How to Contest a Will in the UK: Grounds, Deadlines, and Costs

To contest a will in the UK (specifically in England and Wales), you take one of two routes: you either challenge the will’s legal validity on grounds like lack of capacity, undue influence, improper execution, fraud, or lack of knowledge and approval, or you bring a claim under the Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975 arguing the will failed to make reasonable financial provision for you. The two are not interchangeable. They have different grounds, different eligible claimants, and crucially different deadlines, and most people who say they want to contest a will actually need the second route.

Which Type of Claim You Actually Have

A validity challenge says the will should be set aside because something was legally wrong with how it was made or who made it. If a validity challenge succeeds, the court falls back on an earlier valid will or, if none exists, on the intestacy rules.

A 1975 Act claim does not say the will is invalid. It accepts the will is legally sound and argues it failed to provide adequately for someone the deceased had a responsibility toward. The court can then redistribute part of the estate to put that right.

Picking the wrong route wastes time you may not have. If your real complaint is that an adult child or a cohabiting partner was left with nothing, that is almost always a 1975 Act claim, not a validity challenge, and the six-month clock is already running.

Who Can Bring a Challenge

The law requires a direct interest in the outcome. You cannot contest a will simply because you disagree with it.

For a validity challenge, standing belongs to anyone who would benefit if the will were overturned: beneficiaries under the current will, beneficiaries under an earlier will who were cut out, and anyone who would inherit under the intestacy rules if no valid will existed.

For a 1975 Act claim, the statute sets a closed list:1Legislation.gov.uk. Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975, Section 1

  • A spouse or civil partner of the deceased
  • A former spouse or civil partner who has not remarried or formed a new civil partnership
  • A cohabitant who lived with the deceased as a couple for the entire two years immediately before the death
  • A child of the deceased, including adult children
  • Someone treated as a child of the family in relation to any marriage or civil partnership the deceased was part of
  • Anyone else who was being maintained, wholly or partly, by the deceased immediately before the death

If you do not fall into one of these categories, the 1975 Act is not open to you no matter how unfair the will feels.

Grounds for Challenging a Will’s Validity

Lack of Testamentary Capacity

The testator must have had the mental ability to make a valid will at the moment they signed it. The test from Banks v Goodfellow (1870) requires that the testator understood they were making a will, grasped the extent of their property, appreciated who had a reasonable claim on their estate, and was not suffering from any mental disorder that distorted their judgment.

Capacity is assessed at the moment of signing, not generally. Someone with early dementia may have had lucid days; someone who seemed sharp may have been confused on the specific day. Medical records around the date of execution are often the most important evidence.

Undue Influence

Undue influence means someone coerced the testator into making a will that did not reflect what they actually wanted. The bar is high. Persuasion, emotional appeals, and even persistent nagging do not qualify. The pressure must have been so overpowering that the will became the product of someone else’s wishes.

Evidence is almost always circumstantial, because this kind of pressure happens behind closed doors. Courts look for patterns: isolation of the testator from family, a sudden change in the will favouring someone in a position of trust, the influencer being heavily involved in arranging the will’s preparation, or the testator being vulnerable.

Improper Execution

The Wills Act 1837 sets strict formalities. The will must be in writing and signed by the testator (or by someone else at their direction and in their presence); the signature must be intended to give effect to the will; the testator must sign or acknowledge the signature in the presence of two witnesses present at the same time; and each witness must then sign in the testator’s presence.2Legislation.gov.uk. Wills Act 1837 Section 9

Failures are more common than people assume. A witness who stepped out before the testator signed, witnesses who signed at different times, or an ambiguous mark used by the testator without clear intent to authenticate can all invalidate the will. These challenges are often the most straightforward because the defects are objective.

Lack of Knowledge and Approval

Even if the testator had capacity in general, a will can be challenged on the basis that they did not actually know or approve of its specific contents. Capacity asks whether the testator was capable of understanding a will; knowledge and approval asks whether they actually understood this one.

This comes up where a testator signed a long document without reading it, had poor eyesight and was not offered the chance to have the will read aloud, or did not speak English well and had no interpreter. If the circumstances raise suspicion, the burden shifts to the person upholding the will to prove the testator genuinely knew and approved its contents.

Fraud or Forgery

A will can be challenged where someone fabricated the document, forged the testator’s signature, or deceived the testator about what the will contained. These are the most serious allegations and amount to criminal conduct, so courts require correspondingly strong evidence. Handwriting analysis, forensic document examination, and evidence of the testator’s actual intentions all feature.

Improper Revocation

A will can be revoked by a later valid will or codicil, by the testator’s marriage or civil partnership, or by physical destruction with the intention to revoke. Marriage automatically revokes an existing will unless the will was made in contemplation of that particular marriage.3Legislation.gov.uk. Wills Act 1837 Section 18 If a revocation was carried out improperly, the earlier will may still stand; and if a replacement will fails on any of the grounds above, the earlier one may spring back into effect.

