No-fault insurance is an auto insurance system in which each driver’s own insurer pays for that driver’s medical bills, lost wages, and related economic losses after a crash, regardless of who caused it. In exchange, the law limits when an injured person can sue the at-fault driver for pain and suffering. Twelve states operate under this system today, and each sets its own rules on coverage amounts, lawsuit thresholds, and filing deadlines.1Progressive. No-Fault State Meaning
How No-Fault Insurance Works
In a traditional at-fault, or “tort,” state, an injured driver pursues the other driver’s liability insurer, often after some fight over who caused the crash. No-fault sidesteps that. Each driver carries Personal Injury Protection (PIP) coverage on their own policy, and PIP pays the driver’s accident-related costs no matter who was at fault.2U.S. News & World Report. What Is No-Fault Car Insurance
PIP typically covers:
- Medical expenses from the crash
- A portion of lost wages
- Rehabilitation costs
- Essential household services the injured person can no longer perform, such as childcare or cleaning
- Funeral and death benefits, in some states
PIP does not cover damage to your vehicle, theft, or damage to someone else’s property. In most no-fault states, PIP pays before health insurance when accident-related medical bills come in.3Progressive. Personal Injury Protection
The trade-off is a limit on lawsuits. In a no-fault state, you generally cannot sue the at-fault driver for pain and suffering or other noneconomic damages unless your injury clears a legal threshold set by state law. That threshold is the central feature that distinguishes no-fault from an at-fault system.
Which States Have No-Fault Insurance
Twelve states currently use no-fault auto insurance:1Progressive. No-Fault State Meaning
- Florida
- Hawaii
- Kansas
- Kentucky
- Massachusetts
- Michigan
- Minnesota
- New Jersey
- New York
- North Dakota
- Pennsylvania
- Utah
Three of those states (Kentucky, New Jersey, and Pennsylvania) are “choice” no-fault states. Drivers there can opt out of the no-fault system when they buy their policy and keep the full right to sue after a crash.4Experian. What States Have No-Fault Insurance
Three more states cause confusion because they require PIP coverage without being no-fault states. Delaware, Maryland, and Oregon all mandate PIP, but they don’t limit the right to sue, so the traditional tort rules still apply. These are sometimes called “add-on” states because PIP sits on top of the tort system rather than replacing it.4Experian. What States Have No-Fault Insurance
Florida’s status has been a moving target. The state has operated under no-fault since 1971, with a minimum PIP requirement of $10,000. The Florida Legislature passed a bill in 2021 to repeal PIP and require bodily injury liability coverage instead, but Governor Ron DeSantis vetoed it, citing concerns that the change could raise rates. Repeal bills introduced in 2025 and 2026 died in committee, and Florida’s no-fault system remains in effect.5Insurance Journal. Florida No-Fault Auto Insurance System Remains in Effect6Florida Justice Reform Institute. DeSantis Stands Firm Against Repealing Floridas No-Fault Auto Insurance Law
When You Can Still Sue in a No-Fault State
Every no-fault state uses one of two kinds of thresholds, and sometimes both, to decide when an injured person can step outside the PIP system and sue the at-fault driver for pain and suffering.
A verbal threshold lists the categories of injury serious enough to qualify. A monetary threshold sets a dollar figure for medical expenses that must be exceeded before a lawsuit is permitted.
New York uses a verbal threshold. Under New York Insurance Law § 5102(d), you can sue for noneconomic damages only if you have suffered a “serious injury,” which the statute defines as:7New York State Senate. NY Insurance Law Section 5102
- Death, dismemberment, or significant disfigurement
- A fracture
- Loss of a fetus
- Permanent loss of use of a body organ, member, function, or system
- Permanent consequential limitation of use of a body organ or member
- Significant limitation of use of a body function or system
- A medically determined injury that prevents the person from performing substantially all of their usual daily activities for at least 90 days during the 180 days following the accident
Kentucky combines both approaches. An injured person can sue if medical expenses exceed $1,000, or if the injury involves a broken bone, permanent disfigurement, permanent injury, or death.8Kentucky Department of Insurance. Motor Vehicle Reparations Act
Monetary thresholds have long been criticized as too easy to cross. A claimant can accumulate chiropractic or physical therapy visits until the dollar figure is met, which erodes the litigation-reducing benefit no-fault is supposed to deliver.
