The Nuremberg trials results, delivered by the International Military Tribunal on October 1, 1946, sent twelve senior Nazi leaders to the gallows, imposed prison terms on seven others, and acquitted three. The tribunal also declared four Nazi organizations criminal and rejected the defense that following orders excused participation in atrocities. Twenty-four men had originally been indicted; one killed himself before trial, one was severed for medical reasons, and twenty-two received judgments from the four-power panel of American, British, Soviet, and French judges.
The Twelve Death Sentences
Twelve defendants were sentenced to hang for their roles in planning aggressive war, directing atrocities, and overseeing mass murder:
- Hermann Göring, commander of the Luftwaffe and Hitler’s designated successor
- Joachim von Ribbentrop, Foreign Minister
- Wilhelm Keitel, Chief of the Armed Forces High Command
- Ernst Kaltenbrunner, head of the Reich Security Main Office
- Alfred Rosenberg, chief Nazi ideologist and Reich Minister for the occupied Eastern territories
- Hans Frank, Governor-General of occupied Poland
- Wilhelm Frick, Interior Minister and drafter of the Nuremberg racial laws
- Julius Streicher, publisher of Der Stürmer, convicted for incitement to extermination
- Fritz Sauckel, plenipotentiary for labor deployment
- Alfred Jodl, Chief of Operations Staff
- Arthur Seyss-Inquart, Reich Commissioner for the occupied Netherlands
- Martin Bormann, Hitler’s private secretary, tried and sentenced in absentia
Ten of the twelve were hanged on October 16, 1946, in a gymnasium converted into an execution chamber. Göring poisoned himself with a cyanide capsule hours before his scheduled execution. Bormann was never found; his remains were later identified in Berlin in 1972.
Prison Sentences
Three defendants received life imprisonment. Rudolf Hess, Hitler’s former deputy, was held at Berlin’s Spandau Prison until his death in 1987 at age 93, the facility’s sole inmate for its final two decades. Walther Funk, the Reich Economics Minister, was released in 1957 on health grounds. Grand Admiral Erich Raeder, who built the German Navy in violation of the Versailles Treaty, was released in 1955, also for health reasons.
Four defendants received fixed terms. Albert Speer, Hitler’s architect and armaments minister, and Baldur von Schirach, head of the Hitler Youth, each received twenty years. Konstantin von Neurath, the Protector of Bohemia and Moravia, received fifteen years. Grand Admiral Karl Dönitz, who briefly succeeded Hitler as head of state, received ten years. The varying terms reflected the tribunal’s effort to calibrate punishment to each defendant’s degree of participation.
The Three Acquittals
Three defendants were found not guilty on all counts: Hjalmar Schacht, the former Economics Minister and Reichsbank president; Franz von Papen, the former chancellor who had helped negotiate Hitler’s appointment; and Hans Fritzsche, a senior official in the Propaganda Ministry. The judges concluded that the evidence fell short of proving direct participation in the charged crimes. The acquittals were arguably the tribunal’s strongest answer to critics who called the proceeding predetermined.
The final tally across all twenty-two judged defendants: twelve death sentences, three life terms, four fixed prison sentences, and three acquittals.
Organizations Declared Criminal
The tribunal also put seven Nazi organizations on trial as entities. A criminal designation carried real weight: under Control Council Law No. 10, any member of a declared criminal organization could be prosecuted in local courts simply for belonging, and the organization’s criminal nature could not be relitigated in those proceedings.
Four organizations were declared criminal:
- The SS (Schutzstaffel), which ran the concentration and extermination camps, though the tribunal excluded members drafted involuntarily who committed no crimes
- The SD (Sicherheitsdienst), the intelligence service of the SS
- The Gestapo (Geheime Staatspolizei), the secret police
- The Leadership Corps of the Nazi Party, limited to those holding positions from September 1, 1939 onward
Three were not. The SA (Sturmabteilung) had been sharply reduced in influence after the 1934 purge known as the Night of the Long Knives. The Reich Cabinet did not function as an organization in the relevant sense. The General Staff and High Command, the judges reasoned, was a loose collection of senior officers rather than a cohesive group, and professional military service alone did not equate to criminal membership.
