The criminalization of homelessness refers to the network of local ordinances and enforcement practices that punish people for sleeping, sitting, resting, panhandling, living in vehicles, or storing belongings in public space. After the Supreme Court’s June 2024 decision in City of Grants Pass v. Johnson, cities have broader authority to enforce these laws than at any point in recent decades, and more than 260 new anti-camping and anti-sleeping ordinances passed in the year that followed. Penalties start with fines and move quickly to misdemeanor charges, jail time, and a criminal record that makes exiting homelessness harder.
What Conduct Local Laws Target
Camping in public is the most common target. About a third of surveyed cities ban it citywide, and roughly half prohibit it in specific locations like parks, sidewalks, and areas near government buildings. The definition is broader than most people assume. Placing a sleeping bag on the ground, wrapping yourself in a blanket, or lying down with a pillow can be enough to trigger a violation, because many local codes define camping as arranging any bedding or shelter material for overnight use.
Sit-lie ordinances prohibit sitting or lying on sidewalks, usually during daytime business hours and usually in downtown commercial corridors. They appear in nearly half of surveyed cities. Resting in a visible public area during the day becomes a citable offense.
Panhandling restrictions are widespread. About a quarter of cities ban soliciting money citywide, and roughly six in ten restrict it near ATMs, transit stops, highway ramps, or similar locations. Because these ordinances regulate speech based on its content, they raise First Amendment problems, particularly after the Supreme Court’s 2015 decision in Reed v. Town of Gilbert tightened the rules on content-based restrictions.
Vehicle residency bans affect a large share of the unhoused population. Nearly four in ten surveyed cities prohibit sleeping or living in a vehicle, and many others ban overnight parking in designated zones. These rules target people who use cars, vans, or RVs as their primary shelter, and Fourth Amendment protections are weaker for vehicles than for fixed residences.
Storing personal belongings in public is also heavily regulated. Clothing, medication, identification, and survival gear kept in bags or carts on sidewalks are frequently classified as obstructions or public nuisances. Property that sits in one spot for more than a few hours may be tagged for removal. Losing identification during one of these removals can set a person back months in efforts to access services, apply for housing, or prove benefit eligibility.
How Grants Pass Changed the Legal Baseline
For decades, the central constitutional question was whether punishing someone for sleeping outside, when they had nowhere else to go, amounted to punishing them for being homeless. The Eighth Amendment’s ban on cruel and unusual punishment framed the answer.
In Robinson v. California (1962), the Supreme Court struck down a state law making it a crime to be addicted to narcotics, holding that imprisoning someone for a condition rather than an act was cruel and unusual.1Justia. Robinson v. California, 370 U.S. 660 (1962) That “status doctrine” became the backbone of challenges to homelessness ordinances. In 2018, the Ninth Circuit applied it directly in Martin v. City of Boise, ruling that a city cannot prosecute homeless individuals for sleeping outdoors on public property when no shelter is available to them.2Justia. Martin v. City of Boise, No. 15-35845 (9th Cir. 2018) As long as a jurisdiction had more homeless people than shelter beds, enforcing camping bans against those people was unconstitutional across the nine western states in the circuit.
That framework collapsed on June 28, 2024. In a 6-3 ruling in City of Grants Pass, Oregon v. Johnson, the Supreme Court held that enforcing generally applicable camping laws does not constitute cruel and unusual punishment, even against people with no access to shelter.3Supreme Court of the United States. City of Grants Pass, Oregon v. Johnson Justice Gorsuch, writing for the majority, reasoned that the Cruel and Unusual Punishments Clause addresses what kind of punishment can be imposed after a conviction, not whether the government may criminalize a behavior in the first place. Questions about what counts as involuntary homelessness or when a shelter is practically available were, in the Court’s view, policy decisions for legislators.
The practical consequence is large. Cities no longer need to demonstrate that shelter beds are available before enforcing camping or sleeping bans. A law that prohibits everyone from pitching a tent in a public park is treated as constitutional because it targets conduct rather than status, regardless of whether the person has any alternative. Challenges based on the Eighth Amendment’s cruel and unusual punishment clause now face a much steeper climb.
Legal Protections That Still Apply
Grants Pass removed the broadest Eighth Amendment shield, but it did not eliminate every constitutional constraint. Several legal theories remain, and some are gaining attention precisely because the camping-ban path is now closed.
