Larceny by an employee is the crime of taking an employer’s money or property with the intent to keep it, and it can be charged as a misdemeanor or a felony depending almost entirely on how much was taken. A low-value taking might mean a few months in jail and a fine. A larger one can mean years in prison, a mandatory restitution order, a civil lawsuit from the employer, and a permanent record that closes off entire industries. The charge sits at the intersection of theft law and the trust an employer places in a worker, and courts tend to treat the betrayal of that trust as an aggravating factor at every stage.
What the Charge Actually Covers
“Employee theft,” “embezzlement,” and “larceny by an employee” get used interchangeably in conversation, but prosecutors have to pick one, and the choice depends on how the employee first got hold of the property.
Ordinary larceny involves taking property the person was never authorized to have. A warehouse worker who pockets merchandise off the shelf fits that pattern. Embezzlement is different: the employee was lawfully entrusted with the property and then diverted it, like a bookkeeper authorized to handle funds who redirects payments to a personal account. Larceny by an employee sits between the two. The worker had some access because of the job, but the taking looks more like a grab than a paper trail. A cashier skimming from a register is the classic example: custody of the cash came with the job, but the act itself is straightforward theft.
The practical consequence is that if prosecutors choose the wrong category, a defense attorney can argue the evidence doesn’t match the legal elements. Penalties often overlap, so the distinction tends to matter more for proof strategy than for sentencing.
Misdemeanor or Felony
The dividing line is almost always a dollar amount. Every state sets a threshold: below it, the charge is a misdemeanor; above it, a felony. Those thresholds vary widely, from around $200 in some states to $2,500 in others, with several states drawing the line between $500 and $1,000.
Aggregation is where many defendants get caught off guard. If an employee took small amounts repeatedly, prosecutors in many jurisdictions can add the incidents together to clear the felony threshold. A series of thefts that looked individually trivial can become a single felony count. Courts measure the loss by fair market value, not what the employee sold the property for and not what it costs the employer to replace.
Certain circumstances push a charge up to a felony regardless of value. Taking from a vulnerable person like an elderly client, exploiting authority in a government agency, or stealing during a declared emergency are common aggravators.
What Prosecutors Must Prove
A conviction requires each element to be proven beyond a reasonable doubt. The wording varies by state, but the elements are consistent:
- A taking or conversion: the employee physically took, transferred, or used the employer’s property in an unauthorized way.
- Intent to permanently deprive: the employee meant to keep the property or its value, not just borrow it. This element decides most close cases.
- Lack of consent: the employer did not authorize the taking.
- Property of value: the item taken has measurable value, and that value determines misdemeanor versus felony.
Prosecutors build these cases with company records, surveillance footage, point-of-sale data, bank statements, and witness testimony. Internal audits often provide the clearest picture when the theft stretched over weeks or months. Digital evidence has become central: access logs, email records, and inventory system data can show exactly when discrepancies appeared and who was on shift.
Position of trust is not technically an element of the crime in most jurisdictions, but it shapes how aggressively prosecutors push the case and how harshly judges sentence. Juries tend to view a workplace betrayal as more culpable than an opportunistic theft.
When Federal Charges Apply
Most of these cases stay in state court. Federal charges come up in specific situations. Stealing property belonging to the United States government is punishable by up to ten years in prison when the value exceeds $1,000, or up to one year when it does not.1Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 18 USC 641 – Public Money, Property or Records
A separate statute targets theft from organizations receiving more than $10,000 a year in federal funding. An employee of such an organization who steals property worth $5,000 or more faces up to ten years in prison.2Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 18 USC 666 – Theft or Bribery Concerning Programs Receiving Federal Funds The reach is broader than people expect. Hospitals, universities, nonprofits, and local government agencies that receive federal grants or contracts all fall within it.
Defenses That Can Actually Work
The strongest defenses attack the elements the prosecution has to prove. Which one fits depends heavily on the facts.
- Lack of intent. If the employee genuinely believed they were borrowing an item and had a realistic ability to return it, that negates the intent to permanently deprive. Vague intention isn’t enough; the circumstances have to back up the claim.
