Tarika Wilson: The SWAT Raid, Lima Outrage, and $2.5M Settlement

Tarika Wilson was a 26-year-old Black mother of six who was shot and killed by a Lima, Ohio, police sergeant during a SWAT raid on her home on January 4, 2008. She was unarmed, kneeling, and holding her 14-month-old son Sincere when Sergeant Joseph Chavalia fired three shots blindly into the bedroom where she and her children had gathered. Sincere was struck in the shoulder and hand and lost a finger. Wilson was not the target of the raid; officers were there to arrest her boyfriend on a drug warrant. Chavalia was charged with two misdemeanors and acquitted by an all-white jury seven months later. Wilson’s family eventually reached a $2.5 million settlement with the city.¹

The Night of the Raid

On the evening of January 4, 2008, a Lima Police Department SWAT team executed a drug warrant at the home of Anthony Terry, Wilson’s boyfriend.² Officers kicked in the door and moved through the house with guns drawn. On the lower level, they shot two pit bulls belonging to Terry.

Chavalia, a 32-year veteran of the department, was upstairs. He later testified that he heard the shots from below and believed he was being fired on. He also said he saw a shadow behind a partially open bedroom door.³ Without seeing whether anyone inside was armed, and without seeing that Wilson was holding a baby, he fired three shots into the bedroom.⁴

Wilson was kneeling and complying with police orders when she was killed.⁵ Sincere was rushed to a Columbus hospital and spent weeks recovering.⁶ No weapon was found on Wilson or anywhere near her.

The Officer’s Trial and Acquittal

Chavalia was charged with negligent homicide for Wilson’s death and negligent assault for the injuries to Sincere. Both are misdemeanors. If convicted on both counts, he faced a maximum of eight months in jail.³ The trial was held in Allen County Common Pleas Court before visiting Judge Richard Knepper.⁷

Prosecutor Jeffrey Strausbaugh argued that Chavalia acted recklessly by firing into a bedroom full of children without knowing whether anyone inside posed a threat. Defense attorney Bill Kluge told jurors not to engage in “Monday morning quarterbacking” by weighing facts, including that Wilson was unarmed, that became known only after the shooting.⁴

Judge Knepper instructed the jury to evaluate the shooting based only on what Chavalia knew at the moment he pulled the trigger, citing a 1985 U.S. Supreme Court standard. Under that instruction, Wilson’s unarmed status was outside what jurors could consider.⁷ Two expert witnesses, a Columbus SWAT officer and a retired FBI agent, testified that Chavalia’s response was appropriate given his belief that he was under fire.

On August 4, 2008, an all-white jury acquitted him of both charges, finding that his actions did not amount to a “substantial lapse of due care.”⁸ Lima Police Chief Greg Garlock said the verdict “confirmed what our sense was and our belief was in this.”⁹ Chavalia returned to work at the department but was no longer permitted to patrol.¹

Anger in Lima

About 50 people gathered outside the Wilson home the night of the raid. The next day, roughly 300 people marched two miles to City Hall, and smaller weekly marches continued for weeks.¹⁰ The local NAACP chapter’s president, Jason Upthegrove, announced plans to request a U.S. Department of Justice investigation into the police department and the county prosecutor’s office. “We’re not asking for answers anymore. We’re demanding them,” he said.

The Reverend Jesse Jackson traveled to Lima a month after the shooting to meet with residents and publicly urge Chavalia’s prosecution.¹¹ Black residents described a pattern of stops without cause, physical abuse, and officers drawing guns on them. Pastor C.M. Manley of New Morning Star Missionary Baptist Church told a reporter, “There is an evil in this town.” Mayor David J. Berger said “serious threats have been made” and that some residents had begun carrying weapons for self-protection.¹⁰

The demographic backdrop sharpened the reaction. African Americans made up roughly 25 to 27 percent of Lima’s population, but only two of the department’s 77 officers were Black.² Chief Garlock defended the department, saying internal investigations had found no evidence of wrongdoing, and acknowledged the difficulty of diversifying the force.

The $2.5 Million Settlement

Wilson’s family filed a wrongful death lawsuit against the city of Lima. In late 2009, the two sides reached a $2.5 million settlement funded by the city’s insurance company. The city stated that the settlement was “not an admission of liability.”¹ An Allen County Probate Court judge approved it on February 10, 2011.

After attorneys’ fees, Wilson’s family and survivors received approximately $1.36 million. A separate amount of more than $253,000 was approved for Sincere to address the injuries he sustained during the raid.¹² The funds were designated for Wilson’s six children, who were raised by her mother and sisters in the years after her death.¹¹

Why the Case Is Remembered

Wilson’s killing is now recalled alongside a series of fatal police encounters with unarmed Black Americans that drew growing national attention over the following decade. The Equal Justice Initiative has documented her case as part of that history, placing it in the context of later killings including those of Ramarley Graham, Jonathan Ferrell, Eric Garner, and Michael Brown.² Her shooting and Chavalia’s acquittal have been cited as events that helped build momentum behind the Black Lives Matter movement in the years that followed.¹¹

Stanford University later included Wilson in its “Say Their Names” exhibit at Green Library, a collection memorializing victims of systemic racism.¹³

1
Police1. Family of Ohio Woman Slain by Police During Drug Raid to Get $2.5 Mil
2
Equal Justice Initiative. History of Racial Injustice: Police Shootings
3
NBC News. Ohio Officer Acquitted in Raid That Killed Mom
4
Cleveland 19. Ohio Officer Acquitted in Deadly Shooting
5
Reason. Death by SWAT
6
Cleveland.com. Lima Shooting Leaves the Town in Turmoil
7
Cleveland.com. Officers Cheer Police Shooting Acquittal
8
ACLU. Officer Acquitted for Fatal Shooting of Unarmed Woman and Baby
9
6ABC. Ohio Officer Acquitted in Deadly Shooting
10
Sarasota Herald-Tribune. Police Shooting of Mother, Infant Exposes Racial Tensions
11
BlackPast. Tarika Wilson (1981-2008)
12
Cleveland.com. $2.5M Settlement in Shooting of Tarika Wilson
13
Stanford University. Say Their Names – Tarika Wilson