Personal Jurisdiction Over Internet Defendants: Zippo, Calder, and Walden

The Zippo test for personal jurisdiction is a sliding scale that courts use to decide whether an out-of-state internet defendant can be sued in a particular state based on the nature and quality of that defendant’s online activity. It comes from the 1997 federal district court decision in Zippo Manufacturing Co. v. Zippo Dot Com, Inc., 952 F. Supp. 1119, which held that the likelihood of jurisdiction being constitutional is “directly proportionate to the nature and quality of commercial activity that an entity conducts over the Internet.”1Justia. Zippo Mfg Co v Zippo Dot Com Inc, 952 F Supp 1119 The scale runs from passive websites at one end to fully commercial ones at the other, with interactive sites in the middle requiring a closer look.

The Due Process Backdrop

The Zippo scale is a tool for answering a constitutional question. The Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment requires that a defendant have “minimum contacts” with the state where a lawsuit is filed, a principle the Supreme Court established in International Shoe Co. v. Washington (1945). A court can only assert jurisdiction when doing so would not offend “traditional notions of fair play and substantial justice.”2Constitution Annotated. Minimum Contact Requirements for Personal Jurisdiction

Two kinds of jurisdiction follow from that rule. General jurisdiction applies when a defendant’s contacts with a state are so extensive that it is essentially “at home” there and can be sued on any claim. Specific jurisdiction is narrower: the lawsuit must arise out of or relate to the defendant’s particular contacts with the forum state.2Constitution Annotated. Minimum Contact Requirements for Personal Jurisdiction For most internet disputes, specific jurisdiction is what matters, and the central question is purposeful availment: did the defendant deliberately reach into the forum state? The Zippo framework exists to help courts answer that question when the defendant’s activity happened online.

Passive Websites: The Low End

At the bottom of the scale sits the passive site. It functions like a digital brochure. Visitors can read the content, but they cannot buy anything, create an account, or exchange data with the host. Under Zippo, “a passive Web site that does little more than make information available to those who are interested in it is not grounds for the exercise of personal jurisdiction.”1Justia. Zippo Mfg Co v Zippo Dot Com Inc, 952 F Supp 1119

The reasoning is that the site owner has not done anything to target a specific state. Allowing jurisdiction based only on a page being viewable in a state would mean every site owner could be sued everywhere, which would gut the minimum contacts requirement.

Interactive Websites: The Middle

Most modern disputes land in the middle. An interactive site lets users “exchange information with the host computer,” and jurisdiction “is determined by examining the level of interactivity and commercial nature of the exchange of information that occurs on the Web site.”1Justia. Zippo Mfg Co v Zippo Dot Com Inc, 952 F Supp 1119 This is a fact-intensive inquiry with no bright line.

Courts look for evidence that the operator deliberately targeted people in the forum state. Relevant facts include how many users from the state actually used the site, whether the site used language or promotions aimed at local residents, and whether it collected meaningful personal data from visitors in that area. A site that lets users create accounts and submit detailed personal information looks more like deliberate outreach than one that merely hosts a comment section.

Geolocation technology has added a dimension to this analysis. If a company uses geo-targeted advertising to reach customers in specific regions or tailors content based on a visitor’s IP address, those choices can support a finding of intentional direction at a particular state. Some scholars argue that the ability to use geolocation tools, combined with a decision not to use them to block access from a state, is itself relevant. The core question stays the same: was the contact with the forum’s residents a deliberate choice or an incidental byproduct of being online?

Active Online Commerce: The High End

At the top of the scale, a defendant “clearly does business over the Internet” by entering “into contracts with residents of a foreign jurisdiction that involve the knowing and repeated transmission of computer files over the Internet.”1Justia. Zippo Mfg Co v Zippo Dot Com Inc, 952 F Supp 1119 When a business regularly accepts payments from, ships products to, or delivers digital services to customers in a particular state, jurisdiction is almost always proper there.

A company that repeatedly profits from customers in a state has made a conscious choice to participate in that market. It has enjoyed the benefits of that state’s consumer base, and it cannot credibly claim surprise when a customer from that state files suit.

Where Zippo Falls Short: The Calder Effects Test

Zippo was built for commercial disputes. It was never designed for intentional torts like defamation, fraud, or intellectual property theft, and for those cases courts turn to the “effects test” from the Supreme Court’s 1984 decision in Calder v. Jones.

