Timothy McVeigh’s Arrest: Traffic Stop, FBI Match, and Execution

Timothy McVeigh’s arrest happened by accident. About 90 minutes after the truck bomb he had parked in front of the Alfred P. Murrah Federal Building in Oklahoma City detonated on the morning of April 19, 1995, Oklahoma State Trooper Charlie Hanger pulled him over on Interstate 35 for driving a yellow 1977 Mercury Marquis with no rear license plate. McVeigh was carrying a loaded pistol, and Hanger booked him into the Noble County Jail on weapons and traffic charges. He sat there for two days as an ordinary local defendant while the FBI hunted the bomber, and federal agents placed a hold on him just minutes before a bail hearing that likely would have set him free.¹

The Traffic Stop on I-35

At roughly 10:20 a.m., Hanger spotted the Mercury heading north near mile markers 202 and 203, about 60 to 65 miles above Oklahoma City. There was no plate on the back of the car. He turned on his lights and McVeigh pulled over without incident.²

McVeigh got out and cooperated. When Hanger asked for a driver’s license, McVeigh reached into a billfold in his right rear pocket, and the movement pulled his partially unzipped blue windbreaker tight against a bulge under his left arm. Hanger told him to unzip the jacket. McVeigh said, “I have a gun.”²

Hanger drew his service weapon, put it to the back of McVeigh’s head, and walked him to the rear of the Mercury. McVeigh warned, “My weapon is loaded.” Hanger answered, “So is mine.”² The gun was a .45-caliber Glock semi-automatic with a Black Talon hollow-point in the chamber, carried in a quick-draw shoulder holster. Hanger also took a spare magazine and a knife from McVeigh’s belt before handcuffing him.³

The Charges That Kept Him in Jail

Hanger drove McVeigh to the Noble County Jail in Perry, Oklahoma, and filed four charges: transporting a loaded firearm in a motor vehicle, unlawfully carrying a weapon, failure to display a current number plate, and failure to maintain proof of liability insurance. A routine records check produced no outstanding warrants, so McVeigh was booked in as an unremarkable weapons-possession defendant.²⁴

Hanger had also searched the Mercury with McVeigh’s consent and pulled a blue ball cap, a piece of lined writing paper, and a thick sealed envelope from the front seat. Three days later, he found a business card for “Paulsen’s Military Supply” on the floorboard of his patrol car with a handwritten note on the back that read, “TNT @ $5 a stick, need more.”²

Why McVeigh Was Driving Without a Plate

The missing plate was the point at which McVeigh’s own plan came apart. Days before the bombing, he had staged the Mercury in an alley in a run-down part of downtown Oklahoma City, backed against a brick wall to serve as a getaway car. He deliberately removed the license plate so the vehicle could not be traced if it sat abandoned. He left a handwritten note on the dashboard reading, “NOT ABANDONED. Please do not tow. Will be removed by April 23rd. (Needs battery and cable),” positioned to cover the car’s VIN.¹

In a later deposition, McVeigh said he had a stolen plate available but chose not to attach it. He had, in his words, “given up,” and felt he had “nowhere to go” and “no allies to continue anything with.” Choosing to drive with no plate at all was what put Hanger behind him on I-35.¹

How the FBI Realized They Already Had Him

While McVeigh sat in Perry, investigators at the blast site recovered the rear axle of a large truck about a block from the Murrah Building on April 20. A partial Vehicle Identification Number on the axle was traced through the National Insurance Crime Bureau to a Ryder rental truck, and from there to Elliott’s Body Shop in Junction City, Kansas, where the truck had been rented on April 17 under the alias “Robert Kling.”⁵ Shop owner Eldon Elliott and his employees helped produce composite sketches that circulated nationally.⁶

Agents canvassed nearby motels and reached Lea McGown, owner of the Dreamland Motel, who identified McVeigh as the guest who had rented room 25 from April 14 to 17. The registration card was signed “Timothy McVeigh” and listed a yellow Mercury as his vehicle. A Chinese-food delivery receipt from the same room was signed “Kling,” matching the alias used on the truck rental.⁵

Once agents had the name, a search of the National Crime Information Center database showed that a Timothy James McVeigh had been arrested on the morning of April 19. A phone call to the Noble County Jail confirmed he was still in custody. Federal authorities placed a hold on him with only minutes to spare before a scheduled bail hearing on the state weapons charge. McVeigh was quickly moved into federal custody.⁴¹

