. Under a negligence theory, your partner knew or should have known about the infection and failed to take reasonable precautions. This is the more common theory and covers careless rather than deliberate conduct. Under a battery theory, your partner knew about the infection and had sexual contact with you without disclosing it. Because you would not have consented to contact had you known, courts treat the act as a harmful touching done on purpose.

Damages can be substantial for permanent conditions such as herpes or HIV. Compensation covers past and future medical expenses, lost wages, pain and suffering, and the psychological impact of living with a chronic illness. These cases rely heavily on medical records: when you were tested, when the infection appeared, and evidence tying the defendant to the transmission timeline.

Using Infidelity Against a Cheating Spouse in Divorce

The most widely available way to get financial accountability for cheating is during the divorce itself. Even in no-fault states, infidelity can affect how property is divided and whether spousal support is awarded.

Dissipation of Marital Assets

When a spouse spends shared money on an affair — gifts, hotel rooms, trips, dinners — a court can treat those expenditures as a dissipation of marital assets. You must show the spending was intentional and had nothing to do with the marriage. Careless spending or poor financial judgment generally does not qualify.

The initial burden is on you to show that substantial marital funds went to non-marital purposes. Once you make that showing, the burden shifts to your spouse to prove the spending was legitimate. Building the case usually means working through bank statements, credit card records, and other financial documents to trace exactly where the money went.

When a court finds dissipation, the typical remedy is an offset in the property division. If your spouse spent $30,000 on a paramour, the judge might award you a larger share of the remaining assets to make up for the diverted funds. The goal is to restore the marital estate to what it would have looked like without the diversion.

Alimony Adjustments

A significant number of states consider marital fault, including adultery, when deciding spousal support. The consequences range from a modest adjustment in the amount to a complete bar. In some states, a spouse who committed adultery cannot receive alimony at all, no matter the financial need or the length of the marriage. In others, the court has discretion to raise or lower support based on the circumstances. Rules vary widely by state.

Enforcing an Infidelity Clause in a Prenup or Postnup

Some couples address cheating in advance through infidelity penalty clauses, sometimes called lifestyle clauses, in a prenuptial or postnuptial agreement. These provisions spell out specific financial consequences for adultery: a lump-sum payment, a larger share of assets, or forfeiture of certain property.

Enforcement is unpredictable. Some jurisdictions treat these as valid contractual terms both parties agreed to voluntarily. Others refuse to enforce them, viewing financial penalties for sexual behavior as contrary to public policy or incompatible with no-fault divorce. In at least one notable case, an appellate court struck down an infidelity fine because it violated the state’s public policy against litigating marital fault. Some courts have gone further, finding that an unenforceable lifestyle clause could undermine the validity of the entire prenuptial agreement.

For these clauses to have the best chance of holding up, both parties should have independent legal representation when signing, the financial terms should be proportional rather than punitive, and both parties should fully disclose their assets. Even with those precautions, enforcement is never guaranteed.

How You Gather Evidence Can Backfire

Proving infidelity requires evidence, and how you collect it matters as much as what it shows. Illegal collection can expose you to criminal charges or civil liability, and courts may refuse to admit the evidence.

Placing a GPS tracker on a spouse’s vehicle is restricted or prohibited in many states. At least 26 states and the District of Columbia have laws on the private use of location tracking devices, and at least nine specifically prohibit installing a tracker on a vehicle without the owner’s consent.1National Conference of State Legislatures. Private Use of Location Tracking Devices: State Statutes Penalties range from misdemeanor charges to coverage under stalking statutes.

Recording conversations is similarly restricted. Federal law generally prohibits intercepting someone else’s phone calls or private conversations. An exception applies if you are a party to the conversation, so you can usually record your own calls, but secretly recording a conversation between your spouse and a third party violates the federal Wiretap Act.2Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 18 U.S. Code 2511 – Interception and Disclosure of Wire, Oral, or Electronic Communications Prohibited Several states add their own restrictions, including all-party consent rules.

Logging into a spouse’s email, social media, or messaging accounts without permission can violate the federal Stored Communications Act, even if you know the password. The law applies regardless of marital status. A first offense can carry up to five years in prison if done for a tortious or malicious purpose, and subsequent offenses up to ten.3Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 18 U.S. Code 2701 – Unlawful Access to Stored Communications

The safest route is to work with a family law attorney familiar with the privacy laws in your state. In some cases, a licensed private investigator or the discovery process during litigation is the only lawful way to get the evidence you need.

Taxes on What You Recover

If you win or settle, the federal tax treatment depends on what the money is paid for. Damages received for personal physical injuries or physical sickness, such as compensation for contracting an STD, are excluded from gross income under federal tax law.4Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 26 U.S. Code 104 – Compensation for Injuries or Sickness The exclusion covers both lump-sum and periodic payments tied to a physical condition.

Awards for non-physical harm are taxable as ordinary income. That includes alienation of affection recoveries, emotional distress awards without a physical injury, and punitive damages. A narrow exception: if a settlement for emotional distress is used to pay medical expenses related to that distress, such as therapy costs, the portion covering those expenses may be excludable, provided you did not already deduct them on a prior tax return.5Internal Revenue Service. Tax Implications of Settlements and Judgments

Because the tax treatment can shift how much you actually keep, the settlement agreement should clearly allocate damages between physical and non-physical categories. Running the numbers with a tax professional before signing helps you understand the after-tax value of what you are agreeing to.