Theft, robbery, and burglary sound interchangeable in everyday speech, but in criminal law they describe three different crimes with three different penalty structures. The short version of robbery vs. burglary vs. theft: theft is taking someone’s property without permission; robbery is taking property directly from a person using force or threats; burglary is entering a building intending to commit a crime inside, whether or not anything is ever stolen. The distinctions matter because the charge you face, and the sentence attached to it, turns on which one the prosecutor can prove.
Theft Means Taking Property Without Permission
Theft is the broadest of the three. Under Model Penal Code Section 223.2, a person commits theft by unlawfully taking or exercising unlawful control over someone else’s movable property with the purpose of depriving the owner of it. Most state statutes track that framework. Three ingredients have to line up: you took something that wasn’t yours, you had no permission, and you meant to keep it.
That last element is where cases turn. Borrowing a neighbor’s lawnmower without asking and returning it the next day is not theft in most jurisdictions, because the intent to permanently deprive the owner isn’t there. Walking out of a store with an item you forgot to scan at self-checkout doesn’t automatically qualify either. Prosecutors have to prove the intent to steal existed at the moment of the taking.
Found property catches people off guard. If you find a wallet on the sidewalk and pocket the cash, that can be prosecuted as theft in many states. The law generally expects finders to make a reasonable effort to locate the owner or hand the property to law enforcement. Keeping it without trying counts as the same purposeful deprivation as shoplifting.
How Theft Penalties Scale
Theft penalties almost always hinge on the dollar value of what was taken. Every state draws a line between misdemeanor “petty theft” and felony “grand theft,” but where that line sits varies widely. Some states set the felony threshold at a few hundred dollars; others wait until the value crosses $2,000 or $2,500. The most common cutoff sits around $1,000.
A petty theft conviction below the felony line is typically a misdemeanor carrying up to a year in county jail and modest fines. Above the line, grand theft becomes a felony with potential state prison time ranging from one year to ten or more, depending on value and criminal history. Courts also commonly order restitution to the victim.
Theft is really an umbrella. Shoplifting, or “retail theft,” is the most frequently charged variety and scales the same way by value. Theft by deception, or fraud, covers property obtained through lies rather than physical taking: the victim hands it over, but only because they were tricked. Embezzlement is another relative, and the difference is where the property started. A regular thief never had lawful possession. An embezzler did, through a position of trust, and then converted the property to personal use. That breach of trust is what makes embezzlement a distinct charge, and in many jurisdictions it carries harsher penalties than equivalent-value theft.
Robbery Is Theft Plus Force or Intimidation
Robbery is theft’s violent sibling. Under Model Penal Code Section 222.1, a person commits robbery by inflicting serious bodily injury during a theft, threatening someone with immediate serious injury, or committing or threatening a serious felony in the course of stealing. Every state follows a similar logic: robbery starts as a theft and escalates because the offender used force or fear to get the property.
Two elements separate robbery from theft. First, the property must be taken from a person or from their immediate presence. Stealing a package off a porch while the homeowner is at work is theft. Confronting that homeowner at the door and demanding they hand it over is robbery. Second, the offender must use force, violence, or intimidation during the taking. The force doesn’t need to be extreme. Snatching a purse hard enough to jerk the victim’s arm can qualify. What matters is that the victim was present and subjected to some physical act or credible threat.
Threats of future harm generally don’t count. Telling someone “give me your wallet or I’ll find you next week” sits closer to extortion than robbery. The threat has to be immediate, something the victim believes will happen right now if they don’t comply. The fear itself can be legally sufficient without any physical injury. A pointed finger inside a jacket pocket implying a gun has supported robbery convictions where the victim genuinely believed the threat was real.
How Robbery Penalties Scale
Because robbery involves a direct threat to human safety, it is always a felony. Grading depends on how much danger the offender created. Most states distinguish simple robbery from aggravated or armed robbery.
Simple robbery, with no weapon and no serious injury, is still a serious felony, with prison terms typically starting in the range of three to ten years. Aggravated or armed robbery, where a weapon was displayed or used or the victim suffered serious physical harm, commonly jumps to ten years or more, and many states impose mandatory minimums that take probation off the table.
