The Michelle Wierson case is the Georgia prosecution of a Decatur psychologist who, in the middle of a psychotic episode after stopping her bipolar medication, drove 51 miles per hour into a stopped car in September 2018 and killed five-year-old Miles Jenness. Wierson was convicted in February 2026 of vehicular homicide and reckless driving. Before her trial could even begin, her appeal reached the Supreme Court of Georgia, which used her case to overturn a 1982 precedent and rule that defendants whose mental state deteriorates because they stopped taking psychiatric medication can still raise the insanity defense.1FindLaw. State v. Wierson, S24G1299
What Happened on September 27, 2018
At about 5:13 p.m., Wierson was driving a Volkswagen Tiguan through a residential area of Decatur when she rear-ended a Toyota Corolla stopped at a red light at Midway Road and South Candler Street. She was going roughly 51 mph in a 25-mph zone and did not appear to brake. The impact shoved the Corolla through the intersection into a third vehicle.2DeKalb County District Attorney. Michelle Wierson Sentencing3Atlanta News First. Woman Off Bipolar Medication Can Use Insanity Defense in Deadly Crash Case, GA Supreme Court Rules
Miles Jenness was in the back seat of the Toyota, in a car seat, riding home from an afterschool program with his father, Samuel Jenness, an Emory University professor. The crash pinned Miles between the back seat and the front passenger seat. He suffered catastrophic brain and spinal injuries and died two days later, on September 29, 2018, at Children’s Healthcare of Atlanta at Egleston. His father was cut in the collision.4Atlanta Journal-Constitution. On Trial: A Woman Wanted to Save Her Daughter. She Killed Someone’s Son5FOX 5 Atlanta. Decatur Woman Sentenced in Crash That Killed 5-Year-Old
Wierson’s Bipolar Disorder and the Delusion
Wierson had been diagnosed with bipolar disorder in 2005 and had struggled with the condition for more than a decade.6Atlanta Journal-Constitution. Psychologist Found Guilty but Mentally Ill in Decatur 5-Year-Old’s Death She was prescribed at least four psychiatric medications, and evidence showed she had stopped taking at least three of them in the weeks before the crash.3Atlanta News First. Woman Off Bipolar Medication Can Use Insanity Defense in Deadly Crash Case, GA Supreme Court Rules
In the hour before the collision, she called 911 and told the operator someone was chasing her. A neighbor had already noticed her behaving strangely and believed she was in a psychotic break. Decatur police encountered her before the crash; Lieutenant John Bender later testified that she seemed “coherent” at times but “detached” and sometimes unresponsive at others.4Atlanta Journal-Constitution. On Trial: A Woman Wanted to Save Her Daughter. She Killed Someone’s Son
Two psychiatrists — one hired by the defense, one appointed by the court — concluded that at the moment of the crash Wierson was in the grip of a psychotic delusion. She believed God was driving her car and had told her that her daughter’s life was in danger and had to be saved. Both experts agreed she could not distinguish right from wrong at that moment.3Atlanta News First. Woman Off Bipolar Medication Can Use Insanity Defense in Deadly Crash Case, GA Supreme Court Rules
The Fight Over Whether She Could Even Argue Insanity
Wierson was charged with first-degree vehicular homicide, reckless driving, DUI, and battery, and pleaded not guilty by reason of insanity.7Atlanta Journal-Constitution. Driver Charged in Death of Year-Old Killed in Decatur Crash Prosecutors argued that by stopping her medication she had voluntarily induced her own mental state, which should bar her from claiming insanity. The trial court agreed and ruled that the jury could consider her decision to stop taking the medication.8FindLaw. Wierson v. State, A24A0241
That ruling climbed the appellate ladder and delayed the trial by years. On June 25, 2024, the Georgia Court of Appeals reversed. It held that Georgia’s insanity statutes were “clear and unambiguous,” focused solely on the defendant’s mental state at the time of the act, and contained no “self-induced insanity” exception. The court also pointed out that vehicular homicide and reckless driving are strict-liability offenses, so why her mental state had deteriorated was legally irrelevant to the elements the State had to prove.8FindLaw. Wierson v. State, A24A0241
