Is Attempted Robbery a Crime? Elements, Penalties, Defenses

The penalties for attempted robbery are nearly identical to those for a completed robbery. Under federal law, an attempt can draw up to 20 years in prison, or up to 25 years if a dangerous weapon was involved, and life or the death penalty if anyone died during the attempt. A conviction is a felony in every jurisdiction, which triggers a lifetime federal firearm ban and long-term barriers to work, housing, and, for non-citizens, remaining in the country.

What the Prosecution Has to Prove

Before any sentence is on the table, prosecutors must establish two things: specific intent to commit the robbery and a substantial step toward carrying it out.1Ninth Circuit District & Bankruptcy Courts. Manual of Model Criminal Jury Instructions – 9.8 Hobbs Act Robbery or Attempted Robbery (18 USC 1951)

Specific intent is a higher mental bar than many crimes carry. It isn’t enough that the defendant intended some physical act; the prosecution must show a conscious plan to take property by force or threat. Idle thoughts, boasting, or research alone won’t support a conviction.

The substantial step is the harder-fought question. Thinking about a robbery, scouting a target, or telling someone your plan generally isn’t enough on its own. The Ninth Circuit’s standard is that the defendant’s conduct must “unequivocally demonstrate that the crime will take place unless interrupted.”1Ninth Circuit District & Bankruptcy Courts. Manual of Model Criminal Jury Instructions – 9.8 Hobbs Act Robbery or Attempted Robbery (18 USC 1951) Courts have found that line crossed by acts like passing a demand note to a bank teller, arriving at the target armed and masked, or brandishing a weapon at the intended victim. Model Penal Code jurisdictions require conduct that “strongly corroborates” the criminal intent, and recognize categories like entering a building unlawfully, lying in wait for the victim, or possessing crime-specific tools at the scene.2H2O. Model Penal Code (MPC) 5.01 Criminal Attempt

Federal Prison Terms

Two federal statutes carry most attempted robbery prosecutions, and each sets a maximum rather than a mandatory minimum for the base offense.

The Hobbs Act covers attempted robbery that affects interstate commerce, which courts read broadly enough to reach ordinary stores stocked with out-of-state goods. The maximum is 20 years in prison, a fine, or both.3Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 18 USC 1951 – Interference With Commerce by Threats or Violence

Federal bank robbery under 18 U.S.C. § 2113 specifically names attempts alongside completed offenses:4Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 18 USC 2113 – Bank Robbery and Incidental Crimes

  • Up to 20 years for an attempt by force or intimidation.
  • Up to 25 years if a dangerous weapon was used or threatened during the attempt.
  • A mandatory minimum of 10 years and a maximum of life imprisonment or death if anyone was killed during the attempt.

Those numbers are the same ones a defendant would face for a completed bank robbery under the same statute. Congress wrote no discount into the text for failing to get the money.

When an Attempt Can Draw a Lower Sentence

Even where the statute treats attempts and completed crimes identically, the federal sentencing guidelines leave some room to argue for less time. Under Guideline § 2X1.1, an attempt starts at the same base offense level as the completed offense, but a judge may reduce the level by three points if the defendant was arrested well before finishing the acts necessary for the crime.5United States Sentencing Commission. 2023 Guidelines Manual – Chapter 2 Offense Conduct The reduction is unavailable if the defendant had completed everything they believed necessary, or if police interrupted the crime at the last moment. Most attempted robbery prosecutions involve nearly completed conduct, so the reduction is rarely applied in practice.

State codes shaped by the Model Penal Code use a similar approach: attempts are generally graded at the same level as the completed crime, with one exception. An attempt to commit a first-degree felony is treated as a second-degree felony.6University of Pennsylvania Law School. Model Penal Code – Section 5.05 Grading of Criminal Attempt, Solicitation and Conspiracy Other states reduce attempt penalties by a fixed percentage or by one offense grade. Some, like federal law under the Hobbs Act, draw no distinction at all.

What Pushes the Sentence Up or Down

Within the statutory ranges, the actual term depends on what the judge finds about the circumstances of the offense and the defendant.

