Famous Intellectual Property Cases: Copyright, Trademark, and Patent

Famous intellectual property cases have redrawn the boundaries of copyright, trademark, patent, trade secret, and publicity law, often in rulings that still control how creators, inventors, and brand owners protect their work today. The decisions below span musical “feel,” software code, parody, smartphone design, instant photography, autonomous vehicle technology, and celebrity identity. Each one answered a question the law had been circling for years, and each one changed what came after.

Copyright Cases That Reset the Rules

Federal copyright law protects original works of authorship, including literary works, music, software, films, and architecture.1Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 17 USC 102 – Subject Matter of Copyright In General Two cases pushed the edges of what that protection covers.

Williams v. Gaye

The Marvin Gaye estate sued Pharrell Williams and Robin Thicke, claiming “Blurred Lines” had copied Gaye’s 1977 track “Got to Give It Up.” The claim did not rest on identical melodies or lyrics. The Gaye family argued that the overall rhythmic feel and harmonic texture had been taken.2Justia. Williams v. Gaye, No. 15-56880 (9th Cir. 2018)

A jury sided with the estate. The final judgment required Williams and Thicke to pay roughly $5 million in combined damages, and the court imposed a 50 percent running royalty on future earnings from “Blurred Lines.” The Ninth Circuit affirmed. For musicians, the lesson was stark: structural similarities in groove and arrangement can trigger liability even when no specific melody is copied note for note.

Apple Computer v. Franklin Computer

Before this case, it was genuinely unclear whether binary software code qualified for copyright protection at all. Franklin admitted to copying fourteen of Apple’s operating system programs so its own hardware could run Apple-compatible software.3Justia. Apple Computer Inc v. Franklin Computer Corp The district court initially denied Apple’s injunction, doubting the programs were copyrightable.

The Third Circuit reversed. It held that computer programs are works of authorship whether they appear as human-readable source code or as machine-readable object code embedded in a chip. The statute allows narrow copying for things like making a backup or an essential adaptation on your own machine, but wholesale duplication of an operating system is not close.4Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 17 US Code 117 – Limitations on Exclusive Rights Computer Programs The ruling became the foundation for treating software as copyrightable text and underpins nearly every software licensing dispute since.

Fair Use: Three Supreme Court Decisions

Copyright protection has limits. Fair use allows others to use copyrighted material without permission in certain circumstances, and courts weigh four factors: the purpose and character of the use, the nature of the work, how much was taken, and the effect on the market for the original. Three decisions have shaped how those factors apply in practice.

Campbell v. Acuff-Rose Music

When 2 Live Crew released a rap parody of Roy Orbison’s “Oh, Pretty Woman,” the copyright holder sued, arguing the group had copied the song’s opening riff and first line of lyrics for commercial gain. The lower courts assumed that because the parody was sold for profit, it was presumptively unfair.

In 1994 the Supreme Court unanimously rejected that reasoning. A parody’s commercial character is one element in the fair use analysis, not a disqualifying factor. The Court also held that the lower court had been too rigid about how much of the original was copied, because a parody has to borrow enough of its target to make the target recognizable. The decision carved out protected space for parody even when the parodist is making money.

Google v. Oracle

One of the most consequential software cases in decades asked whether Google’s copying of roughly 11,500 lines of Java API “declaring code” into its Android platform qualified as fair use. Oracle framed it as straightforward theft. Google argued the declaring code functioned as an interface programmers already knew, and that reimplementing it in Android served a transformative purpose.

The Supreme Court ruled 6-2 for Google. The declaring code was primarily functional rather than creatively expressive, and Google had copied it to let programmers use their existing Java skills in a new platform. All four fair use factors weighed in Google’s favor.5Justia. Google LLC v. Oracle America Inc, 593 US (2021) The ruling gave developers building interoperable software substantial breathing room. It also explicitly left open whether the declaring code was copyrightable in the first place.

Andy Warhol Foundation v. Goldsmith

In the years after Campbell, courts expanded the idea of “transformative use” to the point where adding new meaning or aesthetic expression could justify copying. The Supreme Court pulled that trend back sharply in 2023.

Photographer Lynn Goldsmith had taken a portrait of Prince in 1981. Andy Warhol later used that photograph as the basis for a series of silk-screen prints. When Condé Nast licensed one of the Warhol prints for a magazine cover after Prince’s death, the Warhol Foundation claimed fair use. The Court disagreed 7-2. Because the Warhol print and the Goldsmith photograph served the same commercial purpose, illustrating a magazine story about Prince, the first fair use factor weighed against the Foundation.6Justia. Andy Warhol Foundation for Visual Arts Inc v. Goldsmith, 598 US (2023) Making a work look different is not enough. A secondary use has to serve a genuinely distinct purpose from the original, especially when money is changing hands.

Who Can Author a Copyright, and When It Ends

Two recent developments have forced courts to confront foundational questions about who can hold a copyright and when protection expires.

