Retention Elections for Judges: Rules, Votes, and Outcomes

Retention elections for judges are yes-or-no votes on whether a sitting judge should serve another term. No challenger appears on the ballot. Voters simply decide whether to keep the judge or remove them, and roughly 20 states use this format for at least some of their courts to keep judicial selection out of partisan campaigns while still giving the public a final say.

What a Retention Ballot Looks Like

The retention portion of a ballot is simple. Each judge’s name appears alongside the court where they serve, followed by one question: “Shall Justice [Name] of the [Court] be retained in office?” You mark “Yes” or “No.” There are no opposing candidates and no party labels. The entries usually sit near the bottom of the ballot, organized by court level from the highest court down to trial courts.

Some states list each judge as a separate ballot question. Others group judges by court with one instruction at the top and individual yes/no options next to each name. Colorado amended its constitution in 2018 to use the grouped format. Either way, your task is the same: decide on each judge individually.

Which States Use Them

Twenty states hold retention elections at the state supreme court level: Alaska, Arizona, California, Colorado, Florida, Illinois, Indiana, Iowa, Kansas, Maryland, Missouri, Montana, Nebraska, New Mexico, Oklahoma, Pennsylvania, South Dakota, Tennessee, Utah, and Wyoming. Most of these states also use the format for appellate and trial courts, though the details vary.

Not every state applies retention uniformly. Arizona uses the system in its largest counties but not statewide for trial judges. Indiana uses it only in specific counties. Some states use retention for appellate judges but hold competitive elections for trial seats. Whether your local judges face a retention vote depends on both your state and the court level.

How Judges Are Evaluated Before the Vote

In states with developed retention systems, judicial performance commissions evaluate each judge before the election. These independent bodies survey attorneys, court staff, jurors, and others who have observed the judge’s work. They review courtroom observations, written opinions, and interviews to assess legal knowledge, communication, integrity, and temperament.1Colorado Office of Judicial Performance Evaluation. Colorado Office of Judicial Performance Evaluation Home

The commission produces a narrative profile and a retention recommendation for each judge on the ballot. In Colorado, commissions distribute questionnaires to attorneys, district attorneys, public defenders, jurors, litigants, court personnel, probation officers, and law enforcement, then compile the results into a public report.2Colorado Judicial Branch. Rules Governing the Commissions on Judicial Performance In Arizona, court rules require commissions to determine whether each judge “meets” or “does not meet” established performance standards before the retention election.3New York Codes, Rules and Regulations. Rule 4 – Meetings and Action The Arizona Constitution also requires that performance reviews use written standards and that the public has a full and fair opportunity to participate through hearings and published reports.4Justia. Arizona Constitution Article 6 Section 42 – Retention Evaluation of Justices and Judges

These evaluations are published in state voter guides or on government websites, so you can review them before voting. Not every state invests equally in this process. In states without formal performance commissions, voters may have little information beyond the judge’s name and court.

How Many Votes a Judge Needs to Stay

In most states, a judge needs a simple majority of yes votes to win retention. More than half yes, and the judge serves another full term.5Iowa JNC. What Is a Judicial Retention Election The length of that next term varies by state and court level, commonly ranging from six to twelve years.

Illinois is the major exception. Judges there must receive 60 percent yes votes to win retention. This supermajority means an Illinois judge can lose even when a clear majority of voters support keeping them. Some judges in that position have resigned and run as new candidates in the resulting vacancy election, where only 51 percent is needed to win. Critics describe this as a way to sidestep the higher standard.

What Happens If a Judge Loses

Losing a retention election is rare, but when it happens, the judge must leave the bench. The transition usually occurs at the end of the judge’s current term, in January following the November election. The outgoing judge wraps up pending matters and transfers remaining cases before departure.

The vacancy is then filled through merit selection. A judicial nominating commission reviews applications, conducts interviews, and sends a short list of finalists to the governor, who picks one of the nominees. That new judge serves an initial term before facing a retention election of their own. A key feature of this design: even when outside groups spend heavily to remove a judge, they cannot handpick the replacement, because the nominating commission controls the shortlist.

Campaign Rules and Outside Spending

Judges facing retention operate under ethical constraints that don’t apply to candidates in ordinary political races. The ABA Model Code of Judicial Conduct, which most states have adopted in some form, requires judicial candidates to act consistently with the independence, integrity, and impartiality of the judiciary even while campaigning. Judges may establish campaign committees and speak on their own behalf, but they must personally review and approve all campaign materials before publication.6American Bar Association. Rule 4.2 – Political and Campaign Activities of Judicial Candidates in Public Elections They must also take reasonable steps to prevent supporters from doing things on their behalf that the judge couldn’t do directly.

Those restrictions apply to the judge. They do not apply to outside groups. Retention races were historically quiet, but controversial court decisions now draw millions in spending from interest groups. In Oklahoma’s 2024 retention elections, groups spent a combined $3.6 million on advertising after the state supreme court issued rulings on abortion restrictions and religious charter schools. The previous state record was $600,000, spent in 2012. Arizona saw similar dueling ad campaigns in 2024 after a high-profile abortion ruling.

When Retention Elections Turn Contentious

Judges win retention at extraordinarily high rates. In most cycles, the vast majority receive 70 percent or more yes votes. But when a court issues a politically charged decision close to election time, the backlash can be sharp.

The clearest modern example came in Iowa in 2010, when all three state supreme court justices on the ballot lost their retention elections. Justices David Baker, Marsha Ternus, and Michael Streit were removed after the court’s unanimous 2009 decision legalizing same-sex marriage. Organized opposition campaigns targeted them specifically, and each lost with roughly 54 to 55 percent of voters marking “No.”

Oklahoma saw its first retention loss in 2024, when Justice Yvonne Kauger was voted out after rulings on abortion and religious charter schools drew organized opposition. In Pennsylvania in 2005, Supreme Court Justice Russell Nigro became the first appellate judge in state history to lose a retention vote, swept out in public anger over a legislative pay raise. These cases are exceptions rather than the norm, but they show the tension built into the format. The system is designed to insulate judges from politics, yet the vote itself remains a political act. When voters are angry enough, a yes-or-no question is all the lever they need.