Debra Hartmann: Affair, Insurance Plot, and Murder Conviction

Debra Hartmann is a Chicago-area woman convicted in December 1989 of orchestrating the 1982 murder of her husband, Werner Hartmann, a wealthy Northbrook stereo-business owner who was shot fourteen times in their home. Because no state murder charges were ever brought, the case was prosecuted federally as mail and wire fraud tied to a scheme to collect more than $800,000 in life insurance. A jury convicted Debra Hartmann, her lover John Scott Korabik, and an associate named Kenneth Kaenel. She received a 22-year federal prison sentence.¹

Who Werner Hartmann Was

Werner Hartmann was a 38-year-old German immigrant who ran a successful car stereo sales business in the northern suburbs of Chicago. He and Debra married in 1978 and lived expensively in Northbrook, with a second home in Deerfield and land in Barrington Hills. He had two daughters, Stephanie and Eva, from a previous marriage.²

Debra had worked as an exotic dancer and dance instructor before the marriage. She had dropped out of high school at fifteen, and her attorney later described a childhood marked by domestic violence.¹ Prosecutors told the jury she once said to Werner, “I married you for your money.”³

By late 1981 the marriage was collapsing. In December 1981, Debra reported to police that Werner had taken personal belongings worth over $127,000, including a diamond ring, a diamond necklace, and two fur coats. She filed for divorce in early January 1982 but abandoned the proceedings. Werner was talking about divorcing her himself and had begun moving jewelry, merchandise, and tools from his business to a home in Florida, which prosecutors read as preparation to leave and disinherit her.⁴

The Affair With John Korabik

In late 1981, Debra began an affair with John Scott Korabik Jr., a part-time tennis pro and gun-store clerk she met at Werner’s stereo store in Franklin Park.⁵ By January 1982, Debra was staying in a room shared with Korabik at his father’s home in Chicago. Kenneth Kaenel occupied a bedroom across the hall.⁶

According to prosecutors, Debra and Korabik began planning Werner’s killing in late 1981. The motive: collect the life insurance before Werner could finalize a divorce and cut her out of his estate.⁴

The Insurance Scheme

The financial side of the plot ran through Werner’s life insurance. In June 1981, Werner had bought a $150,000 double-indemnity policy. In March 1982, he applied for another $250,000 double-indemnity policy. Prosecutors alleged Debra forged Werner’s signature on the $150,000 policy, which would have paid $300,000 in the event of a violent death.⁴

In May 1982, Debra allegedly paid a $3,000 bribe to Prudential agent Harvey Loochtan to change the beneficiary on the $250,000 policy from Werner’s daughters to herself. Loochtan also advised Debra to make herself the policy “owner,” which would block Werner from altering the beneficiaries. When Werner later called Loochtan to request a beneficiary change, Loochtan did not send the form. He tipped off Debra instead. The Seventh Circuit later described that phone call as effectively signing Werner’s “death warrant.”⁷

The Murder

On the evening of June 8, 1982, Werner was shot to death in the couple’s Northbrook home. Prosecutors said the killer hid in a closet and waited for Werner to finish showering. When the water stopped, the gunman confronted him and fired four rounds into his back. As Werner spun from the impact, the shooter stood over him and fired ten more rounds into his face and head, fourteen bullets in total, from a MAC-10 machine pistol.⁴

The shooter tried to pick up the spent shell casings, then panicked and fled, apparently after hearing a noise. Running from the house he struck a tree and sprained his ankle. The murder weapon was never recovered and is believed to have been melted down or dumped in a lake.⁸

Debra Hartmann and Werner’s 14-year-old daughter Eva discovered the body around 4 a.m. on June 9. During the shooting itself, Debra had been at a nearby disco with Eva.³ Afterward, Korabik moved into the Northbrook home with Debra. In January 1984, Debra received a $450,000 settlement from Prudential; the government said she collected roughly $589,000 in total from two policies.⁹

How the Plot Was Built

Kenneth Kaenel, the man across the hall at Korabik’s father’s house, played an organizing role. In May 1982, Kaenel approached brothers Donald and Jeff Zorc and offered them $6,000 each to take part in the murder, with the money to come from the insurance payout. He scouted the Hartmann home with the Zorcs and bought walkie-talkies for the operation.¹⁰

The Zorc brothers backed out two days before the killing. Donald Zorc later testified that in the early hours of June 9, hours after the shooting, Kaenel arrived at the Zorc family home in Elmwood Park appearing “in a trance,” confessed to killing Werner, and asked the brothers for an alibi. Two days later, Zorc said, Kaenel showed off two gold necklaces he described as part of his payment from Debra. Zorc’s mother, Josephine, corroborated parts of the account.¹⁰

Who actually pulled the trigger stayed contested. The government’s main theory was that Korabik was the shooter, but Kaenel had separately admitted to others that he killed Werner, and the Seventh Circuit later noted that Kaenel had admitted to firing fourteen rounds, matching the forensic evidence.⁶ Four years after the murder, Kaenel tried to squeeze more money out of Debra, telling Donald Zorc she was spending the proceeds “very fast.”

