Restorative Justice Examples: Mediation, Circles, and Conferencing

Restorative justice examples in the United States generally fall into five recognizable models: victim-offender mediation, family group conferencing, peacemaking circles, community reparative boards, and school-based restorative practices. Each one steps away from the usual question of what punishment fits the crime and asks a different one: what harm was done, and what will it take to repair it? At least 35 states have passed legislation encouraging these approaches for juveniles and adults, and the models in use range from a quiet conversation between two people to a community-wide circle rooted in Indigenous tradition.

Victim-Offender Mediation

Victim-offender mediation is the most widely used restorative justice model in the country. A trained mediator, often a community volunteer, meets separately with the victim and the offender before bringing them together. Those preliminary sessions prepare each side for the conversation ahead and confirm that both are participating willingly.1Office for Victims of Crime. Guidelines for Victim-Sensitive Victim-Offender Mediation – Restorative Justice Through Dialogue Even when a court nudges a defendant toward mediation, the offender can decline without automatic penalty.

In the session itself, the victim describes how the crime affected them financially, physically, and emotionally. The offender listens, responds, and takes direct responsibility. About 87 percent of these mediations produce a written restitution agreement, and roughly 80 to 90 percent of those agreements are completed, well above the 58 percent completion rate for court-ordered restitution.2United States Courts. The Impact of Victim-Offender Mediation – Two Decades of Research Agreements commonly include financial payments for medical costs or stolen property, community service, or direct service to the victim.

Historically these programs have handled juvenile property offenses and minor assaults, though there is a growing push to extend them to adult offenders and more serious crimes.3Utah Law Review. Participation in Victim-Offender Mediation and the Prevalence and Severity of Subsequent Delinquent Behavior – A Meta-Analysis Each program sets its own case-selection criteria, so eligibility varies from one jurisdiction to the next. If the offender fails to follow through on the agreement, the case typically returns to court for standard sentencing.

Family Group Conferencing

Family group conferencing widens the circle beyond victim and offender to include relatives and support networks on both sides. The model traces back to New Zealand’s 1989 Children, Young Persons, and Their Families Act, which was shaped by Maori traditions emphasizing extended-family decision-making. It later spread to parts of Australia and then to the United States, where it is most commonly used in juvenile justice and child welfare cases.

A coordinator facilitates the meeting, making sure the young person, their family, the victim, and sometimes a social worker or teacher each get to speak. The distinctive feature is private family time: the offender’s family meets alone, without professionals in the room, to develop a plan for addressing the harm and preventing future problems. The step is grounded in the idea that families, not institutions, should lead the decision-making.4ResearchGate. Private Family Time – The Heart of Family Group Decision-Making

The plan must then be approved by the victim and the facilitator. When the young person successfully completes it, many jurisdictions dismiss the charges, keeping the juvenile record clean. These conferences have been used for offenses ranging from theft and vandalism to arson and drug offenses.5University of Nebraska-Lincoln. Family Group Conferencing

Peacemaking Circles

Peacemaking circles draw on First Nations and Native American traditions that predate the U.S. legal system by centuries. The Navajo Nation, which embedded peacemaking into its tribal judiciary, is the best-known example, but similar models operate across multiple tribal jurisdictions. Participants sit in a physical circle to signal equality: the victim, the offender, elders, community members, and sometimes social workers all occupy the same ring.

A talking piece, an object chosen for its significance to the group, moves from person to person around the circle. Only the person holding it may speak; everyone else listens. The pace is deliberately unhurried, and no one is pressured to talk when the piece reaches them. The structure prevents the loudest voice from dominating and gives quiet participants the same platform as outspoken ones.

The circle works toward consensus rather than a ruling. Instead of a judge deciding consequences, the group collectively agrees on what the offender should do to restore balance. If the offender declines to enter peacemaking or fails to cooperate, the matter returns to court. Urban courts have adapted the model as well. A pilot program at Brooklyn’s Red Hook Community Justice Center used peacemaking circles as a pretrial diversion option for misdemeanor cases, dismissing charges for defendants who completed the process.6Center for Court Innovation. Peacemaking Circles – Evaluating a Native American Restorative Justice Practice in a State Criminal Court Setting in Brooklyn

Community Reparative Boards

Community reparative boards put trained citizen volunteers, not judges, across the table from the offender. These boards operate as a court-sanctioned diversion program, typically for adults who have pleaded guilty to nonviolent offenses. Board members and the offender discuss the crime, its impact on the neighborhood, and what repair should look like. Together they negotiate a reparative agreement: community service hours, educational classes, letters of apology, or direct restitution to the victim.

