Some of the most interesting court cases in American law began with ordinary moments: a married couple driving home, a woman buying coffee at a drive-through, a monkey picking up a camera. The rulings that followed decided who can legally marry, what a company owes a burned customer, whether a soda ad can promise a fighter jet, and who counts as the author of a photograph or a piece of AI-generated art.
The Two Cases That Redefined Marriage
The Fourteenth Amendment says no state can deny any person equal protection of the laws or deprive someone of liberty without due process.1Congress.gov. U.S. Constitution – Fourteenth Amendment Those few words sit behind two of the most consequential marriage decisions the Supreme Court has ever issued.
Loving v. Virginia (1967)
Richard Loving, a white man, and Mildred Jeter, a Black woman, traveled to Washington, D.C., to marry in 1958. When they returned home to Virginia, they were arrested under the state’s Racial Integrity Act, which made interracial marriage a crime. They were sentenced to a year in prison, suspended on the condition that they leave Virginia and not return together for 25 years.
The Supreme Court took up a question it had not directly answered before: whether a state could ban marriage based on racial classification.2Justia U.S. Supreme Court Center. Loving v. Virginia The justices unanimously struck down the Virginia law, holding that marriage is a fundamental civil right and that restricting it by race violated both the Equal Protection Clause and the Due Process Clause. Similar laws in roughly a dozen other states fell with it.
Obergefell v. Hodges (2015)
Nearly fifty years later, fourteen same-sex couples and two men whose partners had died challenged laws in Michigan, Kentucky, Ohio, and Tennessee that defined marriage as between one man and one woman. They argued the Fourteenth Amendment required states to issue marriage licenses to same-sex couples and to recognize same-sex marriages performed in other states.3Justia U.S. Supreme Court Center. Obergefell v. Hodges
By a 5-4 vote, the Court agreed. The majority held that the right to marry is a fundamental liberty protected by the Due Process Clause and that denying it to same-sex couples also violated the Equal Protection Clause. The opinion drew explicitly on Loving, framing marriage as central to individual autonomy and dignity. Same-sex marriage became legal nationwide, and every state was required to recognize lawful same-sex marriages from other jurisdictions.
The McDonald’s Coffee Verdict That Wasn’t Frivolous
For decades, Liebeck v. McDonald’s Restaurants has been treated as a punchline. The facts are not funny.
In 1992, 79-year-old Stella Liebeck bought a cup of coffee at a McDonald’s drive-through in Albuquerque, New Mexico. She was sitting in a parked car when the cup spilled in her lap. The coffee, served between 180 and 190 degrees Fahrenheit, caused third-degree burns over 16 percent of her body, including places where the skin burned down to the muscle and fatty tissue. She spent eight days in the hospital, had skin grafts, and needed two years of medical treatment.
Trial testimony filled in the rest. McDonald’s had received more than 700 prior complaints from customers burned by its coffee. Industry experts testified that other restaurants served coffee at roughly 140 degrees, meaning McDonald’s product ran 40 to 50 degrees hotter than the norm. The company’s own quality control manager testified that McDonald’s knew its coffee caused serious burns but had no plans to lower the temperature or warn customers beyond a small reminder on the cup.
The jury found McDonald’s liable for gross negligence and awarded Liebeck $160,000 in compensatory damages, reduced from $200,000 because the jury assigned her 20 percent of the fault. It added $2.7 million in punitive damages, roughly two days of McDonald’s coffee revenue at the time.
The trial judge then used a process called remittitur, which lets a judge who finds a jury award excessive reduce the amount and give the plaintiff the choice between accepting the lower figure or going to a new trial. He cut the punitive damages to $480,000, three times the compensatory award, while describing McDonald’s conduct as “willful, wanton, and reckless.” The parties settled for a confidential amount reportedly under $500,000. Liebeck, who initially just wanted her medical bills covered, never received millions.
A Harrier Jet for Seven Million Pepsi Points
In the mid-1990s, Pepsi ran a promotion called “Pepsi Stuff” that let customers trade points from Pepsi products for merchandise. A television commercial showed a teenager landing at school in a Harrier military jet, captioned “HARRIER FIGHTER 7,000,000 PEPSI POINTS.”4Justia. Leonard v. Pepsico, Inc.
John Leonard took it seriously. The Pepsi Stuff catalog let customers buy additional points for ten cents each, so Leonard raised about $700,000 from investors, bought 7 million points, and submitted an order form for the jet. When Pepsi refused, he sued for breach of contract and specific performance.