The State appealed, and on May 28, 2025, the Supreme Court of Georgia unanimously affirmed in State v. Wierson (S24G1299). The court went a step further than the Court of Appeals had: it expressly overruled Bailey v. State, a 1982 decision that had governed Georgia insanity law for more than 40 years. Bailey had involved a paranoid schizophrenic who ignored medical advice to avoid stress, entered a stressful situation anyway, and killed two people; the court at that time held that a defendant who “brought about” their own delusion could not claim the delusional compulsion defense.1FindLaw. State v. Wierson, S24G1299
In Wierson, the justices called Bailey “unreasoned” and “policy-driven.” The plain text of Georgia’s insanity statutes (OCGA §§ 16-3-2 and 16-3-3) carves out no exception for voluntarily induced mental states, while the voluntary intoxication statute (OCGA § 16-3-4) does contain such a carve-out. The legislature knew how to write that exception when it wanted one, and courts had no authority to supply one it had omitted.1FindLaw. State v. Wierson, S24G1299
The Trial and the Verdict
With the insanity defense preserved, the trial opened in DeKalb County Superior Court in February 2026, more than seven years after the crash. Prosecutors introduced the speed data, the absence of braking, and a recording of Wierson’s voice from the time of the incident, and questioned her about her decision to stop her medications. Her defense, led by attorney Kristen Novay, argued she was in a psychotic episode and could not tell right from wrong, with forensic psychiatrists describing her bipolar disorder and the delusion that God was commanding her to rescue her daughter.4Atlanta Journal-Constitution. On Trial: A Woman Wanted to Save Her Daughter. She Killed Someone’s Son
On February 25, 2026, the jury returned a verdict of “guilty but mentally ill” on two counts of vehicular homicide and guilty of reckless driving.6Atlanta Journal-Constitution. Psychologist Found Guilty but Mentally Ill in Decatur 5-Year-Old’s Death Under Georgia law, “guilty but mentally ill” is not an acquittal. It means the jury accepted that the defendant was mentally ill but concluded that the illness did not prevent her from understanding her conduct was wrong. The designation is a conviction that comes with a requirement that mental health treatment be built into the sentence.9Justia. Georgia Code Section 16-3-2
The Sentence
The next day, February 26, 2026, Judge Courtney L. Johnson sentenced Wierson to 15 years: five in a Department of Corrections facility and ten on probation. Corrections officials will set her mental health treatment plan under the “guilty but mentally ill” finding. During probation she is permanently banned from driving and must comply with ongoing medical and mental health requirements.2DeKalb County District Attorney. Michelle Wierson Sentencing
Miles’s mother, Leah Jenness, told the court the family had “never been out for blood, only justice and accountability, because that’s what Miles deserved.” After the sentencing she said, “We can lay it down now and focus on Miles.”10Decaturish. Driver Who Caused 5-Year-Old’s Death Will Serve Five Years
Why the Ruling Matters Beyond This Case
The appellate decision in Wierson reshaped Georgia’s insanity defense. By overruling Bailey, the Supreme Court established that medication noncompliance, or other voluntary conduct that contributes to a mental health crisis, cannot by itself bar a defendant from raising the insanity defense. Under Georgia law, what matters is the defendant’s mental state at the time of the offense, not how the defendant arrived at that state.1FindLaw. State v. Wierson, S24G1299 A Mercer Law Review article called the ruling a “pivotal shift toward textualism” in Georgia’s insanity jurisprudence, reasserting the primacy of statutory text over judge-made policy exceptions.11Mercer Law Review. Delusions of Judicial Grandeur: State v. Wierson and the Return to Statutory Sanity
The outcome of her own case cut the other way. Wierson won the legal fight that let her raise the defense, and then the jury rejected it, finding that her mental illness was real but had not stripped her of the ability to know that what she was doing was wrong.