Thaler v. Perlmutter

Stephen Thaler sought to register a copyright for an image generated entirely by his artificial intelligence system, the “Creativity Machine,” and listed the AI as the author. The Copyright Office refused. Thaler sued, and in 2025 the D.C. Circuit affirmed the denial. The Copyright Act requires all eligible works to be authored by a human being, the court held, and the word “author” in the statute has always referred to a person. Extending authorship to a machine would require rewriting the law rather than interpreting it.7Justia. Thaler v. Perlmutter, No. 23-5233 (DC Cir. 2025)

The ruling does not mean AI-assisted works are automatically unprotectable. The court noted that a human who creates, operates, or uses an AI tool can still qualify as the author, provided they contribute enough original creative expression. What the decision eliminates is listing an AI system itself as the copyright owner.

Steamboat Willie Enters the Public Domain

Copyright does not last forever. Works created by a corporate author (legally, “works made for hire”) receive protection for 95 years from publication or 120 years from creation, whichever expires first.8Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 17 US Code 302 – Duration of Copyright Works Created on or After January 1 1978 On January 1, 2024, the version of Mickey Mouse that appeared in the 1928 animated short Steamboat Willie entered the U.S. public domain after its 95-year term expired. Disney acknowledged the expiration, while making clear that modern versions of Mickey remain protected and that the Mickey Mouse trademark, which can last indefinitely with continued use, still applies.

Expiration is limited to the specific character design as it appeared in 1928. The familiar red-shorted, white-gloved Mickey most people picture today debuted later and remains under copyright for its own term.

Trademark Cases That Defined Brand Protection

Trademark law under the Lanham Act prohibits using a mark in commerce when the use is likely to confuse consumers about who made or endorsed a product.9Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 15 USC 1114 – Remedies Infringement Innocent Infringement by Printers and Publishers Two decisions show how courts apply that standard to visual branding.

Adidas v. Payless ShoeSource

Adidas has used three parallel stripes on its athletic shoes since 1952 and holds federal trademark registrations for the design. When Payless ShoeSource began selling sneakers with two or four parallel stripes, Adidas sued, arguing the designs were close enough to mislead shoppers. The court applied the standard multi-factor test for likelihood of confusion, weighing the strength of the Adidas mark, product similarity, and overlap in retail channels.

A jury awarded Adidas $305 million. The district court later reduced the amount to $65 million after recalculating lost profits and punitive damages. Even the reduced figure ranks among the largest trademark verdicts in U.S. history.

Christian Louboutin v. Yves Saint Laurent

Louboutin’s red outsole on women’s high-heeled shoes had become synonymous with the brand. When Yves Saint Laurent released an all-red shoe (red upper, red sole), Louboutin filed for trademark infringement. The question was whether a single color on a specific part of a product could function as a trademark in fashion.

The Second Circuit said yes, with a limit. The red sole trademark is valid when it contrasts with the upper portion of the shoe, because that contrast is what consumers recognize as Louboutin’s signature. An entirely red shoe does not trigger the same brand association. The ruling protected Louboutin’s identity while preventing the company from claiming exclusive rights to an entire color in all contexts.10Justia. Christian Louboutin SA v. Yves Saint Laurent America Inc, No. 11-3303 (2d Cir. 2012)

When Trademarks Become Generic

Trademark protection can also be lost. A registered mark can be cancelled if it becomes the generic name for the goods or services it covers. The test is whether the primary significance of the mark to the relevant public is as a product category rather than a brand identifier.11Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 15 USC 1064 – Cancellation of Registration “Aspirin,” “escalator,” and “thermos” all lost trademark status this way because consumers began using the brand name to describe any product of that type. Companies like Xerox and Google actively police their marks for the same reason.

Patent Cases With Industry-Changing Stakes

Patent holders can sue anyone who makes, uses, or sells their patented invention without authorization.12Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 35 US Code 271 – Infringement of Patent Successful claims entitle the owner to damages, and courts can increase the award up to three times for willful violations.13Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 35 US Code 284 – Damages

Apple v. Samsung

The litigation between Apple and Samsung over smartphone design and utility patents ran for nearly a decade. Apple alleged that Samsung copied the iPhone’s rectangular front face with rounded corners, its bezel, and the grid layout of colorful icons on a black screen. A jury initially awarded Apple over $1 billion.14Justia. Samsung Electronics Co v. Apple Inc, 580 US (2016)

The case reached the Supreme Court on a specific question. When a patented design covers only a component of a product, should the infringer forfeit total profits from the entire product, or just the portion attributable to the patented feature? The Court ruled unanimously that total profits should be calculated based on the relevant “article of manufacture,” which could be a component rather than the whole device. On remand, a 2018 jury awarded Apple $539 million, and the parties ultimately settled. The ruling fundamentally changed how courts calculate design patent damages for multi-component products.

