Less Than Lethal Force: Police Standards and Civilian Rules

Less-than-lethal force covers any weapon or technique meant to stop a threat without a high likelihood of killing, and the legal rules around it split sharply along one line: police use is judged against the Fourth Amendment’s reasonableness standard, while civilian use is governed by state possession laws and the ordinary law of self-defense. The category exists in a middle band between verbal commands and deadly force, and the “less than” in the name is doing real work. More than a thousand people in the United States have died after being struck by weapons in this category, so the rules treat these tools as serious instruments, not harmless alternatives.

Why the Label Matters

The Department of Justice and the National Institute of Justice use “less than lethal” or “less lethal” rather than “non-lethal” because no weapon or technique can guarantee zero risk of death or permanent injury.1National Institute of Justice. The Use-of-Force Continuum That word choice carries legal weight. When a manufacturer or agency calls something “non-lethal,” the label itself can become evidence in a lawsuit if someone dies from its use. “Less than lethal” acknowledges that these tools are designed to minimize fatal outcomes, not eliminate them.

The design goal is temporary incapacitation or pain compliance, buying enough time to control a situation or escape danger. When the effect wears off, the person should recover fully. That is the intent. Reality does not always cooperate, which is why the legal framework and the medical follow-up protocols are built around the possibility that it will not.

The Main Tools

Conducted Energy Devices

Conducted energy devices, often called by the TASER brand name, fire small probes that deliver a high-voltage, low-amperage charge. The charge overrides voluntary muscle control, producing full-body cramping that prevents coordinated movement for a few seconds. Range runs roughly 15 to 25 feet, which is why law enforcement agencies rely on them so heavily.1National Institute of Justice. The Use-of-Force Continuum

Reuters investigations have documented over 1,000 deaths after exposure since the early 2000s, with autopsies listing the device as a cause or contributing factor in roughly 150 cases, often alongside heart conditions or drug use. Some federal courts have responded by limiting authorized use to actively aggressive individuals, and several states now restrict deployment against people in mental health crisis.

Chemical Sprays

Oleoresin capsicum, or OC, is the active ingredient in pepper spray. It produces an inflammatory reaction in the eyes, nose, and throat, causing temporary blindness, difficulty breathing, and burning that overwhelms the ability to fight or flee. Effects usually last 20 to 30 minutes, though contaminated clothing can extend discomfort for hours.2Poison Control. How Dangerous Is Pepper Spray? FBI guidance says normal breathing should return within two to three minutes once the person reaches fresh air.3FBI Vault. Less-Than-Lethal Devices Policy Guide

Kinetic Energy Projectiles

Bean bag rounds, rubber bullets, and foam-tipped projectiles deliver blunt-force impact from a distance. Officers fire them from specialized launchers meant to hurt and deter without penetrating skin. Intended injuries are bruising and localized pain. In practice, these rounds have fractured skulls, destroyed eyes, and killed people when fired at close range or aimed at the head. Accuracy drops significantly beyond about 20 feet.

The Constitutional Standard for Police Use

Every use of force by an officer during an arrest or stop is a “seizure” under the Fourth Amendment, and the only legal question is whether that seizure was reasonable. The Supreme Court settled the framework in Graham v. Connor, holding that excessive force claims against officers are evaluated under Fourth Amendment reasonableness rather than a broader due process analysis.4Library of Congress. Graham v. Connor, 490 U.S. 386

Three factors drive the analysis:

  • The severity of the crime at issue.
  • Whether the person posed an immediate threat to officers or others.
  • Whether the person was actively resisting or trying to flee.

The Court said this analysis must be made from the perspective of a reasonable officer on the scene, not with the benefit of hindsight.4Library of Congress. Graham v. Connor, 490 U.S. 386 A deployment that looks excessive in a calm courtroom may be reasonable if the officer faced a fast-moving threat. One common misconception: the Constitution does not require officers to pick the least forceful option available. The standard is whether the force used fell within the range a reasonable officer would consider appropriate. That lane is wider than most people assume.

De-Escalation

Department of Justice officers must attempt de-escalation before resorting to force whenever doing so is feasible and would not increase danger to the officer or others.5United States Department of Justice. Department of Justice Policy on Use of Force That means verbal commands, creating distance, calling for backup, or simply slowing the encounter. The DOJ also requires annual training on de-escalation alongside use-of-force training.

Many state and local agencies have adopted similar policies, though the specifics vary. Some treat de-escalation as a hard requirement that must be documented; others frame it as best practice. Where it is policy, skipping it without justification can turn an otherwise defensible use of force into an actionable violation.

Passive Resistance Versus Active Threats

Someone who refuses to move during a protest, or goes limp when being handcuffed, is engaging in passive resistance. Someone who swings at an officer or reaches for a weapon is an active threat. That distinction drives the legal analysis more than almost any other factor. Deploying a conducted energy device or chemical spray against a person sitting on the ground and refusing to stand has produced successful civil rights lawsuits and criminal charges against officers. The general principle: the more passive the resistance, the harder it is to justify anything beyond hands-on control techniques.

Duration and Repetition

Continuing to apply force after someone is compliant or incapacitated is where many excessive force claims originate. Delivering multiple electrical cycles after a person has stopped resisting, or spraying someone after they are restrained, almost always crosses the legal line. Policies typically require a verbal warning before deployment when circumstances allow and a reassessment after each application. If the person is no longer an active threat, continued force becomes legally indefensible.

Medical Care After Force

Officers have a constitutional duty to ensure medical care is provided to anyone obviously in need of it after being taken into custody, and that duty is especially clear when the need was created by the force used. Failing to summon help or delaying transport can create separate civil liability for deliberate indifference, independent of whether the original force was justified.

