You generally get one eviction appeal as a matter of right, and after that, one or sometimes two further levels of review that a higher court can choose to hear or refuse. So the technical answer to how many times you can appeal an eviction is usually two or three, but the realistic answer for almost every tenant is one. Each level after the first costs more, demands tighter legal arguments, and faces courts that accept only a small fraction of the cases brought to them.
The One Appeal You Are Guaranteed
After a trial court enters an eviction judgment, the losing side has a right to one appeal. You start it by filing a Notice of Appeal with the clerk of the court that issued the order. The deadline is short. Depending on the jurisdiction, you may have as few as five days or as many as thirty from the date the judgment is signed. Miss it and the judgment is final. The landlord can then move straight to removal.
How this first appeal works depends on where you live. In many jurisdictions it is a trial de novo, a brand new trial in a higher court. The earlier proceedings are set aside, both sides present evidence and witnesses from scratch, and new evidence that was not available before can come in. It is a genuine second hearing, not a review of the first one.
In other jurisdictions, the first appeal is traditional appellate review. The higher court examines the trial record for legal errors and does not hear new evidence or testimony. That difference matters. A trial de novo gives you room to fix mistakes from the first hearing; a record-based appeal confines the court to what already happened below.
Discretionary Review at Higher Courts
If you lose the first appeal, there is no automatic right to another. You can petition a higher appellate court, but at that stage the court decides whether to take the case. This is discretionary review, and courts accept only a small share of eviction petitions.
Getting a higher court to agree to hear your case requires more than claiming the lower court got it wrong. Courts typically look for a novel legal question that has not been settled, a split among lower courts applying the same statute, or an issue of broad public importance. The U.S. Supreme Court’s own rules state that review “is not a matter of right, but of judicial discretion” and “will be granted only for compelling reasons.”1Cornell Law – Legal Information Institute. Supreme Court Rule 10 – Considerations Governing Review on Writ of Certiorari State supreme courts apply a similar standard.
If a higher court does accept the case, the proceeding runs on written briefs, sometimes with oral argument. The court can affirm, reverse, or send the case back for further proceedings. The timeline typically adds months.
What Has To Be Wrong For an Appeal To Work
Outside of a trial de novo, an appeal is not a chance to re-argue the facts. The appealing party has to show that the trial court committed a specific legal error serious enough to have potentially changed the result.
The errors that tend to carry weight include the trial court misinterpreting the landlord-tenant statute, misapplying precedent, or committing a procedural violation. One of the most common and most successful grounds is defective service of process: the landlord failed to properly deliver the required notices before filing. If the trial court lacked jurisdiction because notice was deficient, the whole case can fall apart.
Other viable grounds include the court refusing to hear a legitimate defense, admitting evidence that should have been excluded, or denying the tenant adequate time to prepare. Disagreeing with how the judge weighed the evidence is almost never enough by itself. Appellate courts give substantial deference to trial judges’ factual findings.
Staying in the Home While an Appeal Is Pending
Filing a notice of appeal does not, on its own, stop a lockout. To remain in the property during the appeal, most jurisdictions require you to post an appeal bond (sometimes called a supersedeas bond) or deposit money with the court. The bond protects the landlord against losses, like unpaid rent, that pile up while the appeal moves forward. Once the bond is posted and the appeal is properly filed, the court generally cannot issue a writ of possession to remove you.
You usually also have to keep paying rent into the court’s registry throughout the appeal. Stop paying and you can lose the right to stay even though the appeal itself is still going. Courts treat the ongoing rent obligation as separate from the appeal, and the landlord can ask for permission to proceed with removal if you fall behind.
If a sheriff’s lockout is already scheduled before your appeal paperwork is complete, you may need to file an emergency motion for a stay of execution, showing that immediate removal would cause irreparable harm. The timeline is measured in days.
Costs and Fee Waivers
Money is the biggest practical reason tenants rarely get past the first appeal. Costs include the filing fee, the expense of preparing the trial court record (often requiring transcripts), and attorney’s fees. Filing fees for eviction appeals vary widely and commonly fall between a few dollars and several hundred.
The appeal bond is usually the largest hurdle. Bond amounts are often calculated from the total judgment, including back rent and damages, and the full amount has to go to the court clerk before the appeal can proceed.
Tenants who cannot afford these costs can apply for a fee waiver by filing a financial hardship affidavit, sometimes called an “in forma pauperis” petition. Federal law allows any person to proceed without prepaying fees or posting security by submitting an affidavit showing an inability to pay.2Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 28 USC 1915 – Proceedings In Forma Pauperis Most state courts have an equivalent process. Even where a waiver covers filing costs and the appeal bond, you may still have to deposit ongoing rent payments into the court’s registry to stay in the property.
Risk of Sanctions for Frivolous Appeals
Courts can punish appeals that have no legitimate legal basis. Under the Federal Rules of Appellate Procedure, when a court finds an appeal frivolous, it can award the opposing party damages along with single or double costs.3United States Courts. Federal Rule of Appellate Procedure 38 – Frivolous Appeal, Damages and Costs State courts have parallel rules allowing sanctions, including reasonable attorney’s fees against the party who filed the meritless appeal, against their attorney, or both.
An appeal is most likely to be called frivolous when the lower court’s judgment was so clearly correct that no reasonable argument supports overturning it, or when the appealing party engages in misconduct. Filing repeated appeals purely to delay a lockout, without identifying a genuine legal error, can leave you owing the landlord’s attorney’s fees on top of everything else. Those awards can reach into the tens of thousands of dollars depending on the legal work involved.
Why the First Appeal Is Effectively the Only One
The system offers two or three levels of review on paper, but the realistic number of appeals most tenants can pursue is one. Each successive level demands more money, more sophisticated legal arguments, and more time. The requirement to keep posting bonds and paying rent into the registry throughout the process makes stacked appeals financially unsustainable for most people. The legal standard also tightens at every stage. The first appeal may be a trial de novo where you get a fresh start; later review is limited to narrow questions of law where appellate courts give wide latitude to the judges below.
The best move is to treat the first appeal as the main event. File within the deadline. Post the bond or apply for a waiver right away. Deposit rent with the court on time. If the appeal will be a new trial, gather every piece of evidence and every witness you can. Getting the first appeal right matters far more than counting on a second one.