What the Four Counts Covered
Every defendant faced up to four charges. Count One, conspiracy to wage aggressive war, was read narrowly by the tribunal and produced only eight convictions. Count Two, crimes against peace, covered the planning and waging of aggressive wars against sovereign nations and produced twelve convictions. Count Three, war crimes, covered the murder and mistreatment of prisoners of war, forced labor deportations, and the killing of hostages, producing sixteen convictions on ground long established by the Hague and Geneva Conventions.
Count Four, crimes against humanity, also produced sixteen convictions. It covered the murder, extermination, and enslavement of civilian populations and persecution on racial, political, or religious grounds. This was the tribunal’s most significant legal innovation. For the first time, an international court held that a government’s systematic atrocities against civilians were punishable under international law, not just mistreatment of foreign populations during wartime.
Why the Common Defenses Failed
Two defense arguments came up repeatedly and both failed. The “superior orders” defense was foreclosed by Article 8 of the tribunal’s charter: obeying a superior’s order did not free a defendant from responsibility, though it could reduce the punishment if the judges decided fairness required it. The “tu quoque” defense, which argued that Allied nations had committed similar acts, was refused on the straightforward logic that one party’s wrongdoing does not excuse another’s. No international tribunal has accepted tu quoque since.
The Twelve Subsequent Nuremberg Trials
Twelve additional proceedings were held at Nuremberg between December 1946 and April 1949 under Control Council Law No. 10. These were conducted by American military tribunals rather than the four-power international panel, and they targeted the professionals, industrialists, and mid-level officers who made the Nazi machinery function. Roughly 185 defendants were tried across the twelve cases, resulting in 142 convictions.
The Doctors’ Trial produced sixteen convictions and seven death sentences against physicians who had conducted lethal medical experiments on concentration camp prisoners. The Judges’ Trial convicted ten former judges and Justice Ministry officials for using the legal system as an instrument of persecution. The Einsatzgruppen Trial produced twenty-two convictions and fourteen death sentences against commanders of the mobile killing units responsible for over a million deaths in Eastern Europe, though most of those death sentences were later commuted. The Krupp and IG Farben trials convicted industrial executives for using slave labor, but their sentences were notably light compared to those handed to military and political leaders. Several IG Farben defendants received terms that, with credit for time served, meant near-immediate release.
Clemency and Early Release
By 1958, every surviving Nuremberg prisoner except Rudolf Hess had been released. The turning point came on January 31, 1951, when U.S. High Commissioner John J. McCloy announced clemency decisions for eighty-nine German war criminals held at Landsberg Prison. McCloy reduced seventy-nine sentences and confirmed only five of the fifteen outstanding death sentences, all for Einsatzgruppen members. Thirty-two prisoners became eligible for immediate release, and twenty-nine walked out of Landsberg on February 3, 1951. Among them was Alfried Krupp, the industrialist sentenced to twelve years, freed along with eight of his co-defendants.
The advisory board that recommended the reductions had spent only a few weeks in the summer of 1950 skimming judgments and meeting briefly with defense counsel, and it did not re-examine the trial evidence in depth. Cold War politics was unmistakably present: West Germany was becoming a critical ally against the Soviet Union, and the continued imprisonment of German military and industrial leaders was seen as an obstacle to that partnership. The clemency decisions remain among the most contested parts of the Nuremberg legacy.
The Legal Legacy
The tribunal’s most lasting result was not any individual sentence but the legal framework it created. In 1946, the United Nations General Assembly passed Resolution 95(I), directing the International Law Commission to formalize the principles underlying the judgments. By 1950, the Commission had distilled them into seven principles that became foundational to international criminal law.
The core ideas were simple. Anyone who commits an act that qualifies as a crime under international law bears personal responsibility, regardless of whether their own country’s laws prohibit the act. Heads of state and government officials enjoy no immunity. Following superior orders does not eliminate responsibility where the person had a genuine moral choice. Every accused person has the right to a fair trial. The principles also defined three categories of international crime (crimes against peace, war crimes, and crimes against humanity) and made complicity in any of them a crime in itself.
These categories did not stay theoretical. The Nuremberg framework shaped the International Criminal Tribunals for the former Yugoslavia and Rwanda in the 1990s, and in turn the jurisprudence that produced the 1998 Rome Statute establishing the permanent International Criminal Court. The Rome Statute’s definition of crimes against humanity expanded on Nuremberg in one critical way: it dropped the requirement that such crimes be connected to armed conflict, recognizing that governments can commit atrocities against their own people in peacetime as well.