Malfeasance is the legal term for an intentional, unlawful act committed by someone who had no right to do it, resulting in physical or financial harm to another person. The malfeasance definition turns on two ideas working together: the act itself is forbidden, and it was done on purpose. That separates malfeasance from an honest mistake or a careless slip and explains why it carries the heaviest consequences of the three “feasance” categories courts use to describe wrongful conduct.
A public official who takes a bribe, a corporate executive who routes company money into a personal account, and a trustee who forges records are all textbook examples. The wrongdoing lives in the action, not in how the action was performed.1Legal Information Institute. Malfeasance
What a Plaintiff Has to Prove
Two elements define a civil malfeasance claim. The defendant’s conduct must have been willfully wrongful rather than accidental or negligent, and that conduct must have caused the plaintiff actual harm. The plaintiff carries the burden of proof, typically by a preponderance of the evidence, meaning the claim is more likely true than not.2Legal Information Institute. Burden of Proof
Claims rooted in fraud often require more. Many jurisdictions impose a clear and convincing evidence standard for fraud, which sits between the ordinary civil threshold and the criminal “beyond a reasonable doubt” bar.
Malfeasance vs. Misfeasance vs. Nonfeasance
The three terms describe a spectrum of wrongdoing, and the distinctions decide what a plaintiff must prove and what remedies are on the table.
Malfeasance is doing something inherently unlawful. A city treasurer who steals public funds commits malfeasance because the act of stealing was never permissible to begin with.
Misfeasance is doing something lawful in a careless or improper way. A contractor hired to replace a roof who uses substandard materials and causes a leak commits misfeasance. The job was legitimate; the execution caused the harm.
Nonfeasance is failing to act when a legal duty required action. A lifeguard who watches a swimmer drown without attempting a rescue commits nonfeasance. No wrongful act occurred, but the failure to perform a required duty caused the injury.
The practical dividing line is intent. Malfeasance requires proof that the defendant deliberately performed a forbidden act. Misfeasance typically involves negligence. Nonfeasance involves inaction. Courts treat malfeasance as the most serious of the three because intentional wrongdoing justifies harsher consequences, including punitive damages that are rarely available for ordinary negligence.1Legal Information Institute. Malfeasance
Malfeasance in Public Office
When a government employee or elected official commits an unlawful act while exercising official duties, it is often called malfeasance in office or official misconduct. The classic examples are accepting bribes, using public funds for personal benefit, extortion, and deliberately falsifying official records.
The standard language for removing federal officers allows termination for “inefficiency, neglect of duty, or malfeasance.” Malfeasance is consistently treated as the most serious of the three because it involves intentional wrongdoing rather than incompetence or inattention.3Legal Information Institute. Removing Officers – Current Doctrine
Consequences arrive on two tracks. Administratively, officials can be removed from office through statutory procedures or recall elections, and they may be ordered to pay fines and restitution. Criminally, most states classify official misconduct as a felony. Prison exposure in some states runs up to five years; in others, up to ten or even twenty for serious offenses. Financial penalties can reach tens of thousands of dollars, and some states require the official to disgorge any personal gain. Criminal prosecution and administrative removal can run in parallel because they serve different purposes.
Section 1983 Lawsuits
When a state or local official’s malfeasance violates someone’s constitutional rights, the injured party can file a federal civil rights lawsuit under 42 U.S.C. § 1983. The statute lets anyone deprived of constitutional rights by someone acting under government authority sue that person for damages.4Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 42 US Code 1983 – Civil Action for Deprivation of Rights
The plaintiff has to show two things: the defendant was acting under state or local government authority, and the defendant’s conduct deprived the plaintiff of a right protected by the Constitution or federal law. If the claim succeeds, the official is personally liable, meaning the individual pays the judgment unless the government has agreed to indemnify them.
Why Suing a Government Official Is Hard
The right to sue a public official for malfeasance looks broader on paper than it is in practice. Two doctrines block most cases before a jury ever hears the facts.
Qualified Immunity
Qualified immunity shields government officials from personal liability unless their conduct violated a “clearly established” constitutional or statutory right. The plaintiff must show not just that the official broke the law, but that a prior court decision with closely matching facts had already put officials on notice that the conduct was unlawful. If no sufficiently similar case exists, the official is immune no matter how egregious the misconduct.5Legal Information Institute. Qualified Immunity
This is where most civil rights cases against officials die. The “clearly established” standard is demanding, and it often protects officials whose conduct was plainly harmful but factually novel.
