Sanctuary City Laws: Funding Cuts, Court Wins, and Injunctions

Sanctuary city funding penalties come in three forms: federal grant conditions that bar money from going to jurisdictions that limit immigration cooperation, outright termination of federal funds under a 2025 executive order, and state laws that impose daily fines, criminal charges against local officials, and withheld state revenue. Courts have struck down or paused several of these penalties, and the ones still in force are being actively litigated.

What Triggers a Penalty

A jurisdiction becomes a target when it refuses to honor civil immigration detainers, restricts its employees from sharing immigration status information with federal authorities, or otherwise declines to assist Immigration and Customs Enforcement. A detainer asks a local jail to hold someone up to 48 hours past their scheduled release so federal agents can take custody.1U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement. Immigration Detainers2Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 8 USC 1373 – Communication Between Government Agencies and the Immigration and Naturalization Service3Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 8 USC 1644 – Communication Between State and Local Government Agencies and Immigration and Naturalization Service Compliance with those information-sharing statutes is the main hook federal agencies use to attach strings to grants.

As of August 2025, the Department of Justice has identified 35 jurisdictions as sanctuary jurisdictions, including 13 states, 4 counties, and 18 cities.4United States Department of Justice. Justice Department Publishes List of Sanctuary Jurisdictions Being listed is what opens the door to the funding consequences described below.

Federal Grants on the Line

Byrne JAG

The Edward Byrne Memorial Justice Assistance Grant program is the most prominent target. Byrne JAG distributes roughly $199 million a year to state and local law enforcement.5Grants.gov. View Grant Opportunity – Search Results Detail The FY 2025 solicitation bars recipients from using funds for any program or activity that “directly or indirectly, violates … federal immigration law (including 8 U.S.C. § 1373) or impedes or hinders the enforcement of federal immigration law,” including failing to provide federal agents access or declining to honor their requests.6U.S. Department of Justice. BJA FY25 Edward Byrne Memorial Justice Assistance Grant (JAG) Program

COPS Grants

Community Oriented Policing Services grants carry similar strings. During the first Trump administration, DOJ gave priority scoring to jurisdictions that cooperated with federal immigration enforcement.7United States Department of Justice. Department of Justice Announces Priority Consideration Criteria for COPS Office Grants The Biden administration suspended those requirements in 2021 and told recipients they no longer needed to submit standalone § 1373 compliance certifications.8Office of Community Oriented Policing Services. Office of Community Oriented Policing Services Immigration FAQs The current administration has reversed course.

SCAAP Zeroed Out

The State Criminal Alien Assistance Program once reimbursed state and local jails for part of the cost of incarcerating convicted noncitizens held at least four consecutive days with felony convictions or multiple misdemeanors. SCAAP never covered the full cost, and for FY 2026 the program received zero funding. One financial lever is gone, but so is one source of money that sanctuary jurisdictions used to receive.

The April 2025 Executive Order

On April 28, 2025, an executive order titled “Protecting American Communities from Criminal Aliens” sharply expanded the federal approach. The order directs the Attorney General and the Secretary of Homeland Security to publish and update a list of sanctuary jurisdictions, notify them, and then have every cabinet-level agency identify federal funds flowing to them that could be suspended or terminated.9The White House. Protecting American Communities from Criminal Aliens

The order also instructs the Attorney General and DHS Secretary to pursue legal remedies against listed jurisdictions, citing federal criminal statutes covering obstruction, harboring, and conspiracy. It targets federally funded benefits administered by private organizations in sanctuary areas and takes aim at state policies offering in-state tuition to noncitizens while denying it to out-of-state U.S. citizens.9The White House. Protecting American Communities from Criminal Aliens The reach extends well beyond law enforcement grants, potentially to any federal dollars going to a listed jurisdiction.

State-Level Penalties

Several state legislatures have passed their own anti-sanctuary laws, adding a layer of pressure separate from federal funding conditions. The penalties can be heavy. Some states impose civil fines reaching $25,500 per day for ongoing violations. Others make it a criminal offense for a sheriff or police chief to refuse federal detainer requests. The most aggressive versions allow removal from office for elected or appointed officials who defy the law. States may also withhold shared revenue, which for some municipalities is a meaningful chunk of the operating budget.

Why Cities Often Win in Court

Funding penalties face three serious constitutional problems, and cities have used all three to secure court orders blocking enforcement.

Spending Clause Coercion

The Supreme Court has held that the threat of losing a large existing funding stream can cross the line from persuasion into unconstitutional coercion. In the 2012 Medicaid expansion case, the Court struck down a provision that would have stripped states of all existing Medicaid funds if they refused to expand, holding that Congress lacks authority under the Spending Clause to threaten states with complete loss of federal funding on that scale. That framework governs sanctuary funding challenges. The broader and less immigration-related the funding stream being cut, the more likely a court will find the pressure coercive.

Separation of Powers

Congress controls federal spending, not the executive branch. A federal appeals court applied that principle directly to Byrne JAG when the Attorney General tried to add immigration conditions Congress never authorized. The court held that the AG lacked statutory authority and warned that “if the Executive Branch can determine policy, and then use the power of the purse to mandate compliance with that policy by the state and local governments, all without the authorization or even acquiescence of elected legislators, that check against tyranny is forsaken.”10United States Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit. City of Chicago v Sessions This reasoning limits how far an administration can go in attaching new conditions to grants Congress funded without them.

Anti-Commandeering

The Tenth Amendment reserves to the states powers not delegated to the federal government, and the Supreme Court has read it to mean Congress cannot force state or local officials to carry out federal programs. The 1997 ruling in Printz held plainly that “the Federal Government may not compel the States to enact or administer a federal regulatory program.”11Justia. Printz v United States The Court reinforced this in 2018, noting that “conspicuously absent from the list of powers given to Congress is the power to issue direct orders to the governments of the States.”12Justia. Murphy v National Collegiate Athletic Association A federal appeals court applied the doctrine directly to immigration, holding that reading the detainer regulation as a binding command “would violate the anti-commandeering doctrine of the Tenth Amendment” and that local agencies “are free to disregard detainers.”13Justia. Galarza v Szalczyk, No 12-3991 A funding penalty that effectively forces local enforcement of federal immigration law runs into the same wall.

The 2025 Injunctions and the Bond Rule

Litigation is active and still shaping the landscape. In early 2025, a federal district court issued a preliminary injunction blocking FEMA from implementing a manual review process that was effectively pausing grant disbursements to sanctuary jurisdictions. The court found the review was designed to carry out the April 2025 executive order and amounted to “a categorical pause or freeze of funding appropriated by Congress,” and it ordered FEMA to resume normal disbursement.14Congressional Research Service. Congressional and Executive Power Over Spending – Selected Recent Litigation

Winning a preliminary injunction requires a city to show a likelihood of success on the merits, irreparable harm without relief, a balance of hardships in its favor, and that an injunction serves the public interest. Final rulings often take a year or more, so the preliminary injunction phase is where cities keep funding flowing while the constitutional questions get sorted out.

One recent complication: a March 2025 executive order directs courts to enforce the security bond requirement of Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 65(c), which would require cities seeking injunctions to post financial security covering the government’s potential losses if the injunction turns out to be wrong.15The White House. Ensuring the Enforcement of Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 65(c) If judges impose large bonds in these cases, challenging funding cuts could become significantly more expensive for municipalities, even when they have strong legal claims.