Is Sampling Fair Use? Parody, De Minimis, and the Circuit Split

Sampling is not automatically fair use. Under federal copyright law, the fair use defense in 17 U.S.C. § 107 is narrow and unpredictable, and in commercial music releases courts rarely side with the sampler. If you are asking whether sampling is fair use because you want to release a track built on someone else’s audio, treat clearance as the default and fair use as the rare exception. The situations where a court will actually excuse an uncleared sample are specific, and most commercial uses do not fit them.

Why Commercial Sampling Usually Loses the Fair Use Analysis

Courts weigh four factors from § 107 together. No single factor decides the case, and judges have wide discretion in how much weight to give each one. Commercial sampling tends to run into trouble on three of the four at the same time.

The first factor looks at the purpose and character of the use, including whether it is “transformative” — whether the new work adds new meaning, expression, or purpose rather than repackaging the original. A producer who chops, pitch-shifts, and layers a sample into something that sounds and functions completely differently has a stronger argument than one who loops a recognizable hook under a new beat. The commercial nature of the release weighs against fair use, though it is not automatically disqualifying.

The second factor considers the nature of the copyrighted work. Creative works like songs get stronger protection than factual material. Because nearly every sampled source is a creative recording, this factor almost always favors the original copyright holder.

The third factor is the amount and substantiality of the portion used. This is not purely about duration. A two-second snippet can be “substantial” if it captures the most recognizable part of the song — what courts call the “heart of the work.” A forgettable transitional passage is treated very differently from a signature riff listeners associate with the original.

The fourth factor asks about the effect on the market. If your track could substitute for the original or undercut its licensing value, a fair use defense will almost certainly fail. Courts look at both actual harm and the harm that would result if the use became widespread. Sample licensing is itself a market, so unauthorized sampling tends to cut directly against this factor.

When Fair Use Actually Works: Parody and Genuinely Transformative Use

The strongest fair use cases involving music tend to involve parody. In Campbell v. Acuff-Rose Music, Inc. (1994), the Supreme Court ruled that 2 Live Crew’s parody of Roy Orbison’s “Oh, Pretty Woman” could qualify as fair use despite being sold commercially. The Court rejected the idea that a commercial parody is presumptively unfair and held that the lower court had given too little weight to the parodic purpose when evaluating how much of the original was copied.

The key distinction is that parody comments on or criticizes the original work itself, which gives it a transformative purpose that ordinary sampling for a new beat typically lacks. If you sample a guitar riff because it sounds good and you want that sound in your track, that is not parody. It is borrowing, and courts have been far less sympathetic to that kind of use even when the final product sounds meaningfully different from the source.

Transformation outside parody is possible but hard to predict. The further the new work moves from the function and feel of the original, the better the argument. The closer it stays, the more a court will see the use as substitution.

“It’s Only a Second” Is Not a Safe Answer

In copyright law, the de minimis principle holds that some uses are so trivially small the law ignores them. For musical compositions — the underlying melody and lyrics — this principle generally applies. If you sample a fragment so tiny and altered that no reasonable listener would recognize it, a court could dismiss the claim on that ground.

Sound recordings are a different story, and federal courts disagree about the rules.

The Sixth Circuit: No Amount Is Too Small

In Bridgeport Music, Inc. v. Dimension Films (2005), the Sixth Circuit ruled that any unauthorized copying of a sound recording — even a fraction of a second — can constitute infringement. The court reasoned that because a sound recording can be licensed cheaply and easily, there is no reason to excuse even tiny uses. The opinion famously concluded: “Get a license or do not sample.” This rule applies in Kentucky, Michigan, Ohio, and Tennessee.

The Ninth Circuit: De Minimis Still Applies

In VMG Salsoul, LLC v. Ciccone (2016), the Ninth Circuit explicitly rejected Bridgeport’s reasoning. The court held that the de minimis exception applies to sound recordings just as it does to every other type of copyrighted work. The Ninth Circuit pointed to the text of 17 U.S.C. § 114(b), which limits a sound recording owner’s exclusive rights to works that “directly or indirectly recapture the actual sounds fixed in the recording,” and found that Bridgeport had misread the statute.1Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 17 U.S. Code 114 – Scope of Exclusive Rights in Sound Recordings This rule applies in California, Washington, Oregon, and several other western states.

