Robbery vs Burglary vs Larceny: Charges, Overlap, and Defenses

The difference between robbery, burglary, and larceny comes down to what the crime targets: larceny is taking someone’s property without permission, burglary is entering a building intending to commit a crime inside, and robbery is taking property directly from a person using force or threats. The three get mixed up constantly in everyday speech, but prosecutors treat them as separate offenses with separate elements and very different penalties. Robbery is almost always a felony because a person was threatened or harmed. Larceny can be a misdemeanor when the item is cheap. Burglary turns on what you intended when you walked through the door, not what you ended up taking.

Larceny: Taking Property

Larceny is the simplest of the three. You take someone else’s property without their consent, intending to keep it permanently. The common-law version required four elements: a wrongful taking, carrying the property away (even a few inches counts), the property belonging to someone else, and the intent to permanently deprive the owner of it. Many states have modernized their codes and now call the offense “theft,” but the core idea is the same.

Intent is what separates larceny from an honest mistake. Grabbing a jacket off a restaurant coat rack because you thought it was yours is not larceny. Grabbing the same jacket knowing it belongs to someone else is, and the crime is complete the moment you move it. Prosecutors don’t have to show you made it out of the building or kept the item for any length of time.

Larceny doesn’t require any contact with the victim. The owner can be miles away. There’s no force, no confrontation, and no need to enter a building unlawfully. A pickpocket lifting a wallet from an unaware pedestrian commits larceny. So does someone who takes a bicycle left unlocked on a public sidewalk. Keeping lost property can qualify in many states if you had a reasonable way to find the owner and didn’t try.

Shoplifting is usually treated as a form of larceny, though some states have carved out separate shoplifting statutes with lighter penalties. The dividing line is often whether you left the store with the merchandise or were caught concealing it inside.

Burglary: Unlawful Entry With Criminal Intent

Burglary is about the invasion of a space, not the successful theft of property. Under the FBI’s Uniform Crime Reporting definition and most state statutes, burglary means unlawfully entering a structure with the intent to commit a crime inside.1FBI. FBI UCR Burglary That intended crime is often theft, but it doesn’t have to be. Someone who enters a building planning to vandalize, assault, or set a fire has committed burglary too.

The biggest misconception is that burglary requires a “break-in.” Old common law required a physical breaking, such as smashing a window or forcing a lock. Modern statutes in most states have dropped that requirement. Walking through an unlocked door or an open loading dock counts as unlawful entry if you don’t have permission to be there. You can also commit burglary by entering legally and then staying after your permission expires. A customer who hides in a store restroom until closing with plans to rob the register fits that pattern.

The intent must exist at the moment of entry, or at the moment the person decides to remain unlawfully. This is the critical distinction. If you walk into a friend’s apartment with no criminal purpose and later decide to pocket their watch, that’s likely larceny but not burglary. Prosecutors have to prove you planned to commit a crime before or at the time you crossed the threshold.

The FBI’s definition of “structure” is broad, covering homes, apartments, barns, offices, houseboats used as dwellings, railroad cars, and stables.1FBI. FBI UCR Burglary State definitions vary but generally include garages, sheds, and other outbuildings tied to a residence. Whether the building is residential or commercial usually drives the degree of the charge, with homes carrying harsher penalties because of the greater risk to occupants.

Robbery: Theft Plus Force

Robbery combines the taking element of larceny with actual or threatened violence against a person. Under the federal Hobbs Act, robbery means “the unlawful taking or obtaining of personal property from the person or in the presence of another, against his will, by means of actual or threatened force, or violence, or fear of injury.”2Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 18 USC 1951 Interference With Commerce by Threats or Violence State definitions follow the same logic.

The force or threat has to be aimed at a person, not just the property. Snatching a package off a porch while the homeowner is at work is larceny, because there’s no confrontation. Yanking a purse strap off someone’s shoulder is robbery, even if the victim isn’t seriously injured. The victim’s reasonable perception of danger carries as much weight as the offender’s actual capacity to cause harm.

Robbery is always treated as a more serious offense than larceny because of the personal danger. Even a so-called “simple robbery” with no weapon carries significant prison time. In federal court, the average sentence for robbery offenders without a firearms conviction was 76 months in fiscal year 2024, while those convicted of using a firearm during the robbery averaged 162 months.3United States Sentencing Commission. Robbery Offenses State sentences vary, but the jump from unarmed to armed robbery is steep everywhere.