How Much PIP Coverage States Require
Minimum PIP coverage varies widely by state. New York requires $50,000 of basic no-fault coverage, which pays medical expenses, a portion of lost wages (subject to a 20% statutory offset), and other economic losses.9New York Department of Financial Services. No-Fault FAQs Kentucky and Florida each set the minimum at $10,000 per person per accident.8Kentucky Department of Insurance. Motor Vehicle Reparations Act
Policyholders in most no-fault states can buy higher PIP limits than the minimum, and some states allow deductibles on PIP to bring the premium down. Michigan, as discussed below, offers tiered choices that go all the way up to unlimited lifetime medical coverage.
Michigan: The No-Fault Outlier
Michigan has long been the most distinctive no-fault state. Its law, codified beginning at MCL 500.3101, requires every registered motor vehicle to carry Personal Injury Protection, Property Protection Insurance (which pays up to $1 million for damage a vehicle causes to other people’s property), and Residual Liability Insurance. Motorcycles, mopeds, farm tractors, off-road vehicles, and golf carts are excluded from the statute’s definition of “motor vehicle.”10Michigan Legislature. MCL 500.310111FindLaw. Michigan Compiled Laws Section 500.3101
For decades Michigan was the only state that guaranteed unlimited, lifetime PIP medical benefits. That coverage made the state the most generous in the country for catastrophically injured people, and also the most expensive. By 2019 the average annual Michigan premium had reached $2,611, the highest in the nation, with Detroit premiums running past $5,400.12National Association of Insurance Commissioners. Michigan Auto Insurance Reform
The 2019 Reforms and Tiered PIP
Governor Gretchen Whitmer signed Public Acts 21 and 22 in June 2019, the biggest changes to Michigan no-fault in its history. For policies issued or renewed on or after July 1, 2020, drivers can now choose among six tiers of PIP medical coverage:13Michigan Department of Insurance and Financial Services. Choosing PIP Medical Coverage
- Unlimited coverage (the default if no selection is made)
- $500,000 per person per accident
- $250,000 per person per accident
- $250,000 with exclusions, available if the policyholder and excluded household members have qualifying non-Medicare health coverage
- $50,000 per person per accident, available only if the policyholder is enrolled in Medicaid
- Opt-out (no PIP medical), available only if the policyholder has both Medicare Parts A and B
Wage loss benefits, replacement services, and funeral expenses remain in every policy no matter which medical tier is chosen. Drivers who pick a limited tier must document qualifying health coverage at each renewal.14Michigan Department of Insurance and Financial Services. Auto Insurance Frequently Asked Questions
Insurers were ordered to cut statewide average PIP premiums by set amounts depending on the tier: at least 45% for the $50,000 option, 35% for $250,000, 20% for $500,000, and 10% for unlimited. The reforms also barred insurers from using sex, marital status, home ownership, credit score, education level, occupation, or zip code to set rates.13Michigan Department of Insurance and Financial Services. Choosing PIP Medical Coverage
Did the Reforms Lower Costs?
