No law caps how long a jury can deliberate. A jury can reach a verdict in minutes or take months, and the judge has no authority to impose a deadline that forces a decision. The longest recorded deliberation in U.S. history ran four and a half months in a 1992 civil trial; other juries have come back in under an hour. What a judge controls is the daily schedule and the point at which a deadlocked jury is sent home for good.
Typical Deliberation Times
Most juries finish somewhere between a few hours and a few days. A straightforward case with one charge and limited evidence can wrap up in an afternoon. A complex case with multiple defendants or technical evidence can stretch into weeks.
High-profile verdicts give a sense of the range. The O.J. Simpson murder jury deliberated roughly four hours. The Kyle Rittenhouse jury took about 27 hours over several days. The Elizabeth Holmes fraud jury spent more than 50 hours before returning its verdict.
The outer edges are genuinely extreme. A Connecticut jury once convicted a defendant in six minutes. A criminal jury in Oakland deliberated for four months before acquitting on some charges and deadlocking on the rest. These outliers matter because they illustrate the underlying rule: no external clock controls the process. The jury decides when it is done.
What Makes Deliberations Longer or Shorter
Several factors push the timeline up or down, and they interact in ways that make prediction difficult even for experienced trial lawyers.
- Number of charges and defendants. Each count requires its own decision. A multi-defendant case with dozens of charges can amount to several trials’ worth of questions. In federal court, the jury can return a verdict on any defendant or count it has agreed on while continuing to deliberate on the rest.1Office of the Law Revision Counsel. Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure Rule 31 – Jury Verdict
- Volume and complexity of evidence. Extensive documents, expert testimony, forensic evidence, and financial records all take time to sort through. White-collar fraud juries routinely deliberate longer than those deciding assault charges, even when both involve a single defendant.
- Unanimity requirements. Every criminal conviction in the United States requires a unanimous jury. In federal court this is spelled out in Rule 31 of the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure, which states that “the verdict must be unanimous.” The Supreme Court extended the same rule to state criminal trials in Ramos v. Louisiana, eliminating the last holdout states that had allowed 10-to-2 convictions. Civil juries in federal court must also be unanimous unless the parties agree otherwise before deliberations begin, though many states allow civil verdicts on a three-quarters or five-sixths vote. Lower agreement thresholds generally mean shorter deliberations.1Office of the Law Revision Counsel. Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure Rule 31 – Jury Verdict2Supreme Court of the United States. Ramos v. Louisiana3Legal Information Institute. Federal Rules of Civil Procedure Rule 48 – Number of Jurors, Verdict, Polling
- Jury dynamics. Twelve people with different reasoning styles and life experiences have to talk their way to agreement. One holdout can add days. Interpersonal friction can slow things down even when the evidence points one way.
- Clarity of jury instructions. If the judge’s legal instructions are confusing or involve unfamiliar concepts, jurors spend more time figuring out what standard to apply before they get to the evidence.
- Readbacks of testimony. If jurors ask to hear a witness’s testimony again, the court reporter reads the relevant portion aloud, usually in open court. If the witness testified for hours, the jury may have to hear all of the direct and cross-examination rather than just a snippet, which adds significant time.4Ninth Circuit District & Bankruptcy Courts. Model Jury Instructions – Readback or Playback
When the Jury Cannot Agree
When jurors send a note telling the judge they are deadlocked, the judge does not immediately give up on them. The standard response is an Allen charge, named for the Supreme Court’s 1896 decision in Allen v. United States, which approved the practice.5Justia US Supreme Court. Allen v. United States, 164 U.S. 492 These instructions are sometimes called “dynamite charges” because they are designed to blast a verdict out of a stuck jury.6United States Courts for the Ninth Circuit. Model Criminal Jury Instructions – 7.7 Deadlocked Jury
The core message is that jurors should reconsider their positions with an open mind, listen to each other’s reasoning, and be willing to change a vote if persuaded. At the same time, no juror should abandon an honest belief just to end the deadlock. Courts tread carefully here. An Allen charge that reads as too aggressive can be grounds for appeal if a losing party argues that holdout jurors felt coerced.
If the jury still cannot agree after further deliberation, the judge declares a mistrial. The jury is discharged and the case ends without a resolution.
What Happens After a Hung Jury
A mistrial caused by a hung jury does not prevent the case from being tried again. The Double Jeopardy Clause bars the government from prosecuting someone twice for the same offense after an acquittal, but a hung jury is not an acquittal. The Supreme Court established this principle nearly 200 years ago in United States v. Perez and reaffirmed it in Richardson v. United States, holding that a jury’s failure to reach a verdict is a “manifest necessity” that lets the judge end the trial without barring a second one.7Justia US Supreme Court. Richardson v. United States, 468 U.S. 317
In practice, the prosecution decides whether retrying the case is worth the expense and uncertainty of another trial. There is no limit on how many times a defendant can be retried after a hung jury. Some cases go through two or three trials before producing a verdict or being dropped. In civil cases, the plaintiff makes the same calculation. Either side can also use a hung jury as leverage in settlement or plea negotiations.
One wrinkle in federal court: if the jury agrees on some counts but deadlocks on others, the judge can accept the partial verdict and declare a mistrial only on the unresolved counts.1Office of the Law Revision Counsel. Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure Rule 31 – Jury Verdict The government can then retry the defendant on the unresolved charges while the completed verdicts stand.
Daily Schedule and Sequestration
Jurors do not deliberate around the clock. A typical court day runs from roughly 8:30 or 9:00 a.m. to sometime between 2:30 and 5:00 p.m., with breaks built in. During deliberations the schedule may flex, but judges generally send jurors home at a reasonable hour. Exhausted jurors do not produce good verdicts.
Full sequestration, where jurors are housed in a hotel and cut off from the outside world, is rare. It is reserved almost exclusively for high-profile cases where media saturation or public pressure could influence the outcome. In the vast majority of trials, jurors go home each night with instructions not to discuss the case, read news coverage, or do their own research.
Replacing a Juror Mid-Deliberation
If a juror becomes ill, has a family emergency, or commits misconduct after deliberations have started, the court can substitute an alternate. Federal courts may retain alternates for exactly this purpose even after the jury retires. The catch matters for timing: when an alternate replaces a sitting juror, the judge must instruct the entire jury to start deliberations over from scratch.8Legal Information Institute. Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure Rule 24 – Trial Jurors All prior discussion is legally erased. That protects the new juror’s right to participate fully, but a substitution late in a long deliberation can add substantial time.
If no alternates are available and a juror must be excused, the court can allow the remaining 11 jurors to continue and return a verdict, provided the parties agree or the court finds good cause.