- Claim of right. An employee who genuinely believed the property was theirs or that they were owed it, perhaps as part of compensation, can raise a good-faith defense even if the belief turns out to be wrong.
- Consent. If the employer authorized the taking or use, there is no crime. This defense comes up often where workplace practices around borrowing equipment or taking samples were informal and poorly documented.
- Entrapment. If a supervisor or officer induced the employee to take something they would not otherwise have taken, entrapment can apply. The employee has to show no prior inclination to commit the theft.
- Challenging the value. Even when the taking is clear, disputing the dollar amount can push the charge from felony to misdemeanor. Defense attorneys regularly argue that prosecutors used replacement cost rather than fair market value.
- Duress. An employee who stole under a threat of harm to themselves or a family member did not act voluntarily. It’s uncommon but real, especially where organized criminal activity is involved.
Penalties and Sentencing
State penalties track the misdemeanor-felony line. Misdemeanor larceny by an employee typically carries a maximum of six months to one year in jail along with fines. Felony convictions range from one year to ten or more years, depending on the amount taken and the jurisdiction.
Prior criminal history has an outsized effect. A first-time offender who took a moderate amount may get probation with conditions. An employee with earlier theft convictions facing the same charge is likely to serve time.
The Federal Abuse-of-Trust Enhancement
Federal cases run through the U.S. Sentencing Guidelines. The judge starts with a base offense level for theft, increases it based on the dollar loss, and cross-references the final level against the defendant’s criminal history to find the recommended range in months.3United States Sentencing Commission. Annotated 2025 Chapter 5 – Determining the Sentencing Range and Options
On top of that, employees face an enhancement other defendants don’t. If the court finds the employee used a position of trust to commit or conceal the crime, the offense level goes up by two.4United States Sentencing Commission. Annotated 2025 Chapter 3 – Adjustments That two-level jump can add months or years to the recommended sentence. The enhancement applies broadly: an accountant with access to financial systems, a manager who controls inventory, or a government employee entrusted with procurement authority all qualify.
Mandatory Restitution
Restitution is separate from any fine or prison sentence, and in federal court it is mandatory for property offenses when there is an identifiable victim with a financial loss.5GovInfo. 18 USC 3663A – Mandatory Restitution to Victims of Certain Crimes The judge enters the order at sentencing, directing the defendant to reimburse the employer for actual losses caused by the crime.6U.S. Department of Justice. Restitution Process
Restitution covers the value of what was taken, plus related costs the employer incurred, such as internal investigation expenses or audit fees needed to determine the full scope of the loss.7U.S. Attorney’s Office – Central District of California. Understanding Restitution What it won’t reach is indirect loss like lost business opportunities or reputational harm; the employer has to sue in civil court for those. Restitution orders survive bankruptcy in many circumstances and can be enforced through wage garnishment. Nonpayment can trigger revocation of probation or supervised release.
The Civil Lawsuit That Usually Follows
Criminal prosecution and civil litigation run on separate tracks, and employers frequently pursue both. The civil case is easier for the employer to win because the burden of proof is preponderance of the evidence rather than beyond a reasonable doubt. Employers who struggle to secure a criminal conviction often prevail in civil court.
The most common civil claim is conversion, the civil equivalent of theft. Employers also bring breach-of-fiduciary-duty claims against employees in positions of responsibility, which can open the door to punitive damages designed to punish rather than compensate. Consequential damages that restitution doesn’t cover are also on the table: forensic accountants, increased insurance premiums, overtime paid to employees who covered the accused worker’s duties, and revenue lost to operational disruption. In large or systematic cases, employers sometimes seek a prejudgment attachment, a court order freezing the employee’s assets before the case ends. That requires showing a real risk the employee will hide or dissipate assets before a judgment can be collected.
In sustained schemes, employers may reach for civil RICO. The statute allows anyone injured in business or property by racketeering activity to recover three times actual damages plus attorney’s fees.8Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 18 USC 1964 – Civil Remedies The bar is high: the employer has to prove at least two qualifying criminal acts within ten years that are related and show a continuing pattern.9Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 18 USC 1961 – Definitions Theft schemes involving falsified invoices, forged checks, or electronic transfers often satisfy the mail or wire fraud predicates.
