In What States Can You Resist an Unlawful Arrest?

Only a handful of states still recognize the common law right to resist an unlawful arrest. States where that right has been preserved through case law or statutory language include Georgia, Michigan, Mississippi, Alabama, Louisiana, Maryland, South Carolina, and West Virginia. The majority of U.S. jurisdictions have abolished the right by statute or court decision, requiring you to submit to any arrest by a known officer and challenge its legality later. Even in states where the right survives, it is narrower than most people assume, and criminal defense attorneys in those states almost uniformly advise against using it.

States That Still Recognize the Right

This area of law shifts as courts revisit old precedent, so the following reflects the current legal picture rather than a permanent list.

  • Georgia. The Georgia Supreme Court reaffirmed the right in 2020 in Glenn v. State, holding that “the common-law right to resist an unlawful arrest includes the right to use proportionate force” to escape an unlawful detention.1Justia Law. Glenn v. Georgia (2020)
  • Michigan. The Michigan Supreme Court ruled in People v. Moreno (2012) that the common law right to resist an unlawful arrest still applies, overturning a lower court decision that had tried to abolish it.
  • Mississippi. The state’s resisting arrest statute criminalizes obstructing only a “lawful arrest,” which courts have read as preserving the right to resist an arrest that lacks legal authority.2Justia Law. Mississippi Code 97-9-73 – Resisting or Obstructing Arrest
  • Alabama
  • Louisiana
  • Maryland
  • South Carolina
  • West Virginia

Tennessee is sometimes included on older lists, but the state has legislatively abolished the defense. Tennessee’s resisting arrest statute explicitly provides that “it is no defense to prosecution under this section that the stop, frisk, halt, arrest or search was unlawful.”3Justia Law. Tennessee Code 39-16-602 – Resisting Stop, Frisk, Halt, Arrest or Search Any source that still lists Tennessee is outdated.

The U.S. Supreme Court endorsed the broader common law principle in 1900 in Bad Elk v. United States, holding that a person could resist an officer who had no right to arrest them using “no more force than was absolutely necessary to repel the assault constituting the attempt to arrest.”4Justia U.S. Supreme Court Center. John Bad Elk v. United States, 177 U.S. 529 (1900)5Cleveland State Law Review. Resisting Unlawful Arrest: A Due Process Perspective6University of Pennsylvania Law School. Model Penal Code – Article 3, General Principles of Justification

What Counts as an Unlawful Arrest

The right only applies where the arrest is actually unlawful, so the threshold question matters. An officer must either hold a valid arrest warrant or have probable cause to believe you committed a crime. Probable cause means more than a hunch. The officer needs enough factual basis that a reasonable person would conclude a crime occurred or is occurring. An arrest without a warrant and without probable cause violates the Fourth Amendment and is unlawful.

Courts in states that still recognize the right have not read it as a broad license to fight back against any arrest a person disagrees with. It applies when the arrest genuinely lacks probable cause or a valid warrant, and only when the response stays within strict force limits.

How Much Force the Law Allows

In states that recognize the right, the force you can use is limited to what is reasonable and proportional. That means non-deadly force. Pulling your arm away from an officer’s grip or physically disengaging from a hold sits inside the line. Striking an officer, using a weapon, or causing injury almost certainly does not, regardless of whether the underlying arrest was lawful.

The Bad Elk standard of “no more force than was absolutely necessary to repel the assault” still frames the analysis.4Justia U.S. Supreme Court Center. John Bad Elk v. United States, 177 U.S. 529 (1900) Passive resistance like going limp or verbally refusing sits at one end of the spectrum. Actively fighting back sits at the other. The further the response moves toward active violence, the harder it becomes to argue the force was reasonable, even where the arrest was clearly unlawful.

South Carolina’s statute illustrates how courts treat the escalation. Simple resistance is a misdemeanor carrying up to one year in jail and a $1,000 fine. Resistance involving assault on an officer is a felony carrying up to ten years and a $10,000 fine.7South Carolina Legislature. South Carolina Code of Laws Title 16, Chapter 9

When the Officer Doesn’t Identify Themselves

The Model Penal Code’s prohibition applies only when “the actor knows” the person making the arrest is a peace officer. If a plainclothes or undercover officer grabs you without identifying themselves, that knowledge requirement may not be met, and even states that have otherwise abolished the right to resist may treat the resistance differently.

