ISP Subpoena List: SCA Tiers, Warrants, and Notification

There is no single public document called the ISP subpoena list. The phrase usually points to one of two things: the categories of subscriber data an internet service provider must turn over when it receives a subpoena, or the transparency reports major providers publish showing how many government demands they handle. Federal law sorts user data into tiers, and each tier takes a different legal instrument to pry loose. A plain subpoena gets basic account information. A court order gets connection and transaction records. A warrant is needed for the content of your communications and for historical location data. The gap between the top and bottom of that ladder is wide, and it decides what actually leaves the ISP.

The Three Tiers Under the Stored Communications Act

The Stored Communications Act, 18 U.S.C. § 2703, sets the framework. Each tier protects a different class of data and demands a higher showing than the one below it.1Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 18 U.S. Code 2703 – Required Disclosure of Customer Communications or Records

  • A subpoena (administrative, grand jury, or trial) compels basic subscriber information. No judge reviews it in advance.
  • A court order under § 2703(d), sometimes called a “D order,” requires a government attorney to present specific and articulable facts showing reasonable grounds to believe the records are relevant and material to an ongoing criminal investigation. A judge signs off, but the standard sits well below probable cause.
  • A search warrant requires a judge to find probable cause that the data contains evidence of a crime. Same bar police must clear to search a home.

A subpoena takes a signature. A warrant takes convincing a judge that a crime likely occurred and that the records will prove it. That distance controls everything that follows.

What a Subpoena Actually Reveals

When an ISP receives a subpoena, § 2703(c)(2) spells out exactly six categories it must disclose:

  • Name of the account holder
  • Address on the account
  • Local and long-distance connection records, and records of session times and durations
  • Length and type of service, including when the account was opened
  • Subscriber number or identity, including any temporarily assigned IP address
  • Payment method, including credit card or bank account numbers on file

The payment line catches people off guard. A subpoena hands over the card you used to pay your internet bill. The IP piece matters even more in practice, because it ties an anonymous online action to a physical subscriber at a specific moment in time. For most civil cases and a large share of criminal ones, that identification is the whole point of serving the ISP.1Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 18 U.S. Code 2703 – Required Disclosure of Customer Communications or Records

What a Court Order Adds

Beyond the subscriber basics, ISPs hold transactional records that paint a fuller picture of your activity: connection logs showing when you signed on and off, which IP addresses were assigned over time, and similar metadata about your usage. These records expose patterns of behavior without revealing the actual substance of what you read, wrote, or downloaded.

To reach them, the government needs a § 2703(d) order. The application must present specific and articulable facts giving reasonable grounds to believe the records are relevant and material to an ongoing criminal investigation. That is a real hurdle, deliberately set higher than a subpoena and deliberately lower than probable cause. It is more than a hunch and less than a warrant.1Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 18 U.S. Code 2703 – Required Disclosure of Customer Communications or Records

What a Warrant Is Required For

The substance of your communications gets the strongest protection the statute provides. Content means the text of emails stored on the ISP’s servers, saved messages, and uploaded files. Reaching that material takes a search warrant based on probable cause, the same constitutional standard as searching a home. In practice, most ISPs today require a warrant for stored content regardless of how long it has sat on the server. If law enforcement wants to read your email, expect a warrant.1Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 18 U.S. Code 2703 – Required Disclosure of Customer Communications or Records

Historical location data sits in the same tier. In Carpenter v. United States (2018), the Supreme Court held that the government’s acquisition of historical cell-site location records is a search under the Fourth Amendment and requires a warrant. The Court specifically rejected the argument that a § 2703(d) order was enough. The decision was narrow, acknowledging emergency exceptions, but for routine investigations the line is clear: your historical movements traced through cell towers are constitutionally protected, and a judge has to be convinced before a carrier produces them.2Supreme Court of the United States. Carpenter v. United States

Where Encryption Changes the Picture

A warrant only reaches data the ISP can actually read. End-to-end encryption scrambles messages so that only sender and recipient can decrypt them, which leaves the provider holding ciphertext. The warrant compels production, but the company physically cannot produce readable content. The FBI has publicly advocated for what it calls responsibly managed encryption, meaning systems where providers retain decryption capability. Most major technology companies have resisted, arguing any built-in access point creates a vulnerability others can exploit. For you as a subscriber, traditional browsing data and email stored on the provider’s servers remain reachable under a warrant; messages sent through end-to-end encrypted apps largely are not, even with a court order in hand.3Federal Bureau of Investigation. Lawful Access

