Arbitrators can award punitive damages in most cases, and that is the baseline rule for punitive damages in arbitration unless the parties’ agreement clearly says otherwise. The U.S. Supreme Court established this in Mastrobuono v. Shearson Lehman Hutton, Inc. (1995), reasoning that a broad agreement to arbitrate carries with it the full range of remedies a court could grant, punitive awards included.1Justia U.S. Supreme Court Center. Mastrobuono v. Shearson Lehman Hutton, Inc., 514 U.S. 52 (1995) What ends up mattering in any given case is the exact language of the arbitration clause and whether anything else in the contract muddies it.
What the Arbitration Agreement Says Controls
The contract is the first and most important place to look. Three patterns cover almost every situation.
The Agreement Is Silent
Most arbitration clauses never mention punitive damages. When the agreement says nothing, the default from Mastrobuono applies: the arbitrator has authority to award them. Courts read a broad agreement to arbitrate “any controversy” as an implicit grant of every remedy the underlying claim could produce.1Justia U.S. Supreme Court Center. Mastrobuono v. Shearson Lehman Hutton, Inc., 514 U.S. 52 (1995)
The Agreement Expressly Allows Them
Some negotiated commercial contracts spell out that the arbitrator may award punitive or exemplary damages. The clause is less common than you’d think, because the default already permits them, but it eliminates any argument about scope.
The Agreement Expressly Prohibits Them
A clear clause stating that the arbitrator has no authority to award punitive or exemplary damages will usually be enforced. Parties get to define the limits of their arbitration, and a well-drafted bar closes the door.
Prohibitions aren’t absolute. In consumer and employment contracts, where the weaker party had no real chance to negotiate, courts examine the clause more closely. If stripping punitive damages would stop someone from vindicating a statutory right that specifically authorizes punitive recovery, a court may refuse to enforce the prohibition as unconscionable. That challenge rarely succeeds in a negotiated contract between sophisticated businesses.
When a Choice-of-Law Clause Muddies the Picture
The most common ambiguity arises when a contract has a broad arbitration clause plus a choice-of-law provision pointing to a state with its own restrictions. That was the situation in Mastrobuono. The contract chose New York law, and at the time New York barred arbitrators from awarding punitive damages. Lower courts combined the two provisions and concluded the parties had opted into that bar.
The Supreme Court rejected that reading. The choice-of-law clause governed the substantive rights and duties between the parties; the arbitration clause governed how disputes would be resolved. A general reference to state law was “not, in itself, an unequivocal exclusion of punitive damages claims,” and ambiguity gets resolved in favor of letting the arbitrator decide.2Legal Information Institute. Mastrobuono v. Shearson Lehman Hutton, Inc., 514 U.S. 52 (1995)
If you actually want to prevent an arbitrator from awarding punitive damages, pointing to a restrictive state’s law isn’t enough. The arbitration clause itself has to strip the authority in plain terms.
What Conduct Justifies a Punitive Award
Authority to award punitive damages isn’t the same as grounds for them. Even when the arbitrator has the power, the conduct has to earn it. Punitive damages are not available for an ordinary breach of contract or a routine bad business judgment. They are reserved for fraud, intentional harm, reckless disregard of another party’s rights, or malicious behavior. An arbitrator weighs the same factors a court would: how reprehensible the conduct was, whether the wrongdoer acted knowingly, and whether the behavior was a pattern or an isolated event.
One quirk of arbitration matters here. Arbitrators usually don’t write detailed opinions, so the reasoning behind a punitive award is often hard to see from the outside. That opacity makes these awards hard to attack later.
Challenging an Arbitral Punitive Award
Federal law gives the losing side very little room to overturn an arbitrator’s decision, and punitive awards are no exception.
Under 9 U.S.C. ยง 10, a court may vacate an arbitration award only for corruption or fraud in obtaining it, evident partiality or corruption by the arbitrator, misconduct such as refusing to hear relevant evidence, or an arbitrator exceeding the powers granted by the agreement.3Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 9 U.S. Code 10 – Same; Vacation; Grounds; Rehearing
The last ground is the one that bites in punitive-damages disputes. If the agreement clearly barred punitive awards and the arbitrator gave one anyway, a court will probably vacate. If the agreement was merely silent or ambiguous, the arbitrator’s reading almost always stands. Courts won’t reweigh evidence, revisit the arbitrator’s factual findings, or substitute their view on whether the conduct deserved punishment.
A separate judge-made doctrine, “manifest disregard of the law,” once gave losing parties another route. It required showing that the arbitrator knew the controlling legal rule and consciously refused to apply it, not just that the arbitrator got the law wrong.4American Bar Association. Manifest Disregard as Grounds for Vacatur after Hall Street After Hall Street Associates, L.L.C. v. Mattel, Inc. (2008), the Supreme Court held that the Section 10 grounds are exclusive and suggested manifest disregard might be nothing more than shorthand for those grounds. Some federal circuits still apply it in a narrow form; others treat it as gone. Whether you can rely on it depends on where your case sits.5Justia U.S. Supreme Court Center. Hall Street Associates, L.L.C. v. Mattel, Inc., 552 U.S. 576 (2008)
Constitutional Limits Probably Do Not Apply
In court cases, the Due Process Clause caps how large a punitive award can be. BMW of North America, Inc. v. Gore (1996) set three guideposts: the reprehensibility of the conduct, the ratio between punitive and compensatory damages, and the comparison to civil or criminal penalties for similar conduct.6Legal Information Institute. BMW of North America, Inc. v. Gore, 517 U.S. 559 (1996)
Those limits almost certainly don’t apply to arbitration awards. Federal courts have consistently treated private arbitration as lacking the “state action” that triggers constitutional protections. Even a court’s confirmation of the award hasn’t been enough to pull the Due Process Clause into play. An arbitrator could issue a punitive award at a ratio a court would strike down in litigation, and the losing side would have no constitutional argument to challenge it. The arbitration agreement itself, plus the narrow statutory grounds for vacatur, are the only real checks.
Taxes on a Punitive Damages Award
Winning punitive damages produces a tax bill many people don’t expect. The IRS treats punitive damages as taxable ordinary income, reported as “Other Income” on your federal return. That remains true even when the underlying claim involved personal physical injury or sickness; the exclusion that shelters compensatory damages for physical injuries does not extend to the punitive portion.7Internal Revenue Service. Tax Implications of Settlements and Judgments
There is one narrow exception: wrongful death cases in states whose statutes allow only punitive recovery. Outside that specific situation, every dollar of punitive damages is taxable. If an award mixes compensatory and punitive components, keep them clearly separated so the reporting is clean. A large punitive award can push you into a higher bracket for the year, which is worth factoring in before accepting or negotiating any settlement.