Not telling a sexual partner you have herpes can be illegal, and even where it isn’t a crime, it can expose you to a civil lawsuit with damages reaching into the millions. Whether criminal charges are on the table depends on your state’s statutes and how they’re worded. Civil liability, by contrast, exists almost everywhere a partner can prove you knew about your diagnosis, stayed silent, and transmitted the infection.
When Non-Disclosure Is a Crime
Most state criminal statutes aimed at sexually transmitted infections were written for HIV. Around 34 states criminalize HIV non-disclosure or exposure, and only some of those laws reach other infections. Whether herpes is covered comes down to the exact words in the statute.
States that use broad language, like “communicable disease” or “sexually transmitted disease,” sweep herpes in alongside HIV. Minnesota, for example, makes it a crime to knowingly engage in sexual penetration without informing a partner about a communicable disease. States that name only HIV, hepatitis, or tuberculosis leave herpes outside the criminal statute.
California took a different approach in 2017, aligning its HIV law with the rules for other communicable diseases. Intentionally transmitting any communicable disease without disclosure is a misdemeanor there, carrying up to six months in jail. The California law also says that someone who took practical steps to reduce transmission risk lacks the intent needed for conviction.
Even in states without an STI-specific statute, prosecutors sometimes reach for general criminal laws. Assault charges can apply when transmission actually occurs, treating the infection as bodily harm. Reckless endangerment can apply when someone knowingly exposes a partner, even if no transmission is proven.1National Center for Biotechnology Information (NCBI) / PMC. Criminalizing Health-Related Behaviors Dangerous to Others These cases are rare for herpes, partly because prosecutors must convince a court that herpes qualifies as serious bodily harm under the jurisdiction’s definitions, and some courts have been reluctant.
Criminal prosecution for herpes specifically remains the exception. The far more common legal consequence is a civil lawsuit.
Civil Lawsuits Are Where Most Cases Happen
A partner who contracts herpes after you failed to disclose can sue for money damages, and the burden of proof is lower than in a criminal case. A Maryland jury once awarded $8.5 million to a woman who contracted genital herpes from an ex-boyfriend who concealed his diagnosis.
Three legal theories do most of the work in these lawsuits.
Negligence
The core argument is that you had a duty to inform your partner, you breached that duty by staying silent, and your partner was harmed as a result. Courts have long recognized that people with contagious conditions owe a duty of care to sexual partners. The plaintiff must prove duty, breach, causation, and harm. Duty is usually straightforward when you had a confirmed diagnosis. Causation is the contested piece, because the plaintiff has to show they caught herpes from you and not someone else.
Battery
Battery claims argue that your partner consented to sex but not to exposure to herpes, and consent obtained through deception is not valid consent. That makes the sexual contact itself an unauthorized harmful touching. Battery is a powerful theory because it opens the door to punitive damages on top of compensation for actual harm.
Fraud
If you actively lied about your status or made reassuring statements that weren’t true, fraud comes into play. The plaintiff must show you knowingly misrepresented your condition, they relied on that misrepresentation in agreeing to have sex, and they were harmed. Fraud is harder to prove than negligence because it requires evidence of intentional deception, not just silence. Text messages and emails often supply the evidence.
What a Plaintiff Can Recover
Successful plaintiffs can recover ongoing medical expenses for a lifelong condition, including antiviral medication and outbreak treatment. They can recover for emotional distress tied to the diagnosis itself and to the stigma around it. In battery and fraud cases, punitive damages can be added to punish particularly reckless or deceptive conduct, and those can far exceed the compensatory award. The dollar amounts in these cases run high because herpes is permanent, so courts factor in decades of future costs.
Do Condoms or Antiviral Medication Protect You Legally?
Not really. Using condoms or taking a daily antiviral like valacyclovir reduces the chance of transmission, but it does not substitute for telling your partner. The legal question is whether you disclosed, not whether you reduced the risk.
Most states treat disclosure as a separate obligation from risk reduction. In the majority of jurisdictions that criminalize STI exposure, condom use is not a recognized defense. Missouri’s HIV statute, for example, explicitly says condom use does not excuse a failure to disclose. The reasoning is that your partner has an independent right to make an informed choice.
California is the clearest exception, with its statutory recognition that precautions negate criminal intent. A handful of other states with intent-based statutes may allow similar arguments, since consistent precautions can undercut a claim that you intended to transmit the infection.
In civil cases, precautions help your position without eliminating liability. A jury weighing a negligence claim will view someone who used protection more favorably than someone who used none. But no court has held that precautions replace disclosure. The only approach that eliminates virtually all legal exposure is to disclose first and then use protection.
Defenses That Actually Work
A few arguments do real work when non-disclosure cases are filed.
You didn’t know you had herpes. This is often the strongest defense. Many people carry HSV without ever having recognizable symptoms. If you were never tested or diagnosed, you can’t have knowingly withheld information, which defeats the intent or recklessness element of both criminal charges and most civil claims. Medical records showing no prior diagnosis support the argument.
Your partner already knew. If your partner was aware of your status and chose to have sex anyway, they assumed the risk. This requires evidence of actual disclosure, ideally in writing. A vague general awareness that herpes exists isn’t enough; the defense works when you can show you told this specific partner.
They caught it from someone else. Because herpes is extremely common, defendants sometimes argue the plaintiff was exposed by a different partner. This defense is strongest when the plaintiff had other sexual contacts during the relevant window, or when the timeline between contact and symptoms doesn’t fit typical incubation patterns. HSV type testing can sometimes clarify the picture.
Comparative fault. In some states, you can argue the plaintiff shares responsibility for not asking about STI status before sex. Courts have generally been unsympathetic to the idea that a failure to ask excuses a failure to tell, but in comparative-fault states this can reduce the damages owed.
How Long Does a Partner Have to Sue?
Every state imposes a statute of limitations, and missing it ends the case no matter how strong the facts. For herpes transmission, the window typically runs one to six years depending on the state and the theory used. Negligence claims generally have a two- to three-year window. Battery claims run two to four years. Fraud claims can stretch to six years in some states.
When the clock starts matters as much as how long it runs. Most states apply a discovery rule, meaning the deadline begins when the plaintiff discovered, or reasonably should have discovered, the infection, not when the sexual contact occurred. For someone who develops symptoms quickly the start date is obvious. For someone who stays asymptomatic for months or years before testing positive, the discovery rule can extend the window considerably.
Non-Disclosure Inside a Marriage
Herpes transmission between spouses carries additional legal weight. In a 2025 New York case, a court held that one spouse’s transmission of an STI to the other constituted a form of domestic violence. The husband had an extramarital affair, contracted HSV-1, HSV-2, and HPV, and transmitted those infections to his wife through unprotected sex without disclosing. The court found his conduct amounted to reckless endangerment and awarded the wife 100% of the marital assets subject to equitable distribution.
That ruling comes from one state and extreme facts, but the direction matters. In fault-based divorce states, knowingly transmitting an STI can serve as evidence of marital misconduct. In no-fault states, courts weighing property division or alimony may still consider domestic violence findings, and STI transmission is increasingly being analyzed under that umbrella. A spouse who discovers concealment during the marriage may have both a civil tort claim and leverage in the divorce.