Carotid Restraints: Legal Status and Use-of-Force Limits

Laws on carotid restraints vary sharply by jurisdiction, but the common thread is this: almost every agency that still allows the technique treats it as deadly force, meaning an officer can only use it when someone faces an imminent threat of death or serious injury. Federal Department of Justice officers are barred from using it below that threshold by internal policy. A growing number of states have gone further, banning the technique outright or writing criminal penalties into their codes for officers who apply it unlawfully.

A carotid restraint compresses the arteries on the sides of the neck to temporarily reduce blood flow to the brain. That is legally and medically distinct from a chokehold, which applies pressure to the throat or windpipe to restrict breathing. Most policies that address one address both, and most prohibit both outside of deadly-force situations.

When Officers Can Legally Use a Carotid Restraint

Every use of force by a police officer has to satisfy the Fourth Amendment. The Supreme Court set the standard in Graham v. Connor, holding that excessive force claims during arrests and investigatory stops are judged by “objective reasonableness” from the perspective of a reasonable officer on the scene, without the benefit of hindsight.1Justia. Graham v. Connor, 490 U.S. 386 (1989)

Courts look at three things:

  • How serious was the crime the officer was responding to?
  • Did the person pose an immediate threat to the officer or others?
  • Was the person actively resisting or trying to flee?

Because most agencies classify the carotid restraint as deadly force, the bar is higher than for ordinary control holds. Tennessee v. Garner established that deadly force cannot be used to prevent escape unless the officer has probable cause to believe the suspect poses a significant threat of death or serious physical injury to the officer or others.2Justia. Tennessee v. Garner, 471 U.S. 1 (1985) An officer who applies a carotid restraint to subdue someone resisting a misdemeanor arrest, where no weapon is involved and no one is in physical danger, will have a hard time defending that choice.

Justification also has a time limit. Once the threat is neutralized or the subject stops resisting, continuing to apply pressure is no longer defensible. Courts treat continued pressure after a suspect goes limp as a separate act, and it is often that act that turns a questionable force decision into a criminal one.

Federal Agents and DOJ Policy

In 2022, President Biden signed Executive Order 14074, directing all federal law enforcement agencies to ban chokeholds and carotid restraints unless deadly force was legally justified. President Trump rescinded that order on January 20, 2025.3Congress.gov. Trump Administration Deactivates the National Law Enforcement Accountability Database

The prohibition itself still stands at DOJ, through a different mechanism. The Department’s internal use-of-force policy, updated in January 2025, bans both chokeholds and carotid restraints for DOJ law enforcement and correctional officers unless the deadly-force standard is met. The policy defines a chokehold as pressure on the throat or windpipe to restrict breathing and a carotid restraint as restricting blood flow to the brain to cause temporary unconsciousness. Both are explicitly prohibited below the deadly-force threshold.4United States Department of Justice. Department of Justice Policy On Use Of Force

So federal agents under DOJ authority, which includes the FBI and DEA, remain barred from using carotid restraints in routine encounters. Whether that policy will be loosened in the future is an open question, but the internal ban currently holds.

State Laws on Carotid Restraints

State law is the controlling authority for local and municipal officers, and it is where most of the recent legal change has happened. Several states have enacted outright bans that prohibit any law enforcement agency within the state from authorizing the technique. Others have stopped short of a total ban but reclassified carotid restraints as deadly force in their penal codes, meaning officers can only apply the technique under the same narrow circumstances that would justify firing a weapon.

Some states have gone further and created criminal penalties aimed specifically at officers who use prohibited neck restraints. In those jurisdictions, an officer who applies a chokehold or similar restraint and causes serious injury or death can face felony prosecution under state law, separate from any federal charges. Other states have built in automatic investigation triggers: any time an officer uses a neck restraint, an independent review begins regardless of outcome.

No federal statute has filled the gap left by the rescission of EO 14074. The George Floyd Justice in Policing Act, which would have imposed a nationwide ban on chokeholds and created a federal use-of-force standard, was reintroduced in Congress in September 2025 but has not advanced beyond introduction.5Congress.gov. H.R.5361 – George Floyd Justice in Policing Act of 2025

What Happens to an Officer Who Misuses a Carotid Restraint

A person injured by an unauthorized carotid restraint has two main legal avenues, and the officer involved has three categories of exposure: civil liability, criminal prosecution, and loss of their law enforcement certification.