The answer is contested. A 2023 NAIC-affiliated paper reported that Michigan’s average liability premium fell from $892 in 2019 to $671 in 2023, and the overall average premium dropped from $2,611 in 2019 to $2,112 in 2021. The number of uninsured drivers fell from 25.5% to 19.6% between 2019 and 2022.12National Association of Insurance Commissioners. Michigan Auto Insurance Reform
A December 2025 Michigan Public report, drawing on data from consulting firm Milliman, told a different story. Average Michigan car insurance rates rose roughly $200 between 2019 and 2024, and 2024 was the most expensive year measured. The report said any initial dip was offset by later double-digit rate increases approved by the Department of Insurance and Financial Services (DIFS), that the number of uninsured drivers had climbed back past pre-reform levels, and that nearly 4,000 crash victims per year would exhaust their medical coverage under the new capped tiers.15Michigan Public. Michigan Officials Insist 2019 Auto No-Fault Law Lowered Car Insurance Rates. It Didnt
Medical providers were hit hard by new caps on how much they could bill auto insurers. An industry survey found that 86% of providers had little confidence in staying open, more than 1,500 frontline workers had been laid off, and many rural providers closed. The Michigan Brain Injury Provider Council said thousands of crash survivors lost access to specialized post-acute care.16Michigan Brain Injury Provider Council. Fee Schedule Fix
Why Some States Walked Away From No-Fault
No-fault laws peaked in the mid-1970s. By 1976, 26 states had adopted some version of the system; today only 12 use it.17RAND Corporation. Assessing the Effects of No-Fault Automobile Insurance Several states repealed their laws after concluding the system did not deliver the promised savings.
Georgia eliminated no-fault in 1991 and mandated a 15% premium rollback, with average liability premiums falling 12.5% the next year. Connecticut repealed its system effective January 1, 1994, after six consecutive years of average premium increases of 8% or more; the average liability premium there dropped 9.7% in the year of repeal.18Consumer Watchdog. Failed Experiment: Analysis and Evaluation of No-Fault Laws19Connecticut General Assembly. No-Fault Auto Insurance Repeal Colorado converted back to a tort system effective July 1, 2003. RAND documented premium drops of 10% to 30% across these states following repeal.17RAND Corporation. Assessing the Effects of No-Fault Automobile Insurance
Pennsylvania took a middle path in 1990, shifting to the choice system still in effect, which lets drivers pick between no-fault and traditional tort coverage. An estimated 60% of Pennsylvania motorists opted for the tort side, and the state’s ranking among the most expensive premium states dropped.18Consumer Watchdog. Failed Experiment: Analysis and Evaluation of No-Fault Laws
Supporters of no-fault still point to its original logic. Under the tort system, an estimated 30% of injured people recover nothing at all, while no-fault guarantees basic economic coverage to everyone involved in a crash. A Congressional Joint Economic Committee analysis estimated that a well-designed no-fault system could save consumers $47.7 billion annually by cutting the bodily injury premium portion by 56%.20National Association of Mutual Insurance Companies. Auto Reform
Critics counter that the data has not borne this out. A RAND study found that by 2004 liability premiums in no-fault states were 50% higher than in tort states. No-fault systems cover more medical services and pay more for them, and medical providers often bill auto insurers before health insurers, pushing costs into the more expensive system. The Insurance Research Council has estimated that 12% to 17% of PIP claims show evidence of fraud or buildup.20National Association of Mutual Insurance Companies. Auto Reform
Deadlines for Filing a PIP Claim
No-fault states enforce strict notice and filing deadlines, and missing one can bar a claim entirely.
In Michigan, under MCL 500.3145, a person must file a lawsuit for PIP benefits within one year of the accident. That deadline can be extended if the claimant provides written notice to the insurer within the one-year window, or if the insurer has already made a PIP payment on the injury. The notice must include the claimant’s name and address and describe the time, place, and nature of the injury in ordinary language. The Michigan Supreme Court held in Dillon v. State Farm (2017) that notice of one injury does not automatically preserve the right to claim benefits for a different, unrelated injury from the same crash.21Michigan Legislature. MCL 500.3145
In New York, Regulation 68 requires written notice of a claim within 30 days of the accident, healthcare bills within 45 days, and lost wage claims within 90 days. Disputes over payment can go to arbitration.9New York Department of Financial Services. No-Fault FAQs
If you’ve been in a crash in a no-fault state, the first calls to make are to your own insurer and, if the injury is serious, to a lawyer who handles no-fault claims in that state. The window to put your insurer on notice is short, and the question of whether your injury clears the lawsuit threshold is often the difference between a modest PIP payout and a full recovery against the at-fault driver.