What a 1975 Act Claim Has to Show

The court asks whether the will, the intestacy rules, or some combination made “reasonable financial provision” for the applicant.1Legislation.gov.uk. Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975, Section 1

What counts as reasonable depends on who is claiming. A surviving spouse or civil partner is measured against a broader standard: what would be reasonable for a spouse to receive in all the circumstances, whether or not they need it for day-to-day living. Everyone else is measured against a maintenance standard, so the court asks only whether provision is enough to meet their reasonable living costs.4Legislation.gov.uk. Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975

The distinction matters. A spouse can argue for a fair share of the estate outright. An adult child generally has to show a financial need the will fails to address, though courts have shown some flexibility with very large estates or clear moral obligations.

Deadlines

The deadlines for the two routes are different, and the 1975 Act deadline is the one that catches people out.

Six Months for 1975 Act Claims

Applications under the Inheritance Act 1975 must be made within six months from the date the grant of probate (or letters of administration) is issued. The clock runs from the grant date, not the date of death. After six months you can still apply, but you need the court’s permission, and courts are reluctant once the estate has been distributed. If executors have handed out assets in good faith after the window closes, recovering them is extremely difficult.

No Fixed Deadline for Validity Challenges

There is no statutory deadline for a validity challenge, but delay still kills claims. Under the doctrine of laches, courts can dismiss claims where delay has been unreasonable and caused real prejudice to others. Recent cases have seen challenges barred after seven and a half years once the claimant had the information they needed, and an eighteen-year delay was dismissed as well. Evidence disappears, memories fade, and the estate may already be gone.

Preserving the Estate and Gathering Evidence

Starting early is critical. Records become harder to obtain as time passes, and once an estate has been distributed, undoing that is a different and much harder problem.

Getting the Will and Lodging a Caveat

If probate has already been granted, anyone can obtain a copy of the will from the Probate Registry for a fee of £16 per copy.5The Gazette. Copy Probate Fees Set to Increase If probate has not yet been granted, you can lodge a caveat, which prevents probate from being issued for six months and can be extended for a further six.6GOV.UK. Stopping a Probate Application A caveat buys time to investigate without the estate being distributed while you are still building your case.

The Larke v Nugus Request

One of the most useful tools is a Larke v Nugus request: a letter to the solicitor who drafted the will asking for their file and a detailed account of how the will came about. The response typically covers notes from meetings and calls, who was present when instructions were given, what the solicitor did to satisfy themselves about capacity, whether the testator was alone during the process, and whether any earlier wills were discussed. The solicitor can charge a reasonable fee, and guidance suggests a response within two to three weeks is reasonable. The file can be decisive for claims based on capacity, undue influence, or lack of knowledge and approval.

Other Evidence That Matters

Medical records, particularly GP notes and specialist assessments from around the date of signing, are essential for capacity claims. Financial records can reveal unusual transactions pointing toward undue influence or fraud. Witness statements from people who knew the testator or were present during the will’s preparation give context about state of mind and the circumstances of signing. Correspondence, emails, and messages between the testator and family can show what the testator actually intended and whether their wishes shifted suddenly.

How the Claim Proceeds

Pre-Action Steps

Before issuing proceedings, parties are expected to follow a pre-action protocol: exchange relevant documents, set out the basis of the claim in writing, and give the other side a fair chance to respond. Skipping this or refusing to engage can bring costs penalties later, even if you win at trial.

Mediation

Courts actively encourage mediation in will disputes, and judges take a dim view of parties who refuse to try it. Mediation is private, flexible, and allows families to reach outcomes a court could not impose. Where inheritance disputes are entangled with years of family dynamics, a mediator can often reach an answer a courtroom cannot. A mediated agreement is final once signed.

The cost difference is real. A mediation might resolve the matter in a day. Court proceedings routinely take eighteen months to two years to reach trial, with legal costs mounting the whole time.

Court Proceedings

If negotiation and mediation fail, the claim goes to court. That involves filing a formal claim, exchanging detailed evidence including witness statements and expert reports, and presenting the case at trial. There is no jury. A judge hears the evidence, assesses the witnesses, and decides. Most contested will cases settle before trial; the ones that don’t tend to involve very large estates or deeply entrenched family conflict.

Costs and the Risk of Losing

Legal fees for a case that goes to trial can exceed £50,000 per party, and that figure rises for complex estates or cases involving forensic evidence and multiple experts.

The general rule in English litigation is that the loser pays the winner’s costs, but will disputes carry more nuance. Where the challenge arises from genuine ambiguity in the will or legitimate concerns about capacity, the court may order costs to be paid from the estate. Where someone brings a frivolous challenge or behaves unreasonably, the court can order them to bear the costs personally. Partial orders, splitting costs between the estate and individual parties, are also common.

Contesting a will is not risk-free. Even with a strong case, the possibility of paying the other side’s costs should factor into the decision. Many solicitors offer an initial assessment to gauge the strength of a claim before significant money is committed.

No-Contest Clauses

Some wills include a no-contest or forfeiture clause saying any beneficiary who challenges the will loses their inheritance. In England and Wales these clauses are generally enforceable if clearly drafted. But courts will not allow them to shut down a challenge with legitimate legal merit, such as genuine concerns about capacity, undue influence, or fraud. A no-contest clause also cannot override statutory rights under the 1975 Act, so eligible applicants can still bring a reasonable financial provision claim regardless of what the will says.

The practical effect is that a no-contest clause adds risk for a beneficiary who stands to lose an existing gift by challenging, but it is not an absolute barrier. Where the grounds are solid, the clause is unlikely to survive scrutiny.