Joint locks and compliance holds are physical control techniques that use leverage against a joint or pressure against a nerve-sensitive point to make a person stop resisting or follow instructions. Whether applying one is legal depends almost entirely on who you are: a police officer is judged under the Fourth Amendment’s reasonableness standard, a civilian is judged under state self-defense law, and a private security guard is usually judged under state tort law for battery and false imprisonment. In every case, the force has to match the threat, and it has to end when the threat ends. Push past that line and you’re looking at a civil rights lawsuit, a criminal charge, or a death you’ll have to answer for.
What These Techniques Actually Do
A joint lock isolates a wrist, elbow, or shoulder and uses leverage to push the joint past its comfortable range of motion. Resistance causes sharp pain, which is what gives a smaller person mechanical control over a larger one. A compliance hold works differently: instead of immobilizing a joint, it applies pressure to pain-sensitive areas like the base of the jaw or the collarbone, usually in stages, with the pressure increasing only if the person refuses to cooperate.
The distinction matters legally because compliance holds are explicitly pain-driven. If the person has already stopped resisting and the pressure continues, the legal justification for applying pain disappears quickly.
When Police Can Use a Joint Lock or Compliance Hold
Every joint lock or compliance hold an officer applies during an arrest or investigatory stop counts as a seizure under the Fourth Amendment.1Legal Information Institute. Fourth Amendment The Supreme Court set the governing test in Graham v. Connor: whether the force was objectively reasonable from the perspective of a reasonable officer on the scene, judged without the benefit of hindsight.2Justia US Supreme Court. Graham v. Connor, 490 U.S. 386 (1989) Courts weigh three factors:
- The severity of the crime being investigated.
- Whether the person posed an immediate threat to officers or others.
- Whether the person was actively resisting arrest or trying to flee.
That third factor is where most compliance-hold cases get fought. Passive resistance, like going limp or sitting on the ground, raises the threshold for inflicting pain to force compliance. Active resistance lowers it. The Court also said the reasonableness analysis has to allow for the fact that officers often make split-second decisions under pressure.2Justia US Supreme Court. Graham v. Connor, 490 U.S. 386 (1989)
Where a technique sits on an agency’s use-of-force continuum also matters. The National Institute of Justice places joint locks and similar holds in the “empty-hand control” category as a “soft technique,” one step above verbal commands and below strikes, batons, and chemical sprays.3National Institute of Justice. The Use-of-Force Continuum Officers are expected to work through the continuum rather than jump from talking to takedowns. If an officer skips straight to a painful wrist lock on someone who is standing still and asking questions, that leap becomes evidence of unreasonable force.
When a Civilian Can Use One in Self-Defense
For civilians, the framework shifts entirely from the Fourth Amendment to state self-defense law. Every state allows some physical force to defend yourself or another person against an imminent threat, but the core requirement is proportionality: your response can’t exceed the danger you face. Three elements generally have to be present:
- Proportionality. The force has to roughly match the threat. A joint lock on someone shoving you is far easier to justify than one applied to someone who insulted you.
- Necessity. Force has to be the only reasonable option. If you could safely walk away, some jurisdictions require you to do so, though stand-your-ground states eliminate the duty to retreat.
- Reasonable belief. You have to genuinely and reasonably believe force is needed. Courts test this both subjectively (did you actually believe it) and objectively (would a reasonable person in your position have believed it).
Joint locks and compliance holds generally sit on the non-deadly end of the force spectrum, which helps. But the analysis doesn’t stop at the moment the hold goes on. Maintain a painful lock after the threat has ended, or crank an armbar until it breaks a bone after the attacker has surrendered, and you’ve crossed into criminal assault. The legal protection evaporates the moment you use more force than the situation demands.
When Private Security Can Use One
Private security guards occupy an awkward middle ground. They don’t carry police authority, and they don’t get the constitutional framework that comes with it. When a guard applies a joint lock while acting independently, the legal analysis runs through state tort law: assault, battery, and false imprisonment, with both the guard and the employing company potentially on the hook.
There’s an exception. When a guard acts at the direction of or in coordination with police, courts can treat the guard as a state actor, which means the Graham reasonableness standard applies and the guard can be sued under federal civil rights law just like an officer. Many security companies don’t appreciate this exposure until a lawsuit lands.
Private guards also generally don’t enjoy qualified immunity, which is the defense that often shields police officers from damages. A security guard who applies an unnecessary compliance hold during a store detention faces straightforward battery liability with no special immunity doctrine standing in the way.
Techniques That Are Off-Limits
The biggest policy shift in recent years has been the widespread restriction or outright ban on neck restraints and chokeholds. At least 17 states have enacted legislation restricting these techniques since 2020, and many individual departments have adopted their own bans. At the federal level, the George Floyd Justice in Policing Act, which would have restricted chokeholds and carotid holds, passed the House in 2021 but was never enacted into law.4Congress.gov. H.R.1280 – George Floyd Justice in Policing Act of 2021
The practical line matters. An officer who applies an armbar during a struggle is working within accepted training. An officer who transitions to a chokehold in a jurisdiction that prohibits it faces both departmental discipline and heightened legal exposure in any lawsuit that follows.