The Supreme Court has not resolved this split. If you release music nationally, assume a brief, heavily processed sample can still trigger a lawsuit, because the copyright holder can choose to file in a Sixth Circuit court. Until the Supreme Court weighs in, Bridgeport effectively sets the floor for risk.

What You’re Actually Risking

Fair use is an affirmative defense. You raise it after you have been sued, after you have paid lawyers to get that far, and after a judge has decided whether to let the case proceed. Even a winning defense is expensive. A losing one is worse.

A copyright holder who sues for infringement can elect statutory damages instead of proving actual financial harm. For non-willful infringement, a court can award between $750 and $30,000 per work. For willful infringement — and releasing a track you knew contained an uncleared sample fits that description — the ceiling rises to $150,000 per work.2Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 17 USC 504 – Remedies for Infringement: Damages and Profits Sampling implicates two separate copyrights, discussed below, so a single uncleared sample can generate two damage awards.

Courts can also order you to stop distributing the track. Under 17 U.S.C. § 502, a federal judge can issue temporary or permanent injunctions, pulling the song from every platform until the dispute is resolved.3Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 17 U.S. Code 502 – Remedies for Infringement: Injunctions And long before a lawsuit, a copyright holder can file a DMCA takedown with any streaming service or distributor. The platform must act quickly to remove the material once it receives a valid notice.4U.S. Copyright Office. Section 512 of Title 17 – Resources on Online Service Provider Safe Harbors and Notice-and-Takedown System Repeated takedowns can get your account permanently suspended on major distribution platforms.

The Two Copyrights a Sample Implicates

Every commercially released song carries two independent copyrights, and sampling touches both. A fair use argument has to work for each one separately, and so does a license.

  • The musical composition covers the melody, harmony, and lyrics. It is typically owned or administered by the songwriter and their music publisher.
  • The sound recording covers the specific audio performance captured in the studio. It is usually owned by the record label that financed the recording.

When you sample a recording, you are using both at once. Missing either leaves you exposed to a separate infringement claim.

Safer Paths Than Betting on Fair Use

Clearance is the most direct option. You identify the publisher and the label, request a license for the specific portion you want to use, and sign a formal agreement that spells out which track, which platforms, and which territories the license covers. That document is your legal protection. Without it, platforms and distributors can pull the release at any time in response to an infringement claim.

Interpolation is the main alternative. Interpolation means re-recording part of an existing composition — replaying the melody, chord progression, or lyrics with new musicians in a new studio session — rather than lifting audio directly from the original recording. Because you are creating a brand-new sound recording from scratch, you only need permission from the composition’s copyright owner, not the owner of the original master.5United States Copyright Office. Sampling, Interpolations, Beat Stores and More: An Introduction for Musicians Using Preexisting Music Federal law limits a sound recording owner’s exclusive rights to works that recapture the “actual sounds fixed in the recording,” so an independently recorded sound-alike does not infringe the sound recording copyright even if it closely imitates the original performance. Interpolation will not help if you need the exact sonic texture of the original, but when what you really want is the melody or chord structure, it cuts the clearance process in half.

Public domain and Creative Commons sources require no clearance at all. As of January 1, 2026, sound recordings published in 1925 or earlier are in the U.S. public domain under terms established by the Music Modernization Act. The underlying compositions from that era entered the public domain even earlier. Some living artists also release work under Creative Commons licenses that permit sampling: CC BY allows commercial use with credit, and CC BY-SA allows commercial use if you release your new work under the same terms.6Creative Commons. Creative Commons Licenses Licenses that include “ND” (No Derivatives) do not permit sampling, so read the specific license before building a track around CC-licensed material.

Fair use remains a real doctrine, and in a true parody or a genuinely transformative project it can carry the day. For everything else, the honest answer to “is sampling fair use” is that courts rarely say yes, and the price of being wrong is set by statute.