FBI policy on chemical agents sets out the practical steps: move the person to fresh air, keep them upright to maintain an open airway, allow them to wash but not rub their eyes, and maintain constant verbal contact until the effects wear off. If normal breathing does not return within a few minutes, immediate medical attention is required. For impact weapons, medical assistance must be made available as soon as practical whenever an injury occurs.3FBI Vault. Less-Than-Lethal Devices Policy Guide A conscious, competent person can refuse treatment, but the offer still has to happen. Skipping it entirely is the mistake that generates lawsuits.

When Deaths and Serious Injuries Happen

The “less than lethal” label provides no legal immunity. Officers and agencies face the same Fourth Amendment analysis regardless of which weapon was used, and civil rights lawsuits under 42 U.S.C. ยง 1983 are the usual vehicle for these claims. Settlements in deaths involving conducted energy devices have reached into the millions.

For civilians, the stakes are similar. Using a less-lethal weapon on someone who dies from the exposure can result in manslaughter or murder charges depending on the circumstances. The weapon’s design intent does not override the legal standard for self-defense, which requires proportionality to the threat actually faced. Carrying pepper spray instead of a firearm does not create more legal latitude to deploy it recklessly.

Civilian Possession Rules

No single federal statute governs who may buy pepper spray or a conducted energy device for personal protection. State and local law controls, and the rules vary enormously on canister size, chemical concentration, age minimums, permit requirements, and prohibited persons.

Pepper Spray

Pepper spray is legal for civilian self-defense in all 50 states, but many states impose restrictions. Common limits include maximum canister sizes, which range from as low as 0.75 ounces in the most restrictive jurisdictions up to 2.5 ounces in others. Some states have no size cap at all. Sprays containing more than a specified percentage of tear gas (CS or CN) rather than OC may be prohibited or regulated separately. Most states set a minimum purchase age of 18, and a handful allow younger teens to buy with parental consent. Using pepper spray offensively rather than defensively is a crime everywhere.

Stun Guns and Conducted Energy Devices

These face stricter rules than chemical sprays. Some states require a permit similar to a concealed carry license. A few states ban civilian possession outright. Penalties for unlawful carry range from fines to misdemeanor charges with potential jail time. Nearly all states prohibit possession by anyone with a felony conviction, and federal law separately bars people convicted of qualifying domestic violence misdemeanors from possessing firearms and certain other weapons.6United States Department of Justice. Criminal Resource Manual 1117 – Restrictions on the Possession of Firearms by Individuals Convicted of a Misdemeanor Crime of Domestic Violence

Age

No federal law sets a minimum age, but the practical floor in most states is 18. Several states explicitly prohibit sales to minors, and a few carve out exceptions for teenagers with parental permission or, in at least one case, a firearms identification card. Check the specific statute before buying for or giving one to anyone under 18.

Where You Cannot Bring Them

Federal Buildings

Federal law makes it a crime to knowingly bring a dangerous weapon into a federal facility, and the statutory definition is broad enough to cover pepper spray, stun guns, and conducted energy devices. A first offense in a non-courthouse federal building carries up to one year in prison, a fine, or both. Bringing a dangerous weapon into a federal courthouse carries up to two years.7Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 18 U.S. Code 930 – Possession of Firearms and Dangerous Weapons in Federal Facilities Notice of the prohibition must be posted at public entrances, and conviction generally requires either posted notice or actual knowledge of the restriction.

Air Travel

TSA prohibits all chemical sprays and conducted energy devices in carry-on luggage. Pepper spray may go in checked baggage, but only one container of up to 4 fluid ounces, equipped with a safety mechanism, and containing no more than 2 percent tear gas by mass.8Transportation Security Administration. Pepper Spray Stun guns and conducted energy devices may also go in checked bags, but they must be rendered inoperable, and many contain lithium batteries subject to additional airline rules.9Transportation Security Administration. Stun Guns/Shocking Devices Individual carriers can impose stricter policies than TSA’s baseline, so confirm with the airline.

Schools, Courthouses, and Similar Locations

Most states prohibit less-lethal weapons on school grounds and college campuses, in courthouses and government buildings, and in correctional facilities. Some jurisdictions extend the ban to bars, hospitals, and public events. These restrictions apply to civilians; authorized officers are typically exempt. Penalties range from confiscation to misdemeanor charges depending on the jurisdiction and whether possession was knowing.

When a Civilian Can Legally Use It

Owning a less-lethal weapon legally and using one legally are separate questions. The general rule is that you can use less-lethal force in self-defense when you reasonably believe you face an imminent threat of unlawful physical harm. “Reasonable belief” and “imminent” carry the weight. You do not have to wait to be hit, but you need more than a vague feeling of unease. The threat has to be immediate and specific.

Proportionality matters as much for civilians as it does for police. Spraying someone who merely insulted you, or using a stun gun on a person who bumped into you in a crowd, will likely result in assault charges rather than a successful self-defense claim. Less-lethal weapons sit in a middle band: appropriate for threats of physical violence, not for arguments, annoyances, or property disputes where no one is in physical danger.

A few rules trip people up. You generally cannot use force against someone who is retreating. You usually cannot claim self-defense if you provoked the confrontation. Many states impose a duty to retreat if you can safely do so before using any force at all, though stand-your-ground states eliminate that requirement. Once the threat stops, your right to use force stops with it. Continuing to spray someone who is already incapacitated or running away turns self-defense into assault. Most civilian self-defense claims fall apart not in the first second of the deployment, but in the ten seconds after.