Mandatory minimum sentences reform moved forward in 2023, but not where most people were watching. Congress held hearings and introduced bills, yet none passed. The real change came from the U.S. Sentencing Commission, whose Amendment 821 to the federal sentencing guidelines made roughly 18,000 federal prisoners eligible to seek reduced sentences. Several states adjusted their own mandatory minimums for drug and nonviolent offenses, though at least one high-profile state experiment moved in the opposite direction.
Amendment 821: The Change That Actually Took Effect
The U.S. Sentencing Commission approved Amendment 821 in April 2023. It took effect on November 1, 2023, with retroactive application beginning February 1, 2024.1United States Sentencing Commission. Amendment 821
The amendment has two parts, and both change how federal sentencing ranges are calculated rather than changing any statute.
Part A targets “status points,” the extra criminal history points previously added to anyone who committed a new offense while on probation, parole, or supervised release. Those two added points often pushed defendants into a higher sentencing range. Under the revised guidelines, offenders with fewer than seven total criminal history points no longer receive any status points, and those with seven or more receive one point instead of two.1United States Sentencing Commission. Amendment 821
Part B creates a two-level reduction in offense level for “zero-point offenders,” meaning defendants with no criminal history points who also meet several additional criteria. That reduction lowers the recommended sentencing range for people with clean records.
The scope is significant. The Commission estimated that roughly 11,495 incarcerated individuals would qualify for reduced sentences under Part A, with an average reduction of 11.7 percent, and about 7,272 would be eligible under Part B, with an average reduction of 17.6 percent.2United States Sentencing Commission. Amendment 821 In Brief These are not automatic releases. Each case requires a motion and judicial review. But for nearly 18,000 federal prisoners, the amendment opened a path to a shorter sentence that did not exist before.
The Federal Bills That Stalled
Three major reform bills moved through the 118th Congress in 2023. All attracted bipartisan co-sponsors. None reached a floor vote.
The EQUAL Act
The EQUAL Act, introduced in both the House (H.R. 1062) and Senate (S. 524), would have eliminated the sentencing disparity between crack and powder cocaine by equalizing the two at a 1-to-1 ratio.3Congress.gov. H.R.1062 – 118th Congress (2023-2024) – EQUAL Act It also would have authorized resentencing for people already serving time under the older, harsher crack thresholds. The Senate version was referred to the Judiciary Committee in February 2023 and never received a vote.4Congress.gov. S.524 – EQUAL Act 118th Congress (2023-2024)
Because the bill did not pass, the current disparity remains in place. The original Anti-Drug Abuse Act of 1986 set a 100-to-1 ratio, triggering the same five-year mandatory minimum for 5 grams of crack as for 500 grams of powder cocaine.5Congress.gov. Cocaine: Crack and Powder Sentencing Disparities The Fair Sentencing Act of 2010 narrowed that gap to roughly 18-to-1. Under current law, 28 grams of crack triggers a five-year mandatory minimum, compared to 500 grams of powder cocaine; for the ten-year minimum, the thresholds are 280 grams of crack versus 5 kilograms of powder.6Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 21 USC 841
The Smarter Sentencing Act of 2023
The Smarter Sentencing Act (S. 1152) took a wider approach, targeting mandatory minimums for a range of nonviolent drug offenses rather than only crack cocaine. According to the Senate Judiciary Committee’s summary, the bill would have lowered certain drug mandatory sentences while leaving maximum penalties unchanged, giving judges more room to calibrate punishment case by case without removing the option of the harshest penalties when circumstances warranted them.7United States Senate Committee on the Judiciary. Smarter Sentencing Act Summary The bill also would have required reporting on cost savings from reduced sentences. It did not advance past committee.8Congress.gov. S.1152 – Smarter Sentencing Act of 2023 118th Congress (2023-2024)
The First Step Implementation Act of 2023
The First Step Implementation Act (S. 1251) was designed to extend the reach of the original First Step Act of 2018, which introduced earned time credits allowing federal inmates to shorten time in secure custody through program participation.9United States Sentencing Commission. First Step Act Earned Time Credits The 2023 bill would have allowed courts to retroactively reduce sentences for a broader set of offenses covered by the 2018 law, letting defendants petition for resentencing as though the First Step Act had been in effect when they were originally sentenced.10Congress.gov. S.1251 – 118th Congress (2023-2024) – First Step Implementation Act of 2023 It also remained in committee at the close of the session.