In Calder, two Florida-based journalists wrote a defamatory article about a California entertainer. The Court held that jurisdiction in California was proper because the defendants engaged in “intentional conduct in Florida calculated to cause injury to respondent in California” and “knew that the brunt of that injury would be felt by respondent in the State in which she lives and works.” The defendants were “not charged with mere untargeted negligence” but with intentional actions “expressly aimed at California.”3Justia U.S. Supreme Court Center. Calder v Jones, 465 US 783 (1984)

Applied online, the effects test asks whether the defendant committed an intentional wrong, whether the plaintiff felt the main impact in the forum state, and whether the defendant expressly aimed the conduct at that state. This matters for situations like defamatory posts, where the website might look passive under Zippo but the harm was deliberately directed at a specific person in a specific place. Under pure Zippo analysis, the post could shield the defendant from jurisdiction. Under Calder, if the post was calculated to damage a reputation in a particular state, jurisdiction can be proper regardless of the site’s interactivity level. Some circuits apply Zippo and Calder as separate tests for different claims; others blend them into a hybrid analysis.

The Walden Correction

Any modern Zippo analysis has to pass through Walden v. Fiore, the Supreme Court’s 2014 decision clarifying who the jurisdictional focus belongs to. The Court held that the analysis must look at the defendant’s own contacts with the forum state, not the defendant’s relationship with people who happen to live there. “The plaintiff cannot be the only link between the defendant and the forum.”4Justia U.S. Supreme Court Center. Walden v Fiore, 571 US 277 (2014)

The Court rejected the idea that jurisdiction could rest on a defendant merely knowing their conduct would affect someone with ties to the forum. “Mere injury to a forum resident is not a sufficient connection to the forum,” and a court may not exercise jurisdiction when the defendant’s “sole contact with the forum state is that the defendant knew his allegedly tortious conduct would affect persons with connections to the forum state.”4Justia U.S. Supreme Court Center. Walden v Fiore, 571 US 277 (2014)

This matters for every internet case. Before Walden, a plaintiff might argue: the defendant posted something online, I was harmed in my home state, so jurisdiction is proper here. After Walden, that argument fails unless the defendant independently created contacts with the forum. If someone in Texas publishes a harmful blog post and a reader in Oregon is injured by it, Oregon cannot assert jurisdiction just because the plaintiff lives there. There must be something the defendant did that connects them to Oregon beyond the plaintiff’s presence.

Why Courts Are Moving Past Zippo

The sliding scale was a creative answer for 1997, when most websites were genuinely passive collections of text and images. Almost no site works that way now. Nearly every modern site collects IP addresses, uses cookies, embeds third-party content, and features some form of user interaction. When virtually every website qualifies as “interactive,” the middle category swallows the other two and the framework stops offering real guidance.

Federal circuits have responded differently. The D.C. Circuit has refused to apply Zippo at all, concluding that traditional jurisdiction principles can handle internet cases without a special test. The Second Circuit has acknowledged the scale but declined to adopt it, preferring established purposeful-availment analysis. The Fourth Circuit uses a hybrid that blends Zippo’s interactivity analysis with Calder’s effects test. Several other circuits have grafted a targeting requirement onto Zippo, asking not just whether the site is interactive but whether the defendant specifically directed that interactivity at the forum state.

The Supreme Court has not yet ruled directly on how Zippo applies. In its 2021 decision in Ford Motor Co. v. Montana Eighth Judicial District Court, the Court pointedly noted that it was not addressing “internet transactions, which may raise doctrinal questions of their own.”5Supreme Court of the United States. Ford Motor Co v Montana Eighth Judicial Dist Court (2021) Until a definitive ruling arrives, internet jurisdiction law will vary by circuit.

What This Means in Practice

A few principles hold across circuits despite the doctrinal fragmentation. Selling products or services to customers in a state on a regular basis will almost always subject you to jurisdiction there. The more revenue you earn from a state’s residents, the harder it is to argue you were not purposefully engaged with that market.

Using geo-targeted advertising or location-based promotions aimed at specific states strengthens a plaintiff’s argument that you deliberately reached into that forum. Using geolocation tools to block access or decline orders from certain states can cut the other way. The technology to target or avoid specific markets exists, and courts increasingly treat the choice to use it as evidence of intent.

For a plaintiff deciding where to file against an internet defendant, the strongest cases involve concrete evidence that the defendant specifically targeted the forum state: advertising directed at local residents, contracts with local customers, content aimed at a local audience, or deliberate use of local infrastructure. After Walden, being harmed at home is not enough on its own. The defendant’s own actions have to create a connection to the state that stands apart from the plaintiff’s presence there.