The Bombing He Had Just Carried Out

At 9:02 a.m. on April 19, 1995, a rented Ryder truck loaded with approximately 4,000 pounds of ammonium nitrate and fuel oil detonated in front of the Alfred P. Murrah Federal Building.⁷⁸⁹ It destroyed a third of the federal building and damaged or destroyed more than 300 nearby structures.¹⁰ The FBI has called it the worst act of homegrown terrorism in the country’s history.⁶

McVeigh, a Persian Gulf War veteran who had left the Army in late 1991 deeply hostile to the federal government, later said he chose the Murrah Building to avenge the deaths at the 1993 Branch Davidian siege in Waco, Texas, and timed the attack for April 19, the second anniversary of the fire that ended it.⁸¹¹

Indictment, Trial, and Sentence

On August 10, 1995, a federal grand jury in Oklahoma City returned an 11-count indictment against McVeigh and co-conspirator Terry Nichols, including conspiracy to use a weapon of mass destruction, using a truck bomb to kill people, malicious destruction of federal property resulting in death, and eight counts of first-degree murder for the killings of federal law enforcement officials in the building.¹²

Judge Richard P. Matsch found that the emotional toll of the attack and the saturation of media coverage made a fair trial impossible anywhere in Oklahoma, and on February 19, 1996, he moved the case to Denver.¹³ The trials of McVeigh and Nichols were severed. On June 2, 1997, the jury convicted McVeigh on all 11 counts. Eleven days later, the same jury unanimously recommended death. Judge Matsch formally imposed the sentence on August 15, 1997.¹⁴

Execution

McVeigh dropped his appeals in December 2000, and his execution was set for May 16, 2001.¹⁵ Days before that date, the FBI disclosed that it had failed to turn over more than 3,000 pages of documents to the defense, including roughly 200 interview reports discovered by an FBI archivist on May 8, 2001.¹⁶ Attorney General John Ashcroft postponed the execution by 30 days and ordered the Justice Department’s Inspector General to investigate.¹⁷

McVeigh was executed by lethal injection at the United States Penitentiary in Terre Haute, Indiana, on June 11, 2001, the first federal execution in 38 years.¹⁸¹⁹²⁰ Because more than 250 survivors and family members wanted to witness and only ten could fit in the Terre Haute viewing chamber, the Justice Department arranged an encrypted closed-circuit broadcast to a facility in Oklahoma City.²¹

Charlie Hanger, the trooper who had made the arrest, was named Trooper of the Year in Oklahoma in 1995 and later served as Noble County Sheriff from 2004 to 2020. In June 2024, the Oklahoma Legislature designated mile marker 202 on I-35, where he stopped McVeigh, as the “Trooper Charlie Hanger Honorary Mile.”²²

1
NonDoc. Why Timothy McVeigh’s Getaway Plan Failed
2
Famous-Trials.com. The Arrest of Timothy McVeigh
3
Police1. How Trooper Charlie Hanger Caught the Oklahoma City Bomber
4
Oklahoma City National Memorial & Museum. Investigation Timeline
5
Oklahoma City National Memorial & Museum. Evidence: What Story Does It Tell
6
FBI. Oklahoma City Bombing
7
U.S. Department of Justice, Office of the Inspector General. Oklahoma City Bombing
8
Britannica. Oklahoma City Bombing
9
News9. Oklahoma City Bombing Victims
10
Clinton Presidential Library. Oklahoma City Remembrance
11
CNN. Timothy McVeigh Profile
12
U.S. Department of Justice. Oklahoma City Indictment
13
FindLaw. United States v. McVeigh
14
The Denver Post. United States vs. Timothy James McVeigh
15
The Washington Post. FBI Kept Files From McVeigh’s Lawyers
16
CNN. FBI Failed to Disclose Documents
17
U.S. Department of Justice. Attorney General Statement on McVeigh Execution
18
National Center for Biotechnology Information. McVeigh Execution
19
BBC News. McVeigh Execution
20
The Guardian. McVeigh Execution
21
Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press. Ashcroft Allows Closed-Circuit Coverage of McVeigh Execution
22
Oklahoma House of Representatives. Sign Unveiled Honoring Trooper Charlie Hanger