The case turned on the difference between an offer and a joke. Judge Kimba Wood of the Southern District of New York ruled that no objective, reasonable person would have understood the commercial to be a serious offer for a military fighter jet worth roughly $23 million as part of a soda promotion. The court noted that advertisements are generally invitations for consumers to make an offer, not binding contracts, and that the commercial’s humor made it incapable of forming an enforceable agreement. Pepsi later re-cut the ad to list the jet at 700 million points.
Who Counts as an Author: Monkeys and Machines
Copyright protects original works of authorship. Courts have spent recent years working out who, exactly, qualifies as an “author.”
The Monkey Selfie Case
In 2011, wildlife photographer David Slater left his camera unattended in an Indonesian jungle. A crested macaque named Naruto picked it up and snapped several photographs, including a now-famous grinning selfie. PETA sued on the monkey’s behalf, claiming Naruto owned the copyright.
The Ninth Circuit ruled that whatever Naruto did with the shutter button, animals do not have standing to sue for copyright infringement under the Copyright Act. Giving animals the right to bring lawsuits, the court said, would require Congress to say so, and the statute does not.5United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit. Naruto v. Slater The Copyright Office’s own practices manual echoes the point: the office “will refuse to register a claim if it determines that a human being did not create the work.”6U.S. Copyright Office. Copyrightable Authorship: What Can Be Registered
AI-Generated Art and Thaler v. Perlmutter
The same human-authorship rule has become the central question for artificial intelligence. Stephen Thaler built an AI system he called the “Creativity Machine” and tried to register a piece of visual art it generated, listing the AI as the author. The Copyright Office refused. Thaler sued.
The D.C. Circuit ruled against him, holding that the Copyright Act requires copyrightable work to be authored by a human. The court pointed out that the statute treats authors as having human qualities like lifespans, family members, and nationalities, none of which apply to machines.7United States Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit. Thaler v. Perlmutter On March 2, 2026, the Supreme Court declined to hear the case, leaving that ruling in place.8Supreme Court of the United States. No. 25-449
The ruling does not shut out all AI-involved work. The Copyright Office has issued guidance that people who use AI as a tool can still claim copyright, as long as a human exercised creative control over the final product. The line falls between using AI the way a photographer uses a camera and letting the AI make the creative choices itself. If the AI determines the expressive elements, that output is not copyrightable. If a human selects, arranges, and edits AI material into something new, the human’s contributions can be protected. Applicants have to disclose which parts of a work were AI-generated and claim copyright only over what they personally created.9Federal Register. Copyright Registration Guidance: Works Containing Material Generated by Artificial Intelligence
The $54 Million Pair of Pants
At the other end of the spectrum from Liebeck sits Pearson v. Chung. In 2005, Roy Pearson, himself an administrative law judge in Washington, D.C., dropped off a pair of pants at Custom Cleaners, a small dry cleaner owned by Jin and Soo Chung. He claimed the shop returned the wrong pair.
Pearson sued for $54 million, and the trial judge calculated the claim could reach as much as $67 million under his various theories.10FindLaw. Pearson v. Chung His argument leaned on the shop’s “Satisfaction Guaranteed” sign, which he treated as an unconditional promise enforceable at virtually unlimited value. The trial court rejected that outright, finding no reasonable consumer would read a standard satisfaction guarantee that way. Pearson was ordered to pay the Chungs’ court costs, and the case was affirmed on appeal. The Chungs had already spent years and substantial legal fees defending themselves.
What Stops a Baseless Lawsuit
Pearson’s case raises the obvious question: can courts punish someone for filing a meritless suit? They can, though the threshold is high.
Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 11 requires every attorney or unrepresented party who files a document to certify that it has a legitimate basis. The filing cannot be made for an improper purpose like harassment, the legal arguments must be supported by existing law or a reasonable argument for changing it, and the factual claims must have evidentiary support or a good-faith basis for believing support will emerge in discovery.11Legal Information Institute. Rule 11 – Signing Pleadings, Motions, and Other Papers; Representations to the Court; Sanctions
When a court finds a Rule 11 violation, available sanctions include ordering the losing party to pay the other side’s attorney fees, penalties paid into the court, or non-monetary directives like mandatory legal education. The sanction has to be proportional, limited to whatever is needed to deter the same conduct in the future. Courts in many jurisdictions can also designate someone a “vexatious litigant” after a pattern of meritless filings, which typically means a judge’s permission is needed before filing anything new. For small business owners like the Chungs, who had already spent years defending a claim everyone recognized as absurd, those tools arrive late. The damage from a frivolous lawsuit lands long before any court gets around to sanctioning the person who filed it.