The Obama Hope poster copyright lawsuit began in February 2009, when street artist Shepard Fairey sued the Associated Press in federal court seeking a declaration that his 2008 campaign portrait of Barack Obama was a fair use of an AP photograph, and the AP countersued for infringement. The parties settled in January 2011 without a court ruling on fair use; Fairey later paid the AP $1.6 million and was separately convicted of criminal contempt for fabricating and destroying evidence during the civil case.
The Photograph Behind the Poster
Fairey’s poster was built from a photograph of then-Senator Obama taken by Mannie Garcia at the National Press Club on April 27, 2006. Fairey cropped it, removed the background, adjusted contrast, built multi-layered bitmaps, and applied the red, white, and blue palette that defined the final image.1Harvard Berkman Klein Center. Hope Poster Case Study He used no license and gave no credit to the AP or Garcia.
When he was first asked which photograph he had worked from, Fairey pointed to a different AP image: a shot of Obama seated next to actor George Clooney at the same event. The photograph he actually used was a solo close-up.2Wired. Hope Image Flap That misdirection became the basis of the criminal case that followed.
How the Lawsuit Started
The AP went public in early 2009, accusing Fairey of infringing its copyright by reproducing the photograph without permission, credit, or payment. Fairey filed first, bringing a preemptive action in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York asking Judge Alvin K. Hellerstein to declare the poster a fair use. The AP answered with counterclaims for infringement and for removing copyright management information from the source image under the Digital Millennium Copyright Act. The case was captioned Shepard Fairey v. Associated Press, No. 09-01123.3Justia. Fairey v. Associated Press, Answer and Counterclaims
What Each Side Argued
The fight turned on how much Fairey had transformed the photograph. His side described the creative process as extensive hand work that converted a piece of journalism into political art with a new mood and meaning.1Harvard Berkman Klein Center. Hope Poster Case Study The AP characterized the technique as “a form of computerized ‘paint by numbers'” and argued that Fairey had copied the entire image, keeping the pose, angle, and lighting that reflected the photographer’s creative choices.4Vermont Law Review. Fair Use and the Hope Poster
Money mattered to the analysis. The AP pointed out that Fairey’s company Obey Clothing sold more than 200,000 items featuring the image and that Fairey earned roughly $1 million from the project, with more than $830,000 coming from fine art editions, commissions from the Presidential Inauguration Committee, and work for MoveOn.org.1Harvard Berkman Klein Center. Hope Poster Case Study5Harvard Journal of Law and Technology. The Hope Poster Case
The Photographer’s Claim
In July 2009 the case got a third party. Mannie Garcia moved to intervene, telling the court that he, not the AP, owned the copyright because he had not been an AP employee when he took the picture and had never assigned the rights to the wire service.6Marquette University Law Faculty Blog. The Obama Hope Poster Case: Mannie Garcia Weighs In The court let him in. Garcia dropped his ownership claim in August 2010, with his attorney saying the litigation had taken a “toll on him personally and professionally.”7CBS News. Photographer, AP Drop Claims Against Each Other Whether he was legally an employee or a freelancer that day was never resolved.
The Settlement
The AP and Fairey announced a settlement on January 12, 2011, weeks before a trial scheduled for March. They agreed to share rights to produce posters and merchandise using the Hope image and to collaborate on future images based on AP photographs. Fairey agreed not to use any AP photo in future work without a license.8NPR. Shepard Fairey and AP Settle Copyright Dispute Over Hope Poster Neither side conceded its legal position: the AP maintained the poster was infringing, and Fairey maintained it was fair use.
The financial terms were initially called confidential. Court papers filed later in Fairey’s criminal case showed the deal required him to pay the AP $1.6 million, of which an insurer contributed roughly $450,000. His defense attorneys described the terms as “unfavorable” and said they “included sanctions.”9AP. Obama Hope Poster Artist Shepard Fairey Gets Probation10CBS News. Obama Hope Poster Artist Receives Probation
A separate agreement followed in March 2011 between the AP and Obey Clothing. Under that deal, the two sides would collaborate on apparel using Fairey’s graphics based on AP photographs, with the AP taking a share of future sales. The agreement also resolved claims the AP had brought against three retailers that sold Obey Clothing merchandise.11Poynter. AP, Obey Clothing Settle Copyright Infringement Lawsuit
Because the settlements closed the case before judgment, no precedent was set on whether the Hope poster was fair use. June Besek, executive director of Columbia Law School’s Kernochan Center, called the fair use question “a close question” and said neither side could have been confident of winning at trial.12Columbia Law School. Obama Hope Poster Lawsuit Settlement
The Criminal Case Grew Out of the Civil One
Fairey’s handling of discovery turned into a separate federal prosecution. He had told the court the poster came from the Clooney photograph rather than the solo close-up, and when that story unraveled he admitted he had fabricated documents to support it and destroyed files that would have shown the truth.2Wired. Hope Image Flap
In February 2012 he pleaded guilty to a single count of criminal contempt in United States v. Shepard Fairey, No. 1:12-cr-00180, in the Southern District of New York, for willfully disobeying discovery orders issued by Judge Hellerstein. The charge covered the fabrication of evidence, destruction of documents, and coaching of witnesses.13U.S. Department of Justice. United States v. Shepard Fairey, Misdemeanor Information
On September 7, 2012, U.S. Magistrate Judge Frank Maas sentenced Fairey to two years of probation, a $25,000 fine, and 300 hours of community service. Prosecutors had sought prison time; the court declined to impose any of the six months of incarceration the charge allowed.14New York Times. Shepard Fairey Is Fined and Sentenced to Probation Fairey said in a statement: “I accept full responsibility for violating the court’s trust by tampering with evidence during my civil case with The Associated Press.”15CNN. Obama Poster Artist Gets Probation
What the Case Means After Warhol v. Goldsmith
Because the Fairey settlement left the fair use question open, the law on how far an artist can take a copyrighted photograph came from a later case. In 2023 the Supreme Court decided Andy Warhol Foundation for the Visual Arts, Inc. v. Goldsmith, involving Warhol silkscreens based on Lynn Goldsmith’s photograph of Prince. The Court held that the first fair use factor, “the purpose and character of the use,” turns on whether the secondary use shares “substantially the same purpose” as the original, not simply whether it adds new expression or meaning.16Supreme Court of the United States. Andy Warhol Foundation v. Goldsmith New expression alone, the Court said, is not enough if it would “swallow the copyright owner’s exclusive right to prepare derivative works.”17Harvard Law Review. Andy Warhol Foundation v. Goldsmith
That standard is widely viewed as making fair use harder for appropriation artists working from photographs. Under the Goldsmith framework, the commercial licensing and merchandising of the Hope image, used to depict and promote the same subject the AP photograph depicted, would have weighed against Fairey had his case gone to trial.