Excessive Fines
The Eighth Amendment contains a separate clause prohibiting excessive fines, and the Supreme Court did not address it in Grants Pass. Justice Sotomayor’s dissent flagged this as a viable avenue for future challenges, noting that the district court had already found Grants Pass’s fines “grossly disproportionate to the gravity of the offense” of sleeping outside.3Supreme Court of the United States. City of Grants Pass, Oregon v. Johnson The Court’s 2019 decision in Timbs v. Indiana confirmed that the Excessive Fines Clause applies to state and local governments.4Supreme Court of the United States. Timbs v. Indiana The test, drawn from United States v. Bajakajian, asks whether a fine is grossly disproportionate to the seriousness of the offense. Fining someone hundreds of dollars for sleeping when they have no income and no shelter is the kind of disproportion the clause was designed to address.
First Amendment Protections for Solicitation
Panhandling is speech, and ordinances that single it out must survive constitutional scrutiny. Laws specifically banning requests for money are content-based because they target speech based on its message, and content-based restrictions face strict scrutiny, meaning the government must show the law is narrowly tailored to a compelling interest. Many older panhandling bans were written before this standard tightened and are vulnerable to challenge. Content-neutral time, place, and manner rules that apply to all public communication near roadways tend to fare better.
Americans with Disabilities Act
A significant share of the unhoused population lives with physical or mental disabilities, and the ADA applies to every action a city government takes. Under federal law, no qualified person with a disability can be excluded from or denied the benefits of any public entity’s services, programs, or activities because of that disability.5Office of the Law Revision Counsel. United States Code Title 42 – 12132 Implementing regulations require public entities to make reasonable modifications to their policies when necessary to avoid disability discrimination, unless doing so would fundamentally alter the program.6ADA.gov. Americans with Disabilities Act Title II Regulations In encampment removals, that can mean additional notice, accessible transportation, or accommodations for people with mobility limitations. Safety justifications must be based on actual risks, not stereotypes.
Fourth Amendment Property Protections
The Fourth Amendment protects people from unreasonable government seizure of their property, and that protection reaches unhoused individuals. In Lavan v. City of Los Angeles, the Ninth Circuit held that the Fourth and Fourteenth Amendments protect homeless people from government seizure and summary destruction of their unabandoned but temporarily unattended personal property.7United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit. Lavan v. City of Los Angeles The court barred Los Angeles from seizing property on Skid Row unless officers had an objectively reasonable belief that it was abandoned, posed an immediate health or safety threat, or was evidence of a crime. Seized property had to be stored at least 90 days before disposal. A bag left on a sidewalk while someone uses a restroom is not abandoned, and destroying it without process violates the Constitution.
How Enforcement Escalates
Enforcement typically follows a predictable path that can move from a verbal warning to a criminal record within weeks.
It usually starts with a “move-along” order. An officer tells the person to leave immediately. Compliance ends the encounter, but there is often nowhere to go except somewhere the same conversation repeats. If the person does not move or returns, the next step is a written citation with a fine. Amounts vary widely, ranging from under $100 to several hundred dollars for a first offense. In Grants Pass itself, the fine for sleeping on a sidewalk or alleyway was $295, and repeat violations led to park bans and criminal trespassing charges.3Supreme Court of the United States. City of Grants Pass, Oregon v. Johnson
Repeat citations escalate to misdemeanor charges. A misdemeanor conviction for camping or trespassing can carry jail time and fines of $1,000 or more, and some cities impose escalating penalties for each subsequent offense. A misdemeanor record then creates barriers to housing applications, employment background checks, and benefit eligibility that persist long after any sentence is served.
Encampment Sweeps
Large-scale enforcement takes the form of encampment sweeps, where city crews dismantle camps and remove what is in the area. Notice requirements vary. Some federal court orders have required at least 48 hours’ written notice before any sweep, and seven days for large-scale operations. Other jurisdictions provide as little as 24 hours, or none. Property including clothing, medication, tents, identification, and legal paperwork may be collected and held, or destroyed if classified as a health hazard.
Fourteenth Amendment due process requires that cities not permanently destroy a person’s property without notice and an opportunity to reclaim it.7United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit. Lavan v. City of Los Angeles In practice, storage periods for seized property run from a few days to 90 days depending on the jurisdiction, and some cities charge administrative fees to reclaim belongings. For someone without income, those fees are often an insurmountable barrier, and losing an ID means losing the ability to apply for most forms of assistance.
