The Big Lie: Lawsuits, Criminal Cases, and Pardons

The Big Lie is the false claim, pushed by Donald Trump and his allies, that the 2020 presidential election was stolen from him. Joe Biden won by more than 7 million popular votes and 302 to 236 in the Electoral College, a result confirmed by state officials of both parties, by Trump’s own administration, and by every court that reviewed a fraud challenge on the merits. The claim nonetheless drove the January 6, 2021, attack on the Capitol, produced more than 60 failed lawsuits, led to criminal indictments that have since been dismissed or pardoned away, cost several prominent lawyers their licenses, generated hundreds of millions of dollars in defamation payments, and reshaped voting laws and election offices across the country.

The phrase itself is borrowed from a propaganda concept Adolf Hitler described in Mein Kampf, which held that a sufficiently enormous lie is harder for ordinary people to dismiss than a small one.1Hoover Institution. The Big Lie Exposed: A Rhetorical Analysis of Nazi German in 22 Lessons American critics began applying it in early 2021 to Trump’s refusal to accept Biden’s victory.

What Trump and His Allies Actually Claimed

Trump began attacking mail-in voting months before the election. In April 2020 he called mail-in ballots “fraudulent in many cases.” In July he told interviewers that “mail-in voting is going to rig the election” and refused to commit to accepting the outcome.2NPR. Timeline: What Trump Told Supporters for Months Before They Attacked At 2:30 a.m. on November 4, with counting still underway, he declared from the White House, “We did win this election,” and demanded the counting stop. Three days later he tweeted, “I WON THIS ELECTION, BY A LOT!”3U.S. Congress. House Judiciary Committee Document on Election Denial Claims

In the weeks that followed, Rudy Giuliani told reporters, “I know crimes. I can smell them,” and Sidney Powell pushed a conspiracy theory tying ballot fraud to the deceased Venezuelan leader Hugo Chávez.2NPR. Timeline: What Trump Told Supporters for Months Before They Attacked Trump’s own senior election-security officials, by contrast, had called the 2020 vote “the most secure in American history.”4Brennan Center for Justice. January 6 Hearings and the Big Lie’s Ongoing Damage to Democracy

The Lawsuits That Failed

Trump and his allies filed more than 60 lawsuits attacking the results in multiple states. Judges appointed by presidents of both parties rejected them, often in blunt terms. In Arizona, a court found the ballot-duplication process was 99.45 percent accurate and that errors reflected ordinary human mistakes rather than fraud. In Michigan, a judge found no evidence of ballot alteration. In Nevada, plaintiffs failed to prove voting-device malfunctions, illegal votes, or official misconduct. In Pennsylvania, a federal court rejected Equal Protection claims arising from different notice-and-cure policies across counties, and the Third Circuit affirmed.5Campaign Legal Center. Results of Lawsuits Regarding 2020 Elections One Arizona court ordered the plaintiffs to pay the other side’s legal fees, calling the suit “groundless” and filed for the “improper purpose” of undermining confidence in the results.

A Georgia federal court denied Trump’s request to decertify that state’s results, and a Texas lawsuit asking the Vice President to unilaterally reject Electoral College votes was thrown out for lack of standing.6Federal Judicial Center. Voting Irregularities No court found fraud sufficient to change the outcome in any state.

January 6 and the Criminal Cases Against Trump

The claims culminated on January 6, 2021, when a mob of Trump supporters stormed the Capitol during the congressional certification of Biden’s victory. At the rally beforehand, Giuliani called for “trial by combat.” Trump told the crowd, “You’ll never take back our country with weakness.” That evening he tweeted that the violence followed from having “a sacred landslide election victory” stolen.2NPR. Timeline: What Trump Told Supporters for Months Before They Attacked

The House Select Committee to Investigate the January 6th Attack spent 18 months on the inquiry, held 10 public hearings, took testimony from more than 1,000 witnesses, and released an 800-page report in December 2022. It concluded that the attack was “foreseeable” and that a president serving as its “catalyst” was “unprecedented,” and it formally referred Trump to the Justice Department for criminal prosecution.7NPR. Jan. 6 Committee Report8PBS NewsHour. Read the Jan. 6 Committee’s Summary of Its Final Report

