A Garrity warning is the notice a public employer gives an employee before an internal investigation interview, and a typical example reads: “This questioning concerns administrative matters relating to the official business of the department. Refusal to answer questions relating to the performance of your departmental duties could result in your dismissal. If you do answer, neither your statements nor any information or evidence gained by reason of such statements can be used against you in any subsequent criminal proceeding. However, these statements may be used against you in relation to subsequent departmental charges.”1National PREA Resource Center. Sample Garrity Warning The warning comes from the 1967 Supreme Court decision in Garrity v. New Jersey, which held that forcing a public employee to choose between keeping their job and keeping their Fifth Amendment right against self-incrimination is unconstitutional coercion.2Justia. Garrity v. New Jersey, 385 U.S. 493 (1967)
A Full Sample Warning, Broken Down
Agencies deliver the warning in writing, usually on a form the employee signs to acknowledge receipt. Whatever the format, a valid warning has to communicate three things. Miss any one of them and the warning is defective.
1. The Administrative Scope
The warning opens by stating what the interview is and what it is not. Representative language: “This questioning concerns administrative matters relating to the official business of the department.”1National PREA Resource Center. Sample Garrity Warning That single sentence frames everything that follows as an employment inquiry rather than a criminal interrogation, which is the premise the rest of the warning rests on.
2. The Order to Answer, With Consequences
This is the heart of the warning. The employee has to be told, plainly, that answering is not optional. A standard version reads: “Refusal to testify or to answer questions relating to the performance of your departmental duties could result in your dismissal from the department.”1National PREA Resource Center. Sample Garrity Warning Some agencies phrase it more directly, telling the employee “you are required to respond to all questions asked” and that silence “may be subject to disciplinary action up to and including termination.”3The University of Texas System. Garrity Warning The threat has to be concrete. A vague suggestion that silence “won’t look good” doesn’t count. The compulsion is what triggers the constitutional protection in the next paragraph.
3. The Immunity Clause
In exchange for forcing the employee to speak, the agency has to promise that what they say stays out of criminal court. The standard language: “If you do answer, neither your statements nor any information or evidence which is gained by reason of such statements can be used against you in any subsequent criminal proceeding. However, these statements may be used against you in relation to subsequent departmental charges.”1National PREA Resource Center. Sample Garrity Warning That last line is the one employees miss. Criminal immunity is not immunity from being fired.
Verbal warnings follow the same three-part structure. A supervisor who delivers the warning conversationally rather than reading from a form still has to hit scope, compulsion, and immunity, and the exchange is typically recorded or documented so the agency can prove later that the warning was given.
What the Immunity Actually Covers
The protection has two layers. The first is use immunity: prosecutors cannot play the recording or read the transcript to a jury. The second, derivative use immunity, is broader. If the compelled statement points investigators toward a bank account, a witness, or a piece of physical evidence they would not otherwise have found, that downstream evidence is also tainted. The Supreme Court set this standard in Kastigar v. United States, holding that use and derivative use immunity is “coextensive with the scope of the privilege against self-incrimination.”4Library of Congress. Kastigar v. United States, 406 U.S. 441 (1972)
If prosecutors still want to charge the employee criminally after a compelled statement exists, they carry a heavy burden. At what is known as a Kastigar hearing, the government has to trace every witness, document, and piece of evidence to a source completely independent of the compelled statement.4Library of Congress. Kastigar v. United States, 406 U.S. 441 (1972) In many cases, that burden is high enough to end the prosecution.
What the Warning Does Not Protect
The sample language quietly admits most of this, but it is worth being explicit.
Compelled statements are fully usable in administrative proceedings. An employee who admits misconduct during a Garrity-protected interview has handed the agency the evidence it needs to suspend, demote, or fire them. The Fifth Amendment protection runs against the criminal courts, not against the personnel office.
Compelled statements can also surface in civil lawsuits. If a plaintiff later sues the employee or the department in, for example, a civil rights case, the statements made during the internal investigation may come in as evidence. Garrity shields criminal cases specifically.
And the immunity covers only truthful answers. The Supreme Court held in LaChance v. Erickson that an agency can bring a separate disciplinary charge against an employee who lies during an investigation, on top of the underlying misconduct.5Legal Information Institute. LaChance v. Erickson, 522 U.S. 262 (1998) A false statement is also a new criminal act at the moment it is spoken, so it can be prosecuted as perjury, obstruction, or making false statements without Garrity covering it. The real choice at the interview is answer truthfully or invoke the Fifth. Lying is not a safe third option.
When a Warning Is Required
Two conditions have to be present together. The employee must be ordered to answer, and the employee must face a credible threat of serious discipline for refusing. Without the order, participation is voluntary and Garrity does not apply. Without a real threat, there is no compulsion to immunize.
The warning is used across public employment: police officers in internal affairs, firefighters, teachers, corrections officers, municipal clerks, and other government workers facing an administrative inquiry. The underlying conduct can involve possible crimes, but what controls is the nature of the proceeding. If the agency is asking about workplace rules or professional standards and threatening the employee’s job over the answers, Garrity is in play.
How a Garrity Warning Differs From Miranda and Kalkines
These three warnings get confused because all three touch the Fifth Amendment, but they do different work.
A Miranda warning applies when a person is in custody and being interrogated by law enforcement. It tells them they can stay silent and that anything they say can be used against them in criminal court. Garrity runs the other direction: it tells a public employee they must speak or lose their job, and promises that their words cannot be used against them criminally. An officer who is a criminal suspect in custody gets Miranda. The same officer sitting across from internal affairs gets Garrity.
A Kalkines warning is the stronger cousin of Garrity. Instead of a conditional protection that depends on whether a court later finds the statement was coerced, a Kalkines warning grants formal immunity up front and orders the employee to answer. Refusal is treated as insubordination and leads to termination. Agencies generally issue Kalkines warnings only after coordinating with prosecutors, because the grant of immunity takes criminal charges off the table for the conduct discussed.
If the Agency Does Not Give a Written Warning
The constitutional protection comes from the coercion, not the paperwork. If an employee is compelled to answer under a genuine threat of termination and no formal warning is given, the resulting statements are still likely protected from criminal use. The employee has to show they actually believed they would be fired for staying silent and that the belief was reasonable.
Proving that after the fact is harder without a form on the record. Union representatives often advise employees to put a direct question to the supervisor before answering anything: “Am I being ordered to answer these questions as a condition of my employment?” A yes on the record creates the documented compulsion that triggers Garrity, with or without a signed form. Refusing to sign an acknowledgment form, incidentally, does not void a warning that was clearly delivered, and the refusal itself can be treated as insubordination.