The Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment bars states from denying any person “the equal protection of the laws,” and the Supreme Court has applied it to strike down racial segregation, sex-based statutes, unequal voting districts, same-sex marriage bans, and race-conscious college admissions. The cases below are the clearest equal protection clause examples, grouped by the type of classification each one addressed. Reading them together shows how the clause actually works in practice, because the result in any given case depends almost entirely on which level of judicial scrutiny applies.
The Three Tiers of Scrutiny
Courts do not apply a single test to every equal protection claim. They sort laws into three tiers based on who is being classified or what right is at stake, and the tier chosen usually predicts the outcome.
Rational basis review is the most forgiving. The government only has to show a logical connection between the law and some legitimate interest, and the challenger carries the burden of proving no such connection exists. Most economic and social regulations are reviewed this way and survive.1Congress.gov. Equal Protection and Rational Basis Review Generally
Intermediate scrutiny sits in the middle. The government must show that the law furthers an important interest and that the classification is substantially related to that interest. It applies to sex-based classifications and was formally established in Craig v. Boren.2Legal Information Institute. Craig v Boren, 429 US 190 (1976)
Strict scrutiny is the toughest. The government must prove a compelling interest and show the law is narrowly tailored to achieve it through the least restrictive means. Race, national origin, and alienage classifications trigger it, and laws almost never survive the review.3Congress.gov. Equal Protection – Strict Scrutiny of Racial Classifications
Racial Segregation in Public Schools
Brown v. Board of Education (1954) is the best-known equal protection decision. Before Brown, the “separate but equal” doctrine from Plessy v. Ferguson allowed states to run racially segregated schools so long as the facilities were nominally equivalent. A unanimous Court threw that framework out, holding that separating schoolchildren by race is inherently unequal regardless of whether the buildings and books match on paper.4National Archives. Brown v Board of Education (1954) The segregation itself, the Court concluded, stamps minority students with a badge of inferiority that no physical upgrade can undo.5Justia. Brown v Board of Education of Topeka, 347 US 483 (1954) Brown is strict scrutiny in its clearest form: a government racial classification with no compelling justification cannot stand.
Sex-Based Classifications
Reed v. Reed (1971) was the first case in which the Supreme Court struck down a law for discriminating against women under the Equal Protection Clause. An Idaho probate statute automatically preferred men over women when two equally qualified people applied to administer an estate, and the state defended it as a way to cut down on court hearings. The Court held that a mandatory preference for one sex is precisely the kind of arbitrary classification the Fourteenth Amendment forbids.6Justia. Reed v Reed, 404 US 71 (1971)
Five years later, Craig v. Boren (1976) raised the bar further. An Oklahoma law set different drinking ages for men and women, and the Court used the case to formally establish intermediate scrutiny as the standard for sex classifications. The sex-based line was not substantially related to any important state interest, and the law fell.2Legal Information Institute. Craig v Boren, 429 US 190 (1976) After Craig, administrative convenience is no longer enough to justify sorting people by sex.
Voting Districts and Representation
When legislative districts contain very different numbers of people, voters in crowded districts end up with less influence than voters in sparsely populated ones. Reynolds v. Sims (1964) addressed that imbalance in Alabama, where the legislative map still relied on 1900 census data despite six decades of uneven growth. The Court held that the Equal Protection Clause requires state legislative districts to contain roughly equal populations, giving the country the principle of “one person, one vote.”7Justia. Reynolds v Sims, 377 US 533 (1964) States have to redraw their maps periodically or they discriminate against voters based on where they live.
Equal population does not solve every districting problem, though. In Rucho v. Common Cause (2019), the Court held that partisan gerrymandering claims are political questions that federal courts cannot resolve.8Justia. Rucho v Common Cause, 588 US (2019) Even when a legislature draws lines to entrench one party, the Equal Protection Clause does not supply a workable standard for identifying when partisan advantage becomes unconstitutional. Challenges to partisan gerrymandering now have to run through state courts or the political process instead. This is a real limit on the clause: it equalizes district populations, but it will not police the political motives behind the lines.
Same-Sex Marriage and Its Benefits
Obergefell v. Hodges (2015) held that the Fourteenth Amendment requires every state to license marriages between same-sex couples and to recognize such marriages performed in other states.9Justia. Obergefell v Hodges, 576 US 644 (2015) Marriage is a fundamental right, the Court reasoned, and excluding same-sex couples from it imposes stigma and tangible injury without adequate justification.
The ruling reached further than marriage licenses. In Pavan v. Smith (2017), the Court struck down an Arkansas rule that listed a husband on a birth certificate when his wife gave birth but refused to list the female spouse of a birth mother. If a state grants married opposite-sex couples the right to appear on birth certificates regardless of biology, it must extend the same right to married same-sex couples.10Justia. Pavan v Smith, 582 US (2017) Being left off a birth certificate affects a parent’s ability to prove parentage for school enrollment, medical decisions, and custody disputes. Equal protection, read together across these two cases, requires equal treatment in the legal benefits that follow from marriage, not just access to the ceremony itself.
Race-Conscious College Admissions
For decades, universities used race as one factor in admissions to promote campus diversity, a practice Grutter v. Bollinger (2003) had upheld. That approach ended in Students for Fair Admissions v. President and Fellows of Harvard College (2023), where the Court ruled that the race-conscious admissions programs at Harvard and the University of North Carolina violated the Equal Protection Clause.11Justia. Students for Fair Admissions Inc v President and Fellows of Harvard College, 600 US (2023) The programs lacked a sufficiently focused and measurable objective and used race in ways that amounted to the kind of classification strict scrutiny prohibits.
The decision did not bar applicants from writing about how their racial background shaped their experiences in a personal essay, but universities can no longer assign a plus factor to an applicant for membership in a particular racial group. SFFA shows strict scrutiny doing what it usually does: even where many consider the goal compelling, the Court found the means were not narrowly tailored enough to survive.
Citizenship Requirements for Public Jobs
Laws that discriminate against non-citizens generally face strict scrutiny. In Bernal v. Fainter (1984), Texas barred non-citizens from becoming notaries public. The Court struck the restriction down, finding that notary work is clerical rather than political and that citizenship has no rational connection to witnessing signatures and administering oaths.12Justia. Bernal v Fainter, 467 US 216 (1984)
The “political function” doctrine supplies the exception. In Foley v. Connelie (1978), the Court upheld New York’s requirement that state police officers be U.S. citizens, reasoning that officers exercise broad discretionary authority over the public and perform a core governmental function.13Justia. Foley v Connelie, 435 US 291 (1978) The line between the two cases is the amount of discretion the job carries. A notary follows a script. A police officer makes judgment calls that directly affect people’s liberty. States can restrict the second kind of job to citizens; they cannot restrict the first.
Does the Clause Apply to the Federal Government
The text of the Equal Protection Clause only mentions states, which raises an obvious boundary question. The federal government is bound by the same principles, but through a different route. In Bolling v. Sharpe (1954), decided the same day as Brown, the Court struck down racial segregation in Washington, D.C., public schools. Because D.C. is a federal district rather than a state, the Fourteenth Amendment did not reach it. The Court held instead that the Fifth Amendment’s guarantee of due process prevents the federal government from engaging in discrimination that would be unconstitutional if a state did it.14Justia. Bolling v Sharpe, 347 US 497 (1954) “It would be unthinkable,” the Court wrote, “that the same Constitution would impose a lesser duty on the Federal Government.” Every example above applies to federal action through that principle, even though the clause itself speaks only to the states.