The Federal Case

On August 1, 2023, a federal grand jury in Washington indicted Trump on four felony counts: conspiracy to defraud the United States, conspiracy to obstruct an official proceeding, obstruction of an official proceeding, and conspiracy against rights. The indictment alleged that Trump spread knowingly false fraud claims, organized fraudulent slates of electors in seven states, pressured the Justice Department to launch sham investigations, and tried to enlist Vice President Mike Pence to alter the certification outcome.9U.S. Department of Justice. United States v. Trump Indictment

After the Supreme Court ruled in July 2024 that presidents enjoy immunity for certain official acts, prosecutors returned a superseding indictment based on conduct the court had deemed non-immune. Trump pleaded not guilty. The case never reached trial. After Trump won the November 2024 election, Special Counsel Jack Smith moved to dismiss, citing longstanding Justice Department policy against prosecuting a sitting president. Judge Tanya Chutkan granted the motion on November 25, 2024, dismissing without prejudice.10ABC7 New York. Special Counsel Jack Smith Files Motion to Dismiss Federal Election Interference Case Smith submitted his final report in January 2025.11U.S. Department of Justice. Final Report of the Special Counsel, Volume One

The Fulton County RICO Case

In August 2023, a Fulton County, Georgia, grand jury indicted Trump and 18 co-defendants under the state RICO statute for their alleged efforts to overturn Georgia’s results. Four defendants pleaded guilty. Sidney Powell admitted on October 19, 2023, to six misdemeanor counts of conspiracy to commit intentional interference with election duties, received six years of probation and a $6,000 fine, and was ordered to pay $2,700 in restitution for voting equipment tampered with in Coffee County. She admitted to hiring forensic computer experts to compromise voting software and confidential voter information from a county elections office.12NPR. Sidney Powell Georgia Guilty Plea13Georgia Recorder. Trump Lawyer Sidney Powell Flipped Her Plea to Guilty in RICO Case

District Attorney Fani Willis was disqualified in 2024 after controversy over her relationship with Nathan Wade, the lawyer she had hired to manage the prosecution.14Axios. Fani Willis Georgia Senate Investigation Peter Skandalakis of the Prosecuting Attorneys’ Council of Georgia took over and moved to dismiss, arguing there was no realistic prospect of compelling a sitting president to appear and that proceeding against the remaining co-defendants alone would be unduly burdensome. Judge Scott McAfee granted the motion on November 26, 2025.15Georgia Recorder. Fulton County Election Interference Case Dismissed

State Cases Against the Fake Electors

Several states charged Republicans who had submitted fraudulent Electoral College certificates. Michigan charged 16 with forgery and conspiracy, but a district court judge dismissed the case in September 2025. Arizona charged 18 in a conspiracy case; as of June 2026, the attorney general had dismissed the existing case while vowing to seek a new indictment.16PBS NewsHour. Arizona Prosecutors Dismissing Fake Elector Case but Vow to Seek New Indictment Nevada’s original charges were dismissed for improper venue and refiled in another county.17KCRA. Michigan Judge Dismisses Fake Electors Case None of the state fake-elector cases has reached trial.

The January 6 Defendants and the 2025 Pardons

The Capitol breach produced one of the largest criminal investigations in American history, with upward of 1,500 arrests and more than 170 defendants charged with using a deadly or dangerous weapon against police.18CBS News. DOJ Moves to Dismiss Jan. 6 Convictions Prosecutors secured seditious conspiracy convictions against leaders of two far-right groups. Oath Keepers founder Stewart Rhodes was sentenced to 18 years. Proud Boys leaders Ethan Nordean and Zachary Rehl received 18 and 15 years, respectively.19NPR. Trump Jan. 6 Capitol Riot Seditious Conspiracy

