Longest Sequestered Jury in U.S. History: Simpson’s 265 Days

The longest sequestered jury in U.S. history served on the 1995 O.J. Simpson murder trial in Los Angeles, kept away from home for 265 days. That nine-month stretch of isolation from family, news, and ordinary life has not been matched in any American court before or since, and it is the reason most judges now treat full sequestration as a last resort.

The Simpson Jury’s 265 Days

O.J. Simpson stood trial for two counts of murder in a case that drew live network coverage, tabloid competition for every forensic detail, and public opinion that split sharply along racial and cultural lines. Judge Lance Ito decided that jury instructions alone could not keep that coverage out of the panel’s heads, so he ordered full sequestration from the start of testimony.

The jurors moved into a hotel under constant supervision by sheriff’s deputies. Television news was off limits. Newspapers were screened and anything touching the case was removed before jurors saw them. Phone calls were monitored. Family visits ran on a set schedule, in controlled settings, with the trial itself off the table as a topic of conversation.

For all of that, jurors were paid $5 a day, the standard California rate at the time. The sequestration itself cost taxpayers close to $2 million, according to the Public Law Research Institute.

The attrition was the clearest sign of the strain. Over the run of the trial at least ten jurors were dismissed and replaced by alternates, for reasons that ranged from undisclosed conflicts to the psychological pressure of being locked away. By the time deliberations began in October 1995, the panel bore little resemblance to the one seated in January.

The Record Before Simpson: The Manson Trial

The previous record belonged to the Charles Manson murder trial. Jurors in that 1970–1971 case were sequestered for roughly eight months while hearing testimony about the Tate-LaBianca killings. Judge Charles Older said at the time that no jury in history had been sequestered for so long or put through such an ordeal. The combination of a charismatic cult leader, graphic evidence, and a defendant who regularly disrupted the courtroom made isolation the only realistic way to protect the panel’s impartiality.

Simpson broke that record by about a month, and in the quarter century since, nothing has come close.

What Sequestration Actually Means

Sequestration is straightforward in concept. The court houses jurors in a controlled location and cuts off their access to outside information so that the verdict reflects only what came through the courtroom. The authority to order it flows from the Sixth Amendment’s guarantee of an impartial jury in a criminal trial. When pretrial publicity or ongoing coverage threatens that impartiality, sequestration is one of the strongest tools a judge has.

The decision sits within the trial judge’s discretion. Either side can move for it, and a judge can order it independently. Federal courts and most state courts treat sequestration as an inherent judicial power rather than a procedure written into a single statute. Full sequestration before trial begins is almost never ordered. Judges start with firm jury instructions and escalate only if those prove inadequate.

Daily Life Inside a Long Sequestration

Sequestered jurors live under supervision most people would find hard to tolerate for a week, let alone months. Court officers escort the group everywhere. Jurors sleep in hotel rooms whose locations are known only to court staff. They eat meals together, often ordered by court personnel. The routine is rigid by design: wake up, travel to the courthouse as a group, sit through testimony, return to the hotel, repeat.

The information restrictions are the disorienting part. Smartphones are typically confiscated or locked away. Television access, if permitted at all, is limited to pre-approved entertainment channels. Court staff screen newspapers and mail to pull anything about the case. Phone calls home may be monitored. Family visits happen on the court’s schedule, in a supervised setting, with the trial off limits as a topic. For jurors with children, elderly parents, or other caregiving duties, no hotel amenity offsets that kind of absence.

The social dynamic inside the group also wears down over time. Strangers forced into close quarters with no ability to leave eventually generate friction. In the Simpson trial, that friction contributed directly to jurors being pulled from the panel.

Why No Jury Since Has Come Close

The Simpson experience is the biggest reason full sequestration is now extraordinarily rare. Judges saw what nearly nine months of isolation did to the panel and concluded the cure can be worse than the disease. The cost to taxpayers, the toll on jurors, and the risk of losing panel members to attrition all push against ordering it except in the most extreme situations.

Courts have shifted toward measures that provide some insulation without total confinement. Strong, repeated instructions against media consumption and independent research are the baseline in every high-profile case. Some judges ask jurors after each recess whether they encountered any case-related information. Phones are commonly confiscated during deliberations even in cases where no broader sequestration is ordered.

Recent high-profile trials show the pattern. The 2017 Bill Cosby sexual assault trial sequestered the jury only during deliberations. The 2021 Derek Chauvin murder trial, which followed the killing of George Floyd, used a partial model: sheriff’s deputies escorted jurors to and from the courthouse each day, jurors were monitored during court hours and told to avoid media coverage, but they went home at night. Full sequestration began only once deliberations started.

The rise of smartphones and social media complicates the calculus rather than simplifying it. In the Manson and Simpson eras, keeping jurors away from a television set was enough. Today a single unmonitored moment with a phone opens access to every theory and leaked detail the internet carries. That reality makes device management during deliberations close to universal in serious cases, and it makes a months-long full sequestration even harder to run. Monitoring a juror’s digital life around the clock for that long takes resources most courts don’t have, which is one more reason the 265-day record set in Los Angeles still stands.