Stormy Daniels–Trump Scandal: Charges, Trial, and Appeal

The Stormy Daniels–Trump scandal is the hush money affair that produced the first criminal conviction of a U.S. president: a $130,000 payment made days before the 2016 election to keep Daniels quiet about an alleged 2006 sexual encounter, disguised in Trump Organization records as legal fees, and prosecuted in Manhattan a decade later as 34 felony counts of falsifying business records. A jury convicted Donald Trump on all 34 counts on May 30, 2024. On January 10, 2025, ten days before his second inauguration, Justice Juan Merchan sentenced him to an unconditional discharge — no prison, no fine, no probation — with the conviction itself left intact. Trump is appealing.

The 2006 Encounter and the 2016 Payment

Daniels, whose legal name is Stephanie Gregory Clifford, met Trump at a celebrity golf tournament in Lake Tahoe in July 2006 and later described a sexual encounter with him that evening.¹ She was 27 and working in the adult entertainment industry. Trump has denied the affair.

The story stayed largely private until the closing weeks of the 2016 campaign. Trump’s longtime personal attorney, Michael Cohen, set up a Delaware shell company called Essential Consultants LLC, opened a bank account for it, and on October 27, 2016, wired $130,000 to an attorney-client trust account controlled by Daniels’ then-lawyer, Keith Davidson.² The next day Daniels signed a nondisclosure agreement using the pseudonym “Peggy Peterson,” with Trump referred to as “David Dennison.”³

Cohen funded the payment himself, drawing $131,000 from a home equity line of credit that federal prosecutors later established he had obtained under false pretenses.⁴ Davidson testified that he never believed Cohen was the true source, and assumed the money came from Trump or a Trump-affiliated entity.²

The Catch-and-Kill Arrangement

The Daniels payment was the third in a series. In August 2015, Trump, Cohen, and David Pecker, then chairman of American Media Inc. (AMI) and publisher of the National Enquirer, met at Trump Tower and agreed Pecker would help the campaign by finding and buying negative stories about Trump before anyone else could publish them, a tabloid practice called catch-and-kill.⁵

Two purchases followed. In late 2015, AMI paid $30,000 to a Trump Tower doorman for the rights to a rumor about Trump allegedly fathering a child out of wedlock; Pecker testified that AMI paid to “lock it up” even though the story was never substantiated.⁵ In August 2016, AMI paid $150,000 to former Playboy model Karen McDougal for her account of an alleged affair, with no intention of publishing.⁶

When Daniels shopped her story weeks later, Pecker refused to fund another purchase. He testified that he told Cohen, “I am not a bank,” and worried a payment tied to a “porn star” would damage AMI’s relationships with major retailers.⁶ Cohen made the payment himself, and that decision set the criminal case in motion.

How the Reimbursement Was Disguised

After Trump won the election, Cohen sought his money back. He testified that he met with Trump and Trump Organization chief financial officer Allen Weisselberg between the election and the inauguration to arrange repayment, and Weisselberg told him he would receive twelve monthly installments of $35,000.⁷ The total came to $420,000, more than triple the original $130,000, because it was grossed up to cover Cohen’s taxes and included a $60,000 bonus.³

The reimbursements produced the paperwork at the heart of the prosecution. The 34 felony counts tracked 34 specific documents: 11 invoices Cohen submitted to the Trump Organization referencing a purported “retainer agreement,” 12 ledger entries in the general ledger for Trump’s trust recording the payments as legal expenses, and 11 checks, many signed by Trump personally in black Sharpie and, after he took office, sent by FedEx to and from the White House.⁸ Former Trump Organization financial controller Jeffrey McConney testified he had never seen the retainer agreement the invoices referenced, because, prosecutors argued, it did not exist.⁹

The Charges and the Legal Theory

Manhattan District Attorney Alvin Bragg obtained a grand jury indictment on March 30, 2023, the first criminal indictment of a former or sitting U.S. president. Trump was arraigned on April 4, 2023, and pleaded not guilty to 34 counts of falsifying business records in the first degree, a class E felony under New York Penal Law § 175.10.¹⁰

