Trial by Jury in the UK: Eligibility, Service, and Verdicts

A trial by jury in the UK puts the decision in the hands of ordinary citizens: twelve randomly selected members of the public in England, Wales, and Northern Ireland, or fifteen in Scotland. They hear the evidence in serious criminal cases, decide the facts, and deliver the verdict. The judge runs the courtroom and rules on the law, but guilt or innocence is the jury’s call.

Which Cases Are Tried by a Jury

Most criminal cases never reach a jury. Magistrates’ courts deal with the bulk of prosecutions, including minor theft, most driving offences, and low-level assaults. Jury trials happen in the Crown Court, and they involve two categories of offence.

Indictable-only offences — the most serious crimes, such as murder, manslaughter, rape, and robbery — must be tried at the Crown Court in front of a jury. A magistrate cannot deal with them alone.

Either-way offences can go either route. At an allocation hearing, magistrates decide whether their sentencing powers would be enough on conviction. If they think the case is suitable for the magistrates’ court, the defendant still has the right under section 20 of the Magistrates’ Courts Act 1980 to elect trial by jury at the Crown Court instead.1Sentencing Council. Making the Decision About Where Trials Are Heard (Allocation) If magistrates decide the matter is too serious for them, the case goes up regardless of what the defendant prefers.

Civil juries exist on paper but are rare in practice. Section 69 of the Senior Courts Act 1981 preserves the right to request a jury in Queen’s Bench Division claims involving fraud, defamation, false imprisonment, or malicious prosecution.2Legislation.gov.uk. Senior Courts Act 1981 – Section 69 Outside those categories a civil jury is a matter of judicial discretion, and judges almost never allow one. Coroner’s inquests use juries in a narrow set of circumstances, mostly deaths in state custody or involving police action, with panels of seven to eleven people.3Courts and Tribunals Judiciary. Chapter 11: Jury Inquests

Who Can Serve, and Who Cannot

Under section 1 of the Juries Act 1974, you are liable for jury service in England and Wales if you are aged 18 to 75, registered on the parliamentary or local government electoral roll, and have lived in the UK, the Channel Islands, or the Isle of Man for at least five years since the age of 13.4House of Commons Library. Jury Service There is no volunteering. Selection is random.

Schedule 1 of the Juries Act then sets out who is disqualified, and the categories are stricter than many people assume:

  • Permanent disqualification applies to anyone who has ever received a life sentence, a sentence of five years’ imprisonment or more, an extended sentence, or detention during His Majesty’s pleasure.
  • A ten-year disqualification applies to anyone who has served any part of a prison sentence, received a suspended sentence, or been subject to a community order in the previous decade. A conviction for a juror misconduct offence under the Juries Act within the last ten years also disqualifies you.
  • Anyone currently on bail in criminal proceedings is disqualified for the duration of those proceedings.
  • People liable to be detained under the Mental Health Act 1983, resident in hospital on account of a mental disorder, subject to guardianship or a community treatment order, or lacking capacity within the meaning of the Mental Capacity Act 2005 are also disqualified.

These rules sit in Schedule 1, Parts 1 and 2 of the Act.5Legislation.gov.uk. Juries Act 1974 – Schedule 1 Serving on a jury while disqualified is itself an offence, carrying a fine of up to £5,000.

How You Are Picked and Summoned

The Jury Central Summoning Bureau, part of His Majesty’s Courts and Tribunals Service, runs the whole process. Each year local authorities share their electoral registers, and a computer randomly draws names from each court’s catchment area.6Inside HMCTS. Understanding the Jury Selection Process If your name comes up, a summons arrives by post.

You have seven days to respond, confirming your details, flagging any disqualification, and asking for a deferral if you need one. The GOV.UK jury service portal handles the response. Ignoring a summons without a reasonable excuse is an offence under section 20 of the Juries Act and can draw a fine of up to £1,000.7Legislation.gov.uk. Juries Act 1974

On the day, more jurors turn up than will actually sit. Names are drawn at random in the courtroom to fill the twelve seats. The prosecution has a limited right to ask a juror to “stand by” before being sworn in, but only where an authorised jury check has flagged a specific concern and the Attorney General has personally approved the request, or where someone is manifestly unsuitable and the defence agrees.8GOV.UK. Jury Vetting: Right of Stand By Guidelines Either side can also challenge a juror for cause, giving a specific reason for the judge to rule on. Unlike the American system, there are no peremptory challenges.

Deferrals, Excusals, and Pay

If the dates on your summons do not work, you can ask to defer to a later point in the year. You can also apply to be excused entirely for something like serious illness, a pre-booked holiday, exam commitments, or caring responsibilities. Courts generally prefer deferral to full excusal and will reschedule rather than lose a juror.

Your employer must release you for jury service. They can be held in contempt of court for refusing. There is no legal requirement for them to pay you while you serve, though many do. If they do not, you claim lost earnings back from the court.

The court pays within set caps. For the first ten days, you can claim up to £64.95 per day for loss of earnings, childcare, or other care costs if you spend more than four hours at court, or £32.47 for a shorter day. From day eleven onwards the caps rise to £129.91 and £64.95. Travel is reimbursed at 31.4p per mile for a car, the cost of a standard-class return by train or bus, or 9.6p per mile by bike. There is a food and drink allowance of £5.71 for sessions up to ten hours and £12.17 beyond that.9GOV.UK. Jury Service: What You Can Claim if You’re an Employee Anyone earning well above the daily cap is unlikely to break even.