Civil Lawsuits Under Section 1983

The primary vehicle for civil claims is 42 U.S.C. § 1983, which allows anyone deprived of a constitutional right by someone acting under government authority to sue for damages. An officer who applies a carotid restraint without legal justification can be sued personally for medical bills, lost income, and pain and suffering. Courts can also award punitive damages against officers whose conduct showed reckless indifference to someone’s rights.6Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 42 USC 1983 – Civil Action for Deprivation of Rights

The biggest obstacle is qualified immunity. Government officials are shielded from civil liability unless the right they violated was “clearly established” at the time, meaning either a prior decision with very similar facts, or circumstances so obvious that no reasonable officer could have believed the force was lawful. This is where many excessive force cases stall. If no prior case in the relevant circuit involved a carotid restraint under comparable conditions, the officer may walk away from the lawsuit regardless of what happened to the plaintiff.

Federal Criminal Charges Under Section 242

When an officer’s conduct crosses from excessive into willful, the federal government can bring criminal charges under 18 U.S.C. § 242. The statute makes it a crime for anyone acting under color of law to willfully deprive a person of their constitutional rights.7Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 18 USC 242 – Deprivation of Rights Under Color of Law Penalties scale with the harm caused:

  • No bodily injury: up to one year in prison, a fine, or both.
  • Bodily injury, or use of a dangerous weapon: up to ten years in prison, a fine, or both.
  • Death: any term of years, life imprisonment, or the death penalty.8U.S. Department of Justice. Deprivation of Rights Under Color of Law

Prosecutions under § 242 are relatively rare because willfulness is hard to prove. Prosecutors have to show more than negligence or poor judgment; they must demonstrate the officer knew the conduct was unlawful and acted anyway. Applying a carotid restraint in a jurisdiction that has explicitly banned the technique and trained officers on the ban makes that argument considerably easier.

Loss of Certification

Even officers who avoid conviction can lose the credential that allows them to work in law enforcement. Most states empower a standards board or training commission to revoke an officer’s certification for serious misconduct, including unjustified use of excessive or deadly force, failure to intervene when a colleague uses unlawful force, and tampering with body camera evidence.

The trend is toward broader grounds and fewer escape routes. Some states now require mandatory decertification when an officer pleads guilty to an unlawful use of force resulting in injury or death, or when an internal investigation reaches the same conclusion. Others mandate decertification if an officer resigns or retires while under investigation, closing a loophole that historically let problem officers quietly move to a new department. Revocation actions are tracked in the National Decertification Index, which agencies consult during pre-hire background checks.9IADLEST. National Decertification Index

Officers Who Stand By Face Liability Too

Every federal circuit court recognizes a duty to intervene when an officer witnesses a fellow officer using excessive force. If you watch a constitutional violation happen and you have a realistic opportunity to stop it, doing nothing makes you liable too.

Three elements determine whether an officer breached the duty: the officer had reason to know excessive force was being used, the officer had a realistic opportunity to intervene, and the officer could have taken reasonable steps to prevent the harm. Officers who meet all three can be held personally liable under § 1983 even if they never touched the subject.6Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 42 USC 1983 – Civil Action for Deprivation of Rights

A growing number of states have written the duty to intervene into statute, with consequences that reach beyond civil damages. Some require decertification for officers who fail to stop a colleague’s unlawful force. Others have created state criminal penalties. DOJ’s internal policy requires all department officers to be trained in the duty and to act on it.4United States Department of Justice. Department of Justice Policy On Use Of Force

Medical Care and Reporting Are Not Optional

When a carotid restraint is applied, department policies generally require officers to call emergency medical services immediately and to monitor breathing and pulse continuously until paramedics arrive. Medical evaluation is particularly urgent if the subject lost consciousness, because loss of consciousness can mask developing complications, including delayed respiratory failure and injuries to the neck’s vascular and airway structures.

The risk does not end when the hold is released. A restrained person left face-down after a struggle faces a serious risk of positional asphyxia. Federal guidance is direct: as soon as someone is handcuffed, get them off their stomach and onto their side or into a seated position. Do not sit on their back, do not tie handcuffs to ankle restraints, and do not transport them face-down.10Office of Justice Programs. Positional Asphyxia – Sudden Death

A detailed use-of-force report is required after any application. The officer must document what they did, the threat that justified the technique, and the subject’s condition throughout the encounter. A supervisor typically responds to the scene and reviews body-worn camera footage. Officers who fail to report a neck restraint application, or who submit incomplete or misleading reports, face separate discipline on top of any consequences for the restraint itself.