Aggravating factors that drive sentences higher include:

  • Weapon use. A firearm in the hand changes the calculus completely; under § 2113, simply using a dangerous weapon adds five years to the ceiling.4Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 18 USC 2113 – Bank Robbery and Incidental Crimes
  • Prior serious violent felony convictions. Under federal law, two or more such priors can trigger a mandatory life sentence.7Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 18 US Code 3559 – Sentencing Classification of Offenses
  • Physical injury to the victim, even without completion of the robbery.
  • Targeting elderly, disabled, or child victims.

On the other side, judges weigh a clean record, a minor role in a group offense, cooperation with investigators, and early acceptance of responsibility. The federal guidelines provide specific offense-level reductions for defendants who plead guilty and take responsibility early in the process.

Charges That Stack On Top

Attempted robbery is rarely charged alone. The same conduct almost always supports additional offenses, and the sentences for those can run consecutively.

Assault is the most common companion charge. Any physical contact or threat during the attempt can support a separate count, and if a weapon was involved, the charge rises to aggravated assault with its own lengthy prison term. When two or more people plan the offense together, conspiracy charges apply to every participant, including lookouts and drivers, and conspiracy is a distinct crime that can be punished alongside the attempt.

Felony Murder

This is the exposure that turns an attempted robbery charge into something life-altering. Under the felony murder rule, which exists in nearly every state and in federal law, any death during a robbery or attempted robbery can result in murder charges against everyone involved. Robbery is treated as an inherently dangerous felony, so the rule applies automatically. If a co-defendant fires a gun and kills a bystander during a failed robbery, every participant can be charged with murder, even one who never handled a weapon and never intended for anyone to be hurt. The federal bank robbery statute states the result directly: if death results during the attempted commission of the offense, the penalty is life imprisonment or death.4Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 18 USC 2113 – Bank Robbery and Incidental Crimes

Life After the Sentence

Prison and fines are only the start. A felony conviction for attempted robbery sets off restrictions that outlast the sentence itself.

Federal law bans anyone convicted of a crime punishable by more than one year of imprisonment from possessing firearms or ammunition.8Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 18 USC 922 – Unlawful Acts Attempted robbery is a felony everywhere, so the ban applies in every case. It is a lifetime prohibition unless the conviction is expunged or rights are specifically restored, and violating it is itself a separate federal felony.

Background-check employers treat a violent felony conviction as one of the most disqualifying results they can see. Professional licenses in healthcare, finance, law, and education are often unavailable or hard to obtain with a robbery-related felony on record. Many landlords and public housing authorities screen for violent felony convictions as well.

For non-citizens, the stakes are higher still. Robbery and attempted robbery are generally classified as aggravated felonies under federal immigration law, which can trigger mandatory deportation, permanent inadmissibility, and a bar on future entry. That consequence is often irreversible no matter how old the conviction becomes.

Voting rights depend on the state. Some restore them automatically upon release; others impose waiting periods or require a petition. A felony conviction can also disqualify a person from jury service, holding public office, and certain federal benefits.

Defenses to the Charge

Because the offense is an attempt rather than a completed act, some defenses are available that wouldn’t apply to a finished robbery.

Voluntary Abandonment

Under the Model Penal Code and the laws of many states, a defendant can raise an affirmative defense by proving they voluntarily abandoned the attempt before it was completed. The abandonment has to be both complete and voluntary.2H2O. Model Penal Code (MPC) 5.01 Criminal Attempt

Voluntary means the decision to stop didn’t come from an increased risk of getting caught. Walking away because a security guard appeared, or because the target proved harder than expected, doesn’t qualify. The change of heart has to come from within. Complete means the person actually gave up on the crime rather than postponing it or shifting to a different target. Deciding to rob a different store next week isn’t abandonment. And when accomplices are involved, one person’s abandonment doesn’t protect the others; each participant’s liability stands or falls on its own.2H2O. Model Penal Code (MPC) 5.01 Criminal Attempt

Impossibility

Impossibility defenses arise when the crime couldn’t have been completed. Factual impossibility, where real-world circumstances blocked success (robbing someone who turned out to have no money, for example), is not a defense. A conviction for attempted robbery can stand even if the victim had nothing to take.9Legal Information Institute. Impossibility

Legal impossibility is different. It applies where the defendant believed their conduct was criminal but the act they performed wasn’t actually illegal. It rarely matters in robbery cases, because taking property by force is unambiguously a crime, but it remains an established principle in attempt law.9Legal Information Institute. Impossibility