On January 20, 2025, his first day back in office, Trump issued a proclamation pardoning all January 6 defendants except 14, whose sentences he commuted to time served. The 14 included Rhodes, Nordean, Rehl, and other militia leaders. All were released immediately, and the proclamation directed the Attorney General to seek dismissal of roughly 300 pending indictments.20The White House. Granting Pardons and Commutation of Sentences21Lawfare. Trump Pardons or Commutes Terms of All Jan. 6 Rioters In April 2026, the Justice Department filed motions to vacate the underlying convictions of 12 of the militia members whose sentences had been commuted. U.S. Attorney Jeanine Pirro described the prosecutions as “years-long, Biden-era weaponized” cases that were no longer in “the interests of justice.” Greg Rosen, who formerly led the department’s Capitol Siege unit, said the move overrode “jury verdicts, judicial findings, years of hard-fought litigation, and mountains of evidence.”19NPR. Trump Jan. 6 Capitol Riot Seditious Conspiracy

Lawyers Who Lost Their Licenses

Attorneys who pushed the fraud narrative in court faced professional consequences even where their clients did not. In August 2021, U.S. District Judge Linda Parker sanctioned Powell and eight other lawyers for a frivolous Michigan suit, writing in a 110-page opinion that the case “was never about fraud — it was about undermining the people’s faith in our democracy.” She ordered them to pay Detroit’s and Michigan’s legal fees, complete 12 hours of continuing legal education, and referred them to bar authorities. A federal appeals court upheld the sanctions, requiring Powell and five co-counsel to pay $152,000.22Detroit Free Press. Federal Judge Sanctions Sidney Powell Kraken Team Over Election Case23Mother Jones. Giuliani Disbarment: Lawyers Who Lied for Trump Face Consequences

Rudy Giuliani was suspended in New York in June 2021 and formally disbarred by a five-judge appellate panel on July 2, 2024, for making “repeatedly and intentionally” false and “perjurious” statements about the election. The D.C. Court of Appeals followed on September 26, 2024, permanently revoking his license in a reciprocal action.24Politico. Rudy Giuliani Disbarred in Washington

John Eastman, who devised the legal strategy to have Pence reject the Electoral College count, was disbarred in California after the state Supreme Court declined to review his appeal in April 2026. A state bar judge had found him culpable on 10 of 11 counts, including conspiring to obstruct the electoral count and making misrepresentations to Pence, courts, and the public.25The Hill. John Eastman Disbarred in California26U.S. Supreme Court. Eastman Disbarment Attached Decisions Jenna Ellis was censured by Colorado authorities in May 2023 after admitting she had made false statements about the election, and Lin Wood announced his retirement while facing disciplinary proceedings in Georgia.23Mother Jones. Giuliani Disbarment: Lawyers Who Lied for Trump Face Consequences

Defamation Settlements

Voting technology companies falsely accused of flipping votes sued the networks that aired the claims. Dominion Voting Systems brought a $1.6 billion case against Fox News. Discovery showed that Fox hosts including Tucker Carlson, Sean Hannity, and Laura Ingraham privately dismissed the fraud claims while continuing to air them, and Judge Eric Davis ruled before any verdict that the statements were false and defamatory. On April 18, 2023, Fox agreed to pay $787.5 million. The network’s statement acknowledged “the Court’s rulings finding certain claims about Dominion to be false.”27NPR. Fox News Settles Blockbuster Defamation Lawsuit With Dominion Voting Systems28Fox News Press. Fox News and Dominion Voting Systems Reach Settlement

Smartmatic’s $2.7 billion defamation suit against Fox News, filed in February 2021, remained in discovery as of mid-2026.29New York Courts. Smartmatic USA Corp. v. Fox Corporation Smartmatic separately settled with Newsmax for $40 million in September 2024.30Reuters. Newsmax Agreed to Pay $40 Million to Settle Defamation Suit

What Changed in the Law

Congress rewrote the statute Trump and Eastman had tried to exploit. The Electoral Count Reform Act, signed in late December 2022, overhauled the ambiguous 1887 law. It states that the Vice President’s role in the electoral count is “solely ministerial” and that the office has no power to accept, reject, or adjudicate elector disputes. It raises the threshold for congressional objections from one member of each chamber to one-fifth of both. It designates the state governor as the official responsible for certifying electors, bars state legislatures from changing election rules after Election Day to override voters, and eliminates a vague provision that had allowed legislatures to declare a “failed election” and appoint electors directly.31Protect Democracy. Understanding the Electoral Count Reform Act of 202232Office of Senator Susan Collins. Electoral Count Reform Act One Pager