What Jurors Do at Trial

Once sworn in, each juror takes an oath or affirmation to try the case faithfully and give a true verdict on the evidence. The division is clean. The judge decides questions of law. The jury decides questions of fact. When lawyers argue about whether a piece of evidence can be admitted, the jury leaves the room, and when they come back they hear only what the judge has ruled in.

Jurors sit through opening statements, witness testimony, cross-examination, and closing arguments. Notebooks are often provided, though the notes stay inside the secure court area. The judge gives directions during the trial and delivers a detailed summing-up before the jury retires, explaining the relevant law and running through the key evidence. Jurors are not expected to know the law. The judge’s directions are the only legal guidance that counts.

Talking about the case outside the jury room is strictly forbidden. You cannot discuss the evidence with family, friends, or anyone other than your fellow jurors, and only during formal deliberations. Independent research is treated particularly seriously, as the misconduct rules below make clear.

How Verdicts Are Reached

After the summing-up, the jury retires to a private room. No one else is present. Not the judge, not the lawyers, not court staff. Everything said in that room is confidential, and disclosing the substance of deliberations is a criminal offence.

The court initially requires a unanimous verdict: all twelve jurors must agree. If the jury cannot reach unanimity after what the judge considers a reasonable period, with a minimum of two hours under section 17 of the Juries Act 1974, the judge may direct that a majority verdict will be accepted.10Legislation.gov.uk. Juries Act 1974 – Section 17 On a full panel of twelve, at least ten must agree. If one juror has been discharged during the trial and the panel is down to eleven, ten must still agree. On a jury of ten, nine must agree.

When the foreman delivers a guilty majority verdict, they must state in open court exactly how many jurors agreed and how many did not. That requirement does not apply to not guilty verdicts; the court simply records the acquittal.

If the jury stays deadlocked after the majority direction, the judge may declare a hung jury and discharge the panel. The prosecution then decides whether to seek a retrial with a fresh jury. Retrials after a hung jury are common in serious cases but not automatic.

What Jurors Must Not Do

Penalties for juror misconduct have been sharpened considerably. The Criminal Justice and Courts Act 2015 inserted a set of new offences into the Juries Act, each carrying up to two years’ imprisonment on conviction on indictment:

  • Section 20A makes it an offence for a juror to search the internet, visit the crime scene, or carry out any other independent investigation during the trial period.
  • Section 20B covers passing the results of that research to another juror.
  • Section 20C is a catch-all for other conduct that undermines the trial process but does not fit neatly into the research offences.
  • Section 20D makes it an offence to disclose what was said during jury deliberations, whether during the trial or after it ends.

These provisions are set out in the Act itself.7Legislation.gov.uk. Juries Act 1974 Jurors have been prosecuted and jailed for online research, including one well-known case where a juror searched for a defendant’s previous convictions and shared what she found with the rest of the panel, causing the trial to collapse.

Lesser offences under section 20 — such as failing to attend, making false statements to avoid service, or serving while disqualified — are dealt with by fines of up to £1,000, rising to £5,000 for sitting on a jury while disqualified.

When a Trial Goes Ahead Without a Jury

The right to a jury can be displaced where there is a real and present danger of jury tampering. Sections 44 to 50 of the Criminal Justice Act 2003 let a Crown Court judge order a non-jury trial on the prosecution’s application, provided the judge is satisfied the risk is genuine and that measures such as police protection would not be enough.11Crown Prosecution Service. Non-Jury Trials Indicators include a previous trial in the same case where the jury had to be discharged for tampering, evidence of tampering in related proceedings, or attempted intimidation of likely witnesses. If granted, a High Court judge sits alone and decides both the facts and the verdict.

Under section 46, if tampering appears to be happening in a trial already under way, the judge can discharge the jury and either continue alone or stop the trial, and can order that any retrial also run without a jury.11Crown Prosecution Service. Non-Jury Trials These powers have been used sparingly.

Scotland and Northern Ireland

Scotland

Scottish criminal juries have fifteen members, not twelve. Scotland was also the only part of the UK to use a third verdict — “not proven,” which acquitted the accused in the same way as not guilty but carried a lasting stigma. That verdict has now gone. From 1 January 2026 Scottish juries return only guilty or not guilty.12Law Society of Scotland. Concerns Remain as New Era Begins With Not Proven Abolition The majority needed to convict has also changed. Where a simple majority of eight out of fifteen used to be enough, at least two-thirds of the jury — ten out of fifteen — must now agree on guilt. The fifteen-member panel itself stays the same.

Northern Ireland

Northern Ireland broadly mirrors England and Wales, with twelve-member juries in Crown Court. The main difference is the surviving legacy of the Troubles-era “Diplock courts.” The formal Diplock system ended in 2007, but the Director of Public Prosecutions for Northern Ireland can still certify that a specific trial should go ahead without a jury where there are concerns about juror safety or paramilitary influence. Employers in Northern Ireland must give employees time off for jury service, and can be held in contempt for refusing.13nidirect. Time Off for Jury Service