Scott Nelson Verdict: Life Sentence and 11–1 Juror Split

A Florida jury delivered the Scott Nelson verdict in late June 2019, convicting him of first-degree murder, kidnapping, carjacking, robbery, and tampering with a witness in the September 2017 killing of 56-year-old Winter Park caregiver Jennifer Lynn Fulford.¹ Two weeks later, after a penalty phase in which Nelson himself demanded execution, the jury voted 11–1 in favor of death. Because Florida requires a unanimous recommendation, the single dissenting vote sent him to prison for life without parole instead.²

What Nelson Was Convicted Of

The charges tracked what Nelson did after forcing his way into a Winter Park home on East Webster Avenue on September 27, 2017. Fulford, who worked as a nanny and personal assistant for the Berman family, opened the front door to collect a UPS package. Nelson, armed with a knife, pushed inside, restrained her with zip ties, wrapped her in a comforter, and put her in the trunk of her own 2015 Hyundai SUV.³⁴ He drove her to a Wells Fargo ATM, withdrew $300 from her account, then drove around for roughly an hour before stopping at a vacant lot on Fenton Street in southwest Orange County. There he covered her face in duct tape so tightly she could not breathe and stabbed her seven times, including a wound that pierced her heart. The Orange-Osceola medical examiner ruled the cause of death as stab wounds and asphyxia.⁵

Nelson took the stand at trial and admitted killing Fulford, describing stabbing her “several times in the back, multiple times in the front” and acknowledging that he stabbed her in the heart.¹ He blamed his federal probation officer, Julio Dominguez, for the killing, testifying that Dominguez had gotten him fired and thrown out on the street. Asked directly whether Dominguez had killed Fulford, Nelson answered, “No.”⁶

Why the Sentence Was Life, Not Death

Florida is a unanimity state for capital sentencing. Under a 2016 Florida Supreme Court ruling in effect at the time of Nelson’s trial, a jury’s recommendation of death had to be unanimous; anything less required the judge to impose life without parole. The Nelson jury deliberated roughly 17 hours over two days and returned its recommendation on July 11, 2019. Eleven jurors voted for death. One did not. That was the ballgame.⁷⁸

The panel found that aggravating factors outweighed mitigating ones. Prosecutors, led by Assistant State Attorney Kenneth Nunnelley, argued two statutory aggravators in particular: that Nelson had held Fulford captive while she begged for her life during an hour-long drive, and that he had killed her for money.⁸⁹ It wasn’t enough for twelve votes.

Nelson’s Own Push for Execution

The penalty phase produced something rare: a defendant openly campaigning for his own death sentence. Nelson told the jury he was “a homicidal maniac” and that he wanted to be executed. When Nunnelley asked directly whether he wanted to die, Nelson answered “yes” without hesitation. The defense objected, the judge sustained the objection, and jurors were instructed to disregard the exchange.¹⁰

Prosecutors framed the courtroom performance as calculated. They described Nelson as a narcissist who had killed Fulford as part of a deliberate plan to get caught and “rail against the world.”⁸ At least one juror later agreed with that read. “He said those things to be shocking,” the juror told the Miami Herald. “He said those things, I feel, to call our bluff.”¹⁰

The Mitigation Case

Orange-Osceola Public Defender Robert Wesley’s team put on evidence aimed at Nelson’s background. His brother testified about the abusive childhood the two shared.⁴ The defense argued that chronic trauma, mental illness, substance abuse, and roughly a quarter-century of prior incarceration had left Nelson with severe cognitive deficits, pointing to testing that showed an IQ of 82 and significant short-term memory loss.⁸ Nelson himself testified to what he described as 25 years of brutality in federal prisons, including beatings, sexual assault, extreme heat, and dehumanizing conditions.¹⁰

The Sentence Judge White Imposed

Bound by the jury’s non-unanimous recommendation, Circuit Judge Keith F. White sentenced Nelson to life in prison without the possibility of parole on the first-degree murder count. He added three concurrent life sentences for the kidnapping, carjacking, robbery, and witness-tampering convictions.⁸ Nelson showed no visible emotion when the verdict was read. Asked if he had anything to say, his only question was whether he could speak with his attorneys about an appeal.¹¹

Juror Backlash Over the 11–1 Split

The one-vote outcome did not sit well with the majority of the panel. In anonymous interviews with WESH 2 News, three jurors said the lone holdout had been “never going to vote for death from day one” and had “hijacked the group’s decision.” They said the dissenting juror offered no evidence to support a life vote and simply maintained that nothing justified death, regardless of what the other eleven argued.⁷

Under the unanimity rule then in force, that was enough. One vote decided the Scott Nelson verdict at the sentencing stage, and the man who told the jury he wanted to die was sent instead to serve the rest of his life in a Florida prison.

1
ClickOrlando. Scott Nelson Found Guilty of Killing Winter Park Caregiver
2
Orlando Sentinel. Scott Nelson Should Get Life in Prison, Not Death Penalty, for Killing of Jennifer Fulford, Jury Decides
3
Orlando Sentinel. Scott Nelson Verdict: Guilty of 1st-Degree Murder in Kidnap-Killing of Jennifer Fulford
4
Orlando Sentinel. Scott Nelson’s Brother Testifies About Childhood Abuse
5
Orlando Sentinel. Prosecutors Describe Kidnapping, Brutal Slaying of Jennifer Fulford in Scott Nelson Trial
6
WESH. Scott Nelson Trial Closings
7
WESH. Jurors on Nelson’s Case Say 11 of 12 Wanted Death Penalty Recommendation Instead of Life Imprisonment
8
Orlando Sentinel. Scott Nelson Should Get Life in Prison
9
Law and Crime. Juror Kicked Off of Scott Nelson Case
10
Miami Herald. Scott Nelson Sentenced to Life in Prison for Jennifer Fulford Murder
11
ClickOrlando. Jury Recommends Life in Prison for Convicted Murderer Scott Nelson