Model Penal Code Section 2.06 governs accomplice liability: it makes you guilty of a crime committed by another person if you purposefully solicited, aided, agreed or attempted to aid in it, or failed a legal duty to prevent it. Adopted by the American Law Institute in 1962, the section replaces the old common law split between principals and accessories with a single theory called complicity, and an accomplice faces the same charge and the same punishment as the person who physically carried out the offense.1The American Law Institute. Model Penal Code
Section 2.06(1) states the rule directly. A person is guilty of an offense if it was committed by their own conduct or by the conduct of another person for which they are legally accountable.2OpenCasebook. Model Penal Code 2.06 – Liability for Conduct of Another; Complicity Subsection (2) then lists three routes to that accountability: causing an innocent or incapable person to perform the act, being made accountable by a specific statute, or being an accomplice in the offense.3OpenCasebook. Criminal Law – MPC Section 2.06 The accomplice route carries most of the weight in practice, and the rest of Section 2.06 defines it.
What Makes You an Accomplice Under Section 2.06(3)
Under Section 2.06(3), a person is an accomplice of another in committing an offense if, with the purpose of promoting or facilitating the commission of the offense, they do any of the following:
- Solicit the other person to commit it.
- Aid, agree to aid, or attempt to aid the other person in planning or committing it.
- Having a legal duty to prevent the offense, fail to make proper effort to do so.
The “attempt to aid” language is one of the more aggressive features of the section. At common law, help that never reached the principal or made no difference could leave you outside accomplice liability. The MPC closes that gap. A person who tries to supply a burglar with lockpicking tools and delivers them to the wrong address has still done enough, so long as the purpose requirement is met.2OpenCasebook. Model Penal Code 2.06 – Liability for Conduct of Another; Complicity
The legal-duty prong is narrower than it reads. It does not turn every bystander into an accomplice. It applies to people who have an existing legal obligation to intervene, such as a law enforcement officer or a parent with a duty to protect a child, who purposefully fail to act because they want the crime to succeed.2OpenCasebook. Model Penal Code 2.06 – Liability for Conduct of Another; Complicity Mere presence at the scene, or even knowing a crime is underway, is not enough.
Purpose, Not Knowledge
The mental state requirement is the linchpin of the section and the source of most of the litigation around it. Each form of complicity in 2.06(3) must be done “with the purpose of promoting or facilitating the commission of the offense.”2OpenCasebook. Model Penal Code 2.06 – Liability for Conduct of Another; Complicity Purpose is the highest mental state in the MPC hierarchy. It means the person’s conscious objective was to help the crime happen.
Knowledge is not enough. A hardware store clerk who sells a crowbar knowing the buyer plans a burglary has knowledge of the crime, but the prosecution would still need to show the clerk actually wanted the burglary to succeed. Courts and scholars have debated for decades whether knowledge should suffice, and some federal circuits have moved back and forth on the question. The MPC drafters came down firmly on the side of purpose.
Result Crimes
Section 2.06(4) adjusts the mental state for a particular category: offenses defined by a harmful result rather than specific prohibited conduct. Homicide is the classic example. When the offense is about causing a result, the accomplice is guilty if they acted with the kind of culpability the offense requires for that result.4OpenCasebook. Model Penal Code Section 2.06 So in a drag race where a bystander is killed, the driver who encouraged the race can be liable for manslaughter as an accomplice if they were reckless about the risk of death, because recklessness is what manslaughter demands. The accomplice does not need to have purposefully intended the death; they need to match the mental state the substantive offense requires for its result.
Using an Innocent Person as a Tool
Section 2.06(2)(a) covers the person who uses someone else, legally innocent or incapable, as the instrument of a crime. The manipulator is treated as the principal offender. Trick someone who has no idea the goods are stolen into delivering a package, and you are the one charged with theft. The unwitting courier walks free because they lacked any criminal awareness.2OpenCasebook. Model Penal Code 2.06 – Liability for Conduct of Another; Complicity The “innocent or irresponsible” language is broad enough to cover children too young to form criminal intent, people with severe cognitive disabilities, and people acting under a genuine mistake of fact. The manipulator still has to possess the mental state the underlying offense requires.
