Rehnquist Supreme Court: Federalism, Rights, and Bush v. Gore

The Rehnquist Supreme Court’s landmark cases, decided between September 1986 and September 2005, redrew the constitutional map on federal versus state power, narrowed the reach of the Commerce Clause, reshaped the Establishment Clause, cut back the death penalty, and resolved a presidential election. Chief Justice William Rehnquist led the Court for nearly two decades, and the rulings below are the ones that still define his era.1Justia. William Rehnquist Court

Anti-Commandeering: New York and Printz

The Court’s signature federalism move was the anti-commandeering doctrine, which bars Congress from forcing state governments to carry out federal programs. New York v. United States (1992) struck down a federal law that effectively ordered states to take ownership of radioactive waste or regulate it according to Congress’s instructions. The Court held that Congress may regulate individuals directly but cannot conscript state legislatures into doing the regulating for it.2Justia. New York v. United States, 505 U.S. 144 (1992)

Five years later, Printz v. United States (1997) extended the principle to state officers. The Brady Handgun Violence Prevention Act had required local sheriffs to run background checks on prospective handgun buyers. Justice Scalia, writing for the majority, held that the federal government cannot draft state law enforcement into administering a federal regulatory scheme, even when the task is ministerial.3Justia. Printz v. United States, 521 U.S. 898 (1997) Together the two cases established that neither state lawmakers nor state police could be pressed into federal service without their consent.

Rewriting the Commerce Clause: Lopez, Morrison, and the Raich Limit

For most of the twentieth century, the Commerce Clause had been read so broadly that almost any activity could be reached by Congress if some tie to interstate commerce could be imagined. United States v. Lopez (1995) pushed back. The Court struck down the Gun-Free School Zones Act, which made it a federal crime to carry a firearm near a school. Chief Justice Rehnquist’s majority opinion held that possessing a gun in a local school zone is not an economic activity and has no substantial connection to interstate commerce.4Justia. United States v. Lopez, 514 U.S. 549 (1995) It was the first time in nearly sixty years the Court told Congress it had exceeded its commerce power.

Lopez set out a three-part framework. Congress can regulate the channels of interstate commerce, the people and things moving through those channels, and activities that substantially affect interstate commerce.5Library of Congress. United States v. Lopez Anything outside those categories is beyond Congress’s commerce power.

United States v. Morrison (2000) applied the same reasoning to strike down a provision of the Violence Against Women Act that let victims of gender-motivated violence sue their attackers in federal court. Congress had compiled extensive evidence about the economic impact of such violence, but the Court held that the underlying conduct was not economic activity, and stacking inferences about downstream effects was not enough.6Justia. United States v. Morrison, 529 U.S. 598 (2000)

The federalism revolution had a visible limit. In Gonzales v. Raich (2005), the Court upheld Congress’s power to ban the cultivation and personal use of marijuana, even in states that had legalized medical marijuana. The majority reasoned that homegrown marijuana is part of a broader national drug market and that letting even small-scale local production slip through would undercut the federal Controlled Substances Act.7Justia. Gonzales v. Raich, 545 U.S. 1 (2005) When Congress regulated a genuinely economic class of activity through a broad statutory framework, the Court still deferred.

State Sovereign Immunity: Seminole Tribe, Alden, and Garrett

Alongside the commerce cases, the Court expanded the shield states enjoy from being sued. Seminole Tribe of Florida v. Florida (1996) held that Congress cannot use its Article I powers to strip states of their sovereign immunity from lawsuits in federal court.8Justia. Seminole Tribe of Fla. v. Florida, 517 U.S. 44 (1996)

Alden v. Maine (1999) pushed further. State probation officers had sued Maine for violating the federal Fair Labor Standards Act, filing in state court to sidestep Eleventh Amendment problems. The Court ruled that sovereign immunity is a fundamental feature of the constitutional design, not just an artifact of the Eleventh Amendment, and that Congress cannot use its Article I powers to force states into private lawsuits in their own courts either.9Justia. Alden v. Maine, 527 U.S. 706 (1999) One opening remained: Congress can override state immunity when legislating under Section 5 of the Fourteenth Amendment, but only in proportion to a documented pattern of constitutional violations.

That opening was narrow. In Board of Trustees of the University of Alabama v. Garrett (2001), state employees tried to sue for money damages under Title I of the Americans with Disabilities Act. The Court held the suits were barred because Congress had not identified a sufficient history of unconstitutional disability discrimination by states, and the ADA’s accommodation requirements went well beyond what the Fourteenth Amendment demanded.10Justia. Board of Trustees of Univ. of Ala. v. Garrett, 531 U.S. 356 (2001)

Dickerson and the Survival of Miranda

Many observers expected the Rehnquist Court to weaken Miranda v. Arizona when it got the chance. The chance came in Dickerson v. United States (2000), after Congress passed a statute making confession admissibility turn solely on voluntariness, without requiring the familiar warnings. Chief Justice Rehnquist himself wrote the majority opinion reaffirming Miranda, declaring it a constitutional rule that Congress cannot override by statute and noting that the warnings have “become embedded in routine police practice to the point where the warnings have become part of our national culture.”11Justia. Dickerson v. United States, 530 U.S. 428 (2000) A conservative Chief Justice preserved a liberal landmark because settled expectations deserved respect.