Under the MPC, robbery is a second-degree felony that climbs to first degree if the offender attempts to kill anyone or purposely inflicts serious bodily injury. At the federal level, bank robbery under 18 U.S.C. ยง 2113 carries up to 20 years for a standard offense, up to 25 years if a dangerous weapon is used, and a minimum of 10 years (or life imprisonment if someone dies) in the most extreme cases.1Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 18 USC 2113 – Bank Robbery and Incidental Crimes
Burglary Is Entering a Building With Criminal Intent
Burglary is the most misunderstood of the three. Most people picture someone breaking into a house and carrying off valuables, but burglary has almost nothing to do with stealing and everything to do with entering a building you shouldn’t be in, with criminal intent. Under Model Penal Code Section 221.1, a person commits burglary by entering a building or occupied structure with the purpose of committing a crime inside. That is the whole offense. No theft is required. No one needs to be home. The crime is complete the moment you cross the threshold with that intent.
A person who enters a home planning to commit an assault has committed burglary, even if they never intended to steal anything. A person who breaks into a warehouse intending to steal but gets scared off before touching the merchandise has still committed burglary. The intended crime doesn’t have to actually happen. Intent at the time of entry is what prosecutors prove, usually through circumstantial evidence like tools carried, time of entry, and the defendant’s own statements.
What Counts as Entry
You don’t need to pick a lock or smash a window. Walking through an unlocked door without permission counts. Some jurisdictions recognize “constructive entry,” where a person gains access through deception or threats rather than physical force. Tricking a resident into opening the door under false pretenses can satisfy the entry element. The MPC does carve out exceptions for premises open to the public and for people licensed or privileged to enter, so walking into an open store during business hours isn’t burglary.
The definition of “occupied structure” is broader than people expect. Under the MPC, it includes any structure, vehicle, or place adapted for overnight accommodation or for conducting business, regardless of whether anyone is actually inside. A seasonal cabin empty for the winter still qualifies. So does a closed office building at night.
How Burglary Penalties Scale
Most states grade burglary into degrees based on the type of building and the level of danger during the offense.
First-degree burglary typically involves entering a dwelling, especially at night when residents are likely present. It is almost always charged as a high-level felony, with prison terms commonly running from four to fifteen years or more. Second-degree burglary usually involves commercial buildings, unoccupied structures, or entries that don’t carry the same risk to human safety. Penalties are still substantial but generally lower, and in some states less serious circumstances can bring the charge down to a misdemeanor.
Under the MPC, burglary is a second-degree felony when committed in a dwelling at night, when the offender inflicts or attempts bodily injury, or when the offender is armed with explosives or a deadly weapon. Otherwise it grades as a third-degree felony. The nighttime distinction reflects a practical reality: breaking into an occupied home at 3 a.m. is far more likely to produce a violent confrontation than entering an empty commercial building during the day.
When a Single Incident Triggers All Three
These charges aren’t always separate incidents. One event can produce all three. Someone who breaks into a home, steals jewelry from a bedroom, and then threatens the homeowner who walks in could face burglary for the unlawful entry with criminal intent, theft for taking the jewelry, and robbery for using threats to leave with the property.
One scenario trips people up constantly. A pickpocket on a crowded street commits theft, not robbery, because no force or intimidation is involved. If the victim notices and the pickpocket shoves them to get away, many jurisdictions escalate the charge to robbery because force was used during the course of the theft. The timeline matters. Force used during the taking, or during immediate flight from it, can convert a simple theft into a robbery.
Prosecutors in many states stack these charges aggressively, and plea negotiations often involve dropping one charge in exchange for a guilty plea on another. Knowing which elements the prosecutor actually has evidence for is the difference between a misdemeanor exposure and a decade in prison.
Restitution Applies to All Three
Beyond prison time and fines, anyone convicted of theft, robbery, or burglary can be ordered to pay restitution to the victim. Restitution is not the same as a fine. Fines go to the government as punishment. Restitution goes directly to the victim to cover actual losses: the value of stolen or damaged property, medical bills if someone was injured, lost income, and related expenses. Under federal law, courts must order restitution for victims of qualifying offenses, and the amount is based on either the property’s value at the time of the crime or at sentencing, whichever is greater.2Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 18 US Code 3663A – Mandatory Restitution to Victims of Certain Crimes