The Fifth Amendment Squeeze
Being sued and prosecuted at the same time is one of the hardest positions in American law. The Fifth Amendment protects against compelled self-incrimination, and that protection extends to civil discovery, so an employee can refuse to answer deposition questions or produce documents that might incriminate them in the criminal case.
The catch is that civil courts can allow the jury to draw a negative inference from that silence. The employee faces a choice between answering civil questions and handing the prosecutor evidence, or staying silent and watching the civil case tilt toward the employer. Defense attorneys often ask the court to stay the civil case until the criminal matter resolves, but judges grant those requests inconsistently. Anything said in the civil case, including deposition testimony and written discovery responses, can be used in the criminal prosecution. Separate counsel for each case is typically necessary, and the combined cost can be ruinous.
How Long Employers Have to Act
Criminal statutes of limitations vary by jurisdiction and by whether the offense is a misdemeanor or felony. Misdemeanor periods typically run one to three years. Felony periods are longer, often five to ten years, and some jurisdictions have no limit for the most serious theft offenses.10Justia. Criminal Statutes of Limitations 50-State Survey
Because employee theft often goes undetected for years, most jurisdictions apply a discovery rule: the clock starts when the employer knew or reasonably should have known about the theft, not when the taking occurred. An employee who falsified records to hide the crime cannot benefit from the delay their concealment created.
Civil statutes are separate and generally shorter. Conversion and breach-of-fiduciary-duty claims typically have to be filed within two to five years, depending on the state. Employers focused only on the criminal side sometimes miss the civil deadline, which matters because restitution alone rarely makes an employer whole.
Limits on How Employers Can Investigate
Employers investigating a theft do not have law enforcement powers, and federal law constrains what they can do.
The Employee Polygraph Protection Act generally prohibits private employers from using lie detector tests on employees.11U.S. Department of Labor. Employee Polygraph Protection Act of 1988 (Fact Sheet #36) There is a narrow exception for ongoing theft investigations, but the employer must show the employee had access to the property, must have a reasonable suspicion of the specific employee’s involvement, and must give the employee a written statement identifying the loss, the basis for suspicion, and the employee’s access before testing.12Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 29 USC 2006 – Exemptions Even when the exemption applies, the employee can refuse the test or stop it at any time, and the results cannot be the sole basis for discipline. Employees can sue for violations within three years.
When employers use outside investigators, the Fair Credit Reporting Act applies. A communication from an outside investigator about employee misconduct is excluded from FCRA’s normal pre-investigation disclosure requirements, so the employer does not have to warn the employee that an investigation is underway.13Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 15 USC 1681a – Definitions; Rules of Construction But if the employer then takes adverse action, like firing or suspending the employee, the employer must afterward provide a summary of the investigation’s nature and substance, without having to reveal who provided information.
What a Conviction Does to a Career
Prison sentences and fines end. The record often doesn’t. Theft convictions appear on background checks, and most employers screening for roles involving money, inventory, or sensitive information will reject candidates with dishonesty-related offenses.
Some industries have legal bars, not just preferences. Federal law prohibits anyone convicted of a crime involving dishonesty, breach of trust, or money laundering from working at an FDIC-insured bank or depository institution without prior written approval from the FDIC.14FDIC.gov. Prohibition Under Section 19 of the Federal Deposit Insurance (FDI) Act The bar covers convictions and participation in pretrial diversion programs, and for certain offenses it lasts a minimum of ten years before the FDIC will consider an exception.15FDIC.gov. Section 19 – Penalty for Unauthorized Participation by Convicted Individual
Similar restrictions exist in securities, healthcare, insurance, and government contracting. Professional licenses in accounting, real estate, and law typically require disclosure of convictions, and licensing boards treat dishonesty offenses as grounds for denial or revocation. For an employee weighing a plea, the collateral consequences deserve as much attention as the sentence. A felony conviction with probation instead of prison may feel like a win at sentencing and look very different five years later when it blocks a career move into financial services or government work.