A nitrogen hypoxia execution kills a condemned prisoner by sealing a respirator-style mask over the nose and mouth and feeding pure nitrogen gas through it, so that every breath delivers zero oxygen until the brain and heart shut down. Alabama carried out the first such execution in January 2024, and as of 2025 five states — Alabama, Arkansas, Louisiana, Mississippi, and Oklahoma — authorize the method. The three executions performed so far, all in Alabama, each involved several minutes of visible shaking and gasping before the prisoner stopped breathing.
How Breathing Pure Nitrogen Kills a Person
Ordinary air is roughly 78 percent nitrogen and 21 percent oxygen.1National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration. JetStream – The Atmosphere Nitrogen itself is inert; people breathe it constantly without harm. What keeps the body alive is the oxygen mixed in with it.
When a person inhales pure nitrogen, the lungs keep moving air in and out normally. Carbon dioxide is still exhaled, which matters because the suffocation reflex, the panicked urge to breathe, is triggered by CO2 building up in the blood rather than by low oxygen. So the body does not register that anything is wrong in the usual way. But each breath carries no oxygen into the bloodstream, and blood oxygen levels fall within seconds. The brain begins shutting down.
That silent quality is why nitrogen is dangerous outside the execution context too. The U.S. Chemical Safety and Hazard Investigation Board warns that people die every year from breathing air with too little oxygen in it, and that a nitrogen-enriched environment cannot be detected by smell or taste.2U.S. Chemical Safety and Hazard Investigation Board. Hazards of Nitrogen Asphyxiation Supporters of the method pointed to the rapid loss of consciousness as evidence it would be painless. The executions themselves produced a different picture.
Equipment and What Happens in the Chamber
The procedure uses a respirator-style gas mask connected by medical-grade tubing to pressurized tanks of pure nitrogen. The mask must create an airtight seal over the nose and mouth. If ambient air leaks in, the process can be prolonged and cause pain instead of unconsciousness. An electrocardiogram and pulse oximetry sensors monitor heart activity and blood oxygen in real time.
Corrections staff train in pressurized gas handling and run simulations to verify the mask seal under different conditions. The protocol calls for a final inspection of the mask immediately before the execution begins. Alabama’s published protocol is heavily redacted, so the gas flow rates and timing are not public.
Once the warden gives the command, nitrogen flows into the mask and displaces breathable air. In each of the three Alabama executions, the gas flowed for roughly 15 minutes. Medical personnel watch the EKG until cardiac activity stops, and then a physician or coroner examines the body and formally pronounces death.
Alabama’s protocol also acknowledges risks to other people in the chamber. If the hose supplying nitrogen detaches, free-flowing gas can displace oxygen roughly two feet from the outflow point, and overpressure can build a pocket of nitrogen around the prisoner’s head. Spiritual advisors permitted inside must sign an acknowledgment of these risks before entering.
States That Authorize Nitrogen Hypoxia
Only five states allow it, and each places it differently in a hierarchy of backup methods. Nitrogen hypoxia is not an option in any other state.
Alabama treats nitrogen as the primary fallback if lethal injection is declared unconstitutional or becomes unavailable, with electrocution as the next backup. If all three are struck down, the corrections commissioner may choose any constitutional method.3Alabama Legislature. Alabama Code Title 15 Chapter 18 Article 5 Section 15-18-82.1 Alabama is also the only state where a prisoner can affirmatively elect nitrogen over lethal injection.
Mississippi gives its corrections commissioner discretion among lethal injection, nitrogen hypoxia, electrocution, and firing squad, with lethal injection stated as the preference and each method stepping in only if the one above it fails.4Justia Law. Mississippi Code Title 99 Chapter 19 Section 99-19-51 – Manner of Execution of Death Sentence
Oklahoma follows a similar cascade: lethal injection first, nitrogen second, electrocution third, firing squad last.5Justia Law. Oklahoma Code Title 22 Section 22-1014 – Manner of Inflicting Punishment of Death
Louisiana authorized nitrogen hypoxia alongside lethal injection and electrocution effective July 2024, with no stated preference among the three. Arkansas became the fifth state to adopt it in 2025. Neither Louisiana nor Arkansas has carried out a nitrogen execution.
How an Alabama Inmate Elects Nitrogen Hypoxia
In Alabama, the election window is tight. After the certificate of judgment affirming the conviction is issued, the inmate has 30 days to elect nitrogen hypoxia in writing and deliver the election to the warden.6United States District Court for the Middle District of Alabama. Kenneth Eugene Smith v. John Q. Hamm – Memorandum Opinion and Order No particular form is required; any written statement from the inmate is sufficient under the statute. If the inmate does not elect within those 30 days, the right is permanently waived and the state defaults to lethal injection.