Falsifying business records is normally a misdemeanor in New York. It becomes a felony when the records are falsified with intent to commit or conceal another crime. Prosecutors identified three possible underlying offenses: federal campaign finance violations, a New York election law provision that bars conspiracies to promote a candidate through unlawful means, and tax law violations. Justice Merchan ruled the prosecution did not have to prove any underlying crime was completed, only that Trump acted with the “conscious aim and objective” to commit one.¹¹

The Trial

The trial began on April 15, 2024, and the prosecution called 22 witnesses. Pecker led off, walking jurors through the catch-and-kill scheme and testifying that Trump personally thanked him after the election for “handling” the McDougal and doorman stories.⁶ Cohen, the prosecution’s central witness, testified that Trump directed him to make the payment, approved the reimbursement structure, and knew the payments would be booked as legal expenses.¹²

Daniels took the stand in early May 2024 and gave detailed testimony about the alleged 2006 encounter. Defense attorney Susan Necheles accused her of fabricating the account. Trump’s team moved for a mistrial twice during her testimony, arguing the explicit details were irrelevant to a records case and carried an implication of nonconsensual sex that was “extraordinarily prejudicial.” Merchan denied both motions but acknowledged some testimony was material the jury “should not have heard,” noting the defense had not objected more during her account.¹³

Weisselberg, who had helped structure the $420,000 repayment, never testified. Neither side called him. Prosecutors indicated he had not been truthful with them.¹⁴ Prosecutors urged jurors to rely on the documentary trail rather than on Cohen alone, and called Trump Organization employees to explain how the Cohen payments were handled outside normal channels and coded as legal expenses despite never passing through the legal department.⁹

Verdict and Sentence

The jury convicted Trump on all 34 counts on May 30, 2024.¹⁵ After Trump won the 2024 election, sentencing became entangled with constitutional questions about punishing a sitting president. On January 10, 2025, Justice Merchan imposed an unconditional discharge, the lightest sentence New York law allows. Under New York Penal Law § 65.20, an unconditional discharge releases a defendant without imprisonment, fines, probation, or any other conditions, but the conviction stands as a “final judgment of conviction for all purposes.”¹⁶ Merchan called it “the only lawful sentence” that could be imposed “without encroaching upon the highest office of the land.”¹⁷

Trump attended the hearing virtually from Florida. His attorney Todd Blanche called the case a “hoax” and said Trump would appeal. The U.S. Supreme Court had declined, 5-4 the night before, to block the sentencing.¹⁸

Where the Appeal Stands

Trump is pursuing two tracks. In state court, he formally filed his appeal with the Appellate Division’s First Department on October 27, 2025, arguing the conviction was “fatally marred” by faulty evidence and judicial bias. His brief contends the trial court improperly admitted evidence of “official Presidential acts,” including testimony from former White House aide Hope Hicks and Trump’s social media posts, in violation of the Supreme Court’s July 2024 ruling on presidential immunity.¹⁹

Justice Merchan had rejected that argument in December 2024, ruling the evidence related “entirely to unofficial conduct” and posed “no danger of intrusion on the authority and function of the Executive Branch.”²⁰ Even if some evidence touched on official conduct, Merchan wrote, any error was “harmless in light of the overwhelming evidence of guilt.”²¹

The second track is an effort to move the case to federal court, where Trump’s team believes the immunity framework is more favorable. U.S. District Judge Alvin Hellerstein had previously denied the transfer, calling the hush money payments “private unofficial acts.” In November 2025, a three-judge panel of the Second Circuit ordered Hellerstein to reconsider, instructing him to evaluate whether trial evidence related to “immunized official acts” and whether that evidence “transformed the State’s case into one that relates to acts under color of the Presidency.”²²

Hellerstein held oral arguments on February 4, 2026, and sounded skeptical. He noted Trump’s team had waited 58 days after the Supreme Court’s immunity decision to file for removal, past the 30-day statutory window, and suggested the delay was “fatal.” He also observed the defense had already raised its immunity arguments before Justice Merchan and was seeking “two bites at the apple.”²³ Manhattan prosecutors continued to maintain the conduct at issue was “wholly unofficial and private.” Hellerstein had not issued a ruling as of early 2026, saying he would do so “shortly.”²⁴

