Should Capital Punishment Be Abolished? Arguments, Law, and Trends

Whether capital punishment should be abolished depends on how you weigh several concrete problems against the reasons people support it. The strongest arguments for ending the death penalty are the risk of executing innocent people, the racial and economic disparities in who gets sentenced, the lack of evidence that it deters crime, and the extraordinary cost of capital cases. The strongest arguments for keeping it rest on retributive justice, closure for victims’ families, and permanent incapacitation of the most dangerous offenders. The answer to that question is being worked out slowly, state by state, through legislatures, courts, and governors’ offices.

The Case for Abolition

Innocent People Are Sentenced to Death

Since 1973, at least 200 people sentenced to death in the United States have been fully exonerated after evidence showed they did not commit the crime. Many of those exonerations came through DNA testing that was not available at trial. Others followed recanted witness testimony, prosecutorial misconduct uncovered years later, or forensic methods that have since been discredited.

The timeline for catching these mistakes is long and getting longer. More than half of all death row exonerations took over a decade, and those since 2013 have increasingly taken 25 years or more. More than half the people currently on death row have been there for over 18 years. A wrongful conviction can consume most of a person’s adult life before anyone corrects it, and only for the people fortunate enough to have the error discovered at all. How many innocent people have already been executed is a question nobody can answer precisely, because exonerations depend on surviving evidence, available witnesses, and the resources to investigate. Once an execution is carried out, the institutional motivation to reexamine the case drops sharply.

Because execution is irreversible, this is the argument that carries the most weight for many abolitionists. A wrongful imprisonment can be ended; a wrongful execution cannot.

Race and Money Shape Who Gets Executed

The Fourteenth Amendment guarantees equal protection under the law.1Congress.gov. Fourteenth Amendment – Equal Protection and Other Rights The data on capital sentencing shows a different pattern in practice. A U.S. Department of Justice review of decades of research found that in 82 percent of studies examined, the race of the victim correlated with whether a defendant was charged with a capital crime or received a death sentence. Defendants who killed white victims were significantly more likely to face execution than those whose victims were Black.2Office of Justice Programs. Death Penalty Sentencing – Research Indicates Pattern of Racial Disparities More than 75 percent of executed defendants were sentenced for killing white victims, even though roughly half of all homicide victims nationally are Black.

Money shapes outcomes almost as much as race. A capital defense requires expert witnesses, private investigators, mitigation specialists, and attorneys willing to spend thousands of hours on a single case. Total costs for a capital trial regularly run between $1 million and $3 million more than a non-capital murder case. Defendants who cannot afford private counsel rely on public defenders or court-appointed attorneys whose offices are often stretched thin. When the defense can’t match the prosecution’s resources, the sentencing phase becomes lopsided, and execution risk ends up tracking closely with poverty.

Deterrence Is Unproven

The most frequently cited practical justification for the death penalty is that it deters potential killers. The best available evidence does not support that claim. In 2012, the National Research Council completed a comprehensive review of more than three decades of deterrence studies and concluded that existing research “is not informative about whether capital punishment decreases, increases, or has no effect on homicide rates.” The panel recommended that none of the studies be used to guide policy.

The committee identified three core problems with research that claimed a deterrent effect. The studies failed to account for non-capital punishments like long prison sentences that might produce the same result. They relied on implausible assumptions about how potential murderers perceive their risk of being caught and executed. And the statistical models rested on assumptions the panel called “not credible.” As the panel’s chair put it, “nothing is known about how potential murderers actually perceive their risk of punishment.” States without the death penalty have not experienced higher murder rates than their neighbors that retain it.

Cost

Capital cases cost more than non-capital murder prosecutions by $1 million to $3 million per case, driven by the two-phase trial, the appeals that follow, and the expert and investigative work the defense must mount to be effective. That spending yields a sentence that, in most years, is never carried out: only 25 people were executed nationwide in 2024, out of roughly 2,100 on death row. The expense is a problem on its own terms and compounds the inequality problem, because the cost falls hardest on indigent defense systems that are already underfunded.

The Case for Keeping Capital Punishment

Supporters of capital punishment ground their argument primarily in retributive justice: the principle that certain crimes are so severe that only the most extreme punishment restores moral balance. Under this view, sentencing a person who deliberately took another’s life to anything less than death devalues the victim. Most legal systems recognize proportionality as a core principle of punishment, and proponents argue that abolishing execution removes the upper boundary of that scale.

There is also the question of finality for victims’ families. Retention advocates argue that an execution, once carried out, provides a form of closure that decades of imprisonment and parole hearings cannot. Many families of murder victims have publicly opposed the death penalty, but that doesn’t negate the fact that other families find meaning in the sentence. The system’s legitimacy in their eyes depends partly on the availability of the ultimate sanction for the worst offenses.