How the Three Overlap in One Incident

Part of the confusion is that a single incident can involve all three crimes. Someone who breaks into a house, takes a laptop, and threatens the homeowner who walks in could face charges for burglary, larceny, and robbery at once. Each charge addresses a different harm.

  • Larceny protects your right to your property. No force, no unlawful entry required; the crime is complete when someone takes your stuff with intent to keep it.
  • Burglary protects the security of buildings and dwellings. No property needs to change hands; the crime is complete when someone enters unlawfully with criminal intent.
  • Robbery protects your physical safety during a theft. Property must be taken from or near a person through force or intimidation, and there is always a victim who was present and threatened.

A practical way to keep them straight: larceny is about what was taken, burglary is about where someone went, and robbery is about how the taking happened. A person can commit larceny without burglary (shoplifting), burglary without larceny (breaking in to vandalize), and robbery without burglary (a mugging on the street).

How the Charges Escalate

Each offense is divided into degrees based on aggravating factors. The degree decides whether the charge is a misdemeanor or felony and how much prison time is on the table.

Larceny and Theft

The dollar value of the stolen property is the main dividing line between misdemeanor “petty” theft and felony “grand” theft. Thresholds vary dramatically by state, from as low as $200 to as high as $2,500. Roughly half of states set the line at $1,000, and several have raised theirs in recent years. Below the threshold, a first offense is typically a misdemeanor punishable by up to a year in jail and a fine. Above it, the charge jumps to a felony with potential prison sentences of several years.

Certain stolen items trigger automatic felony charges regardless of value. Firearms, motor vehicles, and property taken directly from a person’s body (like a necklace) commonly push the charge into felony territory even when worth less than the state’s monetary threshold. Repeat offenders also face escalation; some states bump a second or third petty theft to a felony.

Burglary

Burglary degrees track what kind of building was entered and what happened inside. Breaking into an occupied home at night is treated as the most serious form. Most states classify first-degree residential burglary as a felony carrying anywhere from two to seven or more years in prison. Commercial burglary of an unoccupied building generally falls into a lower degree. Using a weapon, injuring an occupant, or bringing accomplices all push the charge higher.

Robbery

Robbery escalation follows the level of violence. Simple robbery, where force or threats are used without a weapon, is already a serious felony in every state. Displaying a weapon bumps it to armed robbery, which carries substantially longer mandatory minimum sentences. If someone is physically injured, or if the victim is particularly vulnerable, the charge can reach first-degree robbery with potential sentences of 20 years or more. Federal armed robbery of a bank can result in up to 25 years.4Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 18 USC 2113 Bank Robbery and Incidental Crimes

Robbery Compared With Extortion

Robbery and extortion both involve taking property through coercion, but the timing of the threat separates them. Robbery requires an immediate threat: hand over the money or get hurt right now. Extortion involves threats of future harm or non-physical consequences. A demand for payment backed by a threat to release embarrassing information next week is extortion, not robbery, because the threatened harm isn’t immediate and isn’t physical. The federal Hobbs Act covers both, but treats them as distinct offenses with different elements; both carry a maximum of 20 years in federal prison.2Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 18 USC 1951 Interference With Commerce by Threats or Violence At the state level, extortion often includes threats to accuse someone of a crime, damage their reputation, or expose secrets, none of which would support a robbery charge.

Defenses That Fit Each Charge

Because each offense has different elements, the defenses that work against one don’t always work against another.

Claim of Right

A genuine belief that the property was yours, or that you had a legal right to take it, can defeat the intent element of larceny and robbery. The belief doesn’t have to be correct, only honestly held. Someone who grabs a bicycle from a rack sincerely believing it’s the one stolen from them last week can raise the defense even if they picked up the wrong bike. The defense fails when the belief is fabricated or when the defendant knew the claim was baseless.

Lack of Intent at Entry

Burglary requires criminal intent at the moment of entry. If a defendant entered a building for a lawful reason and only formed the intent to steal after getting inside, the entry wasn’t unlawful and the burglary charge falls apart. The theft that followed would still support a larceny charge, but not burglary. This comes up often when someone enters a store during business hours and later decides to take merchandise.

Consent

Permission from the property owner defeats larceny. Permission from the building owner defeats the unlawful-entry element of burglary. Consent obtained through deception or coercion doesn’t count, but legitimate consent eliminates a required element of the charge.