Related Legal Fallout

Cohen faced federal charges of his own. In August 2018 he pleaded guilty to eight counts, including tax evasion, bank fraud, and two campaign finance violations tied to the payments to Daniels and McDougal, telling the court he had arranged the payments “at the direction of” a presidential candidate for the purpose of influencing the election.⁴ He was sentenced to three years in prison in December 2018.²⁵

AMI entered a non-prosecution agreement with federal prosecutors in September 2018, admitting the $150,000 McDougal payment was made “in concert” with the Trump campaign to suppress her story before the election.²⁶ Pecker received individual immunity in exchange for his testimony.²⁷

Daniels went public in a 60 Minutes interview with Anderson Cooper on March 25, 2018, describing the alleged encounter as consensual and saying she had signed the NDA because she feared for her family’s safety. She also said that in 2011, after she had agreed to share her story with a magazine, an unidentified man approached her in a Las Vegas parking lot and told her to “leave Trump alone,” with a veiled threat about her infant daughter.²⁸

Daniels sued Trump for defamation in 2018 after he called the parking-lot account a “total con job” on social media. A federal judge dismissed the suit, ruling the statement was rhetorical hyperbole protected by the First Amendment.²⁹ She was ordered to pay Trump’s legal fees, and Trump attorney Harmeet Dhillon put the total attorney fee awards at more than $600,000.³⁰

Daniels’ original attorney in the dispute, Michael Avenatti, was convicted of wire fraud and aggravated identity theft for stealing roughly $300,000 of her book advance from her memoir Full Disclosure, and was sentenced to four years in federal prison in June 2022, partly consecutive to a separate sentence for extorting Nike.³¹

1
The New York Times. Stormy Daniels Donald Trump Timeline
2
Politico. Essential Consultants LLC
3
PBS NewsHour. A Timeline of Key Events in the Trump Hush Money Trial
4
U.S. Department of Justice. Michael Cohen Pleads Guilty in Manhattan Federal Court to Eight Counts
5
ABC News. David Pecker Testified Trump Stories National Enquirer Gold
6
CBS News. Trump Trial Testimony David Pecker
7
BBC News. Trump Trial Hush Money
8
The New York Times. Trump Trial Hush Money
9
Politico. Trump Hush Money Trial Paper Trail Checks
10
Manhattan District Attorney. District Attorney Bragg Announces 34-Count Felony Indictment of Former President Donald J. Trump
11
Lawfare. Charting the Legal Theory Behind People v. Trump
12
Axios. Michael Cohen New York Criminal Trial
13
The Washington Post. Trump Trial Takeaways Hush Money Stormy Daniels
14
CNN. Allen Weisselberg Trump Org CFO Plea Perjury
15
Manhattan District Attorney. D.A. Bragg Announces 34-Count Felony Trial Conviction of Donald J. Trump
16
Politico. Trump Unconditional Discharge Sentencing What That Means
17
BBC News. Trump Hush Money Sentencing
18
NBC News. Trump Sentencing Judge Juan Merchan Live Updates
19
Good Morning America. Trump Formally Appeals New York Hush Money Conviction
20
ABC7 New York. Judge Rules President-Elect Trump Does Not Have Immunity in Hush Money Case
21
The Indiana Lawyer. Judge Rejects Trumps Bid to Toss Hush Money Conviction Because of Supreme Court Immunity Ruling
22
ABC News. Appeals Court Revives Trumps Effort Remove Hush Money
23
CNN. Judge Skeptical Trump Trying to Move Hush Money Appeal to Federal Court
24
Courthouse News. New York Judge Excoriates Trumps Timing in Bid to Scrap Hush Money Conviction
25
U.S. Department of Justice. Michael Cohen Sentenced to 3 Years in Prison
26
The Guardian. National Enquirer Trump Payments David Pecker Catch and Kill
27
CNN. National Enquirer Catch and Kill Trump Trial
28
CBS News. Stormy Daniels Describes Her Alleged Affair With Donald Trump
29
BBC News. Stormy Daniels Defamation Lawsuit
30
NPR. Trump Stormy Daniels Defamation Lawsuit
31
U.S. Department of Justice. Michael Avenatti Sentenced to 48 Months in Prison for Identity Theft and Defrauding Former Client