For inmates sentenced before Alabama’s 2018 law took effect, the state provided a one-time election window from June 1 to July 2, 2018.6United States District Court for the Middle District of Alabama. Kenneth Eugene Smith v. John Q. Hamm – Memorandum Opinion and Order That window produced its own litigation. Inmate Alan Miller submitted his election on time, but Holman Correctional Facility officials chose not to keep any log of who had submitted. When the state later claimed Miller had never elected nitrogen, a federal court found it substantially likely he had, and that Alabama had no rational basis to treat him differently from inmates whose elections were properly recorded.
What the Completed Executions Looked Like
Alabama has performed all three nitrogen hypoxia executions carried out anywhere in the world. Each produced visible physical reactions that contradicted earlier assurances about a quick, peaceful loss of consciousness.
Kenneth Smith, January 25, 2024
Smith’s execution was the first ever carried out by nitrogen. Alabama had already tried to execute him by lethal injection in November 2022; that attempt failed after the execution team spent hours trying to establish intravenous access, at one point strapping Smith into an inverted position and repeatedly puncturing his collarbone area with a large needle. He was left on the gurney for roughly four hours before the state gave up.
Witnesses reported that Smith appeared conscious for several minutes after nitrogen began flowing. He shook and writhed for about four minutes, with movements forceful enough to visibly shift the gurney. He then took a series of deep gasping breaths before his breathing was no longer visible around 8:08 p.m. The nitrogen flowed for about 15 minutes. Smith was pronounced dead at 8:25 p.m.
Alan Miller, September 26, 2024
Miller was the second person executed by nitrogen hypoxia, after the equal protection litigation over his lost election form delayed the execution for months.
Carey Dale Grayson, November 21, 2024
Grayson shook, pulled against his restraints, clenched his fists, and lifted his legs off the gurney after the gas began flowing. He took more than a dozen gasping breaths over several minutes before appearing to stop breathing. The EKG showed no heartbeat about 10 minutes after nitrogen started. He was pronounced dead at 6:33 p.m.
Why Eighth Amendment Challenges Keep Failing
Challenging any execution method under the Eighth Amendment is hard by design. Under Baze v. Rees, Glossip v. Gross, and Bucklew v. Precythe, a condemned person must identify a feasible, readily available alternative method that would significantly reduce a substantial risk of severe pain, and then show that the state refused to adopt it without a legitimate reason.7Justia Law. Glossip v. Gross, 576 U.S. 863 Arguing that a method is painful is not enough; the prisoner must point to something better the state could realistically use.8Supreme Court of the United States. Bucklew v. Precythe
The Court has also held that a state’s refusal to be the first to experiment with a new method is itself a legitimate reason to reject it. That created a bind for challengers before January 2024: nitrogen was untested, so courts deferred to states that would not try it. Now that it has been used, challengers must argue it failed, but the framework still demands they name a better alternative rather than simply show nitrogen caused suffering. In one Alabama case, a court rejected a challenge partly because the inmate relied on a preliminary, unverified report to argue nitrogen would be more humane, and the court found that insufficient.
Medical, Veterinary, and International Objections
The American Medical Association prohibits physician participation in any legally authorized execution and defines participation broadly, covering not just causing death but monitoring vital signs, giving technical advice about the process, and attending in a medical capacity.9American Medical Association. Capital Punishment That creates a direct conflict with nitrogen protocols that rely on EKG and pulse oximetry monitoring to determine when death has occurred.
The American Veterinary Medical Association classifies nitrogen as unacceptable for euthanizing most mammals. Its guidelines report that rodents exposed to nitrogen display signs of panic and distress, including open-mouthed breathing and seizure-like behavior, before collapsing. Nitrogen is considered conditionally acceptable for poultry and pigs under specific protocols, but the AVMA states other methods are preferable for mammals because of the distress an oxygen-depleted environment causes.10American Veterinary Medical Association. AVMA Guidelines for the Euthanasia of Animals: 2020 Edition
United Nations human rights experts have called for an urgent ban on nitrogen executions, stating the method “may amount to cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment, or even torture.” The UN emphasized that the international prohibition against torture is absolute and does not depend on the availability of alternatives.11United Nations Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights. United States: Experts Call for Urgent Ban on Executions by Nitrogen Gas in Alabama That standard is fundamentally different from the U.S. Supreme Court’s framework, which requires a condemned person to propose something better before the Constitution offers any protection.