Some states require officers to identify themselves before using force. Missouri law requires that before using force during an arrest, an officer make “every reasonable effort to advise the person that he is the peace officer engaged in making arrest.” An officer in street clothes who skips that step weakens the prosecution’s ability to charge resisting, because the charge typically requires that you knew or reasonably should have known the person was law enforcement.

Self-Defense Against Excessive Force

The right to defend yourself against an officer using excessive or deadly force is separate from the right to resist an unlawful arrest, and it generally survives even in states that have abolished the resistance right. Tennessee’s statute abolishes the unlawful-arrest defense but explicitly carves out an exception for its self-defense provisions.3Justia Law. Tennessee Code 39-16-602 – Resisting Stop, Frisk, Halt, Arrest or Search

The threshold is high. Excessive force claims are evaluated under an objective reasonableness standard: whether a reasonable officer in the same situation would have used that level of force. An officer generally cannot use lethal force unless facing a reasonable threat of death or serious injury. If an officer crosses that line, the person being arrested may have grounds to use proportionate force in self-defense, but proving it after the fact is extraordinarily difficult. Juries tend to give officers the benefit of the doubt, and the person claiming self-defense bears the burden of showing the force was truly necessary.

Why Lawyers Say Don’t Resist Anyway

Even in states that preserve the right, criminal defense attorneys will tell you not to use it. The reasons stack up quickly.

You are making a real-time legal judgment that courts spend months analyzing with the benefit of full evidence. If you resist and a court later determines the officer did have probable cause, you have committed a crime. Resisting arrest is typically a misdemeanor carrying up to a year in jail, but if the encounter escalates and an officer is injured, felony assault charges with years of prison time become possible.

Physical resistance also creates an escalation cycle. Officers are trained to overcome resistance with greater force. What begins as pulling away can turn into a tasing, a takedown, or worse within seconds. Any injuries you sustain during resistance to what later turns out to be a lawful arrest will receive little sympathy from a court.

A conviction creates lasting collateral damage too. Under EEOC guidance, employers must consider the nature of the offense and the time elapsed when evaluating a criminal record, but a resisting arrest conviction, particularly a felony, can block you from professional licenses, government employment, and security clearances.8U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission. Arrest and Conviction Records: Resources for Job Seekers, Workers and Employers Those consequences persist long after any jail sentence ends.

Challenging an Unlawful Arrest After the Fact

The safer path is to comply during the arrest and challenge its legality through the courts. Several avenues exist.

Motion to Suppress

If you are charged with a crime following an unlawful arrest, your attorney can file a motion to suppress any evidence obtained as a result. If the court agrees the arrest lacked probable cause, the evidence is thrown out, and charges often collapse without it. This remedy works inside the criminal case itself.

Federal Civil Rights Lawsuit

Under 42 U.S.C. ยง 1983, you can sue officers who violated your constitutional rights while acting under the authority of state law.9Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 42 U.S. Code 1983 – Civil Action for Deprivation of Rights A successful claim can yield compensatory damages for lost work, legal fees, and emotional distress, plus punitive damages in cases of egregious conduct. Attorneys’ fees are also recoverable. The main obstacle is qualified immunity, which protects officers from personal liability unless the right they violated was “clearly established” by closely analogous prior cases. Strong facts and experienced counsel matter.

Administrative Complaint

You can file a complaint with the officer’s department, usually through internal affairs. Federal guidelines recommend departments accept complaints in any reasonable form, provide a written acknowledgment with a reference number and investigator contact information, and complete the investigation within 180 days.10U.S. Department of Justice, COPS Office. Standards and Guidelines for Internal Affairs: Recommendations from a Community of Practice An administrative complaint will not get you money, but it creates a paper trail that can support a later civil lawsuit and may trigger discipline.

None of these remedies require you to have resisted. Complying peacefully strengthens your credibility in every one of them.