The Federal Safety Valve
Several of the 2023 proposals referenced the federal “safety valve,” which already exists and lets judges sentence below a mandatory minimum for certain drug offenses. Knowing how it works explains what reformers are trying to expand.
Under 18 U.S.C. ยง 3553(f), a judge can set aside the mandatory minimum for drug offenses covered by the Controlled Substances Act if the defendant meets all five of these conditions:
- No more than four criminal history points (excluding one-point offenses), no prior three-point offenses, and no prior two-point violent offenses.
- No use or threat of violence, and no possession of a firearm during the offense.
- The offense did not result in anyone’s death or serious bodily harm.
- The defendant was not an organizer, leader, manager, or supervisor in the offense.
- The defendant truthfully provided the government all information they had about the offense before sentencing.
When all five are met, the judge sentences under the advisory guidelines rather than the statutory floor.11Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 18 U.S. Code 3553 – Imposition of a Sentence Someone with a modest criminal history or who played even a minor leadership role is disqualified. Reform proposals have generally sought to loosen these criteria so the valve covers a wider pool of defendants.
What States Are Doing
While federal legislation stalled, several states adjusted their own mandatory minimums. The 2023 state-level activity grouped loosely into three areas: reducing or eliminating mandatory minimums for drug offenses, expanding record-sealing and expungement, and narrowing three-strikes laws.
On drug offenses, several states considered or passed legislation allowing judges to impose probation or treatment-focused sentences for crimes that previously carried fixed prison terms. Approaches varied. Some states eliminated minimums entirely for possession; others adjusted the quantity thresholds that trigger harsher penalties.
On record-sealing, more than a dozen states and the District of Columbia had enacted some version of automatic “clean slate” legislation by 2023, sealing records for people who complete their sentences and remain crime-free for a set period.
On three-strikes laws, which impose lengthy mandatory sentences on people convicted of a third qualifying felony, reform efforts generally tried to narrow the list of qualifying offenses so the harshest penalties fell on repeat violent offenders rather than nonviolent third-time offenders.
The direction has not been uniform. Oregon, which decriminalized possession of small amounts of drugs through a 2020 ballot measure, saw significant political backlash by 2023 and reversed course in 2024 by recriminalizing drug possession as a misdemeanor. Sentencing reform does not move in a straight line, and public opinion can shift when a policy is perceived as failing.
The Common Thread: Judicial Discretion
What ties the 2023 reforms together is the return of some discretion to judges. Mandatory minimums shift sentencing power from judges to legislators and, in practice, to prosecutors, because the charging decision often sets the mandatory sentence. When a prosecutor charges a quantity that triggers a minimum, the judge’s role at sentencing narrows to reading the statute and imposing the floor.
Restoring discretion does not mean judges operate without rules. Federal judges still work within the advisory sentencing guidelines, which supply recommended ranges based on offense severity and criminal history. Those guidelines give structure without rigidity, letting a judge weigh whether the defendant was a minor participant, whether they cooperated, and whether a long prison term serves any purpose beyond punishment.
Amendment 821 shows how this plays out. By changing how criminal history points are calculated, the Sentencing Commission moved thousands of cases into lower guideline ranges. The judge still sets the final sentence within that range, but the range now better reflects actual circumstances rather than treating everyone in the same category identically.
The pattern from 2023 is that the Sentencing Commission acted where Congress would not, and states continued experimenting on their own. The federal bills that stalled still drew bipartisan support that would have been unlikely a decade earlier. Whether that support turns into votes in future sessions is the open question.