The offender returns to the board at a later date to show they have fulfilled every term. If they have, the board notifies the court, and the charges may be dismissed or the sentence reduced. If they haven’t, the case goes back through normal channels. What makes this model distinctive is the direct voice it gives to the community most affected by the crime, with neighbors deciding what accountability should look like rather than leaving the answer to a private exchange between the state and the defendant.

Restorative Practices in Schools

Schools increasingly use restorative practices as an alternative to suspension and expulsion. A designated coordinator typically manages these efforts across the student body. Two approaches dominate: peer mediation, where trained students help classmates work through disagreements or minor bullying incidents, and classroom circles, where a group addresses collective issues before they escalate.

The results are measurable. A study of Chicago Public Schools found that restorative practices led to an 18 percent decline in suspension days and a 19 percent decrease in student arrests. Black male and female students saw reductions in out-of-school suspensions more than double the average across all students.7Brookings. A Restorative Approach to Student Discipline Shows Promise in Reducing Suspensions and Arrests A separate RAND Corporation study of Pittsburgh schools found suspension rates fell faster in schools using restorative practices, particularly for African American students and students from low-income families, though arrest rates in that study did not decrease and academic outcomes showed mixed results.8RAND Corporation. Can Restorative Practices Improve School Climate and Curb Suspensions

When a student causes harm, the response focuses on understanding why it happened rather than simply assigning punishment. A student might participate in a circle with the person they harmed, write a genuine apology, or perform service to the school community. The goal is to keep students in school while teaching them how to take responsibility.

Who Can Participate

Eligibility varies by jurisdiction and program, but a few principles are nearly universal. The offender must accept responsibility for the harm, not necessarily through a formal guilty plea, but through acknowledgment that they caused the damage in question. Participation must be voluntary on both sides. A victim who does not want to sit across from the person who harmed them cannot be compelled to, and an offender who is not willing to engage genuinely will undermine the process.1Office for Victims of Crime. Guidelines for Victim-Sensitive Victim-Offender Mediation – Restorative Justice Through Dialogue

Most programs target nonviolent offenses: property crimes, minor assaults, low-level drug charges. Domestic violence and sexual assault remain contested territory. Only about two-thirds of states allow restorative justice for serious crimes in these categories, and far fewer have actually used it. Critics argue that the power imbalance between an abuser and a victim makes genuine voluntary participation impossible and that community involvement may reinforce victim-blaming. Proponents counter that conventional prosecution often fails survivors and that a well-designed restorative process can center the victim’s voice in ways the courtroom does not. The debate is active and unresolved.

Programs also set their own screening criteria beyond offense type. Some limit participation to first-time offenders; others accept people with prior records if the current charge fits. Age matters, with juvenile programs more common than adult ones, and some jurisdictions require a mental health screening or substance abuse assessment before admitting someone.

How Cases Reach These Programs

A restorative justice case can begin at almost any stage of the criminal process. Police officers sometimes divert people at the scene, particularly for minor disorder or juvenile offenses. Prosecutors exercise the most discretion, choosing which cases to route away from trial and toward mediation or conferencing. Defense attorneys can request a referral, and judges can suspend sentencing to allow a restorative process to run its course. Some programs even operate during incarceration or after release.

The referral point shapes what is at stake. A pre-charge diversion keeps the case out of court entirely; if the offender completes the program, no charges are filed. A post-charge, pre-plea diversion typically results in dismissal upon successful completion. A post-conviction referral might reduce a sentence or satisfy a condition of probation, but the conviction itself usually stands.

What the Outcomes Look Like

Participants on both sides of the table consistently report better experiences than people who go through conventional court. Across multiple studies, about 79 percent of victims who went through mediation reported satisfaction with how their case was handled, compared to 57 percent of victims whose cases went through court.9Department of Justice Canada. The Effects of Restorative Justice Programming – A Review of the Empirical Family group conferencing sites in Minnesota reported victim satisfaction rates between 93 and 95 percent.

On recidivism, one meta-analysis found a reoffending rate of 20 percent among restorative justice participants, versus 35 percent in a comparison group that went through traditional processing.10Department of Justice Canada. The Effectiveness of Restorative Justice Practices – A Meta-Analysis Context matters here: people who volunteer for restorative programs may already be more motivated to change than those who do not, which makes it difficult to separate the program’s effect from self-selection.

Restitution completion is where restorative justice most clearly outperforms the traditional system. Around 80 to 90 percent of mediated restitution agreements are fulfilled, compared to roughly 58 percent of court-ordered restitution.2United States Courts. The Impact of Victim-Offender Mediation – Two Decades of Research An offender who helped design the agreement, and looked the victim in the eye while doing it, has a different relationship to the obligation than one who received a payment order from a judge they barely spoke to.