Ending Cash Bail: How It Works and Where It’s Been Done

Ending cash bail means replacing a pretrial system that releases people based on how much money they can pay with one that releases or detains them based on flight risk and danger to others. Under the old approach, a judge sets a dollar amount, and anyone who can pay walks free while anyone who can’t stays in jail, regardless of actual risk. Under a reformed system, low-risk defendants go home without paying anything, and genuinely dangerous defendants are detained after a hearing with no option to buy their way out. Federal courts have operated on a version of this principle since 1984, and a growing number of states are now doing the same.

The Problem Reform Is Trying to Fix

Cash bail sorts people by wealth, not risk. Two defendants charged with the same crime and presenting the same flight risk can have entirely different pretrial experiences based on whether they can scrape together a few thousand dollars. Research has shown that Black defendants are more likely to have monetary bail imposed and receive bail amounts averaging nearly $10,000 higher than white defendants charged with comparable offenses.

Federal courts have started agreeing that this is a constitutional problem. In 2018, the Fifth Circuit ruled in ODonnell v. Harris County that the county’s practice of setting bail amounts from a predetermined schedule, without considering whether people could actually pay, violated the Equal Protection Clause. When two people facing the same charge receive the same bail and one walks free because she has money while the other sits in jail because he doesn’t, the court said, the system is discriminating on wealth alone.1Justia Law. ODonnell v Harris County, Texas, No. 17-20333 (5th Cir. 2018)

California’s Supreme Court reached a similar conclusion in In re Humphrey in 2021, holding that “the common practice of conditioning freedom solely on whether an arrestee can afford bail is unconstitutional.” The court required judges to consider a defendant’s actual ability to pay before setting any monetary condition and demanded clear and convincing evidence before ordering detention.2Justia Law. In re Humphrey (2021) These decisions didn’t abolish money bail outright, but they laid the constitutional groundwork that state legislatures are now building on.

How a System Without Cash Bail Decides Who Goes Home

The federal system has been running a risk-based pretrial model for over four decades, and it shows what the alternative looks like. Under the Bail Reform Act of 1984, federal judges follow a structured sequence. The starting point is release on personal recognizance, meaning the defendant simply promises to return to court. If that’s not enough, the judge moves to supervised release with conditions like drug testing, location monitoring, or reporting to a pretrial services officer.3Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 18 USC 3142 – Release or Detention of a Defendant Pending Trial

One provision of the federal statute is particularly relevant: a judge “may not impose a financial condition that results in the pretrial detention of the person.” Federal law already prohibits using money bail as a de facto detention order. If the only realistic outcome of setting a $50,000 bond is that the defendant stays locked up because they can’t pay, the judge has to either find non-monetary conditions that work or formally order detention after a hearing.3Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 18 USC 3142 – Release or Detention of a Defendant Pending Trial Detention is reserved for cases where no combination of conditions can reasonably ensure community safety and the defendant’s appearance.

Risk Assessment Tools

Without money bail as the default sorting mechanism, courts need another way to evaluate defendants. Most jurisdictions that have reformed their systems use structured risk assessment tools. The Public Safety Assessment, one of the most widely adopted, uses nine factors from a defendant’s record to predict three outcomes: failure to appear for court, arrest for any new crime, and arrest for a new violent crime. The tool generates scores on a scale of one to six and deliberately excludes race, ethnicity, gender, employment status, income, and zip code.4Advancing Pretrial Policy and Research. How the PSA Works

The scores are recommendations, not orders. The judge retains full discretion to weigh them alongside the specific facts of the case and arguments from both sides.4Advancing Pretrial Policy and Research. How the PSA Works

These tools are better than a bail schedule pinned to a courtroom wall, but they aren’t neutral. They rely heavily on criminal history data that reflects decades of racially disparate policing. If Black defendants in a given city were historically arrested at higher rates for the same conduct, those records feed into the algorithm and produce higher risk scores going forward. Research has found that Black defendants are significantly more likely to be falsely flagged as high-risk for future violent crime than white defendants with comparable actual reoffense rates. Defense attorneys can challenge a risk score at the hearing, pointing to data errors, changed circumstances, or factors the algorithm misses.

Who Can Still Be Detained

Ending cash bail doesn’t mean everyone goes home. Reform laws identify categories of offenses where the prosecution can petition for pretrial detention. Illinois, which fully abolished money bail, allows detention petitions for:5Illinois General Assembly. Illinois Compiled Statutes 725 ILCS 5/110-6.1

  • Forcible felonies, including first- and second-degree murder, criminal sexual assault, armed robbery, residential burglary, home invasion, aggravated arson, kidnapping, and aggravated battery causing great bodily harm.
  • Firearm offenses involving use or discharge of a weapon, including aggravated vehicular hijacking.
  • Domestic battery, aggravated domestic battery, stalking, and violations of protective orders where the defendant poses a demonstrated threat to a specific person.
  • Most sex offenses, with limited exceptions for lower-level charges.
  • Non-probationable felonies, where a prison sentence is mandatory upon conviction and the defendant has a strong incentive to flee.

Even for these offenses, detention isn’t automatic. The prosecution must show the defendant poses a “real and present threat” to someone’s safety based on the facts of the specific case. A first-degree murder charge where the evidence is thin looks different from one where the defendant was caught on camera, and judges are expected to weigh that distinction.5Illinois General Assembly. Illinois Compiled Statutes 725 ILCS 5/110-6.1

The Detention Hearing

When a prosecutor wants to hold a defendant without release, they must petition the court for a formal detention hearing. These hearings happen quickly after arrest and are adversarial. The burden falls on the prosecution: under the federal system, the government must show by clear and convincing evidence that no conditions of release can reasonably ensure community safety and the defendant’s return to court.3Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 18 USC 3142 – Release or Detention of a Defendant Pending Trial State systems that have adopted reform generally follow the same framework, requiring the state to carry the burden rather than making the defendant argue their way out of jail.