Sovereign Immunity and the FTCA
When the defendant is a federal agency rather than an individual, sovereign immunity creates a separate barrier. The federal government cannot be sued without its consent. Congress partially waived that protection through the Federal Tort Claims Act, which allows lawsuits for injury or property damage caused by a federal employee’s wrongful act committed within the scope of their duties.6Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 28 USC 1346
FTCA claims come with strict procedure. The plaintiff must first file a written claim with the responsible agency within two years of the injury, and if the agency denies it, the plaintiff has six months to file suit in federal court. Missing either deadline bars the claim permanently.7Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 28 US Code 2401 – Time for Commencing Action Against United States
The FTCA does not create new causes of action on its own. It borrows from the tort law of the state where the wrongful act occurred. The government also remains immune from claims based on certain discretionary functions, and punitive damages are not available in FTCA cases.
Corporate and Fiduciary Malfeasance
Outside government, malfeasance claims arise most often in fiduciary relationships. Corporate officers, directors, trustees, and agents owe duties of loyalty and care to the people they serve, whether shareholders, beneficiaries, or business partners. The duty of loyalty requires these individuals to place the interests of the corporation or beneficiary ahead of their own.8Legal Information Institute. Duty of Loyalty
Corporate malfeasance happens when a fiduciary deliberately violates that duty through an unauthorized or illegal act. An executive diverting company revenue into a shell company they control, a director concealing a conflict of interest to push through a self-serving deal, a trustee forging investment records — the common thread is intentional self-dealing at the expense of the people the fiduciary is supposed to protect.
When the harm falls on the company itself rather than any one shareholder, shareholders can bring a derivative lawsuit on behalf of the corporation. The claim belongs to the company, and any damages awarded go to the corporate treasury rather than to the shareholder who filed the suit.9Legal Information Institute. Shareholder’s Derivative Action
What a Successful Claim Can Recover
When a court finds malfeasance occurred, remedies fall into two broad categories: money and court orders.
Compensatory damages reimburse the plaintiff for actual losses. These can include direct financial harm like stolen funds or lost business revenue, along with related costs such as legal fees. The aim is to put the plaintiff back in the position they would have been in if the malfeasance had never happened.10Legal Information Institute. Damages
Punitive damages are available on top of compensatory damages because malfeasance involves intentional wrongdoing. They exist to punish the defendant and deter similar conduct, and they are typically available only when the plaintiff proves the defendant acted intentionally or with willful disregard for the plaintiff’s rights.11Legal Information Institute. Punitive Damages Malfeasance cases are fertile ground for these awards, though the U.S. Supreme Court has imposed constitutional limits on how large a punitive award can be relative to compensatory damages.
Equitable relief steps in when money alone cannot fix the harm. An injunction is the most common form. A court might order a corporate officer to stop transferring assets, require a trustee to return misappropriated property, or bar a public official from continuing to exercise authority they have abused.12Legal Information Institute. Equitable Relief
For public officials, administrative proceedings can produce removal from office, fines, and mandatory restitution. These operate independently of any criminal prosecution, so the same official can be removed, ordered to repay misused funds, and still face a criminal case.
Filing Deadlines
Every civil claim has a deadline, and malfeasance claims are no exception. Miss the window and the court will dismiss the case no matter how strong the evidence.
For claims against the federal government under the FTCA, the plaintiff files a written claim with the responsible agency within two years and then has six months after a denial to file suit.7Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 28 US Code 2401 – Time for Commencing Action Against United States
For private civil claims involving intentional misconduct like fraud or embezzlement, deadlines vary by jurisdiction but generally run from two to six years. Many states apply a discovery rule that starts the clock when the plaintiff knew or should have known about the misconduct rather than when the act happened. That matters in malfeasance cases because the wrongdoing is often concealed. A corporate officer embezzling through fraudulent accounting may not be discovered for years, and the discovery rule keeps that delay from shielding the wrongdoer.
Check your jurisdiction’s specific deadline early. Consulting a lawyer soon after discovering potential malfeasance protects both the legal claim and the ability to gather evidence before it disappears.