States moved in the opposite direction. Georgia’s S.B. 202 restricted drop-box availability, shortened the absentee application window, expanded partisan poll-watcher rights, and gave the State Election Board power to take over local election administration. Texas’s S.B. 1 banned drive-through voting, imposed new restrictions on absentee ballots, and curtailed voter assistance for people with disabilities or limited English proficiency; nearly 25,000 mail-in ballots were rejected in the state’s March 2022 primary under the new rules, according to the Brennan Center. Florida created an Office of Election Crimes and Security to investigate alleged fraud.33Brennan Center for Justice. 5 State Laws Based on Voter Fraud Myths Will Hamper Future Elections The Brennan Center found that in 15 of 17 states where 2020 election lawsuits had been filed and reviewed, legislatures introduced bills built on the same false claims that courts had rejected.4Brennan Center for Justice. January 6 Hearings and the Big Lie’s Ongoing Damage to Democracy

What the Lie Did to Election Administration

Running elections has become a harder job. A 2023 Brennan Center survey found nearly one in three local election officials had been harassed, abused, or threatened over their work, and more than one in five worried about being physically assaulted. The survey projected a net loss of roughly 1.5 election officials per day between the 2020 and 2024 elections.34Brennan Center for Justice. Poll of Election Officials Shows High Turnover Amid Safety Threats Turnover among local election officials hit 41 percent in 2024, the highest rate in at least 25 years, and roughly two in five officials who ran the 2020 election had left before the next presidential cycle.35NPR. Turnover Among Election Officials A February 2026 report found that roughly half of top local election officials in 11 western states had departed since November 2020. The turnover was worst in competitive counties: 80 percent of jurisdictions with close 2020 margins lost their chief election official, and all 15 counties in Arizona experienced turnover. Violent rhetoric aimed at public officials rose more than 200 percent when comparing late 2021–2022 to late 2024–2025.36Politico. Election Officials Facing Threats Ahead of Midterms

Where the Narrative Stands Now

The claim has proved durable. A September 2023 PRRI survey found 63 percent of Republicans still believed the 2020 election was stolen, close to the 66 percent recorded in March 2021. Among all Americans the figure held near 30 percent, and among viewers of far-right television news it reached 92 percent. The same survey found 23 percent of Americans agreed that “true American patriots may have to resort to violence in order to save our country,” up from 15 percent in 2021; among those who believed the election was stolen, 46 percent endorsed that view.37PRRI. After Three Years, the Big Lie Is Still Believed by Most Republicans

In 2024 the narrative pivoted to the claim that noncitizens were voting in U.S. elections, an assertion election experts have found to be without factual basis. A study of 23.5 million votes cast in 2016 found only 30 suspected incidents of noncitizen voting, or 0.0001 percent. Cleta Mitchell, a lawyer involved in Trump’s 2020 call to Georgia Secretary of State Brad Raffensperger, built the Election Integrity Network and the Only Citizens Vote Coalition to coordinate poll watchers, challenge voter rolls, and draft model state legislation. The Trump campaign and the Republican National Committee filed roughly 90 lawsuits in swing states, many alleging failures to purge noncitizens from the rolls. Experts described these as designed to create a “veneer of legitimacy” for post-election challenges.38NBC News. Trump Election Results 2024: Noncitizens Voting and the Big Lie

After Trump won in 2024, some allies claimed his victory retroactively proved the 2020 result was fraudulent, pointing to the gap between Biden’s 2020 total and Kamala Harris’s 2024 total. Fact-checkers noted that shifts between elections reflect changes in turnout and voter preferences, not fraud.39PBS NewsHour. Fact Check: Trump’s 2024 Win Doesn’t Prove Claims That the 2020 Election Was Stolen A May 2026 Politico poll found that distrust had become bipartisan: more than a third of Americans thought the 2026 midterms were likely to be “stolen,” with roughly 40 percent of both Harris and Trump voters expressing doubts, though Democrats cited voter suppression and Republicans cited voter fraud.40Politico. Poll: Voters Express Stolen Election Concerns