Who Is Not an Accomplice
Section 2.06(6) carves out three situations where a person cannot be treated as an accomplice, even if their conduct would otherwise fit.
Victims
A person who is the victim of the very offense in question is not an accomplice to it. A kidnapping victim who pays a ransom arguably facilitates the crime, but the law does not punish victims for conduct driven by their own victimization.2OpenCasebook. Model Penal Code 2.06 – Liability for Conduct of Another; Complicity
Inevitably Incidental Conduct
When an offense is defined in a way that necessarily involves another person’s participation, that other person is not automatically an accomplice. The buyer in an illegal drug sale participates in the transaction, but the distribution offense targets the seller. The buyer’s conduct is inherent to the transaction the statute targets, so the buyer is not treated as an accomplice to the selling offense.2OpenCasebook. Model Penal Code 2.06 – Liability for Conduct of Another; Complicity The same logic covers statutory rape where the underage participant is the person the law protects.
Renunciation
A person who initially helped plan or set up the crime can escape accomplice liability by withdrawing before it is committed, but the bar is high. The person must terminate their involvement and then do at least one of the following: wholly deprive their earlier assistance of its effectiveness, give law enforcement a timely warning, or otherwise make a proper effort to prevent the crime.2OpenCasebook. Model Penal Code 2.06 – Liability for Conduct of Another; Complicity Walking away or telling co-conspirators you are out is not enough. If you supplied the weapon, you need to get it back. If you cannot undo your contribution, you need to call the police.
Doctrines the MPC Rejects
Two common law doctrines that expand accomplice liability beyond the MPC’s limits are worth knowing, because many jurisdictions still apply them.
Natural and Probable Consequences
At common law, an accomplice is liable not only for the crime they intended to help with, but also for any other offense that was a natural and probable consequence of the original plan. Help plan a robbery, and if the principal kills someone during it, you are on the hook for the murder even if you never intended anyone to be hurt. The MPC commentary called that position “incongruous and unjust.” By requiring purpose for each specific offense, Section 2.06 rejects it. You are an accomplice only to crimes you actually meant to promote or facilitate.
Pinkerton
Named for a 1946 Supreme Court decision, the Pinkerton doctrine holds every member of a conspiracy liable for any crime a co-conspirator commits in furtherance of the conspiracy, as long as the crime was reasonably foreseeable. Federal courts still apply it. Nothing in Section 2.06 makes a person liable for another’s crime based solely on membership in a conspiracy.2OpenCasebook. Model Penal Code 2.06 – Liability for Conduct of Another; Complicity You have to meet the accomplice standard independently as to each offense charged.
Convicting the Accomplice When the Principal Isn’t
Section 2.06(7) addresses a question that surprises many people. An accomplice can be convicted even if the principal has not been prosecuted, has been acquitted, has been convicted of a different offense or degree, or has immunity from prosecution.4OpenCasebook. Model Penal Code Section 2.06 All the prosecution needs to prove is that the offense was committed and that the defendant was complicit in it. If the getaway driver is caught but the robber flees the country, the driver can still be prosecuted as an accomplice to the robbery. The accomplice’s guilt stands on its own.
How Complicity Differs from Conspiracy
These two concepts overlap often enough that it helps to see where they part. Complicity under Section 2.06 is not a separate crime. It is a theory of liability that makes a person guilty of the substantive offense another person committed. Conspiracy under MPC Section 5.03 is an independent offense: the crime of agreeing to commit a crime. A person can be convicted of conspiracy even if the planned crime never happens, so long as there was an agreement plus, for most offenses, an overt act in furtherance of it.5OpenCasebook. MPC 5.03 Criminal Conspiracy
A person can be both a conspirator and an accomplice, and prosecutors often charge both. Agreeing to commit a crime does not automatically make you an accomplice to whatever your co-conspirators actually do. Each theory has its own elements under the MPC. A defendant who joined a conspiracy to steal cars is not automatically guilty as an accomplice to an assault that a co-conspirator commits during a theft, unless the defendant also purposefully promoted or facilitated that assault.