The Case Goes Cold, Then Federal

For years, nothing happened. No murder charges were filed. The conspiracy came apart only when witnesses started cooperating with federal authorities: Donald Zorc began working with the government in 1986 and was granted immunity.¹⁰

In January 1989, a federal grand jury indicted Debra Hartmann, Korabik, and Kaenel on conspiracy and mail fraud counts tied to Werner’s death.¹¹ Murder is a state offense in Illinois, and no state charges were ever brought, so the federal fraud case was the only criminal prosecution to come out of the killing.³

The Trial

The case went to U.S. District Judge James Moran in late 1989. Prosecutors John Farrell and Steve Miller argued that Debra and Korabik conspired to kill Werner to collect the insurance and preempt a divorce. There was no murder weapon, no fingerprints, and no eyewitness to the shooting itself, so the case rested on witnesses.

The government’s most important witness was Debra’s own brother, Curtis Alex Stover. Stover, a convicted burglar brought to court from Cook County Jail, testified that Debra confided in him in late 1982 that she had arranged the killing, telling him, “I had to have Werner killed. He was maniac.” Stover also said that in December 1984 Korabik described the shooting to him, claiming he shot Werner and watched him “spin like a top” before firing ten more rounds into “the Nazi.”¹²

On cross-examination, Stover conceded he had not reported Korabik’s statements until his own arrest on burglary charges years later. Defense attorney Michael Saken questioned Stover’s credibility, suggested he could have pieced his story together from news accounts, and floated the idea that Stover himself could have been the person seen fleeing the scene with a gym bag.¹³ Prosecutor Miller countered that testifying against his own sister cut in favor of Stover’s credibility.

Korabik took the stand and denied the killing. He testified he had been visiting James Pappas in Bensenville on the evening of June 8; James and Elizabeth Pappas both testified in support of that alibi.⁵ Kaenel’s attorney argued that his client had been promised immunity for cooperating, including identifying the location of a bullet fired from a MAC-10 that matched the murder weapon. Prosecutors said the immunity deal had been voided because Kaenel never followed through, and that while he was serving a federal sentence on unrelated weapons charges he had written to Debra and Korabik’s father urging them to “remain firm in their resolve to remain silent.”⁸

Convictions and Sentences

On December 15, 1989, the jury convicted all three defendants on multiple counts of mail and wire fraud for conspiring to kill Werner Hartmann and defraud the insurance companies.³

On March 12, 1990, Judge Moran imposed the sentences:

Debra Hartmann received 22 years in federal prison. She had faced a maximum of 150 years.¹
John Scott Korabik received 16 years in federal prison plus five years of probation.⁶
Kenneth Kaenel received 20 years in federal prison plus five years of probation.⁶

Prudential agent Harvey Loochtan pleaded guilty separately to federal mail fraud for his part in the beneficiary switch and received a two-year prison sentence.¹⁴

Appeals and the Money

All three defendants appealed. In United States v. Hartmann, 958 F.2d 774 (7th Cir. 1992), the Seventh Circuit found “no merit” in their arguments and affirmed the convictions and sentences without modification.²

Werner’s daughters, Stephanie and Eva, sued separately to recover the insurance money paid to Debra. In Hartmann v. Prudential Insurance Co. of America, 9 F.3d 1207 (7th Cir. 1993), they sought to reform the policies to list themselves as beneficiaries and alleged fraud by Debra and Loochtan. The Seventh Circuit acknowledged that Werner had plainly intended his daughters as the beneficiaries, that Loochtan had engaged in “nefarious conduct,” and that Illinois has a “murdering heir” rule barring a killer from collecting insurance on the victim. Even so, the court affirmed summary judgment against the daughters. Their lawyers had framed the case narrowly as equitable reformation and had disclaimed a vicarious-liability theory against Prudential during the appeal, and the court declined to rescue the plaintiffs from what it treated as counsel’s tactical choices, despite calling the case “sympathetic.”⁷

1
Chicago Tribune. Debra Hartmann Gets 22-Year Term
2
Westlaw. United States v. Hartmann, 958 F.2d 774
3
Chicago Tribune. Debra Hartmann, 2 Men Convicted
4
Chicago Tribune. The Case of Millionaire’s Death
5
Chicago Tribune. Widow’s Ex-Lover Denies That He Killed Hartmann
6
Justia. United States v. Hartmann, 958 F.2d 774
7
Justia. Hartmann v. Prudential Ins. Co. of America, 9 F.3d 1207
8
UPI. Woman, Lover Indicted for 1982 Murder Scam
9
Chicago Tribune. Daughter: I Accused Hartmann
10
Chicago Tribune. Hartmann Slaying Confession Is Told
11
Chicago Tribune. Widow, Ex-Boyfriend Charged in Plotting ’82 Death
12
Chicago Tribune. Hartmann’s Brother Takes Stand
13
Chicago Tribune. Jurors Considering Hartmann Verdict
14
Chicago Tribune. Hartmann Case Prison Term Upheld