Incapacitation is a quieter but real consideration. A person who has been executed cannot kill again, inside prison or after an unlikely escape or release. Life without parole achieves most of the same result but not identically, because violence within prisons is a real phenomenon and parole systems in some jurisdictions have historically released people who were supposed to die behind bars.

The Constitutional Status of the Death Penalty

Every constitutional challenge to capital punishment runs through the Eighth Amendment’s prohibition on cruel and unusual punishment. Courts apply the “evolving standards of decency” test, looking at legislative trends, jury behavior, and shifts in public values to decide whether a punishment has become constitutionally intolerable.3Legal Information Institute. Death Penalty

In Furman v. Georgia (1972), the Supreme Court struck down every existing death penalty statute as arbitrary and inconsistent, halting executions nationwide.4Justia U.S. Supreme Court Center. Furman v Georgia, 408 US 238 (1972) Four years later, Gregg v. Georgia (1976) upheld a new generation of statutes, ruling that capital punishment is not inherently unconstitutional as long as the sentencing process includes meaningful safeguards.5Justia U.S. Supreme Court Center. Gregg v Georgia, 428 US 153 (1976) That framework is still in place. Abolition through the federal courts would require the Supreme Court to reverse decades of precedent.

Since Gregg, the Court has carved out categorical exclusions. The death penalty cannot be imposed on anyone who was under 18 at the time of the offense (Roper v. Simmons, 2005),6Justia U.S. Supreme Court Center. Roper v Simmons, 543 US 551 (2005) on people with intellectual disabilities (Atkins v. Virginia, 2002), or for crimes against individuals that did not result in death (Kennedy v. Louisiana, 2008).7Justia U.S. Supreme Court Center. Kennedy v Louisiana, 554 US 407 (2008) A prisoner who becomes so mentally ill after sentencing that they cannot understand the execution cannot be put to death. The eligible population for capital punishment is therefore considerably smaller than most people assume.

Where Things Stand in 2026

Twenty-three states have eliminated the death penalty through legislation or court rulings, with Virginia becoming the most recent Southern state to do so in 2021. The remaining 27 states authorize capital punishment on the books, though several have governor-imposed moratoria or haven’t carried out an execution in years. A state can technically “have” the death penalty while going a decade without using it.

At the federal level, the Biden administration imposed a moratorium on federal executions starting in 2021. In January 2025, President Trump signed an executive order titled “Restoring the Death Penalty and Protecting Public Safety,” directing the Department of Justice to pursue capital sentences and resume federal executions.8The White House. Restoring the Death Penalty and Protecting Public Safety Federal law authorizes a death sentence when a defendant intentionally killed someone, caused serious bodily injury resulting in death, or engaged in violence creating a grave risk of death, among other criteria.9Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 18 USC Chapter 228 – Death Sentence

Globally, roughly 150 countries have either eliminated capital punishment outright or maintain formal moratoria, leaving about 55 nations that still use it. The United States is the only Western democracy that continues to execute people.

How Abolition Actually Happens

Abolition can happen through three channels, each with different mechanics and durability.

Legislative repeal is the most common. Lawmakers remove the death penalty from the criminal code and replace it with life without parole. Seven states took this route between 2009 and 2021: New Mexico, Illinois, Connecticut, Maryland, New Hampshire, Colorado, and Virginia. Nebraska’s legislature voted to abolish in 2015, only to have voters reinstate the penalty through a statewide referendum the following year. Legislative repeal is reversible where the state allows ballot initiatives on criminal law.

Judicial abolition occurs when a state supreme court rules that capital punishment violates the state constitution’s protections against cruel punishment. Washington State’s supreme court took this path in 2018. Judicial rulings typically result in resentencing everyone on death row and take effect immediately. They are harder to reverse than legislation.

Executive moratoria are the most temporary option. A governor can halt all executions during their time in office, leaving the death penalty on the books but preventing it from being carried out. California’s governor did this in 2019 for the largest death row in the Western Hemisphere. The federal moratorium from 2021 to 2025 is a direct example of how quickly these can be reversed: any successor can lift the order.8The White House. Restoring the Death Penalty and Protecting Public Safety

Where the Trend Points

Annual executions have stayed below 30 for ten consecutive years. New death sentences have fallen to historic lows. The death row population dropped to roughly 2,100 at the start of 2025, the largest single-year decline in two decades. More states have abolished the penalty than at any previous point in American history, and no state that has abolished it has reinstated it through its legislature.

At the same time, the federal government has moved in the opposite direction, and several states continue to carry out executions regularly. The question of whether capital punishment should be abolished is being answered slowly, in state capitals and courthouses, not resolved all at once. Which arguments weigh heaviest depends on the reader, but the shape of the debate is now settled: wrongful convictions, disparities, deterrence evidence, and cost on one side; retribution, closure, and incapacitation on the other.