Polaroid v. Eastman Kodak

Polaroid sued Kodak in 1976, alleging that Kodak’s entry into the instant photography market violated ten of Polaroid’s patents covering the chemical and mechanical processes behind instant film. After more than a decade of litigation, the court found Kodak had infringed seven of those patents and issued a permanent injunction forcing Kodak to stop manufacturing instant cameras and film entirely.

Kodak paid $925 million, consisting of an $873 million court-ordered award plus $52 million in post-judgment interest. At the time it was one of the largest patent damages awards in American history. Beyond the money, the injunction was devastating. Kodak had to abandon an entire product line, leaving millions of customers with cameras they could no longer buy film for. Patent protection, the case showed, can do more than extract money. It can eject a competitor from the market.

eBay v. MercExchange

For years, many courts treated injunctions in patent cases as near-automatic once infringement was proven. The Supreme Court changed that in 2006, holding that a patent holder has to satisfy the same four-factor test that applies in any equity case before a court will order the infringer to stop. The patent holder must show irreparable injury, that monetary damages are inadequate, that the balance of hardships favors an injunction, and that the public interest would not be disserved.15Justia. eBay Inc v. MercExchange LLC, 547 US 388 (2006)

The decision responded directly to concerns about “patent trolls,” entities that acquire patents not to make products but to sue and extract licensing fees. Before eBay, the threat of an automatic injunction gave those entities enormous leverage in settlement negotiations. After it, a patent holder who does not practice the invention often cannot clear the irreparable injury hurdle, which cut the settlement pressure trolls could apply.

The Biggest Trade Secret Case of the AV Era

The Defend Trade Secrets Act of 2016 created a federal cause of action for trade secret theft, letting companies sue in federal court when confidential business information is stolen and relates to a product or service in interstate commerce.16Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 18 US Code 1836 – Civil Proceedings The highest-profile test of that law involved two of Silicon Valley’s most valuable companies.

Waymo v. Uber

Waymo, Google’s autonomous vehicle subsidiary, alleged that engineer Anthony Levandowski downloaded more than 14,000 confidential files related to LiDAR sensor technology before leaving to start his own company, which Uber quickly acquired. The files reportedly included circuit board designs and laser configurations critical to self-driving systems. Waymo argued Uber used the data to shortcut years of development and build a competing LiDAR system in a fraction of the time.17Justia. Waymo LLC v. Uber Technologies Inc, No. 17-2235 (Fed. Cir. 2017)

Waymo sought approximately $1.86 billion. Five days into trial, the parties settled. Under the agreement, Uber paid Waymo 0.34 percent of its equity, valued at roughly $245 million at the time. The settlement remains one of the largest trade secret resolutions on record. The case also showed the practical challenge of trade secret litigation. Once the information is out, proving exactly how it was used and quantifying the resulting competitive advantage requires expensive expert testimony and extensive discovery. Trade secret protection also depends on the owner having taken reasonable steps to keep the information secret, through nondisclosure agreements, access restrictions, confidentiality labeling, and security controls. Companies that treat sensitive information casually may find their claims dismissed at the threshold.

Right of Publicity: Identity Beyond a Photograph

White v. Samsung Electronics

The right of publicity, recognized primarily under state law, prevents others from commercially exploiting a person’s identity without permission. Samsung ran a series of advertisements depicting a humorous vision of the future. One ad featured a robot dressed in a wig and gown, standing next to a game-show letter board clearly meant to invoke Wheel of Fortune. Vanna White was never named, and no photograph of her was used, but the reference was unmistakable.

The Ninth Circuit held that the right of publicity under California common law is not limited to literal use of a person’s name or likeness. If a company evokes a celebrity’s identity clearly enough that the public easily recognizes who is being depicted, the right is violated regardless of the method.18Justia. White v. Samsung Electronics America Inc, 971 F2d 1395 (9th Cir. 1992) Advertisers cannot evade liability by swapping in a look-alike, a robot, or a distinctive set of visual cues instead of a celebrity’s actual image. The principle has become more pressing as deepfakes and AI-generated likenesses raise new questions courts have not fully resolved.

Statutory Damages: The Backstop

Many famous copyright cases involve enormous actual damages, but copyright law also offers a powerful alternative. A copyright holder can elect statutory damages instead of proving actual losses, which matters most when real harm is hard to calculate. Standard infringement runs from $750 to $30,000 per work at the court’s discretion. Willful infringement can reach $150,000 per work if the copyright holder proves the infringer acted deliberately. Innocent infringement can go as low as $200 per work if the infringer shows no reason to believe their actions were infringing.

These amounts apply per work, not per copy. A single willful infringement of one song, photograph, or software program can produce a $150,000 award without the copyright holder proving a dollar of actual loss.19Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 17 USC 504 – Remedies for Infringement Damages and Profits For small creators who cannot trace every unauthorized copy, statutory damages are often the only realistic enforcement tool. For large-scale infringers distributing thousands of works, the math turns catastrophic fast.