How People Get Hurt or Killed
These techniques are designed to control without causing permanent damage. The gap between “designed to” and “actually does” is where the serious injuries and deaths happen, and that gap drives most of the lawsuits.
Orthopedic Injuries
The most common injuries from joint locks are ligament tears, dislocations, and fractures of the elbow, wrist, and shoulder. An armbar applied too fast or with too much force can rupture the ligaments that stabilize the elbow, sometimes requiring surgical reconstruction and months of rehabilitation. Resistance from the person being restrained can make the joint absorb force unpredictably. Someone who jerks against a wrist lock can fracture their own wrist even if the officer used textbook technique.
Positional Asphyxia
The deadliest risk during physical restraint isn’t the hold itself but the body position it forces. Positional asphyxia happens when a person’s body position prevents them from breathing adequately. Face-down prone positioning is the primary cause, especially when weight is applied to the person’s back.5Office of Justice Programs. Positional Asphyxia—Sudden Death The risk climbs sharply when the person being restrained has certain predisposing factors:
- Obesity, which compresses the diaphragm when face-down.
- Alcohol or drug intoxication, which reduces respiratory drive so the person may not realize they’re suffocating.
- An enlarged heart, which increases susceptibility to cardiac arrhythmia under low-oxygen stress.
- A prior violent struggle, where extreme physical exertion can cause respiratory muscle failure even after the struggle ends.
Behind-the-back handcuffing combined with a stomach-down position creates the highest-risk scenario. A person who becomes unresponsive during or immediately after being restrained may already be in cardiac arrest.5Office of Justice Programs. Positional Asphyxia—Sudden Death The person who most needs to be physically controlled, meaning combative, intoxicated, and large, is often the person most likely to die from the restraint method used to control them.
The Duty to Get Medical Help
Officers have a legal obligation to obtain prompt medical care for anyone in their custody who shows signs of medical distress. The duty runs before, during, and after the arrest. Under federal law, emergency departments must provide an appropriate medical screening examination to determine whether an emergency condition exists, including for patients brought in by law enforcement.6National Center for Biotechnology Information. Best Practice Guidelines for Evaluating Patients in Custody in the Emergency Department Failing to summon medical attention for someone who becomes unresponsive after a compliance hold can turn a legally justified use of force into a wrongful death claim.
What Happens When the Force Was Too Much
When a joint lock or compliance hold crosses from reasonable to excessive, the consequences flow through two parallel channels: federal civil rights claims and state tort lawsuits.
Federal Civil Rights Claims
The primary federal remedy is a lawsuit under 42 U.S.C. § 1983, which lets anyone whose constitutional rights were violated by a government official acting under color of law sue for damages.7Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 42 USC 1983 – Civil Action for Deprivation of Rights If a court finds an officer used a joint lock without justification, both the officer and the employing municipality can face monetary liability. Damages typically cover medical expenses, lost income, and pain and suffering, with punitive awards possible in egregious cases. Settlement amounts vary enormously depending on the severity of injury, from five figures for brief incidents without lasting harm to millions of dollars for cases involving permanent disability or death.
Suing a municipality requires clearing an additional hurdle set in Monell v. Department of Social Services. A city or county can’t be held liable just because it employs an officer who used excessive force. The plaintiff has to show the constitutional violation resulted from an official policy, custom, or deliberate choice by municipal decision-makers.8Justia US Supreme Court. Monell v. Department of Social Services, 436 U.S. 658 (1978) In practice, that often means proving the department had a pattern of tolerating excessive force or failed to train officers adequately on when compliance holds are appropriate.
Qualified Immunity
The single biggest obstacle in most excessive force lawsuits is qualified immunity, which shields government officials from liability unless they violated a “clearly established” right.9Legal Information Institute. Qualified Immunity To overcome it, the plaintiff has to point to existing court decisions that would have put a reasonable officer on notice that the specific conduct was unlawful. The doctrine doesn’t require a prior case with identical facts, but it does require enough legal clarity that the officer should have known better.
The doctrine has drawn sharp criticism. Justice Sotomayor has described the Supreme Court’s approach as transforming the doctrine into “an absolute shield for law enforcement officers, gutting the deterrent effect of the Fourth Amendment.” The practical effect for plaintiffs is that even clearly excessive force may not produce liability if no prior court decision addressed similar enough circumstances.
State Tort Claims
Separate from federal civil rights claims, plaintiffs can pursue state-level lawsuits for battery, assault, or intentional infliction of emotional distress. These don’t require proving a constitutional violation, which sometimes makes them easier to win. The trade-off is that state tort claims against government employees often face sovereign immunity caps that limit damages, and many states require plaintiffs to file an administrative claim with the agency before going to court. For claims against private security personnel, state tort law is usually the only avenue available.