DMCA Subpoenas: How Most People Encounter This

The most common way an ordinary subscriber ends up on the receiving end of an ISP subpoena has nothing to do with a criminal case. Copyright holders use a special process under the Digital Millennium Copyright Act to identify people accused of file-sharing. Under 17 U.S.C. § 512(h), a copyright owner can ask a federal court clerk to issue a subpoena directing the ISP to reveal the subscriber tied to a particular IP address.4Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 17 U.S. Code 512 – Limitations on Liability Relating to Material Online

The process is streamlined to the point of being alarming. The copyright owner files a takedown notification, a proposed subpoena, and a sworn declaration that the information will be used only to protect copyrights. If the paperwork is in order, the clerk issues the subpoena with no judicial review of the underlying infringement claim. The ISP must then expeditiously disclose enough information to identify the alleged infringer, meaning the subscriber name and address linked to the IP address at the time of the alleged activity. This is the engine behind the thousands of settlement demand letters sent to people accused of downloading movies or music through BitTorrent. The person on the account is not necessarily the person who downloaded the file, but they are the person who gets the letter.4Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 17 U.S. Code 512 – Limitations on Liability Relating to Material Online

National Security Letters

Outside the Stored Communications Act framework entirely, the FBI can obtain subscriber records through National Security Letters under 18 U.S.C. § 2709. These are administrative demands with no judge involved. The FBI director or a designated senior official must certify in writing that the information sought is relevant to an authorized investigation to protect against international terrorism or clandestine intelligence activities. The statute limits the take to subscriber name, address, length of service, and toll billing records.5Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 18 U.S. Code 2709 – Counterintelligence Access to Telephone Toll and Transactional Records

National Security Letters carry a built-in gag provision. When accompanied by the proper certification, the ISP is barred from telling anyone, including you, that the FBI asked. Providers can only report the number of these letters they receive in broad bands rather than exact figures. Comcast’s most recent transparency report listed between 0 and 499 National Security Letters for the second half of 2025. That imprecise range is all federal law allows.

How Often ISPs Get These Requests

Major ISPs publish periodic transparency reports breaking down government demands by type. These are the closest thing to a public ISP subpoena list that actually exists. The volume is substantial. In the first half of 2024 Verizon received 72,856 subpoenas, 25,945 warrants, 4,362 general court orders, 6,108 pen register or trap-and-trace orders, and 384 wiretap orders.6Verizon. Transparency Report First Half of 2024 AT&T reported 152,561 total U.S. criminal and civil demands over the same period.7AT&T. Transparency Report August 2024 Comcast received 18,618 criminal demands in the second half of 2025, with subpoenas making up 12,938 of them.8Comcast. Transparency Report Second Half of 2025

Subpoenas consistently dominate every provider’s totals, dwarfing warrants and court orders. That tells you what the government most often seeks: the basic subscriber data at the lowest tier.

Will You Be Notified, and Can You Fight It?

ISPs generally try to notify you before producing records in response to civil subpoenas, including DMCA demands, giving you a window to challenge the request in court. Criminal investigations are different. Under 18 U.S.C. § 2705, a court can issue a non-disclosure order telling the ISP to say nothing to you. Courts grant these when there is reason to believe notification could endanger someone, lead to evidence destruction, cause witness intimidation, or otherwise seriously jeopardize the investigation. When the non-disclosure period eventually ends, the government must serve you with notice explaining what was collected and under what authority.9Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 18 U.S. Code 2705 – Delayed Notice

If you do get notice, your options exist only before the ISP produces the records. Once the data is handed over, there is nothing to quash. The primary tool is a motion to quash under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 45, which requires a court to quash or modify a subpoena that fails to allow reasonable time to comply, demands privileged information, or imposes an undue burden. In copyright file-sharing cases, common arguments include lack of personal jurisdiction (the issuing court has no authority over you because you live in another district), overbreadth, and the point that an IP address alone cannot identify the actual infringer. Courts have been receptive to jurisdictional challenges when plaintiffs file in one district and then subpoena subscriber information for people scattered across the country.

A motion for a protective order under Rule 26(c) offers a related path. Rather than killing the subpoena, a protective order can limit how your information is used, require confidentiality, or delay disclosure while you build a fuller defense. Speed is the variable that controls everything. ISPs include a deadline in their notification letter, and missing it means they will comply. Getting an attorney involved quickly after receiving notice is the single most important step; filing in the wrong court or missing the response window forfeits the right to challenge the demand at all.

How Long Your ISP Keeps the Records

The United States has no federal law requiring ISPs to retain customer data for any specific period. How long your provider holds IP address assignments, session logs, and billing records is a matter of internal policy. Some providers keep IP logs for months; others for over a year. Retention windows are not publicly standardized, so a subpoena served years after the activity in question may come back empty if the provider has already purged the relevant records. A provider with long retention may have years of your connection history ready to produce. The answer to what any particular subpoena will reveal starts with the statute, but it ends with whatever your ISP still has on its servers the day the paperwork arrives.