Metal Theft: State and Federal Penalties, Stacked Charges

Penalties for metal theft run from misdemeanor fines and up to a year in jail at the low end to 20 years in federal prison when the theft damages an energy facility. Where a specific case lands depends on three things: the dollar value of what was taken or damaged, whether critical infrastructure was involved, and what collateral charges prosecutors add on top of the theft itself.

State Penalties Turn on Dollar Value

Every state treats metal theft as a property crime, and the severity of the charge tracks the value of what was taken or damaged. Lower-value thefts are typically misdemeanors carrying up to a year in jail plus fines that vary by jurisdiction. Once the loss crosses a felony threshold, which runs roughly from $750 to $2,500 depending on the state, the charge escalates and prison time enters the picture.

Felony theft convictions can produce multi-year prison sentences, with length tied to the value tier and the defendant’s prior record. Many states have layered enhanced penalties on top of their general theft statutes for specific scenarios: stealing copper from utility infrastructure, removing catalytic converters, or targeting critical public safety equipment. These enhancements exist because the collateral damage from metal theft usually far exceeds the raw scrap value.

Restitution comes on top of fines and imprisonment, and in metal theft cases that number can dwarf the sentence’s financial penalties. Restitution covers not just the scrap value of the stolen material but the full cost of repair or replacement and any lost revenue the victim suffered during the outage. A business whose HVAC system is gutted in July or a neighborhood that loses power for three days generates restitution figures that climb quickly.

Why Non-Ferrous Metals Matter More

Scrap-metal statutes commonly distinguish ferrous metals (iron, steel) from non-ferrous metals (copper, aluminum, brass, bronze). Non-ferrous metals bring much higher prices per pound, which is why copper wiring and aluminum components get stolen at far higher rates than steel. That distinction isn’t just market trivia; many jurisdictions impose stricter penalties or additional regulatory requirements when non-ferrous metals are involved, so the same weight of stolen material can carry a different charge depending on what it is.

Federal Penalties for Energy Infrastructure Damage

Metal theft becomes a federal crime when it damages energy infrastructure. Under 18 U.S.C. ยง 1366, anyone who knowingly damages the property of an energy facility faces up to 20 years in prison if the damage exceeds $100,000 or causes a significant interruption to the facility’s operations.1Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 18 USC 1366 – Destruction of an Energy Facility Even when the damage falls below $100,000, if it exceeds $5,000 the offense still carries up to five years in federal prison.

Federal fines are heavy. Under the general federal sentencing framework, an individual convicted of a felony faces fines up to $250,000, and an organization up to $500,000.2Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 18 USC 3571 – Sentence of Fine Federal mandatory restitution also applies to property offenses where a victim suffered financial loss, requiring the defendant to pay the greater of the property’s value at the time of destruction or at sentencing.3Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 18 USC 3663A – Mandatory Restitution to Victims of Certain Crimes

Charges That Stack On Top of the Theft

Metal theft rarely results in a single charge. Prosecutors regularly add trespassing counts when the defendant entered private property or a restricted area to reach the metal. Criminal mischief or vandalism charges apply to the damage caused during removal, which is almost always substantial because thieves rip out wiring rather than carefully disconnecting it. When the stolen material crosses state lines on its way to a scrap dealer, interstate transportation of stolen property under federal law can apply as well.

The most serious add-on arises when someone dies during the theft. Stripping copper from energized electrical equipment kills people every year, and research published through the National Institutes of Health has documented the pattern of devastating high-voltage burns and fatalities associated with copper theft from live electrical systems.4National Institutes of Health. Copper Wire Theft and High Voltage Electrical Burns When a co-conspirator dies from electrocution during a theft, the surviving participants can face felony murder charges in many states because the death occurred during the commission of a felony.

What Counts as Metal Theft

At its core, metal theft is the unauthorized taking of someone else’s property for the value of the metal it contains. The Model Penal Code defines theft by unlawful taking as exercising unlawful control over another person’s movable property with the intent to deprive the owner of it. Most states have adopted some version of that framework and many have gone further with scrap-metal-specific statutes that spell out which materials trigger enhanced scrutiny.

Catalytic converters are the most commonly targeted item because they contain platinum, palladium, and rhodium, and can be removed in under two minutes with a battery-powered saw. Replacement costs the vehicle owner between $800 and $3,500 depending on the make and model, with hybrid vehicles like the Toyota Prius toward the higher end. Copper wiring is the other headline target, taken from construction sites, utility substations, telecommunications hubs, vacant buildings, and HVAC systems. Aluminum siding, gutters, downspouts, manhole covers, guard rails, bronze memorial plaques, and even bleachers from public parks have all been stolen for scrap.

Pending Federal Catalytic Converter Legislation

As of 2026, Congress is considering the Preventing Auto Recycling Theft Act, known as the PART Act, which would create a dedicated federal criminal penalty for stealing, selling, or knowingly purchasing stolen catalytic converters. The bill proposes up to five years in prison for these offenses.5Congress.gov. H.R. 5221 – 119th Congress – PART Act It was introduced in the House in September 2025 as H.R. 5221 and remains pending. If enacted, it would give federal prosecutors a tool tailored specifically to catalytic converter theft rather than requiring them to fit these cases into broader infrastructure-damage or interstate-theft statutes.

If You Are the Victim

The scrap payout and the repair bill are rarely in the same universe. A thief might collect $50 to $300 for a catalytic converter that costs the owner $1,000 to $3,500 to replace. Copper stripped from an air conditioner might fetch $20 at a scrap yard against a $5,000 repair bill, and those figures don’t include lost business revenue, emergency service calls, or temporary housing. That gap is one reason restitution orders in these cases tend to run high.

For vehicle owners, comprehensive auto insurance typically covers catalytic converter theft. The policy pays for the replacement converter and related removal damage, minus the deductible. If you park where converter theft is common and your vehicle is a known target, carrying comprehensive coverage is worth serious consideration because replacement costs easily exceed $2,000.

Property owners face a more complicated picture. Commercial property policies may cover metal theft under their theft or vandalism provisions, but that coverage often comes with sublimits well below the overall policy cap. A property insured for $100,000 might have only $30,000 allocated specifically to theft losses, and theft deductibles sometimes differ from the standard policy deductible. Vacant properties are especially vulnerable, and many insurers exclude theft coverage entirely unless the owner maintains specific protective measures like boarding windows, securing entry points, and conducting regular site visits.

Some states operate victim compensation funds that reimburse crime victims for out-of-pocket losses, but these programs are primarily designed for violent crime victims and may offer only limited assistance for property crimes. Eligibility rules and reimbursement caps vary widely. In practice, most metal theft victims recover through insurance, court-ordered restitution, or some combination of the two.