If the judge orders detention, the decision must be supported by a written order explaining why less restrictive conditions were insufficient, and the defendant can appeal. If the judge denies the petition, the defendant is released under whatever conditions the court sets, from a simple check-in with a pretrial services officer to GPS monitoring and no-contact orders.

Conditions of Release and What a Violation Costs

Defendants released pretrial without posting bail aren’t simply turned loose. Courts impose conditions calibrated to risk. For low-risk defendants, that might mean nothing more than a promise to show up. For higher-risk cases, conditions can include regular check-ins, GPS ankle monitoring, drug and alcohol testing, curfews, surrender of firearms, and no-contact orders protecting victims.

Violating these conditions carries real consequences, even for infractions that aren’t crimes in themselves. Missing a check-in, failing a drug test, or leaving a monitored zone are “technical violations” that can trigger a revocation hearing. At that hearing, the judge can tighten supervision, add new conditions, or revoke release entirely and order detention until trial. Many states cap how long someone can be jailed for a technical violation, with limits that vary by jurisdiction and prior history.

Severity matters. Missing one check-in because of a work conflict is treated differently from cutting off an ankle monitor and disappearing for a week. Getting arrested for a new crime while on pretrial release is the most serious violation and almost always results in detention for both the original and the new charge.

The Cost of Being Monitored

One irony of bail reform is that some tools used to replace cash bail carry their own costs. GPS monitoring frequently comes with daily fees ranging roughly from $5 to $15 per day. Court-ordered drug testing can add another $8 to $20 per test, and defendants on intensive supervision may be tested multiple times per month. These costs accumulate for someone who was released precisely because they couldn’t afford bail in the first place.

Whether defendants actually pay varies widely. Some jurisdictions absorb the costs through their pretrial services budgets. Others charge on a sliding scale based on ability to pay, and some impose flat fees regardless of income. Falling behind on monitoring fees can technically constitute a violation, potentially sending someone back to jail for inability to pay rather than any safety concern. A few jurisdictions have responded with indigency waivers or by eliminating supervision fees altogether, but the practice is far from uniform. This remains one of the unresolved tensions as more places transition away from money bail.

Where Cash Bail Has Actually Been Eliminated

Illinois

Illinois became the first state to completely eliminate cash bail when its Pretrial Fairness Act took effect on September 18, 2023. The law is part of the broader SAFE-T Act, and it fundamentally changed how bond court operates statewide.6Loyola University Chicago Center for Criminal Justice. Tracking The Pretrial Fairness Act Judges can no longer set a price for release. Every pretrial decision comes down to two questions: does this person pose a real threat to someone’s safety, and are they likely to flee? If the answer to both is no, the defendant goes home. No bondsman, no percentage deposits, no property liens.

New Jersey

New Jersey rewired its pretrial system in 2017 through a constitutional amendment paired with the Criminal Justice Reform Act. The amendment allowed courts to deny release based on dangerousness rather than requiring monetary bail as a default, and specified that release could be denied only when no amount of money or non-monetary conditions would reasonably ensure public safety and court attendance.7State of New Jersey. Council on Local Mandates – In re Complaint Filed by The New Jersey Association of Counties

The results came quickly. Within the first five months, the statewide jail population dropped 19 percent. Comparing the jail census on May 31, 2017, to the same date two years earlier showed a decline of nearly 36 percent. Some counties saw their jail populations fall by more than a quarter.8New Jersey Courts. NJ Jail Population Down Almost One-Fifth After Bail Overhaul Cash bail technically still exists in New Jersey, but the legal presumption now favors non-monetary release, making money bail rare in practice.

California

California’s path has been rockier. The legislature passed Senate Bill 10 in 2018, which would have replaced cash bail statewide with risk assessments and non-monetary conditions.9California Legislative Information. SB-10 Pretrial Release or Detention – Pretrial Services The bail bond industry backed a referendum, Proposition 25, and voters rejected the law in November 2020, keeping cash bail in place.

But the courts stepped in. The California Supreme Court’s 2021 Humphrey ruling established that judges must consider a defendant’s financial ability before imposing any monetary condition and cannot use bail to effectively detain someone who simply can’t pay. Detention requires clear and convincing evidence that no less restrictive alternative would work.2Justia Law. In re Humphrey (2021) California now operates under a judicial mandate that accomplishes much of what SB 10 attempted legislatively.

Other Jurisdictions

Beyond these examples, numerous cities and counties have eliminated cash bail for low-level offenses like misdemeanors and minor ordinance violations. Several other states and the District of Columbia have adopted various restrictions on money bail. The trend is toward treating cash bail as a last resort rather than a default, even in places that haven’t fully abolished it.

Has Crime Gone Up Under Reform

This is the question opponents raise most, and the available data doesn’t support their fears. A study examining crime trends in 22 cities before and after bail reforms, compared against 11 cities without reforms, found no significant changes in crime rates during the 12 months following reform. Even when researchers isolated cities with the most aggressive reforms, the results held.

That finding makes sense given what cash bail actually does. It doesn’t keep dangerous people locked up; it keeps poor people locked up. A defendant charged with assault who has $5,000 in savings walks free under the old system. A defendant charged with shoplifting who has $200 to her name stays in jail. Replacing that sorting mechanism with one based on actual dangerousness shouldn’t make communities less safe, and the evidence so far suggests it doesn’t.