Narrowing the Death Penalty: Atkins and Roper

The Court also pulled back on who could be executed. Atkins v. Virginia (2002) held that executing people with intellectual disabilities violates the Eighth Amendment’s ban on cruel and unusual punishment. The majority pointed to a growing national consensus among state legislatures against the practice and reasoned that people with significant cognitive limitations are less culpable and less likely to be deterred.12Justia. Atkins v. Virginia, 536 U.S. 304 (2002)

Roper v. Simmons (2005) extended that logic to juvenile offenders, holding that the Eighth Amendment forbids executing anyone who committed their crime before turning 18.13Justia. Roper v. Simmons, 543 U.S. 551 (2005) Together the two rulings carved whole categories of defendants out of capital punishment.

Religion in Public Life: Zelman and Van Orden

The Court shifted from strict separationism toward a neutrality framework for religion. Zelman v. Simmons-Harris (2002) upheld Cleveland’s school voucher program. Most families used the vouchers at religious schools, but the Court ruled the program was constitutional because it was neutral with respect to religion, directed aid to parents rather than schools, and let families choose from public, private, secular, and religious options. Public money that flowed through genuine private choices did not count as government endorsement of religion.14Justia. Zelman v. Simmons-Harris, 536 U.S. 639 (2002)

Religious displays produced a more context-driven answer. Van Orden v. Perry (2005) allowed a Ten Commandments monument to remain on the Texas State Capitol grounds. The plurality emphasized that the monument sat among numerous secular displays recognizing Texas’s legal and political history, had gone unchallenged for 40 years, and functioned as a passive acknowledgment of the Commandments’ role in Western legal tradition.15Justia U.S. Supreme Court Center. Van Orden v. Perry, 545 U.S. 677 (2005)

Casey and Lawrence: Autonomy Cases

Planned Parenthood v. Casey (1992) reaffirmed the core holding of Roe v. Wade that the Constitution protects the right to an abortion before fetal viability. The joint opinion by Justices O’Connor, Kennedy, and Souter replaced Roe’s trimester framework with a new “undue burden” standard: states could regulate abortion so long as the regulation did not place a substantial obstacle in the path of a woman seeking the procedure. The change gave states considerably more room to impose requirements like waiting periods and informed consent.16Justia. Planned Parenthood of Southeastern Pa. v. Casey, 505 U.S. 833 (1992)

Lawrence v. Texas (2003) struck down state laws criminalizing consensual sexual conduct between adults of the same sex. Justice Kennedy’s majority opinion held that intimate consensual sexual conduct is part of the liberty protected by the Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment, overruling the Court’s 1986 decision in Bowers v. Hardwick. Lawrence was the Rehnquist Court’s broadest statement about personal autonomy.

Grutter and Race in University Admissions

Affirmative action in higher education reached the Court through two cases from the University of Michigan decided the same day. Grutter v. Bollinger (2003) upheld the law school’s holistic admissions review, which considered race as one factor among many. Justice O’Connor’s majority opinion accepted that the educational benefits of a diverse student body constitute a compelling government interest and that using race as a potential “plus” factor in individualized review satisfies narrow tailoring. The opinion expressed hope that race-conscious admissions would no longer be necessary within 25 years.17Justia U.S. Supreme Court Center. Grutter v. Bollinger, 539 U.S. 306 (2003) The companion case struck down Michigan’s undergraduate policy, which awarded a fixed number of points based on race, because that mechanical approach did not involve the individualized consideration the Constitution requires.

Bush v. Gore

The most publicly contested decision of the era was Bush v. Gore (2000). After the presidential contest between George W. Bush and Al Gore produced an extraordinarily close result in Florida, the Florida Supreme Court ordered manual recounts across several counties. The U.S. Supreme Court halted the recount and, in a per curiam opinion, held that the absence of uniform standards for evaluating ballots violated the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment. Different counties, and even different teams within the same county, were using inconsistent methods to determine voter intent, so identical ballots could be counted differently depending on who reviewed them.18Justia. Bush v. Gore, 531 U.S. 98 (2000)

The majority limited its holding to the specific circumstances of the case. Four dissenters, Justices Stevens, Souter, Breyer, and Ginsburg, argued the Court should have sent the case back to Florida’s courts to develop uniform recount standards rather than stopping the process entirely. Stevens’s dissent warned that the ruling undermined state courts and risked eroding public confidence in the judiciary. The decision effectively resolved the election in Bush’s favor.

Hamdi and Wartime Executive Power

The attacks of September 2001 brought a new question to the Court: how far can the executive branch go in detaining people it labels enemy combatants? Hamdi v. Rumsfeld (2004) involved a U.S. citizen captured in Afghanistan and held in a military brig without charges and without access to a lawyer. Justice O’Connor’s plurality opinion acknowledged that Congress had authorized the detention of enemy combatants but held that due process still applies. An American citizen detained on U.S. soil must receive notice of the factual basis for the government’s classification and a meaningful opportunity to challenge it before a neutral decision-maker.19Justia. Hamdi v. Rumsfeld, 542 U.S. 507 (2004) A state of war did not give the president an unchecked power to hold citizens indefinitely.

How This Court Produced So Many Landmarks

After Justice Stephen Breyer joined in 1994, the same nine justices served together for eleven consecutive years without a single vacancy, the longest such stretch in Supreme Court history.1Justia. William Rehnquist Court That stability let doctrines develop over time, and it made the pivotal votes predictable. In the closely divided cases on federalism, abortion, affirmative action, religion, and executive power, Justices Sandra Day O’Connor and Anthony Kennedy decided the outcome. The era closed in September 2005, when Rehnquist died of thyroid cancer and was succeeded by John Roberts; O’Connor, who had announced her retirement weeks earlier, was replaced by Samuel Alito.20Supreme Court of the United States. Justices 1789 to Present