Disgorgement of Infringer’s Profits in Copyright Cases

Disgorgement of an infringer’s profits in copyright cases is a monetary remedy under 17 U.S.C. § 504(b) that lets you recover the money an infringer earned from using your work without permission. The statute uses a burden-shifting structure: you prove the infringer’s gross revenue, and the infringer must then prove any deductible expenses and any portion of profits attributable to factors other than your copyrighted material. Whatever is left is yours, and you can recover it on top of your own actual damages when the two don’t overlap.1Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 17 USC 504 – Remedies for Infringement: Damages and Profits

Why You Can Recover Profits On Top of Actual Damages

Actual damages compensate you for what you lost: diverted sales, licensing fees you would have charged. Disgorgement targets what the infringer gained. Section 504(b) awards both — “the actual damages suffered by him or her as a result of the infringement, and any profits of the infringer that are attributable to the infringement and are not taken into account in computing the actual damages.”1Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 17 USC 504 – Remedies for Infringement: Damages and Profits

The phrase “not taken into account” is the guardrail against double counting. If every infringing sale was a sale you would have made yourself, those profits already appear in your actual damages. But when the infringer reached buyers you never would have, sold at better margins, or exploited channels you couldn’t, those extra profits remain recoverable. The structure keeps infringers from pocketing windfalls just because the copyright owner’s personal losses were modest.

Step 1: Proving the Infringer’s Gross Revenue

Your initial burden is light. You only need to prove gross revenue — the total money that came in from the infringing activity before any expenses are subtracted.1Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 17 USC 504 – Remedies for Infringement: Damages and Profits Sales receipts, bank deposits, invoices, and accounting ledgers are the standard discovery tools. Once that number is in front of the court, the entire amount is treated as recoverable profit unless the infringer proves otherwise. That default puts immediate pressure on the defendant to open the books.

Step 2: What the Infringer Can Deduct

After gross revenue is on the table, the burden flips entirely. The infringer must prove every dollar they want subtracted.1Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 17 USC 504 – Remedies for Infringement: Damages and Profits Direct production costs are the easiest: materials, labor tied to making the infringing product, packaging. Marketing and distribution expenses can also come off, but only when spent specifically on the infringing work, not on the business generally.

Overhead is the fight. Rent, utilities, insurance, and administrative salaries support an entire operation, not just one infringing line. Courts require the infringer to clear two hurdles before deducting overhead. First, the overhead category must actually have been involved in producing or selling the infringing product. Second, the infringer must offer a reasonable formula for allocating the right proportion of that overhead to the infringement.2Justia Law. Hamil America Inc v GFI, 193 F3d 92 A blanket claim that office rent helped the whole business doesn’t satisfy either hurdle.

Sloppy records are expensive. If the infringer can’t back up claimed expenses with organized financial documentation, the court can reject the deductions entirely and award the full gross revenue amount.

How Willfulness Changes the Analysis

Courts split on whether a willfulness finding tightens the review of deductions. Some apply heightened scrutiny: the allocation formula must meet “a particularly high standard of fairness,” and overhead categories without a direct, clear connection to the infringement get rejected.2Justia Law. Hamil America Inc v GFI, 193 F3d 92 The reasoning is that a knowing infringer shouldn’t get the benefit of the doubt on fuzzy numbers.

Other courts reject the distinction. One federal court held that denying overhead deductions as punishment for willful infringement would impose “affirmative punishment” the Copyright Act doesn’t authorize, turning a compensatory remedy into a penalty.3Justia Law. ZZ Top v Chrysler Corp, 70 F Supp 2d 1167

A parallel split exists on income taxes already paid on infringing revenue. Many courts let innocent infringers deduct those taxes but deny the deduction to willful infringers. Which circuit you’re in affects the math.

Step 3: Apportioning Profits to the Infringement

Not every dollar the infringer earned necessarily came from your work. When a product combines your copyrighted material with other elements, the court divides the profits to isolate what the infringement actually drove. The burden of proving that split is on the infringer.1Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 17 USC 504 – Remedies for Infringement: Damages and Profits

The Supreme Court set the apportionment rule in Sheldon v. Metro-Goldwyn Pictures Corp., holding that the purpose of profit disgorgement is “to provide just compensation for the wrong — not to impose a penalty by giving to the copyright proprietor profits which are not attributable to the infringement.” When a motion picture used a copyrighted play but also drew on expert direction, well-known actors, and expensive production, profits had to be divided among those contributions.4Library of Congress. Sheldon v Metro-Goldwyn Pictures Corp, 309 US 390 (1940)

In practice, the infringer presents evidence that customers bought the product for reasons other than the copyrighted material: brand reputation, non-infringing components, marketing. If an unauthorized song appears on an album with nine original tracks, the infringer needs numbers showing how much of each sale came from the other tracks, the artist’s name, or promotion unrelated to the stolen song. Consumer surveys, sales data, and expert testimony about purchasing behavior do that work.

