Sasha Suda Lawsuit: Firing, Theft Claims, and Arbitration Ruling

The Sasha Suda lawsuit is a wrongful-termination and breach-of-contract action filed on November 10, 2025, by the former director and CEO of the Philadelphia Art Museum after the board fired her three years into a five-year contract. Suda is seeking $1.5 million in damages. The museum has countered with allegations that she misappropriated funds by giving herself unauthorized raises, and in February 2026 a Philadelphia judge ordered the entire dispute into confidential arbitration.¹

How Suda Was Fired

Suda started at the museum on September 21, 2022, on a starting salary of $720,000.²³ Tensions with parts of the board built over her tenure and came to a head in the fall of 2025, when the board opened what it described as a broad financial investigation.

On October 28, 2025, board vice chairman Osagie Imasogie and three other board members, including new chair Ellen Caplan, told Suda the investigation had found her to have been “dishonest, twice.” When Suda asked for specifics, Imasogie declined to elaborate. She was told to resign or be fired.³ She refused.

A separate controversy was running in parallel. In October 2025, Suda had led a rebranding that changed the institution’s name from “Philadelphia Museum of Art” to “Philadelphia Art Museum,” at a cost of $250,000 not counting paid media and wayfinding. Trustee Jerry Wind said the board “never approved the final version,” and trustee Jennifer Rice said “the board should have been told when the launch was happening.”⁴ A Philadelphia Inquirer story reporting that the launch had blindsided the board appeared the night before Suda’s firing.⁵

On November 4, 2025, the board voted 12-0 to terminate her. She was notified by email that she was being “terminated for cause” minutes before an emergency board meeting that, according to a New York Times account, was scheduled so the board could “be advised on what, exactly, the cause is.”⁶⁷

What the Lawsuit Alleges

Six days after the vote, Suda filed a 30-page complaint in the Philadelphia Court of Common Pleas alleging breaches of contract, bad faith, unfair treatment, and abuse. She requested a jury trial and demanded $1.5 million.⁸⁹

The central claim: Suda was “terminated when her efforts to modernize the museum clashed with a small, corrupt, and unethical faction of the board intent on preserving the status quo.”⁹¹⁰³¹¹

On the money at the heart of the dismissal, Suda says a 3 percent cost-of-living adjustment to her salary, amounting to roughly $39,000 over two years, was authorized, budgeted, and consistent with increases negotiated in the museum’s 2022 union contract. She characterizes the board’s financial investigation as a “sham” designed to justify a decision that had already been made.⁸⁹

Suda also claims her contract entitled her to two years of severance. The museum offered six months, which her camp put at roughly $370,000 against the $1.4 million she believed she was owed.¹¹¹² The suit further alleges that board officers and agents made false statements to the media to “disparage, belittle, and discredit” her, and it seeks an injunction to enforce confidentiality and non-disparagement clauses in her employment agreement.⁸ The museum called the claims “without merit.”

The Museum’s Theft Allegations

On November 20, 2025, the museum filed its own petition, seeking to compel arbitration and accusing Suda of “misappropriated funds” and “theft.”¹³ According to the filing, Suda awarded herself three unauthorized salary increases, two in 2024 and one in July 2025, despite knowing that all compensation changes required approval from the board’s compensation committee.⁷

The museum alleges that Suda repeatedly requested raises through the proper channel, was refused, and then “took the money anyway, defying the board and violating her contract.” When questioned by a special committee, the museum says, Suda falsely stated that subordinates had advised her she was entitled to the increases.⁷ The board’s position is that her contract set her salary at $720,000 with no cost-of-living adjustment “unless explicitly approved by the board,” and that Suda had been specifically told she would not receive the same annual adjustments as other staff.¹²

Suda’s attorney, Luke Nikas, called the theft accusations “recycled allegations from the sham investigation that the museum manufactured as a pretext for Suda’s wrongful termination.”¹³ None of the allegations from either side have been tested in court.

Judge Sends the Case to Arbitration

On February 2, 2026, Philadelphia Court of Common Pleas Judge Michael E. Erdos ruled that Suda’s lawsuit must go to confidential arbitration rather than a public jury trial. The ruling relied on a clause in Suda’s employment contract requiring work disputes to be settled privately.¹

The practical effect for anyone following the case: filings, testimony, and any eventual award will not be public. Nikas said Suda’s team was “not surprised that the museum wants to hide its illegal conduct in a confidential arbitration” and would “hold the museum accountable wherever the case is heard.”¹ Because arbitration is private, the specifics of how the raises dispute and the severance claim are ultimately resolved may never appear on a public docket.

Who Is Running the Museum Now

After Suda’s firing, Louis Marchesano, the deputy director of curatorial affairs and conservation, was appointed to manage day-to-day operations.⁶ On November 21, 2025, the museum announced that Daniel H. Weiss, the former president and CEO of the Metropolitan Museum of Art, would take over as director and CEO effective December 1, 2025, with a commitment to stay through at least 2028. Board chair Caplan cited his “proven track record of museum leadership” and “ability to navigate complex institutional challenges.”¹⁴

1
ARTnews. Judge Rules Philadelphia Museum Director Suit Must Go to Arbitration
2
Philadelphia Museum of Art. Philadelphia Museum of Art Names Sasha Suda as New Director and CEO
3
Philadelphia Magazine. Philadelphia Art Museum Sasha Suda
4
The Art Newspaper. Philadelphia Art Museum Director Sasha Suda Ousted After Rebrand
5
The Philadelphia Citizen. Board Leadership Sasha Suda
6
The New York Times. Philadelphia Art Museum Director Dismissed
7
6abc. Former Philadelphia Art Museum CEO Accused of Misappropriating Funds
8
The Philadelphia Inquirer. Sasha Suda Lawsuit PMA
9
Artnet News. Sasha Suda Philadelphia Art Museum
10
The Art Newspaper. Sasha Suda Sues Philadelphia Art Museum Over Firing
11
Billy Penn. Philadelphia Art Museum Sasha Suda Complaint Lawsuit
12
National Review. A Catfight in a Snake Pit in Philly’s Art Museum
13
The Art Newspaper. Philadelphia Art Museum Filing Sasha Suda Lawsuit Theft
14
The New York Times. Former Met Museum Chief Named Philadelphia Museum Director