The Cycle of Fines, Warrants, and Lost Housing
The collateral consequences of homelessness citations do more long-term damage than the initial penalties, because each enforcement action makes stabilization harder.
When someone cannot pay a fine, the court sets a hearing date. Missing that hearing, which is common for people without reliable transportation, a fixed mailing address, or a phone, produces a bench warrant for failure to appear. The next police encounter, even a routine one, can then lead to arrest. People experiencing homelessness are arrested at roughly 11 times the rate of housed individuals, and homelessness is between 7.5 and 11.3 times more prevalent among the jail population than among the general public.
Each arrest generates new court costs, new fines, and potentially new charges. A person who started with a $150 camping citation can accumulate thousands of dollars in fines and a string of misdemeanor convictions within months. That record follows them into every housing application. Most landlords and many subsidized housing programs run background checks, and a pattern of trespassing or public-order convictions is treated as a red flag even though the underlying conduct was sleeping outside. The feedback loop is tight: homelessness leads to citations, citations lead to warrants, warrants lead to arrests, arrests build a record, and the record blocks the housing that would end the cycle.
Federal Direction and State Follow-Through
Federal policy on criminalization has shifted sharply, and the current direction pushes cities toward enforcement.
In 2015, the Department of Justice filed a brief arguing that criminalizing sleeping in public when shelter is insufficient unconstitutionally punishes people for being homeless, and called the approach “poor public policy.”8Department of Justice. Justice Department Files Brief to Address the Criminalization of Homelessness That posture has reversed.
In July 2025, the White House issued an executive order titled “Ending Crime and Disorder on America’s Streets” that treats encampment enforcement as a federal priority. The order directs the Attorney General, along with the Secretaries of HUD, HHS, and Transportation, to give grant priority to jurisdictions that actively enforce prohibitions on urban camping, loitering, open drug use, and squatting. Federal law enforcement assistance funds are made available for encampment removal where state and local resources are deemed inadequate. The order also directs HUD to end support for “housing first” policies and encourages moving people with substance use disorders or serious mental illness into treatment, including through civil commitment where legally available.9The White House. Ending Crime and Disorder on Americas Streets
Even before that order, HUD’s FY 2024 and FY 2025 Continuum of Care competition awarded up to two points to communities that demonstrated strategies to prevent criminalization, including social services-led responses and minimized enforcement of public sleeping bans.10U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development. FY 2024 and FY 2025 Continuum of Care Competition and Renewal or Replacement of Youth Homeless Demonstration Program Grants How future competitions will reconcile that scoring with the executive order’s enforcement mandates is unresolved.
The combined effect of Grants Pass and the federal shift has been a wave of state legislation. States have passed standalone anti-camping laws, created large exclusion zones around schools and other facilities, authorized residents to withhold municipal taxes if local governments fail to clear encampments, and tied work requirements to homelessness-related penalties. The pace is not slowing.
Alternatives Cities Use
Criminalization is expensive. The U.S. Interagency Council on Homelessness has stated that approaches relying on criminal penalties cost roughly three times more than providing housing and services and do not reduce homelessness in the short or long term.11U.S. Interagency Council on Homelessness. 19 Strategies for Communities to Address Encampments Humanely and Effectively The daily cost of incarceration dwarfs the cost of supportive housing, sometimes by a factor of 20 or more.
Homeless courts are one direct alternative. These specialized sessions let people resolve outstanding citations and warrants by completing service activities instead of paying fines or serving jail time. Participants typically sign up through a service provider, complete a set of activities like treatment sessions or case management meetings, and present proof to a judge. Most cases are dismissed, which removes the warrants and record entries that block housing and employment. Sessions are often held at service provider locations to reduce barriers to attendance.
Some communities use co-responder models that pair law enforcement with social workers or mental health professionals during contacts with unhoused people. Others route encampment calls to outreach teams instead of police. Safe parking programs provide designated lots where people living in vehicles can stay overnight legally, often with access to restrooms and case management. These programs require working through local zoning and insurance questions, but they convert an illegal act into a service entry point.
Whether these alternatives expand or contract depends on local political will and the outcome of pending litigation under the Excessive Fines Clause and the other protections that survived Grants Pass. The rules governing where unhoused people can exist in public are more restrictive now than at any point in recent memory, and they continue to change.