If your work is the main reason people bought, the infringer keeps very little. If your work was a minor piece of a complex product, the award shrinks. And if the infringer offers no evidence for apportionment at all, the court can award the entire profit. The statute places that risk squarely on the defendant.

Indirect Profits

Disgorgement reaches beyond direct sales of the infringing product. Courts recognize that infringement can generate revenue indirectly, and those profits are recoverable under the right conditions.5Ninth Circuit District and Bankruptcy Courts. 17.36 Copyright – Damages – Defendants Profits (17 USC 504(b)) A copyrighted photograph used in an advertisement drives foot traffic that produces sales of unrelated items. Copyrighted music in a commercial lifts brand recognition and sales across a product line.

The evidentiary bar is higher. You must prove a causal link between the infringement and the broader revenue, and the “gross revenue” you present cannot be the infringer’s company-wide total — it has to be revenue specifically tied to the infringement.5Ninth Circuit District and Bankruptcy Courts. 17.36 Copyright – Damages – Defendants Profits (17 USC 504(b)) Courts throw out claims that rest on speculative connections. Forensic accountants and economists typically carry this part of the case, tracing how the infringement enhanced brand value or lifted sales elsewhere in the business.

How Far Back Your Profit Recovery Can Reach

You must file your infringement suit within three years of the claim accruing.6Legal Information Institute. Petrella v Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer Inc When accrual happens, and what that means for how far back profits can go, has shifted recently.

In Petrella v. Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer (2014), the Supreme Court held that an infringement is actionable within three years of its occurrence, and the equitable defense of laches cannot block a damages claim brought in that window.6Legal Information Institute. Petrella v Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer Inc For ongoing infringement, each new infringing act restarts the clock, so a defendant who keeps selling stays exposed even when the conduct began long ago.

The larger shift came in 2024 in Warner Chappell Music v. Nealy. The Court held that if a copyright owner has a timely claim, the Copyright Act imposes no separate time limit on how far back monetary recovery can reach. In circuits applying the discovery rule, where the limitations period starts when you knew or should have known about the infringement, you can recover profits stretching back years or even decades before filing. The Court rejected the argument that monetary relief should be capped at the three years before suit, noting such a cap would “gut” the discovery rule.7Legal Information Institute. Warner Chappell Music Inc v Nealy

Profits vs. Statutory Damages: You Have to Choose

Copyright owners face a strategic fork. You can recover actual damages plus the infringer’s profits, or you can elect statutory damages instead. You cannot do both. The election can be made any time before the court enters final judgment.8Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 17 USC 504 – Remedies for Infringement: Damages and Profits

Statutory damages run from $750 to $30,000 per work infringed, in the court’s discretion. For willful infringement, the ceiling rises to $150,000 per work. If the infringer proves they had no reason to know their conduct was infringing, the floor drops to $200.8Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 17 USC 504 – Remedies for Infringement: Damages and Profits These figures have not been adjusted since 1999.

The call depends on what you can prove. Statutory damages are attractive when profits are hard to document, when harm is real but revenue is thin, or when the per-work range exceeds what a profits analysis would yield. Profit disgorgement makes more sense when the infringer earned large, well-documented sums that dwarf the statutory caps.

One trap catches many copyright owners: statutory damages and attorney’s fees are only available if you registered your copyright before the infringement began, or within three months of first publication.9Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 17 USC 412 – Registration as Prerequisite to Certain Remedies for Infringement Miss that window and actual damages plus profit disgorgement are your only monetary remedy. If your work has commercial value, register it early.

Prejudgment Interest

Federal courts have discretion to add prejudgment interest to a disgorgement award, compensating you for the time value of money between the infringement and the judgment. The Copyright Act doesn’t mention it, but courts award it as part of making the plaintiff whole. Interest typically runs from the date the infringement occurred rather than the date you discovered it. Factors include the length of the delay, whether you contributed to it, and whether a genuine dispute existed about the work’s copyrightability. On a large award that took years to litigate, prejudgment interest can add a meaningful sum. Courts generally decline to award it on statutory damages, since Congress already built discretion into the statutory range.

Taxes on a Disgorgement Award

The IRS treats a profit-disgorgement recovery as ordinary income. The character of the recovery follows the underlying claim, and the IRS specifically lists damages for copyright infringement as taxable ordinary income, whether paid under a judgment or a settlement.10Internal Revenue Service. Publication 525, Taxable and Nontaxable Income A $500,000 award doesn’t put $500,000 in your pocket. Attorney’s fees and litigation costs further reduce the net, and the interaction with contingency arrangements can get complicated. Price the tax impact before you settle or go to trial.